Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be confused about church baby groups

117 replies

Lemondrizzle77 · 16/09/2022 14:26

So I have being doing the rounds on the baby group scene for a short while and have recently been to a few local church and ministry baby groups. They tend to be completely free or a £1 contribution for entire family plus free food and drink.

The one we went to ystrday the people running it were ever so attentive as we were new comers taking turns to sit and talk with us, bring us snacks and waiting on us hand and foot. Of course this was lovely and I was made to feel great especially as in some mums groups I can feel excluded as they can come across ever so cliquey.

I am used to paying up to £10 for my two dcs at the other non religious baby groups.

My husband and myself are relatively comfortable. Perhaps I'm a bit cynical but are these groups aimed at families in the community who are struggling? Or is it a way to recruit more religious members into their community? Or are they just being nice?

My children are small so I am new to the scene. Any sessioned playgroup goers please enlighten me!! I just don't want to be going if the group isn't essentially what I need or what I'm looking for..

OP posts:
mast0650 · 16/09/2022 16:53

I guess it varied, but I used to go to an inexpensive toddler group run by the local free church. I'm an atheist, and even I didn't give this a second thought. There was no real sense of it having anything to do with the church at all, apart from being in the free church hall, though in retrospect I'm pretty sure it was run by church members. It was just the only group of that kind in the village!

Provided you are not made to feel uncomfortable by any religious aspect or pressure, I wouldn't over think it and keep going if you like it.

Whisperedew · 16/09/2022 16:47

We go to one that is £1. I do think it is a little bit recruitment, but I don’t mind. Not religious.

nicknamehelp · 16/09/2022 16:46

One I went to was 50p kids loved it was so cheap so all in community could attend. They would read a bible story (at toddler level) but kids didn't have to sit and listen and at Christmas had a special session but never once did I feel they where trying to get me to join church.
I wish I was religious as I would of joined as such a lovely group (I went to a couple of ladies evenings run by them).
Just enjoy it and enjoy their company (the ones helping often have older kids and have a lot of good advice I found)

Rutland2022 · 16/09/2022 16:46

Our local one is not “recruiting”, I’m vehemently atheist but the one in our village is just a cheap place to go and the small fee is just to cover the refreshments and to make it inclusive. I couldn’t actually go much as it was off for most of my mat leave due to
Covid and it clashes with work now but I went a few times and it just run by nice people with tea, squash, biscuits and ancient toys (I loved the vintage playmobil especially!).

The Sunday School thing they do at ours is definitely for recruiting families but the parent and baby/toddler group is definitely not.I don’t think you need to be on guard @Lemondrizzle77

LastWordsOfALiar · 16/09/2022 16:40

I think they're just trying to be nice really. I know people who are openly other religions who are welcomed in the same way

Somuchgoo · 16/09/2022 16:38

I'm my experience of going to them, the religious content and 'sell' ranges from:

None
Mentioning the times of their services
A Christian song to finish at the singalong
A Bible story and a song

They do it as an act of Christian service and for community. Of course they love it when people start coming along to services, but I've never been anywhere where is pushed, usually just the times mentioned.

Buttons294749 · 16/09/2022 16:35

I used to go to one. There was a "toddler service" at 10am then the playgroup, about half the people attended playgroup only. It's usually run by mum members of the congregation simply to serve the local community. My area was very wealthy but the contribution was still only £1/2 for the family to cover your coffee.

It was a great way to meet people as a lot of the people were members of the congregation so aware we were supposed to be welcoming and nice to new people. It was a really good way tp get local primary school info lol

Confrontayshunme · 16/09/2022 16:28

I helped run our church one because I wasn't working and love babies. My toddlers could play with people who found them fun, and I became locally known as the baby whisperer and got to sleep many a colicky baby while mum relaxed with a hot drink for the first time in days. The cost of other types of baby groups is for profit, the £1 is to cover your tea and biscuits. We don't secretly recruit people via some vast baby group ring. 😂

SunflowerSmith · 16/09/2022 16:24

I used to attend one and it was by far the best one in the area, the helpers were really lovely and the whole atmosphere was relaxed and friendly, it even had a waiting list because of how popular it was.

