Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You're not working class!

568 replies

Womeninthesequel · 16/09/2022 15:08

Ridiculous conversation with an NCT acquaintance - we as a group were discussing the cost of living crisis and it was mentioned that working class families are really going to struggle. He scoffed and said "not all working class families, we're going to be fine." To which I goggled, and said "you're not working class!" He looked cross and said "of course I am, I grew up on a council estate, my dad was a binman."

This is true, he definitely is from a working class background, but he went to university, then med school, is now a senior surgeon doing mainly private practice, he makes six figures (which he'll tell anyone who walks past him) and his house is currently on the market for £1.2mil! He's not working class! This was pointed out to him (not by me) and he was vastly offended. He seems to genuinely believe that his upbringing means he'll always be working class, but that's not right, right? Class isn't innate, is it?

He's a bit of a dick in general, but this has raised a wider conversation at home. DH is from a working class background and is now uni educated and a professional and feels he's now middle class, so is confused by the idea that he's not.

OP posts:
RudsyFarmer · 18/09/2022 07:18

the whole point of social mobility was the option to move class through education. Your friend may have been raised ‘working class’, but he is now middle class abd enjoying all the trappings of that.

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 07:11

Juced · 18/09/2022 07:02

Maybe it’s time we dropped the class system at this point…it’s vastly damaging!

It is vastly damaging but Britain has very poor (and in some ways worsening) social mobility so it is hard to 'drop' it.

British inequality is far more extreme than most European neighbours - for example in Ireland the bottom 20% in income terms are 63% better off than in Britain - so our class structure is entrenched.

Plus no big political shake ups in history unlike most countries.

Juced · 18/09/2022 07:02

Maybe it’s time we dropped the class system at this point…it’s vastly damaging!

RockyReef · 18/09/2022 06:59

I don't really ever think about class as it's a rather outdated notion, more of my parents generation than mine, but I suppose by the accepted standards then I am upper class and my husband is working class. Confusingly we both appear middle class now, and have typical middle class professional jobs, our children go to good schools (but we don't pay anything for them due to scholarships) and because we both work in the public sector we are getting poorer by the day, and have been on a pay freeze for 12 years! We live in a large house with land, but again we have a mortgage on, and we were only able to buy it because of gifted money for that purpose from my parents. Day to day we are ok financially at the moment but we will struggle hugely in 2 years when our fixed mortgage rate ends, if interest rates haven't gone back down. The cost of heating oil is vast at the moment and our tank will need filling in about November but I'm.not sure we will have saved enough to do so. Because we earn over the govts idea of 'low income' we aren't eligible for any help that is means tested, so I think it's families like ours that will have the unseen struggle - we both work in good but relatively low paid jobs and on the face of it have a nice big house that we own, but in reality we could never have afforded the house if it wasn't for being helped with the cost of it, and it's not one that would sell quickly so we could move to a smaller home for a temporary fix to financial worries (something we have considered doing). So I think people from across the old British class system are going to struggle not just the working class (many of whom are in high paid jobs and pay full whack for their children's education). As a nun used to say to me when I was a child "money isn't the same as class".

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 06:50

Jewel1968 · 18/09/2022 06:45

What about someone who grew up in money, went to university etc... But then later in life doesn't work, lives off benefits and has little to do with family. Still speak with a posh accent and talks about the arts etc .. What class are they?

The are middle class and skint.

And they will get a lot less shit and judgement about being poor than someone WC would Angry

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 06:48

Codswallop20 · 18/09/2022 00:37

I grew up in a working class family.

I am university educated and work in a professional role.

I was working class, I am now middle class. Social mobility.

This is not how social mobility works. You are not suddenly middle class, you can't change your past.

What has happened is someone from working class background has taken a role that previously society would have expected someone from a middle class background to fill.

Social mobility means (in theory, a whole other thread about UK issues in this regard) class and family circumstances don't limit future opportunities - e.g. working class people can become barristers - it isn't a process of converting working class people into middle class people.

Jewel1968 · 18/09/2022 06:45

What about someone who grew up in money, went to university etc... But then later in life doesn't work, lives off benefits and has little to do with family. Still speak with a posh accent and talks about the arts etc .. What class are they?

CovidCath · 18/09/2022 06:21

Eastangular2000 I fully accept your point. What I was trying to say is that people should be comfortable with who and what they are rather than trying to fit a stereotype so they’re accepted into a particular group. None of those things are wrong in any way except that they are essentially trends followed for the wrong reasons. I just don’t get why people are not comfortable to just be who they are especially in a world where you can be anything.

hotdiggetydog · 18/09/2022 05:19

Why do you need to pigeon hole people?

Bleachmycloths · 18/09/2022 01:25

It is disconcerting that he is a senior surgeon and thinks like that 😵‍💫. Hasn’t he heard of social mobility? He sounds like he can’t believe how well he’s done with his showing off his six figure salary to anyone who will listen. There is. A term for it, but I can’t remember what it is 😄

Codswallop20 · 18/09/2022 01:13

@Womeninthesequel
He is not working class. He is just a nobhead. That is a separate class.

pompomdaisy · 18/09/2022 01:09

Surely in the context of struggling due to cost of living he cannot be placing himself in the same category? He may have come from WC roots but that's not what you were discussing.

Codswallop20 · 18/09/2022 00:51

If I were to do a market research survey tomorrow, I would be classified as middle class.

Personally I don't care, I think of myself as working class, but I do believe that technically I am middle class.

Codswallop20 · 18/09/2022 00:47

@Eastangular2000

Funnily enough, at university I was taught that as I was in a professional role that requires a higher level of education that actually does change my class.

