Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be confused about church baby groups

117 replies

Lemondrizzle77 · 16/09/2022 14:26

So I have being doing the rounds on the baby group scene for a short while and have recently been to a few local church and ministry baby groups. They tend to be completely free or a £1 contribution for entire family plus free food and drink.

The one we went to ystrday the people running it were ever so attentive as we were new comers taking turns to sit and talk with us, bring us snacks and waiting on us hand and foot. Of course this was lovely and I was made to feel great especially as in some mums groups I can feel excluded as they can come across ever so cliquey.

I am used to paying up to £10 for my two dcs at the other non religious baby groups.

My husband and myself are relatively comfortable. Perhaps I'm a bit cynical but are these groups aimed at families in the community who are struggling? Or is it a way to recruit more religious members into their community? Or are they just being nice?

My children are small so I am new to the scene. Any sessioned playgroup goers please enlighten me!! I just don't want to be going if the group isn't essentially what I need or what I'm looking for..

OP posts:
InsertPunHere · 16/09/2022 15:07

I used to volunteer at one and I'm an atheist. They aren't generally trying to "recruit" although the minister would do a short relaxed sort-of service near Christmas and Easter telling the story in age-appropriate language for a toddler group.

Everyone involved was a volunteer, the church provided the room free of charge. The £1-2 fee was to cover the cost of the tea, coffee and biscuit and cleaning supplies. Every half term we'd spend a morning cleaning all the toys and mats etc.

Our area was relatively affluent but had some pockets of poverty. It wasn't about provinging a service for familiers in povert specifically, it was providing a sense of community to everyone.

Many of the volunteers were retired women who enjoyed spending time around small children again.

Passanotherjaffacake · 16/09/2022 15:07

We went to a really popular local one once with a friend who was very religious. It was a normal playgroup for 90mins and then we suddenly had 30 mins of hymns and sermons from a (lovely) vicar. I was really shocked as I just expected a playgroup - not sure why in retrospect. I had to break out my CoE early schooling days to try and remember the hymns!

my husband is hugely anti church stuff though so we didn’t go back as it didn’t feel right.

AnneLovesGilbert · 16/09/2022 15:04

The one I run is in a church but it’s not a church group. I’m an atheist, friendly with the vicar who often attends as she loves children but there’s nothing religious about it at all. It’s a suitable venue with kitchen and loo and plenty of space to play safely. The cost covers a small contribution to the church’s costs and snacks, drinks, toys etc. It ends up costing me a bit here and there but I wanted somewhere to take my DD and there weren’t any groups where we live.

It’s a community thing, no agenda bar people getting together for a hot drink while their babies and young children play safely and socialise.

frogswimming · 16/09/2022 15:03

They've probably been going for years run by volunteers. One near us was the standard £2, cup of tea and a biscuit with parents volunteering and doing a sing along at the end. One of the parents then set himself up doing baby music charging £10 a class for what he'd been doing at the sing along at the end previously Confused

choirmumoftwo · 16/09/2022 15:00

We're just about to start one at our church as there is demand in the local area. It's primarily a service to the community but I'd be lying if I said we wouldn't be delighted to see some young families coming along to regular services as well.
We intend to charge a minimal amount but it would be wrong to say as a pp did that the building is there anyway, almost as though there are no running costs. Our utility bills have gone through the roof!
If op can afford to give more, perhaps put it in the collection plate or use the contactless machine if they have one.

Fink · 16/09/2022 15:00

I've worked in churches that run them and there's no expectation that people will ever attend the church, it's just part of our service to the community. When I had young dc, I attended one in another denomination where it was a standard toddler group but at the end of the songtime they sang one Christian song (which people were free to join in with or not) and they would invite everyone as a group to the weekend services. There was never any individual conversation about it or attempt to convert people. There's a bit of variation in whether church run groups will do any evangelisation at all, but even in those that do it's very minimal and never an expectation that anyone will want to come to church, or be unwelcome at the group if they don't.

