Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be confused about church baby groups

117 replies

Lemondrizzle77 · 16/09/2022 14:26

So I have being doing the rounds on the baby group scene for a short while and have recently been to a few local church and ministry baby groups. They tend to be completely free or a £1 contribution for entire family plus free food and drink.

The one we went to ystrday the people running it were ever so attentive as we were new comers taking turns to sit and talk with us, bring us snacks and waiting on us hand and foot. Of course this was lovely and I was made to feel great especially as in some mums groups I can feel excluded as they can come across ever so cliquey.

I am used to paying up to £10 for my two dcs at the other non religious baby groups.

My husband and myself are relatively comfortable. Perhaps I'm a bit cynical but are these groups aimed at families in the community who are struggling? Or is it a way to recruit more religious members into their community? Or are they just being nice?

My children are small so I am new to the scene. Any sessioned playgroup goers please enlighten me!! I just don't want to be going if the group isn't essentially what I need or what I'm looking for..

OP posts:
nowaynotnownotever · 16/09/2022 19:06

The ones I know of and have been to are just nice groups run by nice volunteers who want to do something nice for their community. I wouldn't over think it.

Jackiebrambles · 16/09/2022 19:05

The baby/toddler group that was run in a church near me was fantastic, it was so popular sometimes you couldn't get in! They had loads of toys, a big space, plus tea and juice/biscuits and only £2 donation to get in. My dd still talks about how she loved it.

We aren't religious at all but it didn't matter, a bible story was read at the end of the session but you weren't forced to join in! Grin

Good kind people and I was grateful for them.

CharlotteFlax · 16/09/2022 19:02

I used to volunteer run a church playgroup and I am firmly an atheist.

As a previous poster pointed out, the venue is free and it's run by volunteers.

Not one but of churchy stuff was ever pushed on anyone by anyone in our group.

(The vicar was lovely though!)

Mangogogogo · 16/09/2022 19:00

Two of my friends run them in churches and are not religious in any way, nor are they members of the church who’s room they use!
i went to another church one whne my daughter was little that was ran by the church members and they never even once mentioned anything about god/Jesus.
i do the same church’s food bank for my clients and they do shout ‘Jesus loves you!’ on your way out but I quite enjoy that!

RoobarbandCustud · 16/09/2022 18:56

Churches just like serving the people in their community. It's sort of what they do. They don't do it for a return, neither do they only want particular sorts of family. Middle aged and older people often love to be around kids. That's what they get out of it.

Fizbosshoes · 16/09/2022 18:52

I used to help at a church toddler group. I think it was £2 per family. Parents got coffee and biscuits, toddlers got drinks snacks and a craft activity that they could take home (could be a collage, handprint, a sunflower seed they had planted etc) Mums got flowers when they had a new baby and on Mothers day. Children got (Christian) books at Easter and Christmas. That was what the donations were used for. Everyone there was a volunteer.

The religious element was that they were invited to Carol Services or other sociable events at church from time to time. (And we prayed before the children and families arrived)

GreenRainbowSun · 16/09/2022 18:47

My experience is most of them are just run by people volunteering for the community.
There was one I went to that was a more evangelical church but their recruitment attempts were still limited to handing out the odd invitation to church events e.g. at Christmas.

I'm very glad these groups exist - I'm not poor but also not rich and the cost of all the paid classes adds up and it's good to get out of the house.

FinallyHere · 16/09/2022 18:47

we love it and it is a welcome change so we will keep going¥

Just to reassure yourselves, you might in conversation with anyone say how much you enjoy it and ask whether they see any obligations as part of your attendance ?

I'd expect them to say 'of course not' but it might set your mind at rest to hear it.

SouperNoodle · 16/09/2022 18:46

My favourite baby groups were church ones and they expected nothing in return.
Every Christmas, one of them would read a nativity book to the kids but that's about as religious as it got.

whenwillthemadnessend · 16/09/2022 18:37

When mine were little I went to a church group and it was lovely. No pressure at all. We sang nursery rhymes and maybe the odd song like whole world in his hands but there was no pressure to come to church or anything.

I think the old ladies also liked to see the little ones and feel useful to the community as well. Very rare to see the vicar.

SparkyBlue · 16/09/2022 18:37

I help run a toddler group in a church hall but I've no connection to the church as we just use the hall.

SwayingInTime · 16/09/2022 18:31

My best faux pas ever was reassuring a newbie at a similar group that the lovely old ladies stopped trying to recruit you after a bit then discovering she was a visitor from their sister church 😖

Hugasauras · 16/09/2022 18:19

Ours are just really lovely people! I'm not religious at all but they do loads in the community for kids and they barely mention religion. The lovely church playgroup we go to is £3.50 and that's half an hour of songs and rhymes, then an hour of play with toys, snacks for kids and coffee/tea and cake for adults. There are two mentions of religion: at the start they say they would love to pray for you if you have anything you want them to pray for and the final song mentions God. Nothing else.

They also do Easter egg hunts, and other family fun days.

UnagiForLife · 16/09/2022 18:10

From when mine were little I recall church groups were the friendliest and best playgroups we frequented. Usually they just asked for a donation or whatever you could afford. They will be hoping to bring you into the church community but mainly just doing a good thing for the community. The ones I went to were run by retired doting grandparent types who clearly loved seeing all the little ones, the people were so lovely and there was no pressure at all to come to church although they always mentioned the services at the end of each group.

