Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt they’re planning holiday without me?

196 replies

MarvelMom · 16/09/2022 08:50

I (36) fell out with my sister (23) about 6 months ago, we haven’t spoken since. Prior to falling out, me, my sister, my other sister (30) and my mum had planned a trip to Paris to celebrate my youngest sisters 21st (belated due to covid).

After the falling out I decided not to go and pulled out. It was a big falling out, family agree she was the a-hole in the situation and without giving every little detail, it boiled down to me feeling like I’m always there when she needs help e.g uni work (we did the same course), boyfriend trouble, any time she was upset, etc, but then talking to me and treating me (and everyone else in my opinion) like crap. She honestly won’t even ask you how you are when meeting up and just flat out lied to my face. I’d had enough.

Fast forward a couple months and the airline cancelled the flights (karma??) so now none of them are going. But, and here’s now where I’m feeling hurt, my mum and two sisters and planning another trip for next year, just the 3 of them. I still get on with my mum and other sister. I’m not sure what I expect? I don’t want to go, well I would want to if we hadn’t fallen out, but I’m worth more than being spoken to how she speaks to me and will not pretend it’s ok, like the family seems to.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Misspepperpotts · 17/09/2022 19:13

I understand you are upset. Your sister sounds narcissistic to me. Just be careful that she doesn’t turn your family against you behind your back! Narcissists recruit disciples to further their agenda and they don’t care where they recruit them from as long as they win the battle and the war! Get some therapy to help to deal with the hurt this fall out has caused and to find a way to deal with the narcissistic crap she will continue to dish out. Don’t loose out on family relationships that you value because of her.

NumberTheory · 17/09/2022 19:08

I would be a bit pissed off with my family if they did this, I think. I’m not sure it would be entirely reasonable if I wouldn’t have gone on the trip with them anyway.

Your sister sounds self-centered and not nice to spend time with. But your mum and other family members still want to maintain a fairly close relationship. You, on the other hand, have gone past your tolerance level and don’t want to put up with it anymore. These two approaches don’t really work in the same room well, so I can see why they feel that a trip away can’t include the two of you. But to not try and include you in something similar when they have agreed with you in the past that she’s at fault would really sting.

There is a possibility here that you can’t see past your own passion about her behaviour and have, actually, been unreasonable yourself to the extent your family pander to you telling you what you want to hear about your sister but don’t really mean it. It doesn’t sound like they’re very up front. Possibly you’ve crossed the line a time or two and they see you as as much a “problem” as your younger sister. You haven’t posted anything that particularly gives that impression, I’m just putting it out because it can be difficult, when you’re feelings are heightened, not to be a bit tunnel visioned about things.

But assuming that’s not the case I think a bit of a heart to heart with your mum., not blaming her but pointing out that you were hurt, might be useful. It does, as I said, look like your family have a tendency to sweep things under the carpet/avoid/minimise that means they may not think about the impact of their actions on you because they’re too use to ignoring things. Letting them know it hurt you (but not going on about it and becoming another unpleasantness they just pretend hasn’t really happened) might help make them think twice in the future

StaunchMomma · 17/09/2022 19:01

It does sound like this new trip is to replace the cancelled trip that was for her birthday tho, so why would they invite you if you'd pulled out of the cancelled trip already?!

LampLighter414 · 17/09/2022 18:54

So you don’t want to go but you should be invited? Is that what you’re saying?

Or none of them should go on this long belated 21st birthday holiday? Why?

skyeisthelimit · 17/09/2022 18:50

I say this as nicely as I can, but YABU. This is a 21st birthday trip for the sister that you do not get on with, so I can understand you not being invited, and as you say it is a replacement trip for the cancelled one that you pulled out of.

You just need to readjust your thinking, you have not been left out, you chose not to go.

Silvers11 · 17/09/2022 18:44

This could be ME talking. I completely, completely understand exactly where you are coming from. I really absolutely do @MarvelMom .

