Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 17/09/2022 19:21

I feel that in a situation like this — someone grew up working class and is now a wealthy professional — it would be crass to insist that they're middle class if they think of themselves as working class because of their background and who they are, but equally crass to insist that they will always be working class if they think of themselves as having become middle class.

Like the hypothetical Iranian-born man becoming a British citizen as an adult that I talked about earlier — if he thinks of himself as at heart Iranian, it would be rude to tell him no, you're not Iranian, you're British, and if he thinks of himself as at heart British it would be rude to tell him that he's not British, he's Iranian. As I said before, not an exact analogy, I know, but there are parallels in terms of culture and belonging and feeling that something is who you really are, which might be different from what outside indicators would suggest.

DisneyMillie · 17/09/2022 19:13

I just spoke to my DH about it - he says the difference for him between me being born MC and him not is things like it means he permanently feels a bit of a fraud at our kids (private) school parties etc!

miltonj · 17/09/2022 19:11

Nah, I'll always be working class no matter how my circumstances change. It's in your bones.

DisneyMillie · 17/09/2022 19:06

I think changing your mindset on what class you are can be quite a struggle so although he’s a bit tactless to voice it I kind of understand. My dad is definitely middle class - from the job he had, lifestyle he lives, friends he has etc but he’s also from a fairly poor working class background and he still sees himself as a working class boy that happened to do well in work.

I can see it in my DH too - I’d say I’m solidly MC, he came from a WC background but we live a MC life - I can see he struggles to relate to the lifestyle our children have sometimes compared to his childhood and often says how lucky he feels with everything whereas I just see it as “normal”.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 17/09/2022 19:00

I think of it more as being about belonging and community user29. If you grew up in one social class, for want of a better word to describe these social categories, will you ever feel truly accepted and like you belong with another social class, and if you do, will that make spending time with your family of origin and maybe your old friends more awkward?

user29 · 17/09/2022 18:57

...maybe education too.

user29 · 17/09/2022 18:55

I think class is a lot more complex than occupation or income level. It's more about values .

LaDamaDeElche · 17/09/2022 18:42

I think working class to some people means lower income families, where people are doing jobs like cleaning, bin man, post man etc. I would probably call him middle class with working class parents.

Thisgroupneverceasestoamazeme · 17/09/2022 18:38

He can consider himself ‘working class’ lots of people who’ve done well for themselves do…but sounds like he’s an idiot who wants to be awkward…I’m sure, as such an educated fellow he can interpret what you meant and knows he doesn’t come under the category of people you were referring to 🙄

AviatorMama · 17/09/2022 18:24

Haven’t read all the replies but here is my take:

Class is not innate. It would be more accurate to say that he’s middle class from a working class background. Whilst he was raised on a council estate, he can’t conceivably suggest that he truly understands the struggles that working class folk face in this COLC, given that he earns 6 figures and lives in a £1.2M house. He may have empathy, he may have memories of his childhood, but he’s never lived that experience as an adult! To be honest, I find it the height of condescension to continue to claim you’re working class when you’re living a very middle (dare I say upper-middle) class existence. It belittles the struggles and true definition of working class!

Thinking2022 · 17/09/2022 18:17

Working class- the social group consisting primarily of people who are employed in unskilled or semi-skilled manual or industrial work.
More accurate to describe yourself as coming from the working class if your parents were so employed but you hold a degree

Rummikub · 17/09/2022 18:06

Oh I loved that programme!

TrixieMixie · 17/09/2022 17:57

Cameleongirl · 16/09/2022 16:49

What would Kate Middleton be defined as then? Dad MC/UC?, Mum WC, now she's a Princess.

I honestly have no idea how to define Kate's "class."

Look at how she was portrayed on that comedy ‘The Windsors’- a comedy but like many jokes a germ of truth….

PeachyPeachTrees · 17/09/2022 17:51

He's middle class but identifies as working class.

threatmatrix · 17/09/2022 17:49

Relocatiorelocation · 16/09/2022 15:11

DH and I grew up on council estates. We both went to uni, own a fuck off house, have a huge joint income and our kids have what they want within reason.
We are definitely still working class. The way we vote / our values and beliefs / the way we speak. Just because we're educated and have a few quid, you'd never catch me wearing Hunter wellies walking a labrador. I'm more likely to be smoking a fag outside Weatherspoons on a Saturday night.

