Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
AviatorMama · 19/09/2022 22:15

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 21:19

I suggest you reread the thread because it seems you have mischaracterised quite a lot of what people are saying. maybe reflect on the fact that if ‘so many’ people are disagreeing with you perhaps the position is more nuanced and less black and white than you think it is.

Laughable. You’re the one that’s painting it as black and white. “You’re born into a class, and you die in that class. You can never change class.” That’s as black and white as it gets.

@fiftytontheresa is the person who is adding nuance to the situation. Explaining social mobility (which can be intragenerational!). Oh, and she’s qualified in the subject… shock horror. Just fyi @Eastangular2000 Sociologists don’t just sit around making theories up, they do so based on research! 🙄I’d listen if I were you, you might learn a thing or two!

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 21:19

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 21:10

@Eastangular2000 maybe. But your assertion that your class is based on your parents class, no matter what, and that people will know what social class to put you in is based on...nothing.
I don't know why so many people on here are adamant that a person remains the same class as the household they were brought up in. No one has been able to give an explanation as to why that must be so.
It has been a fascinating read though.

I suggest you reread the thread because it seems you have mischaracterised quite a lot of what people are saying. maybe reflect on the fact that if ‘so many’ people are disagreeing with you perhaps the position is more nuanced and less black and white than you think it is.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 21:10

@Eastangular2000 maybe. But your assertion that your class is based on your parents class, no matter what, and that people will know what social class to put you in is based on...nothing.
I don't know why so many people on here are adamant that a person remains the same class as the household they were brought up in. No one has been able to give an explanation as to why that must be so.
It has been a fascinating read though.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 20:40

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 20:30

@Eastangular2000 I also know that too. Maybe you should let the ONS know?

What are you rambling about? Literally no one has contested that there are a variety of narrow definitions of economic class that are used to collect quantitative data. But this thread was started based on an interpersonal interaction not a Doctoral thesis or a government survey.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 20:30

@Eastangular2000 I also know that too. Maybe you should let the ONS know?

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 20:15

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 20:11

@Eastangular2000 of course I know people are judged by their accent and background. But that doesn't change their social class however many times you say it does.

Life is not a sociology project no matter how much you might want it to be. What happens in real life is far more nuanced than your sociological categories can cater for.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 20:11

@Eastangular2000 of course I know people are judged by their accent and background. But that doesn't change their social class however many times you say it does.

palygold · 19/09/2022 20:04

This thread really sheds light on the fact that even in 2022 people are still judged by their accent or background.

Definitely

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 19:59

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 19:56

@Paigeycakey there are no contradictions in my posts though.

The lawyers in your family - are MC, doesn't matter what you are.

The doctors you work with are MC, whatever accent they have.

This thread really sheds light on the fact that even in 2022 people are still judged by their accent or background.

Keir Starmer would be pleased though. He always gets slammed for being out of touch with the working classes. But on here, he'd still be working class as his parents very much were. Despite being a lawyer and the Director of Public Prosecutions.

There you go.

I am astonished that you have got to adulthood without realising people are judged on their background and accent (alongside many other things). Did you really think that wasn’t the case? That I do find surprising.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 19:58

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 19:56

@Paigeycakey there are no contradictions in my posts though.

The lawyers in your family - are MC, doesn't matter what you are.

The doctors you work with are MC, whatever accent they have.

This thread really sheds light on the fact that even in 2022 people are still judged by their accent or background.

Keir Starmer would be pleased though. He always gets slammed for being out of touch with the working classes. But on here, he'd still be working class as his parents very much were. Despite being a lawyer and the Director of Public Prosecutions.

There you go.

No I know my own family members I don't need you telling me or about my collegues. I thought you would be back to have the last word Miss know it all.....

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 19:56

@Paigeycakey there are no contradictions in my posts though.

The lawyers in your family - are MC, doesn't matter what you are.

The doctors you work with are MC, whatever accent they have.

This thread really sheds light on the fact that even in 2022 people are still judged by their accent or background.

Keir Starmer would be pleased though. He always gets slammed for being out of touch with the working classes. But on here, he'd still be working class as his parents very much were. Despite being a lawyer and the Director of Public Prosecutions.

There you go.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 19:43

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 19:31

@Paigeycakey
MC people do not all have RP accents. Do you think that there are no lawyers / doctors etc who come from Birmingham / Basildon / Bolton??
The person in the OP was MC as soon as he qualified to be a doctor, not once he made consultant.
And you really don't have to have rich grandparents to be MC. If that were true then there'd be no social mobility at all.

You like some others are basing your definitions of class on stereotypes. Which is quite sad really. But, I'm certainly not going to change your mind so crack on.

You've proved your own point. How silly... no I have lawyers in my own family and we are WC!!! My point exactly.

Your posts are full of contradictions. Let's agree to disagree.

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 19:40

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 19:31

@Paigeycakey
MC people do not all have RP accents. Do you think that there are no lawyers / doctors etc who come from Birmingham / Basildon / Bolton??
The person in the OP was MC as soon as he qualified to be a doctor, not once he made consultant.
And you really don't have to have rich grandparents to be MC. If that were true then there'd be no social mobility at all.

You like some others are basing your definitions of class on stereotypes. Which is quite sad really. But, I'm certainly not going to change your mind so crack on.

No not all but some MC people certainly do.

I'm basing my opinion on the people who I have met and my OWN job. Read my posts why are you telling me what I mean when I have stated and I work along side medical people from various levels. Your the one replying and getting uppity that I don't agree with you.

ComtesseDeSpair · 19/09/2022 19:36

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 19:33

Why on earth would I?

Because otherwise how do you know that the person you’ve assessed as middle class is actually middle class?

