Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
QuebecBagnet · 18/09/2022 10:19

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:54

Considering he manages DC United and lives out in the USA, I would say he spends most days managing/training elite athletes on a football pitch.

That’s his job. Not his free time activities/culture.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 10:14

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 10:09

Rooney is nouveau riche, the middle class never accept them but will go to their parties Grin

You got that right!

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 10:09

Rooney is nouveau riche, the middle class never accept them but will go to their parties Grin

StinkyWizzleteets · 18/09/2022 10:07

My MIL is faux mc, her dad was a manual worker and mum a housewife. She’s very plummy, educated to within an inch of her life and will “only consume high culture” so living abroad was never an option because you apparently cant get high culture outside of the UK 🙄. She decided I “must be middle class behind the cheap looking piercings and tattoos” because I played a middle class sport growing up. This weird British obsession with class that really is just snobbery makes me laugh.

I am probably considered middle class but it certainly doesn’t feature in my life as something worthy of discussion or even relevant. What I’m not is a snob.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:59

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:49

He earned £350k a week, lives in a multi million pound house with staff, children go to top private schools and he hobnobs with the elite on a daily basis. He lives a very privileged existence and works in a unbelievably skilled job.

In other countries he would be upper class, but the UK limits that possibility with our unique class system. In the broadest sense he would be middle class but I would say his daily culture allows him to be defined at the higher end of that MC spectrum.

So the house is money, the staff are money, the schools are money - remove those and you have come up with

’hobnobs with the elite’. Does he? Other than through work which elites is Wayne Rooney socialising with? Certainly my understanding is that he and Coleen have mainly kept local friends fro when they were younger and also spend a lot of time with family.

‘works in an unbelievably skilled job’ or has a talent that he has nurtured. Being incredibly talented is not something that is down to class, people of phenomenal talent can be found in any class.

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:54

QuebecBagnet · 18/09/2022 09:51

In the broadest sense he would be middle class but I would say his daily culture allows him to be defined at the higher end of that MC spectrum.

personally I picture his daily culture to be sat on the sofa (settee), watching Eastenders, drinking lager while scratching his bollocks. I may well be wrong. 😁

Considering he manages DC United and lives out in the USA, I would say he spends most days managing/training elite athletes on a football pitch.

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 09:52

I think it is interesting to note that income and wealth are distinct in the description above.

Being middle class in professional/educational terms no longer generates the same income/wealth benefits it used to. This is getting less clear cut with high student debts etc.

QuebecBagnet · 18/09/2022 09:51

In the broadest sense he would be middle class but I would say his daily culture allows him to be defined at the higher end of that MC spectrum.

personally I picture his daily culture to be sat on the sofa (settee), watching Eastenders, drinking lager while scratching his bollocks. I may well be wrong. 😁

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:50

WanderingFruitWonderer · 18/09/2022 09:45

The craziest one I ever encountered was a very successful lawyer. Her dad was also a lawyer. She is educated to the hilt, including a very posh girls school in Kent, and at least two degrees. She owns two homes. But she identifies as working class because her grandfather on one side was a miner. Her granddad was working class. Her dad became middle class, and she is solidly middle class. I nearly choked when she told me she's working class! Give me strength!

That would be an example of social mobility across generations

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:49

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:45

‘Social class is dependent on education, wealth, occupation, income and culture.‘

You have completely contradicted yourself.

Please do share though the educational, occupational and cultural markers that show that Wayne Rooney is upper middle class.

He earned £350k a week, lives in a multi million pound house with staff, children go to top private schools and he hobnobs with the elite on a daily basis. He lives a very privileged existence and works in a unbelievably skilled job.

In other countries he would be upper class, but the UK limits that possibility with our unique class system. In the broadest sense he would be middle class but I would say his daily culture allows him to be defined at the higher end of that MC spectrum.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:49

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:42

Well this is an interesting point… how others identify you.

Do you think many people would identify a doctor as working class?

I gave Sir Paul Nurse as an example
up thread. He is a world leading academic, knighted and has a Nobel prize. The first time I saw him interviewed, I immediately ‘read’ him as working class.

Another example is Alan Johnson was a government minister who was very clearly working class.

Its not a negative judgement it’s just a judgment.

QuebecBagnet · 18/09/2022 09:49

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:42

Well this is an interesting point… how others identify you.

Do you think many people would identify a doctor as working class?

Depends. How would people initially identify the person if they met them in a non work setting? Would they be surprised to find out they’re a doctor or not surprised?

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:45

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:39

It’s not the narrowest definition at all. It’s THE definition by dictionary.

Social class is dependent on education, wealth, occupation, income and culture.

The only thing you can ‘identify’ with is culture. The rest is defined by what you do and what you earn.

Class ultimately isn’t about identity, it’s about economic power.

The outlier class is upper class. You can’t earn your way into this class. This is typically hereditary.

‘Social class is dependent on education, wealth, occupation, income and culture.‘

You have completely contradicted yourself.

Please do share though the educational, occupational and cultural markers that show that Wayne Rooney is upper middle class.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 18/09/2022 09:45

The craziest one I ever encountered was a very successful lawyer. Her dad was also a lawyer. She is educated to the hilt, including a very posh girls school in Kent, and at least two degrees. She owns two homes. But she identifies as working class because her grandfather on one side was a miner. Her granddad was working class. Her dad became middle class, and she is solidly middle class. I nearly choked when she told me she's working class! Give me strength!

