Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
CinnamonOrangeCremeBrulee · 16/09/2022 17:57

Too some people 'working class' represents their cultural background to others it is a social category. Sounds like the two of you don't agree what exactly you are talking about and he was being a bit twatty, bit rude of you too though.

fyn · 16/09/2022 17:57

He is right though, lots of working class people will be absolutely fine. Electricians, plumbers, bricklayers. A family member is a property developer, he said they make more money in a recession that they do when everything is running smoothly.

Palmtreesandsand · 16/09/2022 17:54

Talk of class is so utterly meaningless and tedious. What really matters at the end of the day is what you earn.
If you area low earner, you'll struggle. Middle income, will tighten their belts, really wealthy will do just fine or down size / sell off an asset.

What made up British class construct you are supposed to belong to will have no bearing on how you will survive the environmental disasters, a war, cost of living crisis or a health scare or whatever life throws at you. Only money will help you survive more comfortably.

So those saying imperiously that class not wealth is an indicator. Why does knowing your 'etiquette' trump having the money to actually improve your life?

GiBlues · 16/09/2022 17:52

Relocatiorelocation · 16/09/2022 15:11

DH and I grew up on council estates. We both went to uni, own a fuck off house, have a huge joint income and our kids have what they want within reason.
We are definitely still working class. The way we vote / our values and beliefs / the way we speak. Just because we're educated and have a few quid, you'd never catch me wearing Hunter wellies walking a labrador. I'm more likely to be smoking a fag outside Weatherspoons on a Saturday night.

Can I be your friend @Relocatiorelocation? you sound mint

5128gap · 16/09/2022 17:51

MissFranKubelik · 16/09/2022 17:39

I don't have an issue either from a personal perspective and I was brought up in a lower socio-economic environment and now am middle class.

The point I was badly trying to make (and is made very well in the radio show I linked to) is that people who are middle class who believe themselves to be working class have little empathy for the difficulties and struggles facing the real working class, and thus this has an adverse impact.

I disagree. If you grow up in hardship you never forget. Just because I don't have to choose between food and utilities now, doesn't mean I don't know exactly what that feels like. It actually makes me hyper aware of my fortunate circumstances and how different they are from families like the one I was raised in.
The only time I find this to be the case is with those insufferable 'ex WC' people who point to their own rags to riches story as an example to 'prove' that anything is possible if you work hard enough and people who are still poor didn't try hard enough.

Cyw2018 · 16/09/2022 17:47

wonderstuff · 16/09/2022 17:39

My dad always maintained that anyone who had to work for a living was working class. He saw only two classes, working and landed gentry. I think there are so many shades of grey between working class and middle class it's often difficult to see where the line between the two is. I went to a comp, neither parents or grandparents went to university, but they did go to grammar school and they did earn a comfortable amount of money - my upbringing was less privileged than some, more than others, I find it impossible to know if I'm MC or WC.

I'm a paramedic, the last healthcare profession to go down the degree route, but now that it has they are rapidly pushing people into Masters level. So there are many of us who started on the old in house training system, but then topped up with uni, so have degrees or diplomas, and now have, or are studying for, our Masters, to put us working at the level of a mid grade doctor as Advanced Practitioners. Where the hell does that place us in the class brackets?

Add to that I already had a unrelated degree before joining the ambulance service (like many of my colleagues) and my Dad was university educated in the 60s/70s and briefly an RAF officer, but I went to the local Comp. So am I MC or WC or what?!

Silene · 16/09/2022 17:44

This reminded me of an embarrassing episode at school, a private all-girls one, got a bursary, and it was no better than any other. I was ten, and the class was asked to statecwhich class we belonged to...I had no concept of class whatsoever and thought working class meant you worked. My mother was a teacher, father in the Merchant Navy, all grandparents farmers. I shot up my hand and said Working Class. Certainly not, shock horror, you are middle class! Was no wiser, but learned not to put up my hand! Such nonsense!

Honestly34 · 16/09/2022 17:43

Please be my friend 😂😂😂

jacostajune · 16/09/2022 17:40

Your class certainly used to be officially defined by the job you do. White collar - middle class, blue collar - working class. I imagine it's more fluid these days. But I do not agree at all that this man is working class. He's got a WC background and may share working class morals and ideals, but he is most definitely middle class now.

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 16/09/2022 17:39

mackthepony · 16/09/2022 17:20

Someone on the other thread said Mike Tindall wasn't working class. He is completely WC

Of course he isn’t, irrelevant of his parents class, social mobility, upward mobility and inter generational mobility is a fact, pretending no such thing exists and we all stay the same class as our mums and dads is an Ill informed comment, just take sone time to read up on it and educate yourself

MissFranKubelik · 16/09/2022 17:39

Beezknees · 16/09/2022 17:34

I'm working class and I have no issue with people who were brought up working class calling themselves that. I don't think you can change what class you are.

I don't have an issue either from a personal perspective and I was brought up in a lower socio-economic environment and now am middle class.

