Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
WanderingFruitWonderer · 20/09/2022 19:49

Paigeycakey · 20/09/2022 06:11

Class is all over the world I discussed this with my friend from Zimbabwe it's all over the world. You may not like it but it's not going to change

There's something unique about the class conversation in Britain though. In most parts of the world it's completely accepted that it's about occupation etc. In America and elsewhere it's mostly based on income. It's only here that we'd be having this conversation. As mentioned up thread, it's also the only place you'd find very obviously middle class people insisting they're working class. I've literally never encountered that anywhere else.

HappyBinosaur · 20/09/2022 17:48

@Eastangular2000 and @AviatorMama your argument is interesting to read. I have such a stereotypically MC life but don’t see myself as MC at all!

My dc go to private school but I don’t feel judged by other parents because I’m not pretending to be anything that I’m not. I don’t fit neatly into their middle class world but I don’t particularly want to. It doesn’t mean I haven’t made friends and people are very friendly, but I have a regional accent and have very WC parents so I feel I am still WC, despite having 3 degrees and living in a nice place! I did go to grammar school but I think more WC class people did in the 80s/90s when we didn’t have tutoring. My parents ended up well off but that’s because they saved hard whilst working in very WC jobs.

My job has some degree of ‘social status’ where I live but I still don’t think anyone thinks I’m pretending to be MC.
My children fit in here much more than me and we have a good income, nice house etc so we don’t stand out as different on the surface. Maybe they’ll be classed as MC when they are older (but hopefully they also won’t be that bothered!)

Eastangular2000 · 20/09/2022 15:25

ComtesseDeSpair · 20/09/2022 14:29

If the privately educated child of a doctor and a professor decided - quite rationally, all considering - that university and all its debt was a mug’s game and that most doctors and professors are ultimately incredibly stressed and overworked, and that they’d rather learn a trade or vocation instead; I doubt the resultant hairdresser or plumber would be considered middle class. This thread demonstrates that people who still care about class would automatically ‘read’ “plumber” or “hairdresser” and assign class accordingly.

The people who seem to think your job defines your class would define them as working class, I personally wouldn’t.

palygold · 20/09/2022 14:38

MC is not just your job. There's many people that have been privately educated but they are not doctors.... and doing ordinary jobs. Does that take away their MC status? No it doesn't! You could be MC and work in Tesco! Perhaps they were privately schooled but just didn't make it high flying..... it happens IRL.

This is true! That's why, as I said way back in the thread, you can have an upper class, unemployed person living in council accommodation. Class is not just linked to occupation, or wealth.

ComtesseDeSpair · 20/09/2022 14:29

Paigeycakey · 20/09/2022 14:20

MC is not just your job. There's many people that have been privately educated but they are not doctors.... and doing ordinary jobs. Does that take away their MC status? No it doesn't! You could be MC and work in Tesco! Perhaps they were privately schooled but just didn't make it high flying..... it happens IRL.

If the privately educated child of a doctor and a professor decided - quite rationally, all considering - that university and all its debt was a mug’s game and that most doctors and professors are ultimately incredibly stressed and overworked, and that they’d rather learn a trade or vocation instead; I doubt the resultant hairdresser or plumber would be considered middle class. This thread demonstrates that people who still care about class would automatically ‘read’ “plumber” or “hairdresser” and assign class accordingly.

SleeplessInEngland · 20/09/2022 14:23

You can argue about correct definition all day, but I think we can all agree that anyone who regards their class status as a badge of honour is a dickhead.

Paigeycakey · 20/09/2022 14:20

Databe · 20/09/2022 08:43

In the anthropology book, 'Watching the English', class was described, l believe by what your taste is, not finances. As in, an upper middle class person has wooden floors and fabric sofas for eg. It was funny that the lowest working class and the most upper class tier were compared, as they both loved gambling and may be more idle, if l recall correctly. 7 classes were listed, l think. Now panick unfolds in the middle class, which level am l? The middles most concerned with socia mobility.
No a surgeon is not working class. His roots yes, but not since Uni and top job, in my opinion. Social mobility is possible for the few, and meritocracy is a lie.

MC is not just your job. There's many people that have been privately educated but they are not doctors.... and doing ordinary jobs. Does that take away their MC status? No it doesn't! You could be MC and work in Tesco! Perhaps they were privately schooled but just didn't make it high flying..... it happens IRL.

palygold · 20/09/2022 10:21

What, or which, sociological theories are people arguing about? Do we have a link?

