Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 17:49

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 17:44

@Eastangular2000 but you can "educate yourself out of your class"...

@Paigeycakey in the gentlest way back at you, I do understand how the class system works due to having a degree in sociology.
I'm not clear what you are basing your definitions on, but you're giving the impression that it's based on stereotypes. That's not really helpful.

In the gentlest possible way @fiftytontheresa you have a very narrow academically constructed understanding of class, dare I say probably because you studied sociology. In fact I would hazard a guess that you may have been the first in your family to attend university and are therefore seemingly quite invested in the idea you can educate yourself out of your class.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 17:47

@fiftytontheresa so explain please what is your defination of class??

To list your qualification or state is irrelevant.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 19/09/2022 17:47

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 17:12

Disagree. You are talking about wealth not class. Is Wayne Rooney MC? Is Colleen?

Would you and I be MC if we won the lotto tomorrow? All the chanel handbags in the world wouldn't change our class overnight 🙄

Nope. I'm not just talking about wealth.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 17:44

@Relocatiorelocation love love love your post. Good for you that you have stayed grounded.

I think some still don't understand your post. Money can't buy class it's as simple as that.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 17:44

@Eastangular2000 but you can "educate yourself out of your class"...

@Paigeycakey in the gentlest way back at you, I do understand how the class system works due to having a degree in sociology.
I'm not clear what you are basing your definitions on, but you're giving the impression that it's based on stereotypes. That's not really helpful.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 17:35

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 17:22

@Paigeycakey absolutely no one is saying it's just about money. Read / listen to some of the articles linked to in this thread.

You are aware that you tagged MY post aren't you? Tbh I don't know what exactly you are asking me.

I know what class is. So I shall not be reading any articles thanks. There's a difference between a Doctor who has parents who were doctors and other family members that are nurses, teachers or a physiotherapist (this is partly how class is formed).

You then can just get an ordinary person that has worked hard and become a Doctor..... but parents and other family members have non degree jobs. I think in the gentlest way YOU don't know what class is.

Tbh I grew up on a council estate I defo know class when I see it! I don't need any article to clarify for me.... like I said I work with surgeons and they are NOT all MC.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 17:29

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 17:22

@Paigeycakey absolutely no one is saying it's just about money. Read / listen to some of the articles linked to in this thread.

Why would @Paigeycakey need to read an article. She has stated quite clearly that she can identify class without needing a specific academic definition, much like most of the population. What the academic definitions have done is seemingly convince some people that you can earn or educate yourself out of your class, they then discover in the real world this isn’t the case. Not saying that that is right but it is reality.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 17:22

@Paigeycakey absolutely no one is saying it's just about money. Read / listen to some of the articles linked to in this thread.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 17:15

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 17:12

@Paigeycakey but no it's really not. Why do you think it is?

I have explained in my other post see below.

Do you want to explain to me why you think all surgeons are MC or doctors? I work with surgeons and I can tell you straight away that it doesn't make you MC just because you have gone to med school.... MC is your family background also.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 17:12

WanderingFruitWonderer · 18/09/2022 09:36

I agree totally OP. He has a working class background, but is now very definitely middle class. A working class doctor is an oxymoron. They're mutually exclusive. It's also quite offensive to people working minimum wage jobs or working zero hours.
It's a uniquely British phenomenon, clearly middle class people thinking they're working class. I've encountered it many times, and it never ceases to amaze me. If you have a profession, to my mind, you're middle class. It's nothing to be ashamed of anyway, so I don't know why people are so worried about being seen as middle class?

Disagree. You are talking about wealth not class. Is Wayne Rooney MC? Is Colleen?

Would you and I be MC if we won the lotto tomorrow? All the chanel handbags in the world wouldn't change our class overnight 🙄

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 17:12

@Paigeycakey but no it's really not. Why do you think it is?

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 17:07

Your friend is quite right he's working class.

Tbh you can see class and when you see it you definitely won't be confused.

You could be a bin man and have class also. It's your background and generation wealth that's linked to class not the money per say....

WanderingFruitWonderer · 19/09/2022 16:54

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 16:50

This is the research that's discussed in the episode of Thinking Allowed earlier in the thread.

I need to show it to DH who has at no point in his life been MC but identifies as such as he works for a living (as an IT consultant) and worked in a factory for three months after he left university HmmGrin

Ah, sorry, I think I missed that bit of the thread. I'll read through it later

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 16:50

WanderingFruitWonderer · 19/09/2022 16:38

This is the research that's discussed in the episode of Thinking Allowed earlier in the thread.