PuzzledObserver · 16/09/2022 18:03

I’m a retired Methodist minister, and the majority of the churches I’ve had responsibility for over the years have had some form of toddler group at some time.

Believe it or not, when people attend church over many years and repeatedly hear the message about caring for others, being kind and generous etc - some of them take it to heart and act on it. So, for the most part - it genuinely is church people wanting to do something to benefit the wider community, as an out working of their own faith. That includes groups run on church premises by people who are not themselves part of the church - the church will have set the rent at a low level, because enabling the premises to be used is part of their service to the community.

At the same time, I don’t know of a church which wouldn’t be delighted if some of the families who came to the toddler group started to show up on a Sunday.

Piglet89 · 16/09/2022 18:02

@Juicesausagecake what a lovely thing to do!

TheYearOfSmallThings · 16/09/2022 17:56

I found the church groups excellent, especially the Methodists (homemade cake, no religious chat), the Congregationalists (digestive biscuits, no religious chat) and the Anglicans (no snacks, lots of colouring in Jesus, few rounds of All Things Bright and Beautiful).

None of them tried to convert me, they were all very nice.

Hiddenplastic · 16/09/2022 17:53

My church is soon going to be running groups like this and from our perspective, it's really just an opportunity to show some love and help to the community we're based in. Obviously if people decide to attend a service, then great, but there's no expectation that will happen. Some of these groups are also able to get grant funding so that's another reason why it's cheap.

SarahAndQuack · 16/09/2022 17:52

In our church, it's not 'recruiting' - but we know we've got an ageing congregation so this is one of the ways we justify to the church hierarchy that we're making an effort to be involved with children and parents in the community. A church is meant to be part of the local community. If someone came and it helped them feel comfortable about coming to other church events, that's nice, but it's not why it's done.

DorritLittle · 16/09/2022 17:45

I went to loads and was never recruited!

They were all just really lovely groups, my favourite kind after children's centres were shut down. All of them run by really lovely people. Nothing not to like.

AloysiusBear · 16/09/2022 17:36

My experience is that the people who give up their time to run these sorts of thing are Christians who believe reaching out to children & families is a core part of the religion.

Don't be fooled though, there is a often a very mild (and usually completely ineffective) evangelising motive in their too, simply in that it gets you into a building where there are posters for alpha courses everywhere, they can mention events that draw a wider community like christmas services and easter, and on a basic level they sometimes sing mildly religious songs (carols etc at christmas) and it's all exposing children on some level. If there are people open to considering religion already it's another way to reach those people. Where I lived these more religious aspects barely intruded, I think they just wanted community element of running the playgroup really. It's a charitable thing of supporting the community.

CraftyGin · 16/09/2022 17:26

I am part of a church toddler group. We have around 80 children per week so we are meeting a community need.

There is absolutely no pressure to 'join' the church, whatever that means. We do invite families to Christmas activities, and others, such as Mothering Sunday and Harvest. Our job as Christians is to spread the word, which basically means inviting.

The attendees of our group very much reflect the make-up of our local community, so not at all white skinned Anglicans.

In terms of money, we don't charge, but are happy to accept donations. The donations work out about £1 per child (£1.25 with Gift Aid). Most of the money is in the form of £2 coins or notes, so plenty are getting in without having to pay anything. As I said, we invite the whole community. We give out tea/coffee, cold drinks and lovely fruit pots for the children, so we probably don't profit.

In the words of St Francis - preach the gospel at all times, without words.

lanthanum · 16/09/2022 17:21

I used to run a baby/toddler group for my church.

Most baby groups have to rent the hall they operate from - churches tend to have a hall they can use. It does mean they can't rent it out to other groups that morning, and they need to heat it, but that cost is basically not there.

Most baby groups need to make sure they have insurance - a church group will be covered by the church's insurance.

Some baby groups are run by people as a business, so they need to make an income; church groups are normally run by volunteers.

The franchises probably have to pay a whack for that.

So, all in all, the costs for a church-run group boil down to the refreshments, consumables such as craft materials (our toys were almost all donated), and a contribution to the heating (which the church may be happy to absorb as part of their contribution to the local community).

Our group didn't actually charge a set amount - we just said that donations towards the refreshments and craft materials were welcome. That way we didn't exclude anyone who couldn't afford it. Some people probably put in just enough to cover the consumables; some probably put in whatever they were paying at other similar groups - which is why "donations" may actually bring in more than "£1".

As for how they are run and the motivation, the balance will vary, but may include service to the local community, opportunity to meet church members, chance to advertise church events, telling children Bible stories and teaching them Christian songs and rhymes, stepping stone to coming along on a Sunday morning, etc. They'll usually welcome everyone, regardless of faith.

Hawkins001 · 16/09/2022 17:00

In an area I frequent, they have a morning cafe and baby morning at a church and it's always excellent and attentive service.

HeyItsPickleRick · 16/09/2022 16:57

I live in Northern Ireland (relevant as divided communities historically) and am an atheist. Some catholic friends and I go to the local free CofE one. I know one friend in particular like us is a high earning family. No one tries to ‘recruit’ us. I’ve offered to donate money, biscuits, anything and they won’t take a penny. As far as I can work out it’s just a community service they decide to provide!