Prescottdanni123 · 16/09/2022 15:00

I volunteer at my church's baby group. We charge £2 because we don't want to make a profit and we know while some mums aren't struggling for money, others are. But we are not targeting struggling parents specifically. We want as many people as possible to come as possible no matter what their financial circumstances

BaileySharp · 16/09/2022 14:59

I went to a lovely one on maternity leave. There was no pressure to join the church, the volunteers just want to help the community. I'm a bit sad that it closed and now I'm pregnant again and it won't be there this time. Other groups are more structured and expensive and less good for befriending other mums I found

Beseen22 · 16/09/2022 14:57

We go to a church for mothers and toddlers. I guess essentially there is an element of spreading the gospel as how would you tell someone what you believed without getting to know them but for the most part it's just opening up their church and allowing people to feel more comfortable in that setting. We get free coffee and fresh cake and snacks for the kids and they give us a present at Christmas. It's the only group I've found that isn't cliquey and we love it and don't quite know what to do with out Thursdays during the summer when it's off.

Pootles34 · 16/09/2022 14:56

My Grandma is very churchy (high CofE), she loved doing stuff like this until her age got the better of her. It's just doing a nice thing for the community - she loves being part of the local community, and she also quite enjoys cooing over babies I think.

Fingernails4Cash · 16/09/2022 14:55

I have been to this sort of group as well as the more clicky/less friendly fee paying kind.

The church groups are just trying to build community. Don't try to read anything into it, just enjoy their wonderful hospitality. You'll probably find after a couple of visits that you become more comfortable in the church group environment.
For the record I'm not a Christian / churchgoer and have no interest in joining the faith side of things. But I did appreciate the community and have made one or two lifelong friends there, after familiar faces cropped up again in life when the DC went to school

antelopevalley · 16/09/2022 14:55

These kind of things used to be normal. I used to run lots of free or virtually free children's activities. This is what being a community used to mean.

Trinity65 · 16/09/2022 14:54

Lemondrizzle77 · 16/09/2022 14:26

So I have being doing the rounds on the baby group scene for a short while and have recently been to a few local church and ministry baby groups. They tend to be completely free or a £1 contribution for entire family plus free food and drink.

The one we went to ystrday the people running it were ever so attentive as we were new comers taking turns to sit and talk with us, bring us snacks and waiting on us hand and foot. Of course this was lovely and I was made to feel great especially as in some mums groups I can feel excluded as they can come across ever so cliquey.

I am used to paying up to £10 for my two dcs at the other non religious baby groups.

My husband and myself are relatively comfortable. Perhaps I'm a bit cynical but are these groups aimed at families in the community who are struggling? Or is it a way to recruit more religious members into their community? Or are they just being nice?

My children are small so I am new to the scene. Any sessioned playgroup goers please enlighten me!! I just don't want to be going if the group isn't essentially what I need or what I'm looking for..

Don't overthink it OP
Its been a very very long time since I took mine to Baby and Toddler Groups but the best one, by far, was a popular Church ran one.
Yes,, they do try to get you to attend Church but they do not go on and on about it and if you decline, all is good.
One thing though that everyone enjoyed, parents and toddlers, was their yearly Christmas Party inside the church itself (Playgroup was in a hall adjoining said Church) and there was a little service for the Children then time to play and eat and drink,

bnotts · 16/09/2022 14:54

I'm an atheist but I ran the playgroup on my day off in our local church hall. We charged just £2 a family - tea/coffee and squash. We had a grandma who did the tea and coffee. It wasn't anything to do with the church - their hall was just cheap. It was run by Mum's so costs were really low costs where as other groups are obviously making. profit / paying for staff. I passed on my duties once my daughter was old and bored of it - but groups did struggle for volunteers

Cleothecat75 · 16/09/2022 14:53

I used to love going to the church run toddler groups when mine were little. They were cheap, had volunteers already recruited to deal with the money, make the drinks, wash up (I also helper to run a toddler group on a different day and it was a nightmare to get people to help out even a small amount), play with the dc and sit with mums and chat to them.

there was never an expectation that we went to church, although family services, especially at Christmas were advertised (in that a poster would go by the sign in sheet and the lady who took the money would point it out to you), but we never pressured to go.
I think they are an excellent way for the church to be part of the community and reach out to those who otherwise might not be able to afford to get out to groups with their dc. (My sil pays £1.50 for Church run toddler group and sensory baby is £8 a session).