The exact details are obviously different and due to the fact that if I give too many details it could be outing to those who know either of us I need to keep this vague but I recognise the feeling of 'something' which isn't quite identifiable but leaves me feeling sad/angry when certain things happen. Logically I can see (as you do) that there is no reason why something should or should not happen but on these occasions I still feel bad anyway

A couple of things I would say that I have discovered along the way ( with a little background):

I am very angry with my Sister and haven't got on with her for a very long time especially in regard to the way she has treated my elderly mother over the years - but also the way she speaks to and behaves to other Family Members: Unless she wants something in which case she is all sweetness and light until she gets it as she is also very manipulative and a bit of a bully too. Trust me when I say she has done some really pretty very reprehensible things over the years. My Mother has been upset often and both very angry and very hurt at my Sisters behaviours and things she has said and continues to say to My Mum

But the thing is, Family dynamics and relationships are not straightforward. Ever. My Mother says often that she doesn't like my Sister but she Loves her and I'm sure that is true. She is delighted on the rare occasions that my Sister meets up with her in spite of everything she has been angry/upset about - because the alternative would be to never see her at all if they had a major falling out. That would be far worse, as far as My Mother is concerned than putting up with my Sister's unkind and horrible behaviour

It is also true that other family members, like your Mum, your other sister or my family may genuinely totally agree that someone has behaved very badly/unkindly, even dishonestly but they are at a step removed from how you ( or I are feeling). They do not feel the anger first hand and it may be much easier for them to stand back, just a little and decide they want to keep the peace even if they do entirely agree with you

Like you I find it difficult to pin down exactly what I am feeling: but for me, I think it's because I feel as if by not doing what I am doing (not speaking to my Sister) they are somehow not supporting me and it isn't fair!! I think it is a perfectly understandable reaction and I can't help feeling the way I do ( nor you do) so that isn't going to change but I think the only way to deal with it is to try and accept that the others still speaking to your sister are not actually dissing you personally. They just are dealing with difficult family dynamics in the way which is best for them.

It's really hard, so don't beat yourself up. Sometimes I have found that telling my woes to good friends, who will be honest, rather than family I can get the validation I am looking for, if they agree about the situation (which they usually do, or if they don't I get other points of view to think about, which can be just as helpful

KarmaStar · 17/09/2022 18:43

I understand what you are saying she sounds like a narcissist.
Let them go away and you plan something of your own to enjoy.

Kissingfrogs25 · 17/09/2022 18:39

I second counselling as a minimum it will help you with extra support.

Wheneber I am faced with any situation, I let people choose whatever they want to do - sometimes I will say I am hurt if we are close, or nothing if that’s better. And go ahead and make my own plans with good friends/close family! I’ll try and do something that’s really meaningful or super fun and leave them to it. If you are on SM block or mute and move on.

Then you are on an equal footing and you can decide the best move in future or let time pass.

I think it’s okay to tell others until she grows up and learns some manners you are not willing to do any more favours/bail her out. It’s up to them what they do with the information.

You are doing wrong by expecting to be treated with respect

Happyher · 17/09/2022 18:32

Would you have gone if they’d asked you? If not you’ve made your bed so lie in it

MissyCooperismyShero · 17/09/2022 18:18

They have chosen to go on holiday with her. They presumably see good qualities in her that you don't see. None of us have any idea who is right. Probably there is right on both sides. But they definitely have the right to go on holiday with whoever they chose, as do you. You have all made your choices.

Thinking2022 · 17/09/2022 18:13

I think you are hoping your mother will do some mothering and address your sister's behaviour but if that has yet to happen and she is now 23, it will not happen. As everyone else has said, cutting her off is going to lead to a lifetime of division and stress for your family leaving you feeling hurt when it seems as if they have chosen you. I would see an independent counsellor if I was in your situation to help you find a way to manage your reactions to her appalling behaviour

BLT2022 · 17/09/2022 18:10

I get you op. I've had similar myself, where my sister had a blow out with several people but is fine with everyone else now, apart from me, because I don't go along with her behaviour. Ìt is hurtful, because they choose to enable her, which does feel like they take her side/prioritise her. I have no advice, because I don't know how to handle it either, but just wanted to say I empathise!

