Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:23

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:18

He isn’t saying he’s poor he’s saying he is working class. You can be poor and upper class and stinking rich and working class.

You can’t be stinking rich and working class. The very definition of working class is the social group consisting primarily of people who are employed in unskilled or semi-skilled manual or industrial work.

Class is not a feeling. Class is about economic power.

We’re straying into identity politics here. I fear this is Class-Dysphoria territory. Perhaps we should start a new Tavistock to help people comes to realities with their class identities 🙄

Grandeur · 18/09/2022 09:19

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:18

He isn’t saying he’s poor he’s saying he is working class. You can be poor and upper class and stinking rich and working class.

You can be stinking rich and working class? That's the biggest laugh I've had all week, thanks for that! 😂

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:18

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:15

He can absolutely recognise that he came from a working class background, but it is grossly offensive to continue to claim to be working class when you have the level of economic power that he has. Imagine telling someone who is struggling to make ends meet, working all hours of the day on a zero hour contract, that you’re working class too on a 6 figure salary with all the cushy trappings of a MC lifestyle?! Utterly nonsensical.

He isn’t saying he’s poor he’s saying he is working class. You can be poor and upper class and stinking rich and working class.

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:17

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:15

So wrong . Money/wealth is a factor but by your reckoning Wayne Rooney is upper class 😂

No, I’m not wrong. That’s the economic definition of class.

And no, Wayne Rooney would be upper-middle. He’s not aristocracy/nobility/political.

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:15

He can absolutely recognise that he came from a working class background, but it is grossly offensive to continue to claim to be working class when you have the level of economic power that he has. Imagine telling someone who is struggling to make ends meet, working all hours of the day on a zero hour contract, that you’re working class too on a 6 figure salary with all the cushy trappings of a MC lifestyle?! Utterly nonsensical.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:15

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 08:41

All this rubbish about not being able to change class 🙄

Class is about categorising people based on their economic position in society. The higher your class the more power, status and influence you have in the economy.

Upper class refers to the very wealthiest and powerful people in society, often the very top percentage of the population. They are usually connected to politics and includes anyone in the aristocracy or nobility. Middle class includes people who work in high status, secure and stable jobs, like doctors and lawyers and the people who own their own homes. Working class refers to those who have to work in order to to survive. They don’t have many savings and may even be in debt, and have low wage and insecure jobs.

He is Middle Class. End of.

So wrong . Money/wealth is a factor but by your reckoning Wayne Rooney is upper class 😂

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 18/09/2022 08:54

Grandeur · 18/09/2022 08:50

Completely agree with everything you've said.

The people going on about how you can't change/move up or down the classes aren't even providing any evidence or reasoning behind it. Just touting their own personal opinions as "facts".

Surely it’s subjective though. There might be indicators of material things you can use to indicate class but that’s not the whole picture.

Someone that comes from a WC background could move into an MC lifestyle but still identify strongly with their cultural upbringing and that frames their perspective on their whole life. How can you say - fact, end of! - when talking about how someone views themselves based on such strong elements such as culture, experience and upbringing?

mamabear715 · 18/09/2022 08:52

Does it matter? I'm just me & take people at face value. Dislike pigeonholes.

Grandeur · 18/09/2022 08:50

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 08:41

All this rubbish about not being able to change class 🙄

Class is about categorising people based on their economic position in society. The higher your class the more power, status and influence you have in the economy.

Upper class refers to the very wealthiest and powerful people in society, often the very top percentage of the population. They are usually connected to politics and includes anyone in the aristocracy or nobility. Middle class includes people who work in high status, secure and stable jobs, like doctors and lawyers and the people who own their own homes. Working class refers to those who have to work in order to to survive. They don’t have many savings and may even be in debt, and have low wage and insecure jobs.

He is Middle Class. End of.

Completely agree with everything you've said.

The people going on about how you can't change/move up or down the classes aren't even providing any evidence or reasoning behind it. Just touting their own personal opinions as "facts".