FredrikaPeri · 19/09/2022 19:35

Not just about money though is it.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 19:33

ComtesseDeSpair · 19/09/2022 19:29

How many people, whose class you seemingly confidently establish to yourself through “tells”, do you then actually ask for further information about to find out if you were correct?

Why on earth would I?

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 19:31

@Paigeycakey
MC people do not all have RP accents. Do you think that there are no lawyers / doctors etc who come from Birmingham / Basildon / Bolton??
The person in the OP was MC as soon as he qualified to be a doctor, not once he made consultant.
And you really don't have to have rich grandparents to be MC. If that were true then there'd be no social mobility at all.

You like some others are basing your definitions of class on stereotypes. Which is quite sad really. But, I'm certainly not going to change your mind so crack on.

palygold · 19/09/2022 19:31

Just to add ( for a couple of pps) that 'middle class is not one homogeneous mass there are many subsections - your lower middles, upper lower middles, lower upper middles and so on.

You might think you've moved up into the middle classes because you went to university, or now have a better job, shop at Waitrose, etc, but if your accent and background is deemed 'wrong' by some it doesn't matter what you call yourself.

Some people were saying, on the other class threads, that it takes a couple of generations to be able to call yourself middles, so more like your grandchildren than your children.

ComtesseDeSpair · 19/09/2022 19:29

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 19:24

The point is that there is a lot you can’t change, often because you don’t know the difference. It’s the being in the ‘don’t know what you don’t know’ category. There are so many subtle markers and differences that most of the time people don’t even know what they are revealing about themselves. Of course anyone can pretend to be anything but I am assuming we aren’t talking about deliberate fraud.

How many people, whose class you seemingly confidently establish to yourself through “tells”, do you then actually ask for further information about to find out if you were correct?

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 19:24

ComtesseDeSpair · 19/09/2022 19:19

Surely then it relies on somebody a) telling the truth when asked about their background and b) being asked in the first place.

Whilst I know the man he is now relatively well I’ve no idea, for example, what sort of background my neighbour comes from, or what his parents did for a living because I’ve never asked. Likewise, he’s never asked me. If he told me his parents were primary school teachers, I’d believe him. If he told me they were factory workers, I’d believe him. If he told me one was an actuary and the other a nuclear scientist, I’d believe him.

If your entire opinion of somebody’s class can change depending on what they choose to tell you rather than how they actually appear, it’s entirely pointless.

The point is that there is a lot you can’t change, often because you don’t know the difference. It’s the being in the ‘don’t know what you don’t know’ category. There are so many subtle markers and differences that most of the time people don’t even know what they are revealing about themselves. Of course anyone can pretend to be anything but I am assuming we aren’t talking about deliberate fraud.

AviatorMama · 19/09/2022 19:23

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 19:19

Laugh all you like, but those comments were made because whether you like it or not people make judgements. Those same people would be the ones judging your Mother. I am not saying it is right I am saying it is reality. It is one of the contributing factors to inequality in this country, to pretend it doesn’t exist is foolish.

A couple of ridiculous comments to not a class make.

Carole Middleton is the grandmother to the future king. She is at very least MC and may be the exception to the upper class rule when her grandson takes the thrown.

The few people who may perceive CM as WC, are quite frankly idiots!

Paigeycakey · 19/09/2022 19:22

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 19:10

@Paigeycakey
Your social class is still based around your profession. That's because of the opportunities that come with the kind of profession / job that you do.
Someone who picks orders in the Amazon warehouse has very different social economic and cultural opportunities to a doctor.
It's not just about money.
And it's not saying WC bad / MC good.
And it's not based on your parents class (though obviously there is no doubt that coming from a privileged background is huge capital in itself).

Not sure if I can explain it any better than that. And I think we are still taking about two very different ideas of class. But Togo back to the person in the OP, a consultant who earns consultants wages and who has the lifestyle that goes with the job and salary is not working class anymore.

Nah I have to stop you right there. Class stems back from your parents and grandparents. Houses are passed down, inheritance, upbringing and what circles you mix in it's all elements of class. Don't you read the threads where people are saying Grandparents are coughing up school fees for their GRANDKIDS! (MC people)

These aren't the only things buy it's definitely to do with background. A consultant is the highest doctor. There's stages after that 5 years of med school and then they will work as an F1, SHO and so on..... how can you just jump straight to consultant? I agree its a good wage but its neither here or there it still doesn't change the fact that it doesn't give you a free pass to being MC.

What MC people have is encouragement and support also that instill education onto their kids because its what they was taught also...hence doctors coming from doctors families.

Most MC people are well spoken also! I've met many Jack the lads doctors and these were fab don't get me wrong! But definitely not MC there's a lot of assumptions here.

ReadyForPumpkins · 19/09/2022 19:22

He is working class because of his upbringing.

ComtesseDeSpair · 19/09/2022 19:19

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 19:13

Absolutely. Lots of money and living a very MC lifestyle but remains WC. Hence all the ‘doors to manual’ jokes. Like I said class is significantly defined by how others view you rather than how you view yourself.

Surely then it relies on somebody a) telling the truth when asked about their background and b) being asked in the first place.

Whilst I know the man he is now relatively well I’ve no idea, for example, what sort of background my neighbour comes from, or what his parents did for a living because I’ve never asked. Likewise, he’s never asked me. If he told me his parents were primary school teachers, I’d believe him. If he told me they were factory workers, I’d believe him. If he told me one was an actuary and the other a nuclear scientist, I’d believe him.

If your entire opinion of somebody’s class can change depending on what they choose to tell you rather than how they actually appear, it’s entirely pointless.

nocoolnamesleft · 19/09/2022 19:19

He's either middle class or professional class. Education is one of the things that can change your class. My parents were both born working class. Thanks to their degrees and professions, they became middle class.