Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt they’re planning holiday without me?

196 replies

MarvelMom · 16/09/2022 08:50

I (36) fell out with my sister (23) about 6 months ago, we haven’t spoken since. Prior to falling out, me, my sister, my other sister (30) and my mum had planned a trip to Paris to celebrate my youngest sisters 21st (belated due to covid).

After the falling out I decided not to go and pulled out. It was a big falling out, family agree she was the a-hole in the situation and without giving every little detail, it boiled down to me feeling like I’m always there when she needs help e.g uni work (we did the same course), boyfriend trouble, any time she was upset, etc, but then talking to me and treating me (and everyone else in my opinion) like crap. She honestly won’t even ask you how you are when meeting up and just flat out lied to my face. I’d had enough.

Fast forward a couple months and the airline cancelled the flights (karma??) so now none of them are going. But, and here’s now where I’m feeling hurt, my mum and two sisters and planning another trip for next year, just the 3 of them. I still get on with my mum and other sister. I’m not sure what I expect? I don’t want to go, well I would want to if we hadn’t fallen out, but I’m worth more than being spoken to how she speaks to me and will not pretend it’s ok, like the family seems to.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 16/09/2022 09:42

Yes I think you're right 😁

Singinghollybob · 16/09/2022 09:42

@Boomboom22 I took it to mean the OP has fallen out with her youngest sister who is now 23, but the trip was for her belated 21st which had been postponed due to Covid.

Boomboom22 · 16/09/2022 09:41

It's all very confusing but if she is the youngest and both you and other sister are 30+ I think it unlikely she will ever act very mature around you. The dynamic is almost like a parent as well as sister, she won't be doing it on purpose. She probably acts differently outside of the family.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 16/09/2022 09:41

@MarvelMom I think you need to take some time out to think about WHY you're feeling hurt. On the face if it, you said you didn't want to go because she's acting like a brat (fully agree by the way, but she's 21, hopefully she'll grow out if it).
then it was cancelled (not by them) & they've booked another one. You're still avoiding your sister, so what do you think has changed that would make them think they should invite you? You made your position clear, you've stuck to it. It's essentially the same trip....
I'm confused about WHY you're 'hurt'

its not even as though they've just randomly booked another holiday, they've booked it to replace the one you pulled out of!!

ask the others to go away for the weekend or whatever for your birthday/Christmas markets/whatever.

you could slowly start not avoiding her & just pull her up every time she acts like a brat.

Pippylongstock · 16/09/2022 09:40

It’s okay to feel hurt. But as others have said, maybe just find some centre ground to ‘make up’. While her behaviour sound horrendous your other family members don’t want to ostracise her. I think as others have said she may grow up in time and reflect on her bad behaviour. Or not and you simply remain low contact

Singinghollybob · 16/09/2022 09:39

YABU. You pulled out because you didn't want to go. The others did want to go. Their holiday then got cancelled so they're rearranging it. YABVVU

Hiddenplastic · 16/09/2022 09:38

Your sister sounds like she's got a lot of growing up to do but by not speaking to her, you could be enabling all sorts of family drama and tension. If I were you, I'd call a truce but keep firm boundaries in place and just stop doing things for her. As she matures and faces some of life's hard stuff, a lot of this selfishness will probably drop off.

Unless a situation is completely toxic or abusive (which is a totally different scenario), I much prefer living in peace with people.

Boomboom22 · 16/09/2022 09:38

I think most people are muddled here. Your youngest sister who you get on with is turning 21? You also have a 30yr old sister you get on with.
Middle sister is 23 and the one you have fallen out with.

lookthisway · 16/09/2022 09:34

@MarvelMom I hear you on this. I know someone exactly like your sister and 23 is not exactly young so her behaviour should not be so easily dismissed. Of course, it hurts as being left out is never nice but you made a decision that in the long term (whether you make up or not) will probably be more positive for your own well-being.

Other posters are right when they say you can't expect them not to rebook especially as it is a belated 21st celebration. Your sister and mother have made their own decisions knowing what they know. I think you need to try and deal with your own hurt and make sure you have plans during the time they are away.

MarvelMom · 16/09/2022 09:33

@Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim Huh? No the airline cancelled and refunded, had nothing to do with me pulling out

OP posts:
MarvelMom · 16/09/2022 09:31

@LittleOwl153 thanks for you’re input, it isn’t unsupervised, my mum, my partner or family are always there. Nothing has made me think she speaks ill of me in front of them of anything.

OP posts:
Cubangal · 16/09/2022 09:30

Grow up! You fell out with them, said you didn't want to go on holiday with them and now they are going without you.

I see no problem there except with your attitude

Andromachehadabadday · 16/09/2022 09:28

i don’t understand being hurt at all.

You pulled out of the original trip. This trip is being rearranged. A trip you chose to not be part of.