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:42

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:34

This. With the added caveat that it’s probably less based on how you identify yourself and more about how others identify you.

Well this is an interesting point… how others identify you.

Do you think many people would identify a doctor as working class?

QuebecBagnet · 18/09/2022 09:40

I admit I’ve never met the bloke but I would not say that Wayne Rooney is middle class at all, certainly not upper middle class. It’s also about your lifestyle, what you enjoy doing in your free time, what you do for a job. Playing football and being a Wag are not middle class occupations.

The Bbc class decider question thingy asks if you do things like watch sports or go to the ballet/opera. Watch soaps or watch documentaries.

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:39

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:30

Class is only solely about economic power if you are considering the narrowest Marxist definition which is not how the British class system has ever worked. The sad thing is this lie is sold to people who think that if they get rich they are suddenly going to move class, they then can end up getting a bit of a shock when it turns out that they don’t quite ‘fit in’ for some imperceptible reason they can’t quite define. People have posted about it in this thread

It’s not the narrowest definition at all. It’s THE definition by dictionary.

Social class is dependent on education, wealth, occupation, income and culture.

The only thing you can ‘identify’ with is culture. The rest is defined by what you do and what you earn.

Class ultimately isn’t about identity, it’s about economic power.

The outlier class is upper class. You can’t earn your way into this class. This is typically hereditary.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 18/09/2022 09:36

I agree totally OP. He has a working class background, but is now very definitely middle class. A working class doctor is an oxymoron. They're mutually exclusive. It's also quite offensive to people working minimum wage jobs or working zero hours.
It's a uniquely British phenomenon, clearly middle class people thinking they're working class. I've encountered it many times, and it never ceases to amaze me. If you have a profession, to my mind, you're middle class. It's nothing to be ashamed of anyway, so I don't know why people are so worried about being seen as middle class?

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:34

Fairislefandango · 18/09/2022 09:31

We’re straying into identity politics here.

It's not straying. Class has always been about identity, not just wealth.

This. With the added caveat that it’s probably less based on how you identify yourself and more about how others identify you.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:33

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:27

No, I’m talking about economic and societal power. Wayne Rooney was born into a working class background but is no longer working class. Your class changes based on the economic and societal power you wield. It is not a static concept based on what you’re born into. This completely defies the concept of social mobility!

Social mobility - that would be a concept that has been generated by government advisers and academics. Inter generationally families can change class but it takes a certain amount of time.

Fairislefandango · 18/09/2022 09:31

We’re straying into identity politics here.

It's not straying. Class has always been about identity, not just wealth.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:30

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:23

You can’t be stinking rich and working class. The very definition of working class is the social group consisting primarily of people who are employed in unskilled or semi-skilled manual or industrial work.

Class is not a feeling. Class is about economic power.

We’re straying into identity politics here. I fear this is Class-Dysphoria territory. Perhaps we should start a new Tavistock to help people comes to realities with their class identities 🙄

Class is only solely about economic power if you are considering the narrowest Marxist definition which is not how the British class system has ever worked. The sad thing is this lie is sold to people who think that if they get rich they are suddenly going to move class, they then can end up getting a bit of a shock when it turns out that they don’t quite ‘fit in’ for some imperceptible reason they can’t quite define. People have posted about it in this thread

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:27

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:25

😂😂😂 Wayne Rooney upper middle. The fact that you seem to have posted that in all seriousness is astonishing. You are talking about wealth not class. It’s evident that on this thread people are not just talking about wealth. The British class system does not have a simple definition despite the best efforts of social scientists over the years, that’s one of its strengths or problems depending on your view. If it were as simple as wealth it wouldn’t be nearly so effective. It’s something you are subject to whether you want to be or not, you can’t opt out and that has been a source of power for some and misery for many over the years.

No, I’m talking about economic and societal power. Wayne Rooney was born into a working class background but is no longer working class. Your class changes based on the economic and societal power you wield. It is not a static concept based on what you’re born into. This completely defies the concept of social mobility!

Fairislefandango · 18/09/2022 09:27

You can be stinking rich and working class? That's the biggest laugh I've had all week, thanks for that!

What's funny about that? Middle class / upper class doesn't mean the same as rich. Class and wealth level are related, but not synonymous. Lots of markers of social class are cultural, whether we like it or not, and however unimportant we might think class is or should be. Someone who's working class and then wins the lottery doesn't automatically become middle class overnight, because they are still the same person, with the same upbringing, attitudes and social characteristics. Equally, if an aristocrat loses all their money, they don't just suddenly become working class.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 09:25

AviatorMama · 18/09/2022 09:17

No, I’m not wrong. That’s the economic definition of class.

And no, Wayne Rooney would be upper-middle. He’s not aristocracy/nobility/political.

😂😂😂 Wayne Rooney upper middle. The fact that you seem to have posted that in all seriousness is astonishing. You are talking about wealth not class. It’s evident that on this thread people are not just talking about wealth. The British class system does not have a simple definition despite the best efforts of social scientists over the years, that’s one of its strengths or problems depending on your view. If it were as simple as wealth it wouldn’t be nearly so effective. It’s something you are subject to whether you want to be or not, you can’t opt out and that has been a source of power for some and misery for many over the years.