Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School Have basically given up on entire year 11

135 replies

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 16:19

Our school have been questionable at best for a while. I've allowed a few concerns to slide, haven't we all, putting it down to unforeseen Covid related kiboshing.

Our school is different in that it starts GCSE studies in year 9 rather than 10, so they traditionally choose options in March of year 8. It was promoted as being helpful as work is more staggered and worst case they could swap a subject if they hated it in year 9.

So, DD was due to choose their options in March 2020, with an options evening for of all dates the first day of lockdown.

When it didn't happen we assumed they would cancel options picking completely. Except they didn't, we did it with just a booklet giving some idea of the curriculum. They were slow to organise online learning so no virtual event took place (not a surprise, these were very strange times).

DD ended up picking 4 subjects, 1 of which they were on the fence with.

Obviously, as we all know, life didn't go back to normal as predicted, and a few of us parents did voice perhaps by December 2020 that maybe they should start from scratch for year 10. The school was hit hard by Covid isolations from Octopus onwards, whole year groups were off due to a lack of teachers. Then we had the January to March lockdown, and within a week of being back they were on school break.

This has had a hugely negative effect on DD, they've gone from a confident kid to being a shell.

Year 10 was a nightmare, not just for DD, for the entire year group. They did tests before the end of term and it was, to quote one teacher, a nightmare. How it's taken school this long to realise how badly behind they all are and the knock on MH effect of lockdown is beyond me. They also hadn't taken up the government offer of tutoring.

Meanwhile, DS didn't pick his GCSE subjects in 2021 (year 8), down to covid, he waited until year 9 and had the benefit of talking to tutors to ensure they are right for him. He has entered year 10 last week full of confidence and is thankfully very happy.

The one constant we had was the school has always had a place for any pupil who wanted it at the school's onsite sixth form.

Until last night.

We had a curriculum evening, not unusual, but this time, they are about to become part of an academy.

Suddenly, the school has been trumpeting their top 25% results for GCSE this year and top 20% A'levels.

They have now said the kids won't get a place automatically, and of you think they won't do well, then start looking elsewhere. Charming.

They have to apply, have an interview, get grades and have an exemplary record of great grades. DD does not have that since Covid.

On the way out a lot of parents were angry. It felt like because they were going on about the top 20% score and they realised the tests done at the end of last academic year were terrible, they are replacing kids they let down by not responding to covid in year 9 effecting GCSE study to be able to show off.

My AIBU is whether I'm right to raise this with the headteacher? I feel like they've let them down so much and the lack of foresight with their year group is ridiculous.

Is this what happens when a school is an academy?

DD was utterly broken last night, saying they may as well give up now, as even the school thinks they suck and will fail. They know what they want to do post A Level and need GCSEs to do it. It's been so hard to try and reassure a kid who is totally adrift thanks to two years of carnage.

What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 17/09/2022 10:26

Yellowshirt · 17/09/2022 10:23

Teachers downed tools from the start of covid. They didn't go the extra mile to get children through GCSEs .
They just hide behind the unions.
It is what it is. Until the government get a grip of the unions nothing will change in schools.
It is frustrating when you see your child struggling but you just have to support them the best you can.

Absolute rubbish as a generalisation.

Yellowshirt · 17/09/2022 10:23

Teachers downed tools from the start of covid. They didn't go the extra mile to get children through GCSEs .
They just hide behind the unions.
It is what it is. Until the government get a grip of the unions nothing will change in schools.
It is frustrating when you see your child struggling but you just have to support them the best you can.

Motherofacertainage · 17/09/2022 10:15

I think it sounds like your DD just went to pieces in the mocks. If the school and teachers have previously been good then it's unlikely they ALL completely overestimated how she was doing up.to that point. It also sounds like the meeting you attended was clumsily pitched and not aimed at students like your daughter who is struggling with MH/anxiety rather at those who are just not trying at present. Rather than going in all guns blazing and complaining to the Head, I would suggest booking a meeting with your daughter's tutor or head of year and having a chat about how you can all support her with exam skills. Does she have special arrangements such as sitting in a smaller venue than the main exam hall? If not that would be a good starting point .

Doingprettywellthanks · 17/09/2022 10:12

And op it absolutely will not be “the whole cohort struggling”.