People usually bring up the social grade tables, featuring the C2s and so on, on the class threads. That's only occupation based, obviously.

Palmfrond · 20/09/2022 09:48

Databe · 20/09/2022 08:43

In the anthropology book, 'Watching the English', class was described, l believe by what your taste is, not finances. As in, an upper middle class person has wooden floors and fabric sofas for eg. It was funny that the lowest working class and the most upper class tier were compared, as they both loved gambling and may be more idle, if l recall correctly. 7 classes were listed, l think. Now panick unfolds in the middle class, which level am l? The middles most concerned with socia mobility.
No a surgeon is not working class. His roots yes, but not since Uni and top job, in my opinion. Social mobility is possible for the few, and meritocracy is a lie.

Gosh, I really disliked that book. If it could be described as “anthropology”, that description should definitely be prefixed with “pop”. The working class were loud mouth yobs, Al Murray Pub Landlord types, all the poshos were Edward Fox. It’s ages since I read it but I remember it being really two dimensional.

Databe · 20/09/2022 08:43

In the anthropology book, 'Watching the English', class was described, l believe by what your taste is, not finances. As in, an upper middle class person has wooden floors and fabric sofas for eg. It was funny that the lowest working class and the most upper class tier were compared, as they both loved gambling and may be more idle, if l recall correctly. 7 classes were listed, l think. Now panick unfolds in the middle class, which level am l? The middles most concerned with socia mobility.
No a surgeon is not working class. His roots yes, but not since Uni and top job, in my opinion. Social mobility is possible for the few, and meritocracy is a lie.

Paigeycakey · 20/09/2022 06:11

Class is all over the world I discussed this with my friend from Zimbabwe it's all over the world. You may not like it but it's not going to change

WanderingFruitWonderer · 20/09/2022 04:42

The reason I feel it's important to understand the correct sociological definition of class, is that it reduces 'othering'. I wish we didn't have a class system (people are people) but we do sadly; so bearing that in mind, it's about damage limitation for me. The incorrect idea that you're born into a class and there you, and your family, remain is incredibly tribal. The idea that being WC or MC is to be part of a strict inpenetrable club is hugely 'othering' of anyone outside of said club. Reducing class down to occupation and education etc, in a way makes less fuss of perceived difference, and helps society address the important issue of income and opportunity inequality and all its corresponding challenges. It's absolutely possible to have both working class and middle class members of the same family.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 23:47

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 23:29

I really wasn't going to come back to this thread but @Eastangular2000 you are just pushing on with those stereotypes aren't you? Are you genuinely sneering at sociology as an academic discipline, and also claiming that the study of social stratification and class doesn't fit into it anyway? I certainly don't claim to be an expert in the area, but all you are bringing to this discussion is anecdotes and personal beliefs based on what exactly? "I don't believe it so it can't be true"

No I am not sneering at sociology as an academic discipline I was disagreeing with @AviatorMama who seemed to be holding you up as an infallible authority on the subject on the basis that you have studied sociology at some point! I am aware that this is not a claim you have made. It’s not I don’t believe it so it can’t be true it’s more ‘I don’t believe that people make judgements about class
on a day to day basis, using the very narrow parameters used in a formal academic paper’ I am sure you can see the difference. Of course maybe I am in the minority and everyone else has a clear set of academically rigorous parameters that they apply to all interactions, but somehow I doubt it.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/09/2022 23:44

Just be yourself.
It's tiring labelling everything especially when it discriminates against a great group of people.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/09/2022 23:42

Of course you can live a middle class lifestyle with a working class upbringing it is the disassociation that is annoying and insulting to wc people.

Through years of conscious sneering the mc have had a superior complex towards the mc.

It's unfortunate when loved one's and old friends put themselves into a world unknown to their loved ones through denying their heritage like it is a dirty smell or sneering at their taste in items.

It's perfectly okay to be successful happy without the labels and insistence you're in a different league than the people who you were part of.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 23:34

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/09/2022 23:17

This thread really sheds light on the fact that even in 2022 people are still judged by their accent or background.
Only by a certain group.
The hybrid MC.