Fundays12 · 16/09/2022 14:52

Church baby and toddler groups are often community based and lovely in my experience. I found them much better and friendlier than expensive groups.

NerrSnerr · 16/09/2022 14:52

The church groups I went to were just people doing a nice thing for the community. I'm not religious but found the local Cof E community to be lovely. When I went to fetes and events with a baby and toddler there was always someone offering to do some colouring with the older one while I fed the baby, bringing me tea and generally being lovely. No one ever tried to recruit me.

abovedecknotbelow · 16/09/2022 14:50

Dependent on the church, some do try to 'recruit'. IME as a baptised RC no RC or CoE church takes that route.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 16/09/2022 14:48

Church groups are rarely aimed at anyone in particular other than those with small children. It's simply about doing something of benefit to the community and the people within it. If it cost a lot it wouldn't be a kind thing it would just be profitable.

Dontwakeme · 16/09/2022 14:48

Been going to these for years in various churches and never once was approached to join or any pressure at all. Maybe invited to a family service at Christmas or told about a family bbq in summer etc. but never pressure!
usually between£ 1-2 depending on how many children I have. The ones local to me are full of childminders too. As you say some difference between 1hr paid activity at a soft play at £7/8 to £1 at a church group!

JofraArchersFastestBall · 16/09/2022 14:48

I went to a couple of church playgroups when my youngest was little and they were such a lifeline for me during a lonely and challenging time. I'm not religious at all but was always made to feel really welcome and nobody ever tried to convert me. There was sometimes a mention of other church events, but never any pressure.

Of the idea is to make people in the community feel more positively about the church then it worked on me! I'm not a convert but I am very grateful!

AnotherAnxiousMess · 16/09/2022 14:47

I think it depends on the church. But the church I grew up going to, they are just being nice. They want to support the community and get to know people… there’s never any expectation to be more involved. But I can’t speak for all churches.

Juicesausagecake · 16/09/2022 14:47

I run one. There weren’t any baby groups locally, but the church next door to me used to run one in its hall before the pandemic, and it needed volunteers to get it going again.

It took me a year to persuade the priest that we were serious, to get DBSd and first aid trained.

The church is Catholic. I am not. The group is inclusive. If I see someone walking on our street with a baby, I give them a flier and tell them we are there. I don’t advertise, otherwise (we are already very busy).

We charge £2, and it is mainly so that I can manage booking so that we are safe / not overcrowded. Eventbrite (the online platform) take most of the £2. The rest covers tea and coffee. I have a code for anyone who finds the £2 a barrier to attending. We aren’t fundraising, but donations are welcome (… I can sometimes find myself out of pocket).

I do it because I am grateful to the children’s centres for what they did for me and my older dc, and because they have now closed. Mothers should help mothers, make each other comfortable and we should celebrate our children. That is why I run a baby group from a church hall.

I also have a job, and do this on my day off, as do the other volunteers. I will follow this thread with interest.

Mumoblue · 16/09/2022 14:43

I used to take my son to the local Salvation Army toddler group, the only reason we don’t still go is that he’s now in nursery on that morning. It was fun for him and cheap for me.

I will say, with my experience at least, that they are actually trying to recruit you a little bit. But it’s more of a trying to gently persuade you. At the group I went to they did a prayer and a song about Jesus every session, as well as reminding everyone about services their church do for children. Around Christmas time they gave my son a book which was definitely a metaphor for the necessity of going to church (which I’ll admit I did not read to him because I disagree with the message). But generally I consider those things the cost of entry. They were never especially pushy and I never had to actually say “by the way I’m an atheist and I’m raising my son agnostic”. They’re very used to people just using the service and not becoming part of the church.

UnbeatenMum · 16/09/2022 14:42

If it's anything like my church the building is there anyway and the helpers are volunteers so costs are fairly low. You will be welcome regardless of whether you have any intention of ever attending church but you might be invited to at some point, e.g. to a Christmas service or children's service. You won't be pressured though, or any less welcome.