Toomuchtrouble4me · 18/09/2022 08:50

Relocatiorelocation · 16/09/2022 15:11

DH and I grew up on council estates. We both went to uni, own a fuck off house, have a huge joint income and our kids have what they want within reason.
We are definitely still working class. The way we vote / our values and beliefs / the way we speak. Just because we're educated and have a few quid, you'd never catch me wearing Hunter wellies walking a labrador. I'm more likely to be smoking a fag outside Weatherspoons on a Saturday night.

I wear Hunters, and White Stuff gilet’s and you would never see me having a ‘fag’ outside Weatherspoins. My dad smoked ‘fags’ - I would generally never use that word. I live a very middle class lifestyle, in a very middle class area, my accent has changed. I am still working class. I will always be working class and am a better person for it.
But I do like having nice things 🤣

Ayabbadabbado · 18/09/2022 08:47

You can't buy class, but you can buy stuff like food, and heat. If you earn enough to afford it that is. Your friend sounds like a nob.

TheNinny · 18/09/2022 08:47

I used tho think it was your current circumstances that defined your class but learned recently its based on what your parents were/how you were raised. So I think he would be working class (although living now in a middle class environment (but not part of it) and raising his children that way).

Toomuchtrouble4me · 18/09/2022 08:45

He is working class, as am I. My children are middle class due to home owning professional parents and their lifestyle and education. But I will always be/feel working class and will always understand the working class in a way that my children possibly won’t.
I consider myself working class living a middle class lifestyle. It’s not at all about money or where you go, it’s where you’re from and how you were raised.

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 08:41

All this rubbish about not being able to change class 🙄

Class is about categorising people based on their economic position in society. The higher your class the more power, status and influence you have in the economy.

Upper class refers to the very wealthiest and powerful people in society, often the very top percentage of the population. They are usually connected to politics and includes anyone in the aristocracy or nobility. Middle class includes people who work in high status, secure and stable jobs, like doctors and lawyers and the people who own their own homes. Working class refers to those who have to work in order to to survive. They don’t have many savings and may even be in debt, and have low wage and insecure jobs.

He is Middle Class. End of.

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 18/09/2022 08:20

@carefullycourageous yes good point. I am proud of my background, identify strongly with how I was brought up. Social mobility suggests moving up. Whilst this is obviously a good thing in terms of moving out of poverty, all the other things that make someone WC are not necessarily things they would want to move up from - that implies the personal/ emotional elements of being WC are somehow not good enough.

Flutterbybudget · 18/09/2022 08:18

Three different definitions/ statements

the social group consisting primarily of people who are employed in unskilled or semi-skilled manual or industrial work.
"he came from the working class"

/ˌwɝː.kɪŋ ˈklæs/ (UK also the working classes) a social group that consists of people who earn little money, often being paid only for the hours or days that they work, and who usually do physical work: The working class usually react/reacts in a predictable way to government policies.

More than one in five of those earning between £75,000 and £100,000 identify as working class. For context, a salary of £75,000 would have put you in the top 6 per cent of taxpayers in 2019-20, according to HMRC figures published last month.11 Apr 2022

happyscouse · 18/09/2022 08:18

Yes this exactly. Those saying his kids will be MC but not him, what if his kids end up happily working in Asda and living in a modest house are the still MC because of their dads job but he stays WC?

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 08:09

@hotdiggetydog And tbh the fact you see it as lanes, rather than one big pool, makes you the snob!

Why does someone have to leave the WC lane if they become a barrister? Why can't they just be a brilliant barrister and retain all their background too?

Social mobility for me will have worked when working class people don't feel the need to change what they eat, or wear, or speak like or where they holiday to fit in at work Angry.

I want no lanes at all, just free swimming.

JMR185 · 18/09/2022 07:58

I think he's definitely middle class but might be termed as a 'Champagne socialist'. Class isn't fixed and is determined by education, job, lifestyle etc. Whatever his class, he doesn't sound particularly classy! 😁

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 07:58

hotdiggetydog · 18/09/2022 07:49

What a horrendous and absolutely snotty response. Reaks of "stay in your lane"

Wtf? You misread something there.

I don't think being MC is better than WC, or vice versa.

If it makes any difference - I have one parent from each class (massive differences between them). I'm proud of both sides.