The point I was badly trying to make (and is made very well in the radio show I linked to) is that people who are middle class who believe themselves to be working class have little empathy for the difficulties and struggles facing the real working class, and thus this has an adverse impact.

wonderstuff · 16/09/2022 17:39

My dad always maintained that anyone who had to work for a living was working class. He saw only two classes, working and landed gentry. I think there are so many shades of grey between working class and middle class it's often difficult to see where the line between the two is. I went to a comp, neither parents or grandparents went to university, but they did go to grammar school and they did earn a comfortable amount of money - my upbringing was less privileged than some, more than others, I find it impossible to know if I'm MC or WC.

jacostajune · 16/09/2022 17:37

mackthepony · 16/09/2022 17:20

Someone on the other thread said Mike Tindall wasn't working class. He is completely WC

Why do you think that? He's the privately educated son of a banker and a social worker. Is it because he's northern?

Cyw2018 · 16/09/2022 17:37

He had a working class childhood, but that's where it ends. He is presumably now at a point in his life where the majority of his life has been lived MC (including his time at Med skill which is fair from WC), when he's 80 and has lived 75% of his life working in medicine/ retired on a surgeons pension will he still be claiming to be WC then?

I think he can celebrate his WC roots but he is firmly MC now.

One of my friends is a direct descendent of Russian aristocrasy, his Grandad was a baby when he was smuggled out hidden in furniture on a horse and cart. He grew up as a WC londoner, his kids and grankids (my friend) were the same, I'm pretty sure none of them ever see themselves moving in royal circles with their distant cousins or would ever consider themselves aristocracy now.

jennakong · 16/09/2022 17:35

Just out of interest, if a very highly qualified and once well-off and professional person fell on hard times, perhaps through addiction or very sad circumstances, and ended up living on benefits in social housing, what would their class be? Precariat? 'Precariat with letters after name'? I think that 'moving down' may be more complex and difficult than 'moving up' - people can't unacquire education and interests that they may have developed when younger, and in a more stimulating or creative environment. They're hardly going to start knocking round the bookies or going to bingo.

MarryMeTomHardy · 16/09/2022 17:35

Relocatiorelocation · 16/09/2022 15:11

DH and I grew up on council estates. We both went to uni, own a fuck off house, have a huge joint income and our kids have what they want within reason.
We are definitely still working class. The way we vote / our values and beliefs / the way we speak. Just because we're educated and have a few quid, you'd never catch me wearing Hunter wellies walking a labrador. I'm more likely to be smoking a fag outside Weatherspoons on a Saturday night.

Best comment ever!
IRL I think we would be friends !

Beezknees · 16/09/2022 17:34

MissFranKubelik · 16/09/2022 17:33

It does actually matter. People who are now middle class who tell themselves they're working class have a degree of privilege bias. If they think of themselves wrongly as working class - they will not have appreciation for the struggles that face real working class people (as the OP's dude did). There is a really interesting BBC Thinking Allowed episode on this if you're interested.

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m000zdv1

I'm working class and I have no issue with people who were brought up working class calling themselves that. I don't think you can change what class you are.

MissFranKubelik · 16/09/2022 17:33

It does actually matter. People who are now middle class who tell themselves they're working class have a degree of privilege bias. If they think of themselves wrongly as working class - they will not have appreciation for the struggles that face real working class people (as the OP's dude did). There is a really interesting BBC Thinking Allowed episode on this if you're interested.

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m000zdv1

bootseason · 16/09/2022 17:32

Your attitudes and values are set by your upbringing, those are hardwired although you can unpick it with thought. Your earnings are a completely different thing.

5128gap · 16/09/2022 17:30

Ohdearthatwasntgreatwasit · 16/09/2022 17:07

This. People remain the class they were born into for life.

Well done to him for bridging the class divide for his children though, who are, and will always be middle class now. It’s a difficult thing to do, and those who manage it are to be applauded.

What an odd thing to applaud a surgeon for.
I'd be surprised if he looks back on his life's achievements and considers obtaining your permission for his children to consider themselves MC to be amongst the most notable.

BadNomad · 16/09/2022 17:27

Choconut · 16/09/2022 17:04

I don't understand why some people seem to see being 'working class' as some sort of badge of honour.

I think it's very difficult to say who is what really now anyway, I mean neither of my parents went to university but I shop at Waitrose, so make of that what you will.

Because doing well in life is harder the more disadvantaged you are. For example, the further down the social class pecking order you are, the less access you have to opportunities that are an advantage. So when someone from the "bottom" does particularly well, they rightly feel proud of themselves.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/09/2022 17:26

unicormb · 16/09/2022 17:23

His dad was a banker and his mum was a social worker

I don't know why, but I read this post in the tone of the taunting Frenchman: 'Your mother was a hamster and your father smells of elderberries!'

Think I've been spending too much time on this site and some of the whackadoo is starting to affect me 😜

derxa · 16/09/2022 17:25

unicormb · 16/09/2022 17:23

His dad was a banker and his mum was a social worker

And he went to public school. Working class my arse

Halloumiforever · 16/09/2022 17:24

I agree with OP. I've always thought it's what you are now, not what your upbringing was. I would say I'm from a working class background (dad and grandad both miners, grew up on a council estate) but now I would say I'm middle class. I have a professional job and have a typical middle class lifestyle (even though we aren't high earners, just above average). I think my grandparents would scoff at me if I tried to say I was working class! I haven't forgotten my working class roots but i would certainly feel like a fraud if I tried to claim i was still working class now.

Puffalicious · 16/09/2022 17:24

Nap1983 · 16/09/2022 15:10

I disagree, I think class and wealth are entirely different things..

This.

It's a mindset thing.