Not that it matters, the fact that we still have levels of class is an embarrassment as far as I can see. Upper and middle class people find they are above the proles. Society needs a head wobble.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/09/2022 00:47

I was working class, I am now middle class. Social mobility.

It really doesn't work like that.

Does the professional privately/grammar school educated colleagues in your job consider you MC or WC University educated?

I liked the French analogy above.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 00:43

Sir Paul Nurse is a good example of this. He has a knighthood and a Nobel prize, he is still working class.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 00:40

Codswallop20 · 18/09/2022 00:37

I grew up in a working class family.

I am university educated and work in a professional role.

I was working class, I am now middle class. Social mobility.

Your children, if you have them, will be middle class. You however are working class. Going to university doesn't stop you being working class.

Codswallop20 · 18/09/2022 00:37

I grew up in a working class family.

I am university educated and work in a professional role.

I was working class, I am now middle class. Social mobility.

Eastangular2000 · 18/09/2022 00:30

CovidCath · 17/09/2022 23:10

Given that mannerisms and accents etc can be learned, then this is no indicator of class.
All I know is that ‘middle class’ tends to be full of people trying to disassociate themselves from being working class sadly. Nobody should want to be middle class and ‘aspire’ to the nauseating trends of Boden clothes, holidays in Cornwall with the cock-a-poo, probably a Tesla and every other cliché (the list is long……)
Why can’t people just be truly individual, like what they like regardless of the masses and actually not care? Why do people have so much to prove about their worth, by subscribing to a social tribe?
I have no idea what ‘class’ I am having had a very mixed bag of exposure and circumstances and nor do I care. What I do care about is how I make people feel, how good a wife/mother/sister/friend I am and I would never choose friends based on their perceived ‘social class’. I’ve been judged in the past as not fitting in due to perception of my social kudos and what I have to offer (…..based on perceived class I think) and I don’t want those friends anyway. All I know is that I’m in a good and happy place with a lot of life experience behind me which I hope makes me entirely non judgemental.

'All I know is that I’m in a good and happy place with a lot of life experience behind me which I hope makes me entirely non judgemental.'

and

'Nobody should want to be middle class and ‘aspire’ to the nauseating trends of Boden clothes, holidays in Cornwall with the cock-a-poo, probably a Tesla and every other cliché'

Posted in the same post with not even a whiff of irony. I take it self awareness isn't one of your strong points😂

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/09/2022 00:24

I still see myself as working class due to my upbringing and background. Others wouldn’t see me as that.

I think that must be a lovely place to be.

Strong links to your culture that enables you to empathise and understand while enjoying the success from the hard work you put in creating your success.

In WC circles you're one of the good ones we tell others about.

Everyone around here love's a success story.

There are 3 teachers who were past pupils in the local school it creates pride and role models within the community from the DC.

First generation university leavers are not uncommon and are hugely celebrated locally from granny to the local shop assistants.

Anotherpubber · 18/09/2022 00:13

I still see myself as working class due to my upbringing and background. Others wouldn’t see me as that.

CovidCath · 17/09/2022 23:59

It’s ironic that in a society where people feel there is a lack of social mobility, the evidence points in another direction. Plenty of people regularly become upwardly mobile financially which is fantastic and I’m a big fan of baking more pies and giving people a bigger slice. A strong society is one where more people are happy and feel valued. However, people should stop this business of trying to fit into the accepted perception of middle class and proving they got there by shouting about it. . I have way more respect for the traditional working classes (or low income earners) who are far more invested in their families than what their neighbours think of their car on the drive! Middle class behaviour is so gauche and shows such complete lack of comfort and confidence in the self. Maybe it’s because the working class have solid jobs that are actually required by society, whereas there’s lots of ‘fresh air’ wafting around the middle class that has a less solid base but pays more.? Eg holiday firms suffered under covid whereas supermarket workers became ‘key workers’. Marketing jobs were culled……Ultimately, the holiday firm pays more as do the people paying blue sky thinking marketers but none of it is strictly necessary……

EmeraldShamrock1 · 17/09/2022 23:22

@CovidCath Great post.

People would be much happier if they didn't squeeze themselves into social boxes.

I have some old friends who attended university and consider themself mc now, imo they appear very detached from everything that they knew and the place they're trying to be.

We meet once a year or weddings/funerals some of the judgemental comments they have made have caused me to shudder inside.

CovidCath · 17/09/2022 23:10

Given that mannerisms and accents etc can be learned, then this is no indicator of class.
All I know is that ‘middle class’ tends to be full of people trying to disassociate themselves from being working class sadly. Nobody should want to be middle class and ‘aspire’ to the nauseating trends of Boden clothes, holidays in Cornwall with the cock-a-poo, probably a Tesla and every other cliché (the list is long……)
Why can’t people just be truly individual, like what they like regardless of the masses and actually not care? Why do people have so much to prove about their worth, by subscribing to a social tribe?
I have no idea what ‘class’ I am having had a very mixed bag of exposure and circumstances and nor do I care. What I do care about is how I make people feel, how good a wife/mother/sister/friend I am and I would never choose friends based on their perceived ‘social class’. I’ve been judged in the past as not fitting in due to perception of my social kudos and what I have to offer (…..based on perceived class I think) and I don’t want those friends anyway. All I know is that I’m in a good and happy place with a lot of life experience behind me which I hope makes me entirely non judgemental.

WTAFhappened123 · 17/09/2022 23:02

Think you’re a bit out of order TBH