There are plenty of posters on this thread who say they are working class and who are adamant that if your parents are WC then you are too. There's a poster further down the thread who's WC, as defined by themselves, who seems to think that if you don't have a posh accent then you must be WC. Even if you're a doctor or a lawyer. So no it's not the "hybrid MC" that are making those assumptions. Not on this thread anyway.

fiftytontheresa · 19/09/2022 23:29

I really wasn't going to come back to this thread but @Eastangular2000 you are just pushing on with those stereotypes aren't you? Are you genuinely sneering at sociology as an academic discipline, and also claiming that the study of social stratification and class doesn't fit into it anyway? I certainly don't claim to be an expert in the area, but all you are bringing to this discussion is anecdotes and personal beliefs based on what exactly? "I don't believe it so it can't be true"

mynamesnotMa · 19/09/2022 23:20

Good for him. I agree with him. I can't stand the faux snobbery about class it's bollix a man made construct

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/09/2022 23:17

This thread really sheds light on the fact that even in 2022 people are still judged by their accent or background.
Only by a certain group.
The hybrid MC.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/09/2022 23:11

@AviatorMama Maybe you should consider what has set your teeth on edge.

Pp is not wrong.

Most of my friends growing up have good jobs in nice areas, they're not middle class.

The few that think they've class climbed make me cringe the way they speak about working class people and certain areas without ever seeing a positive.

I have a friend who lives social housing, she works 30 hours weekly on minimum wage, she volunteers for the charity alone x 3 nights, saves abandoned animals, would never look down on anyone who hasn't had a decent education or start in life.

She has more class in her baby finger.

Does she feel absolutely shit after our yearly night out, yes every year.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 22:54

And it’s not spite, it’s pity.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 22:51

AviatorMama · 19/09/2022 22:44

Thank you for you psychoanalysis 🤣 hubby and I just had a good laugh. Oh you poor spiteful soul.

Not sure you understand what psychoanalysis is. I can only presume that I touched a nerve as you felt the need to share with your husband. Like I said, I hope you can be happy with who you are.

AviatorMama · 19/09/2022 22:44

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 22:37

Qualified in the subject 😂😂😂. Oh yes an ‘ology’ no less. I am not remotely interested in academic framing of the British class system, if anything it’s more of an anthropological phenomenon. I don’t need your approval for my views, nor am I interested in it. Interestingly though you seem determined to try and make me agree with you. I actually feel a bit sorry for you because believe me, if you do send your little one to public school, you will undoubtedly come across those who will judge you and you can produce every payslip and university transcript you want and it will make not a jot of difference. You won’t know you are being judged or it seems by what standards. I have friends in this position and it is awful to see. Nobody judges those who are true to who they are, as I said before be proud of who you are because despite your protestations you really don’t seem to be.

Thank you for you psychoanalysis 🤣 hubby and I just had a good laugh. Oh you poor spiteful soul.

Grrrrdarling · 19/09/2022 22:40

Relocatiorelocation · 16/09/2022 15:11

DH and I grew up on council estates. We both went to uni, own a fuck off house, have a huge joint income and our kids have what they want within reason.
We are definitely still working class. The way we vote / our values and beliefs / the way we speak. Just because we're educated and have a few quid, you'd never catch me wearing Hunter wellies walking a labrador. I'm more likely to be smoking a fag outside Weatherspoons on a Saturday night.

OMG I love you, your comment, & wish you were my friend. You sound like you are so down to earth despite how well you’ve done for yourselves.
Money doesn’t make people classy their attitude & behaviours do.
I always just assumed that anyone who works is working class & anyone who is affluent enough to not have to work is upper class.

Eastangular2000 · 19/09/2022 22:37

AviatorMama · 19/09/2022 22:15

Laughable. You’re the one that’s painting it as black and white. “You’re born into a class, and you die in that class. You can never change class.” That’s as black and white as it gets.

@fiftytontheresa is the person who is adding nuance to the situation. Explaining social mobility (which can be intragenerational!). Oh, and she’s qualified in the subject… shock horror. Just fyi @Eastangular2000 Sociologists don’t just sit around making theories up, they do so based on research! 🙄I’d listen if I were you, you might learn a thing or two!

Qualified in the subject 😂😂😂. Oh yes an ‘ology’ no less. I am not remotely interested in academic framing of the British class system, if anything it’s more of an anthropological phenomenon. I don’t need your approval for my views, nor am I interested in it. Interestingly though you seem determined to try and make me agree with you. I actually feel a bit sorry for you because believe me, if you do send your little one to public school, you will undoubtedly come across those who will judge you and you can produce every payslip and university transcript you want and it will make not a jot of difference. You won’t know you are being judged or it seems by what standards. I have friends in this position and it is awful to see. Nobody judges those who are true to who they are, as I said before be proud of who you are because despite your protestations you really don’t seem to be.