Typical socialists living a capitalist lifestyle ha ha ha

Eastangular2000 · 17/09/2022 17:18

Quveas · 17/09/2022 17:16

According to Marx, you either own the means of production or you do not. If you don't you are a worker / working class, and stratification is a capitalist ploy to divide people who have more in common with each other than they do with capitalists.

Marx wasn’t British!

Quveas · 17/09/2022 17:16

Retrievemysanity · 16/09/2022 15:13

Isn’t ‘working class’ to do with employment? A surgeon isn’t a working class job so he has a working class background but isn’t working class now.

According to Marx, you either own the means of production or you do not. If you don't you are a worker / working class, and stratification is a capitalist ploy to divide people who have more in common with each other than they do with capitalists.

Whoisshee · 17/09/2022 17:11

He’s hardly MC going to NCT in the first place 😆

I would say WC is who you socialise with, influenced by (socially), work, income, education, it’s not just a mindset or “where you come from” and that’s you for the rest of your life or ‘smoking a fag outside Wetherspoons” with the rest of ‘us’ like someone put earlier 🙄 A night out at Wetherspoons is because it’s all we can afford, it’s definitely not a choice 😆

Footballers from undeveloped parts of the world earning millions a year can’t say they’re relatable to their previous villagers, only that they relate to being in the position once for a small fraction of their lives and are now in a privileged situation and socially climbed so to speak.

Staying WC is hard, it’s a burden and sometimes embarrassing, we work hard, yet skint and live pay check to pay check, we have no ‘surgeon’ friends as we have no opportunity to meet one socially, we have corned beef hash and do all our own painting and decorating 😆 Uni wasn’t an option to me and my DH (we both had to move out and start working to pay for that privilege from late teens) but I do hope it’s an option for our DC.

Rosesandstars · 17/09/2022 17:09

Wealth and class can be separated. David Beckham is working class but very wealthy but your friend as a surgeon is highly educated and is definitely middle class but from a working class background.

palygold · 17/09/2022 17:07

and the snarky responses to the poster who said she grew up working class but was now “firmly middle class”, which were to tell her “er, no, you really aren’t / I can tell just from reading your posts that you aren’t / everyone else will know it and be sniggering behind your back when you pretend you are” etc.

If you have a working class background you're unlikely to be seen as firmly middle class by many, however you see yourself. It's nothing to be ashamed of, being working class, so perhaps those comments were aimed at someone who was perceived to be just that.

I think to be firmly any class takes a couple of generations, and even then perhaps not.

NCFT0922 · 17/09/2022 17:04

@SnackSizeRaisin when I first started reading your post I thought you were being serious 😂

mathanxiety · 17/09/2022 15:31

@ComtesseDeSpair
It is irrelevant until you suddenly realise it's relevant, that there are people whose lives have been lived in circumstances and with cultural references that are completely different from yours, and you find out that they have assumptions about you that are based on cartoons in Punch, circa 1873.

Rummikub · 17/09/2022 15:13

I used to think I might have moved into middle class until I met real middle classes and realised I didn’t quite fit.
I do value education, went to uni but that was immigrant family expectations.

ComtesseDeSpair · 17/09/2022 15:10

People being sad about this whole idea are mis-understanding I think - there's nothing wrong with being WC

I think it’s pretty clear that many people do think being middle class is superior to being working class, just by the supercilious descriptions of perceived “middle class values”: deferred gratification, valuing education, preferring books to TV, saving up rather than getting into debt to keep up appearances, not being materialistic; and the snarky responses to the poster who said she grew up working class but was now “firmly middle class”, which were to tell her “er, no, you really aren’t / I can tell just from reading your posts that you aren’t / everyone else will know it and be sniggering behind your back when you pretend you are” etc.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 17/09/2022 14:39

People being sad about this whole idea are mis-understanding I think - there's nothing wrong with being WC - in my case sure, we didn't have much money growing up, but neither did other people - I also wasn't shuffled off to boarding school or expected to wear scratchy clothes and be polite to visiting dignitaries, or attend umpteen after-school activities or whatever.

WC/MC/UC does correlate with money, but it's really more about cultural expectations - and I'm perfectly happy with my WC upbringing, and slowly getting comfortable in my slightly more MC environment now - but neither is better than the other, they're just different.