Talipesmum · 16/09/2022 09:26

You’re kind of unreasonable to be upset about the holiday because it’s inevitable that that’s what they’re going to do when rebooking a holiday that you said you don’t want to go on. But the fallout sound horrible and you’re not wrong to feel aggrieved about the whole thing - you’re more sad about the falling out than the holiday, really. And the other family members not “siding” with you. That’s v hurtful. Poor you xx

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 16/09/2022 09:25

LittleOwl153 · 16/09/2022 09:23

I'd offer to plan a trip for you your mum and the other sister and see what is said. If they plan to ostracise you from the group totally because you don't get on with your sister then it would be useful to know that. Whilst I don't think you should go/be invited on this trip necessarily as you already pulled out, I would be pretty hurt if what is actually happening is your mum and sister are taking sides and you are the one now loosing out on a family - although sadly that happens.

I'd be careful about giving someone who you says acts as bad as your sister does unsupervised access to your children though.

This is ridiculous. So because of the argument they now have to pay out for two holidays. In this economy?!

This isn't their fault.

MarvelMom · 16/09/2022 09:24

I’m not expecting them not to go, I asked if I was being unreasonable to feel hurt about it, I can can see that everyone thinks ‘yes’

Feeling hurt silently and gauging reaction to either validate or shake off. I got my answer , thanks all

OP posts:
MacarenaMacarena · 16/09/2022 09:23

Your sister sounds a nightmare... But to avoid being and feeling excluded in the future, I'd try to improve things. Your mum and other sisters, having seen the fallout from you taking a stand, won't ever risk calling her out. You need to slide back into some familiarity with the annoying sister - organise another day out soon, cook for them all, think of something. They may not know how to rectify the situation but will probably feel relieved if you make a move to get back to some sort of status quo. Good luck.

LittleOwl153 · 16/09/2022 09:23

I'd offer to plan a trip for you your mum and the other sister and see what is said. If they plan to ostracise you from the group totally because you don't get on with your sister then it would be useful to know that. Whilst I don't think you should go/be invited on this trip necessarily as you already pulled out, I would be pretty hurt if what is actually happening is your mum and sister are taking sides and you are the one now loosing out on a family - although sadly that happens.

I'd be careful about giving someone who you says acts as bad as your sister does unsupervised access to your children though.

MamMedusa · 16/09/2022 09:22

Can't you just swallow your pride and move on from it all? Is it really worth missing out on quality family time with the rest of your family for the sake of biting your tongue and simply ignoring her bad behaviour?
You can't expect your mother & sister to take sides & miss out because you don't want to go, I'm sure they'd rather you go with them but if you refuse then what else can they do?

MarvelMom · 16/09/2022 09:22

@Vikinga no my grandmother was really upset about it the next day. She asked for a pillow and my sister said no. She’s an old 75 if that makes sense, quite stiff after being in bed for a bit.

OP posts:
minipie · 16/09/2022 09:20

It’s a rebooking of the trip you pulled out of

It’s a trip to celebrate the birthday of the sister you’ve fallen out with and clearly don’t like

I expect they presumed you wouldn’t want to go.

If you’d been invited would you have said yes and gone along? How would that work when you “stay away from” the sister whose birthday it’s for?

Marynotsocontrary · 16/09/2022 09:20

Other that a personality transplant for your sister (which may actually happen somewhat as she matures) what are your looking for here OP?
What is your best case scenario?
Do you not want your mum and other sister to see her on their own without you? Is that it?
Because that's asking rather a lot imo.

MarvelMom · 16/09/2022 09:18

@Mamamia7962 really? If you’re sat there and one of your family members is talking to another like absolute crap, you’d just sit there and think ‘not my problem’?

OP posts:
Vikinga · 16/09/2022 09:18

I think you're spending a.lot of energy avoiding her. I would kiss and make up and no longer do her any favours until she grows up. Humans don't fully mature until they're 25 and can be selfish etc. You don't have to pander to it, but no point in missing out and creating a horrible atmosphere.

Regarding the pillows - couldn't the grandmother have found some other ones or used a cushion or some clothes? Are you sure your sister didnt offer and your grandmother refused?

TeeBee · 16/09/2022 09:17

OP, I totally understand what you're saying about her behaviour, it sounds terrible. And your stance on that is to distance yourself from her...fine. But you must be able to understand that the rest of your family won't want to deal with it that way. Do you want them to all fall out with her? You're being childish if so. It would serve your interests better to smooth things over with her, so you can still join in with family things, but totally pull back on any favours to her. I have a sister who takes it in turns to fall out with various people. The best way I've felt to deal with it is empathise with her but continue my relationships with everyone. I'm not saying she's wrong in her feelings, they belong to her, but I'm not falling out with everyone just because she is. Far too much drama. Just keep a healthy distance from each other.
You do know that you falling out with your sister won't change her behaviour so just protect yourself from it.