Doingprettywellthanks · 17/09/2022 10:09

I'm aware also that DD does need to knuckle down but getting someone who is constantly in tears, not sleeping and so at an emotional low point to do so is hard. She's 16 but actually, she's more like 14

OP - I would suggest that your overriding focus needs to be in addressing what would seem to be a fairly serious mental health situation here

TeenDivided · 17/09/2022 09:41

So the grades probably aren't as bad as you said really if she didn't sit the whole exam.
The whole cohort might be 1-2 grades down on where they should be, but your DD might be appearing even lower than that? Due to a mixture of missing part-exams and not revising?
It sounds like she is struggling with her MH, so helping her cope needs to be a priority. A big part of that will be sorting out a plan for y11 that is doable and not too overwhelming.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 17/09/2022 09:33

Oblomov22 · 17/09/2022 09:05

6th form probably isn't the right place for her. Many schools ask for a 7 at GCSE, so that they can cope with A'level's. If you are talking 1 & 2's and seriously struggling, Then surely you should be looking at alternatives?

We are looking at alternatives I've said upthread we have booked to go to open day at the local college

OP posts:
ReformedWaywardTeen · 17/09/2022 09:32

SeasonFinale · 17/09/2022 08:10

I am unsure though why you were shocked by her poor grades. The whole thread was about loads of missed schooling for covid, missed school for 3 months for illness, a demotivated child that you said you couldn't get to work and then no revision for her year end exams.

By the way having to choose options from a booklet rather than after an in school event is not an excuse at all as many schools have to choose subjects that way.

Blaming teachers for the style they teach only works if the whole cohort is doing poorly which presumably they aren't.

I think you missed where I've said that actually, the entire cohort are struggling and not meeting expected grades. And school did not say DD was doing badly. In fact, I had next to no info to suggest any issues at all. We knew they were down in themselves but they were getting merits for good behaviour and work all the time as before.

Also, I've explained that the difference between DD and DS picking GCSE options has been huge. DS was on the fence between two subjects and open evening helped him decide. He had to speak to a teacher about his options after picking who voiced an incorrect and based on old info query on one choice so presumably they could guide others who may have picked the wrong subject. They also picked in year 9 not year 8.

DD had none of that. No open evening, no discussion with a teacher no meeting to ensure they were the right choices. Yes much of that down to covid but in essence it would've been better to delay to year 9 or let them start again in year 10, with the option of switching a subject if need be. DD had asked to do that and despite school explaining they start in year 9 as they can swap, was not given that option after all.

On their reports and points and such I had no reason to think anything educationally was amiss. Parents evening was incredibly positive with nothing flagged at all

That's why it was a shock when they did so badly in July but it was universal across the year group

As I say it's not so much about the dropping them at 16, it's more the way they've handled it all. This has just been the final straw of they've miss managed a lot and not addressed it.

We've spoken to her again but she was in tears again. I've tried nice I've tried getting tough and it ends with the same outcome. And we do feel like she's on borrowed time educationally.

Perhaps instead of being positive last year they could've flagged concerns. I personally don't see how from no concerns we got those grades. It's totally flattened her.

Also someone mentioned 3 months off? This is incorrect they didn't have 3 whole months off not sure where that impression came from.

Also I feel some have seen this thread as a teacher bashing exercise but that's not the case. I recognise throughout that teachers had a thankless task. It's more the way the announcement was made and the management of the school that has disappointed me.

I'm aware also that DD does need to knuckle down but getting someone who is constantly in tears, not sleeping and so at an emotional low point to do so is hard. She's 16 but actually, she's more like 14, this wasn't the case until now she was always very mature. It's almost like she thinks of she hides it will go away.

I am planning on contacting current tutors to see what we need to do or if they can help in school. I doubt they want anyone to fail, much less a whole year group. But I think the low grades came from her being so panicked and she had to leave the hall during the exams. She said she couldn't breathe. It was so unlike her.

I don't think school have prepared for her year as well as they could have, purely because they've gone along with DofE that everything is fine now and no need to change their GCSE exam pattern like they've done up until recently.

OP posts:
Oblomov22 · 17/09/2022 09:05

6th form probably isn't the right place for her. Many schools ask for a 7 at GCSE, so that they can cope with A'level's. If you are talking 1 & 2's and seriously struggling, Then surely you should be looking at alternatives?

sorrelandheather · 17/09/2022 09:05

Sorry should be

they CANNOT waver on some students' grades

sorrelandheather · 17/09/2022 08:59

Head of Sixth Form here. Schools are completely reasonable in setting academic criteria for entry into sixth form and now, due to the Admissions Code, they waver on some students' grades (ie: their own Year 11) and not others. Also, with A Levels being the way they are now, there will be no Covid adjustments for this cohort and they are entitled to talk about need for work ethic. Too many students sail into A Level thinking it's an easy ride and it really isn't. We don't have many vocational pathways for our students so we are kindly honest about the fact that there is likely to be something out there which is better suited for particular students, and we work hard to advise them on what that is. I have seen over the years that there is nothing confidence building for young people in getting Es and Us throughout the two years they're with us, when they could be succeeding in something more appropriate for their learning needs.