Nobody ever attempted to recruit me, the only time religion was bought into it was in the singing section at the end where a couple of the songs were about god, I'm an atheist and had no issue with it same as I had no issues singing about Humpty Dumpty who I also believe never existed.

FriedasCarLoad · 16/09/2022 16:16

I help to run one of these (although I have two young children with!, so I'm not the most useful helper!).

The low costs are because the church provides the building and covers heating toys, etc. The leaders are all volunteers. The money is a contribution towards drinks, biscuits and craft materials but is voluntary. It's £1 per family/childminder at mine.

We want to show love to the families in our community. Jesus loved and welcomed little children and so do we. And all the leaders understand it can be hard and isolating with a baby or toddler.

We have a bible story at ours, and usually one or two of the songs are explicitly Christian. The craft is related to the story. We're not hiding that we love to share our faith. And when we pray for the people who come, we pray for situations in their lives that they've told us about, and we also pray that they'll come to what we'd call saving faith.

So yes, we do hope for converts I suppose, although we don't care whether it's this week or in 20 years, or whether they join our church or another, or whether we even find out about it in this lifetime.

But there's no underhandedness about it. And our love and concern for the mums (and dads and grannies and nannies and CMs etc) who come is genuine. Some have become good friends. I hope they'll be "saved" one day, but even if I somehow found out that would never happen, I'd still want to be their friend just as much.

Sorry, that ended up a bit long...

CocoPlum · 16/09/2022 16:05

I attended a church toddler group when mine were little. Literally the only times it was religious in any way were at Christmas when the gift from Santa at the (free) Christmas party was usually a child's book of part of the Nativity story, and when my DS was born he was gifted a toddler bible. I'm not very religious at all but was not in the slightest offended, it was just like a picture book and I found it sweet.

The other thing is groups that cost £10 a session are usually structured activities - baby music, baby sensory etc and are businesses. Church groups are in the church hall with donated toys and volunteers, £1/child/week is plenty for a few craft supplies and biscuits!

milveycrohn · 16/09/2022 16:02

Unless things have changed dramatically over the last few years, they are not there to recruit you into the church.
My children went to a 'mothers and toddlers group', and a 'playgroup' from the age of 3.
Both held in the church hall. No Problem.
So the Playgroup leader, also went to the church, but no one preached to me, no one asked me to go to church.
It just so happened that church halls (and now quite often the actual church), are often the only large space around.

0live · 16/09/2022 15:53

Juicesausagecake · 16/09/2022 14:47

I run one. There weren’t any baby groups locally, but the church next door to me used to run one in its hall before the pandemic, and it needed volunteers to get it going again.

It took me a year to persuade the priest that we were serious, to get DBSd and first aid trained.

The church is Catholic. I am not. The group is inclusive. If I see someone walking on our street with a baby, I give them a flier and tell them we are there. I don’t advertise, otherwise (we are already very busy).

We charge £2, and it is mainly so that I can manage booking so that we are safe / not overcrowded. Eventbrite (the online platform) take most of the £2. The rest covers tea and coffee. I have a code for anyone who finds the £2 a barrier to attending. We aren’t fundraising, but donations are welcome (… I can sometimes find myself out of pocket).

I do it because I am grateful to the children’s centres for what they did for me and my older dc, and because they have now closed. Mothers should help mothers, make each other comfortable and we should celebrate our children. That is why I run a baby group from a church hall.

I also have a job, and do this on my day off, as do the other volunteers. I will follow this thread with interest.

This is such a lovely post, thank you @Juicesausagecake

chipshopElvis · 16/09/2022 15:47

I went to a lit of church ones and then volunteered at one until covid. It was just a nice community thing no ulterior motive. Plus the old folks usually run them and they love the kids.

newsaint · 16/09/2022 15:46

Perhaps I'm a bit cynical but are these groups aimed at families in the community who are struggling? Or is it a way to recruit more religious members into their community? Or are they just being nice?

I think they are just trying to express their faith and values practically, to benefit the community - "put their money where their mouth is", if you will.