LaDamaDeElche · 18/09/2022 07:52

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/09/2022 00:47

I was working class, I am now middle class. Social mobility.

It really doesn't work like that.

Does the professional privately/grammar school educated colleagues in your job consider you MC or WC University educated?

I liked the French analogy above.

Well, I was born into a working class family to a teen mum and lived with my grandparents on a council house until I was 9. Mu mum had been studying and working during that time and had got a very high paid job in IT. From 10 I went to boarding school and was educated there. What am I? A hybrid of both maybe, as from 0-9 I was in a working class environment living in a council house, then from 10-18 I was educated in a middle class environment, and my mum lived in a big house with a high paying job 🤷🏻‍♀️

hotdiggetydog · 18/09/2022 07:50

Jilltee · 17/09/2022 21:54

fuck off house and earn a fortune. Urgh.

Why shouldn't they be proud?

hotdiggetydog · 18/09/2022 07:49

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 06:48

This is not how social mobility works. You are not suddenly middle class, you can't change your past.

What has happened is someone from working class background has taken a role that previously society would have expected someone from a middle class background to fill.

Social mobility means (in theory, a whole other thread about UK issues in this regard) class and family circumstances don't limit future opportunities - e.g. working class people can become barristers - it isn't a process of converting working class people into middle class people.

What a horrendous and absolutely snotty response. Reaks of "stay in your lane"

5128gap · 18/09/2022 07:42

He was right OP, and you were wrong.
You were technically incorrect in equating financial position with class.
Not only is it patronising to the very many wealthy working class people, but also negates the struggles of professional people on lower incomes, middle class defining people who are ill, disabled etc.
The sort of assumptions that equate how much people will struggle with a judgement made based on their education, accent, fathers job, their job, their leisure activities or whatever any individual wants to dream up next, miss the mark.How much one will struggle depends purely on whether they can afford the increases. Nothing else.
And just because he is wealthy and has the sort of job people considering themselves MC want to be associated with, doesn't mean he can't define any way he chooses. Just like everyone here is doing, simply picking the criteria that best gives them membership to the class they want to be part of.

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 18/09/2022 07:38

Off the back off this thread, me and DH were discussing it last night. We’re both working class but with the outward trappings of being MC. For DH it’s not really a thing that he thinks about - he’s mixed race so for him, there’s other signifiers he uses to kind of categorise himself in context to other people. But for me, I realised that within a few seconds of meeting people, I do kind of instantly recognise myself as working class and categorise them as whatever I think they are.

I guess it makes sense from a tribal perspective, 1000’s of years ago we needed ways to recognise allies or whatever. I don’t know. Probably talking out of my arse. What I do now recognise is that despite all the stuff about how we should be classless, and how stupid class is, I do strongly align to class as a way to categorise people I meet. Not even in a judgement kind of way - not to shun people not like me or anything like that - but just as a simple frame of reference.

Years ago I had a very posh boyfriend. Trust fund family posh. They lived in dolphin square in Pimlico where Members of Parliament lived. After I was initially intimated by his family when I first met them, I got to know them and I was very much a part of the family and adored all of them. I was very close to his sisters and we lived together for about five years. So there was never any inclination of me not being “accepted” because I was working class. But I always, to some small degree, felt the difference between us. Just really tiny things they would do or not do that would signify to me that I was not the same. I couldn’t even tell you what these hundreds of slight differences were but they were enough for me to pick up on.

Years and years later, I was then a stay at home mum in a fairly affluent-ish part of a south London suburb. At baby groups and whatever, meeting different mums, I would pick up on similar things. I made lots of friends so it was never a negative thing, but just a recognition that we hadn’t had the same up bringing and it showed in lots of tiny mundane ways.

I guess it’s about recognition and we use all sorts of ways to give context to people we meet. I now earn over six figures, we live in a nice house in south London, outwardly we probably look middle class. But I think if I met someone who also was working class, within a conversation I think I would “betray” (for want of a better word) certain signifiers that person would pick up on that they would use to categorise me as - oh I thought you were MC but now I recognise you as WC.

Or not if they don’t care about class, maybe 😂