That said, they are absolutely not allowed to interview to decide if a place should be given. You should have the opportunity to have an individual discussion about options and pathways, but this should not form part of the decision making process. Moreover, if your child gets the grades, she should get a place, unless the sixth form is oversubscribed - but I would be highly surprised if the oversubscription criteria ranking is anything other than looked after children, children with an EHCP, then Year 11 from their own school. In which case your daughter should get in.

Look forward. Support your daughter in turning things around (it's September of Year 11, of course she can!) and building her confidence. That way she will have a range of options available to her, of which sixth form is one.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/09/2022 08:31

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 17/09/2022 08:19

You know going elsewhere for sixth form might be exactly what she needs, a different environment, different staff, different friends, different atmosphere.

Neither of you are happy with the current school so start looking for positive aims going forward.

You may need to look further afield, I went to sixth form in a different local authority and it was a good move all round. A few people I knew did similar and they were all pleased they did despite the extra bus! My sister lived in at sixth form (I know a couple of other teenagers who did too and loved it) then there are apprenticeships to consider.

Please start looking at this as an opportunity to do something positive

Cross post. Agreed. Totally.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/09/2022 08:31

Please don’t get into the mindset of blaming the school for your dd getting such poor grades in her mocks. It won’t help your dcs. She didn’t revise and was incredibly stressed during her mocks.

Idk how much time you have on your hands but I would be helping your dcs with the work if you are able. As they’re only a year apart, you could perhaps even work with them both together for certain topics. If there are particular areas to work on, there are great resources out there. I wasn’t a fan of the few Oak Academy year 9 maths classes I saw but perhaps some other were better. I love the Corbett maths explanations for example. The guy has such a soothing voice.

This is the man behind them. John Corbett giving students advice on last minute revision and how to prepare the morning of the exam

As for the English, I will be reading the GCSE texts in case dd (year 10) needs to talk through them with me. I did this with the text for her end of year 9 exam as she’s a bit lazy and despite studying it for a very long time and professed not to know the story! Idk how much or the oak academy is useful. But it is also worth looking at. They have revision sections for example.

A poster upthread said if you say the exam boards and subjects your dcs need help with, they will suggest resources, which I thought was a very kind offer.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 17/09/2022 08:19

You know going elsewhere for sixth form might be exactly what she needs, a different environment, different staff, different friends, different atmosphere.

Neither of you are happy with the current school so start looking for positive aims going forward.

You may need to look further afield, I went to sixth form in a different local authority and it was a good move all round. A few people I knew did similar and they were all pleased they did despite the extra bus! My sister lived in at sixth form (I know a couple of other teenagers who did too and loved it) then there are apprenticeships to consider.

Please start looking at this as an opportunity to do something positive

SeasonFinale · 17/09/2022 08:10

I am unsure though why you were shocked by her poor grades. The whole thread was about loads of missed schooling for covid, missed school for 3 months for illness, a demotivated child that you said you couldn't get to work and then no revision for her year end exams.

By the way having to choose options from a booklet rather than after an in school event is not an excuse at all as many schools have to choose subjects that way.

Blaming teachers for the style they teach only works if the whole cohort is doing poorly which presumably they aren't.

TeenDivided · 17/09/2022 07:51

OP. I suggest you start a separate thread in Secondary if you want advice on how to approach y11 given your DDs end y10 results and her career aspirations.

Neversaygoodbye · 17/09/2022 07:48

We don't have a school sixth form and all I can say is thank goodness from both my point of view as a parent and from both my children's perspective. In my experience most children are more than ready to leave the formal uniform wearing, confirming insisting, rule bearing nature of secondary school and stretch their wings at local colleges. My DD has absolutely thrived at 6th form college and loves being able to express her individuality. My DS is currently year 11 and will be attending the local college open days. There's generally more choice of subjects too. Maybe see it as a positive opportunity.