I am sure they would be delighted if some of the visitors decided to join their congregation and probably hope some do - and that is OK, as long as people are not pressured or guilt-tripped to do so.

00100001 · 16/09/2022 15:46

It's a recruitment thing and a public service thing.

horseymum · 16/09/2022 15:44

I used to run one, it was for everyone. It was popular because there were volunteers to hold your baby while you got a cup of tea. It was entry by donation, you could put nothing or a couple of pounds in. We also welcomed child minders which lots of groups don't so it gave a bit of continuity as some of them were there for several years. We would invite people to Christmas/ Easter services, but no pressure. It was cheap as no overheads. Just enjoy it!

AnnaMagnani · 16/09/2022 15:42

My DM used to run a church toddler group with her friend.

Neither of them gave a stuff about recruiting converts and if the church did, it never mentioned it to them.

It was something the church had always done and my DM loved meeting new people and toddlers.

DarkShade · 16/09/2022 15:34

They charge so little because they don't have to pay for room rental and it is run by volunteers. They are not trying to recruit you!

antelopevalley · 16/09/2022 15:29

Wilkolampshade · 16/09/2022 15:24

Well this makes me feel old. Tbh, when my kids were little, twenty odd years ago, there weren't any fee paying groups that I knew of apart from the odd baby music or yoga type thing - and these were few and far between. All the groups I went to with the girls were in church halls or chapels and run by volunteers, not all of them from the church. No question of recruiting., just good community service. A pound, or 50p to get in. You could join the rota to help - or not, up to you. It was a bloody lifesaver. I had my suspicions that things have changed and the fact you found this playgroup strange kind of proves it OP. Keep on OP, sounds great 😊

Community has died. The number of people who still do community things just to help out is tiny. Now it is all commercial. Very sad.

NarNooNarNoo · 16/09/2022 15:28

Yes echoing other posters, I’ve never had any experience of a church trying to recruit this way.

I’m Catholic but have attended both Catholic and COfE churches for many different baby groups over the years. The Catholic groups I used to go to often had parents who are keen to get entry to the attached primary school so were trying to ‘show their faces’ early so to speak!

Of course if you feel uncomfortable anywhere perhaps stop going, but you may be overthinking the ulterior motive point.

Alternatively if attending church is suggested, it may be being done in a community spirited way, letting you know you are welcome etc rather than being a condition of you attending the baby group.

Sprogonthetyne · 16/09/2022 15:26

Usually has nothing to do with religion, they just have a community space that wouldn't be used otherwise. It's often run by volunteers, who either enjoy it or feel they are doing good work, so are often more enthusiastic then the more expensive groups that are run by someone trying to make a profit, with all the stress that goes with that. The people running the church hall group also probably only do it once a week, so give it their all, whereas someone who's job is running groups/ classes could have several a day.

Wilkolampshade · 16/09/2022 15:24

Well this makes me feel old. Tbh, when my kids were little, twenty odd years ago, there weren't any fee paying groups that I knew of apart from the odd baby music or yoga type thing - and these were few and far between. All the groups I went to with the girls were in church halls or chapels and run by volunteers, not all of them from the church. No question of recruiting., just good community service. A pound, or 50p to get in. You could join the rota to help - or not, up to you. It was a bloody lifesaver. I had my suspicions that things have changed and the fact you found this playgroup strange kind of proves it OP. Keep on OP, sounds great 😊

UWhatNow · 16/09/2022 15:14

The ‘recruitment’ is for you to witness what Christian service means. It means being kind, non-judgmental and welcoming. You can take it and bring your child to bask in that human warmth or not. Christians hope that others will see how a life of service to others is the right way to live. Faith in Jesus is another level and Anglicans are not usually evangelisers so it’s ok -you can relax! My children really benefitted from being around family events at our local church. It’s a lovely gentle expression of spirituality (which happens to be innate in all children).

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 16/09/2022 15:11

I stopped going after reading their 'rules' about dc being raised by the community and being able to tell off other people's dc. Turned in my chair to chat to the woman next to me and caught a lady helper tapping dd's hand for not sharing.
Dd was 8 months.