I need to show it to DH who has at no point in his life been MC but identifies as such as he works for a living (as an IT consultant) and worked in a factory for three months after he left university HmmGrin

WanderingFruitWonderer · 19/09/2022 16:29

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 16:21

Sorry @WanderingFruitWonderer we do indeed agree! I meant to tag @Idontcareboutthestateofmyhair in my post

@fiftytontheresa no worries! Easily done

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 16:21

Sorry @WanderingFruitWonderer we do indeed agree! I meant to tag @Idontcareboutthestateofmyhair in my post

WanderingFruitWonderer · 19/09/2022 16:18

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 15:56

And @WanderingFruitWonderer no one here is looking down on the WC. But i don't think it's helpful for anyone when some who is clearly now MC insisting that they aren't. He can absolutely hold WC moral and ideals. But that's not what defines his class status, and is disingenuous to those who are WC and who may have very different life chances experiences and opportunities to him.

Absolutely. That was my point. I agree. I think you possibly misunderstood my post. I was responding to another post that accused the OP of snobbery.
I completely agree with your post. I actually think it's a bit insulting to minimum wage workers etc when middle class professionals insist they're working class

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 15:56

And @WanderingFruitWonderer no one here is looking down on the WC. But i don't think it's helpful for anyone when some who is clearly now MC insisting that they aren't. He can absolutely hold WC moral and ideals. But that's not what defines his class status, and is disingenuous to those who are WC and who may have very different life chances experiences and opportunities to him.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 15:53

Another interesting read (sociology again I'm afraid) that explains how class is defined in modern Britain.

The OPs friend is absolutely MC still!

revisesociology.com/2016/08/04/social-class-definition-introduction/

WanderingFruitWonderer · 19/09/2022 15:41

Idontcareboutthestateofmyhair · 19/09/2022 10:10

What's wrong with identifying as working class? Working class shouldn't be looked down upon. The problem these days is too many people confuse money with class when that's outdated. I grew up working class and have a better lifestyle than most of my 'middle' friends. I'm not saying I have lots of money, i just have a good attitude to life and I'm not scared to use money to enjoy life to the fullest. You are being a snob by suggesting a surgeon can't identify as working class. It's thoughts like this that kept working class people in their 'place' years ago. My working class upbringing in a lovely council house street in the 70s/80s was filled with families like my own; decent, moralistic, educated. My dad worked hard and my mum stayed at home then had part time jobs. We ate out every Saturday night, went to museums and theatres, always went on holiday every year, coastal England or Scotland or later on Spain, Portugal, Italy. My parents were neither rich nor poor but because my dad was a manual worker we were working class. I had an idyllic childhood that could not have been happier. I'm proud of my upbringing and the values I was taught.. you work hard for yourself, no-one owes you a living and that is what working class means to me. It also means don't put anyone in a box that they can't have different experiences in life because of their 'class'.

Absolutely nothing wrong with identifying as working class, if you're working class; and of course it shouldn't be looked down upon. But that's not the issue here. The issue, is clearly middle class people identifying as working class. It's not snobbery at all to point that out. It's just a statement of fact. If someone used to have brown hair, but now has grey hair, pointing out their grey hairedness doesn't mean you're looking down on brunettes! I realise that's a terrible analogy, but you get my meaning.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 15:39

@Eastangular2000 no of course I don't. So surely my point stands about your class not being based on that of your parents? An academic lens helps with understanding the class system, what it is and how it evolved. It also helps with understanding how people view themselves and others, and how class and it's perception affects life chances.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 15:28

jacostajune · 19/09/2022 14:17

@Eastangular2000 sociology most definitely pre-dates the modern social class system. It was a recognised discipline before "working class" was a recognised term.

And your comment doesn't disprove what I said in my previous post.

You should listen to the Thinking Allowed linked to in a earlier post.

Shock horror! The class system existed before the ‘working class’ did. Modern academic definitions and understanding of class are a world away from how people judge and interact with each other on a daily basis. Do you think when someone makes a judgement that someone is ‘posh’ or ‘common’ they are all doing it through an academic lens?

deedledeedledum · 19/09/2022 15:17

If his beliefs, choices and lifestyle is now middle class which I suspect it is, he is middle class. If he was a builder who had made shit tons of money but was still a bit oi oi and lived a working class lifestyle but with money then he could call himself working class.

jacostajune · 19/09/2022 14:17

@Eastangular2000 sociology most definitely pre-dates the modern social class system. It was a recognised discipline before "working class" was a recognised term.

And your comment doesn't disprove what I said in my previous post.

You should listen to the Thinking Allowed linked to in a earlier post.