RunWalkSwim99 · 17/09/2022 07:47

I feel for you and your daughter this cohort have had a tough couple of years. My DD is same age she was a G7-9 student pre-covid and then had a few G4s on the July exams. Schools attitude was they will pass 🤷🏻‍♀️ we’ve just found a tutor for English as she needs min G6 for A’Levels. It incredibly hard when she too is a quiet not disruptive A-grade primary kid just assumed she’d do A’Levels no problem and now she’s working her butt off. She has a friend who sounds the same as your daughter they were very shocked how low her grades had slipped. The mental health sounds key, what does she enjoy? What motivates her? Can you get her doing something non-school related that gives her a buzz for life, sport, photography, helping out at brownies / parkrun anything? It’s that stuff that’s kept my DD going and she has had to self motivate to revise as the school haven’t been able to cover everything. Inside I’m worried too as they are a huge failing academy.

HappyKoala56 · 17/09/2022 07:38

I honestly thought this was the standard to be honest. At my children's school I know we have to reapply for 6th form - yes you do need certain grades to be able to apply but I think this is because they only offer a levels and there are certain entry requirements. Same for every qualification, there will be conditions to be able to apply. Places aren't allocated by grade results though, if you meet entry requirements you are able to apply and then places allocated just like normal school places (distance from school etc).

This is the case for my niece's and nephews in a different part of the country too (my nephew this September didn't get the GCSE results he needed and couldn't be considered for 6th form). I'm sure this was even the case for me at 16. Do you think children who get 1s across the board should be able to go to 6th form and do a levels? Is that not detrimental to the other children studying a levels too? Another consideration is the number of spaces, does your school have the same number of spaces in 6th form as years 7-11? My children's school certainly doesn't so obviously not everyone can stay on

TeenDivided · 17/09/2022 07:35

I do think the valid complaint is you weren't informed how much she was struggling before July. It sounds like they weren't doing sufficient interim testing. Presumably the end y10 results came back before the holidays though so this isn't new information now.

Oblomov22 · 17/09/2022 07:29

"DD will need at least grade 5 in English and Maths. Their test results from July gave them a 2 and 1. "

Come on now. All this .... we didn't get much info on options. They chose 4 they weren't sure about..... is all nonsense. You do the subjects that you can according to the timetable choices. If you want to do geography and business so badly and it doesn't fit in the timetable then you move schools! then just accept it and knuckle down and get on with it.

This is not what you are talking about though. You are talking about children have been very badly affected by Covid, who need camhs, but it hasn't been available.

but really a 2 and a 1 is not a close fail. It's an absolute fail. The lowest you can get. they are failing, not just a little bit, but very very badly, getting the lowest grades possible. this hasn't been but should have been addressed before.

MsTSwift · 17/09/2022 07:25

She needs to knuckle down. Dd1 has always found science her most challenging subject and I agree I think it was most affected by covid. In her year 11 mocks last autumn the science results were bad across the board as the teaching was weak Dd got a 3 and a 4 other bright girls also dropped grades. Dh found a shit hot tutor and Dd worked so hard. Ended up with 8s for science. So 8s and 9s for everything. So proud but she worked bloody hard.

Oblomov22 · 17/09/2022 07:20

I don't really understand the issue here. Or why you are blaming the school. If dd is struggling then you need to address it. Is the real reason that you're angry with yourself for not addressing it before. The school sounds fine and is doing nothing wrong afaics.

Doingprettywellthanks · 17/09/2022 07:13

This school has made a sensible and entirely reasonable.

It doesn’t suit your DD’s particular circumstances and so you see it as them being uncaring.

No, that is not the case. Allowing a 16 year with has zero GCSEs and has shown zero commitment (as I say not saying your DD but there will be some in this cohort) to automatically get a place is doing a disservice to the other students who will no doubt have lessons disrupted by them; the teachers who have to spend time teaching an 16/17/18 who failed their subject at GCSE and has shown no enthusiasm for the subject; and the child themselves - prolonging the inevitable - they are not going to get any formal educational academic qualifications.

The school is doing a good thing. Unfortunately that means some, such as your DD , will have to make other arrangements. The bigger picture is that it will benefit many many more in the long run.

TeenDivided · 17/09/2022 07:08

From your update I wonder if they have just realised that trying to be like a vast college in the 6th form (catering to all abilities) but with only a school sized cohort is just unsustainable and they aren't doing any of it properly?
They can't be offering a proper full range of BTECs alongside a proper full range of A levels.

I do wonder wrt progress, how much is the school and how much is your DD / mental health / just being overwhelmed?