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 17/09/2022 18:08

giveovernate · 16/09/2022 09:02

She's fallen out with her one of her sisters, not the whole family.

Family will always take sides, it's rarely just one member.

My family stopped talking to me after I tried to talk to them about my brother's alcoholism (both parents already dead for related reasons).

Everyone denied it was an issue and said it was because I didn't drink at all that I was misjudging the situation. They maintained this to me even when he'd been admitted to hospital for alcohol-related reasons and was referred to a rehab unit.

They still don't talk to me.

Beepbeepenergy · 17/09/2022 17:57

I’d just distance myself with all of them and no contact :) simple don’t have another thought about them and get on with your life

Pompom1919 · 17/09/2022 17:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines, as we have suspicions about this user.

Madamum18 · 17/09/2022 17:53

I can’t change it but I can remove myself

Exactly. And as you have made that choice then the rest of your family will have to make their choices around your decision.

I wonder if you are feeling hurt because you also feel that they are choosing you over her. Maybe that has felt like a pattern over time as your sister is clearly able to make herself fairly centre stage!

It's hard I know but I suspect it is hard for your Mum and sisters too. Flowers

Mumof3girlygirls · 17/09/2022 17:39

I think if this was a seperate, new trip they had just decided to all go on without you then you would have very good rights to being annoyed/hurt. But this is still her 21st celebration and you said you didn't want a part in it. That's probably the reason nobody talked to you about it. You have to just stop thinking about it and move on. Also you need to understand we cannot control how others behave only how you react to the behaviour and while you may not like her behaviour, not speaking to her and avoiding family holidays/ events etc is not going to effect her as much as it clearly is you. It may be best to just leave her be her and try to ignore it.

Catg79 · 17/09/2022 17:34

You are so rude. How can tell that someone is argumentative and loves drama from one post? She’s obviously hurt and her sister sounds like a spoiled brat.

whynotwhatknot · 17/09/2022 12:02

i know what you mean you feel the rest are enablingher but until she does something to them then things wont change

just get on with your life and try not to let it get to you

MarvelMom · 17/09/2022 09:15

@Thereisnolight really? This is an acceptable way to treat an elderly person? I’m talking about showing a bit of kindness. My Nan gives her money, paid for her holiday, shows lots of interest in her life. I didn’t come in heavy handed (why to people keep giving responses to things I haven’t actually written), it was an example of the behaviour. I have shown respect, it isn’t returned. I remember her having an eye appointment that was about 45miles away, I drove her otherwise she’s have to wait months for a more local appointment. No thank you and nothing but attitude on the way there. She’s phoned me in tears after arguing with my mum and I drop everything I’m doing.

I’ve excused the behaviour before thinking oh she’s only 15, she’s only 19, she’s only 21. She’s now 23 and I’ve had enough.

This post wasn’t really about whether she or I was right, or even making amends, it was about the holiday they are planning. I feel much better about it as I’ve changed the way I’m looking at it due to what some peoples responses have pointed out.

OP posts:
Lalalolol · 16/09/2022 23:41

Cubangal · 16/09/2022 09:30

Grow up! You fell out with them, said you didn't want to go on holiday with them and now they are going without you.

I see no problem there except with your attitude

Did you have to be this rude?

Mary46 · 16/09/2022 19:43

Op if an atmosphere do you want to go. Families are exhausting at times

TheWayoftheLeaf · 16/09/2022 19:35

I mean she certainly sounds like a selfish and annoying little bint but there's not much you can do.

Make up or don't those are the options

TheWayoftheLeaf · 16/09/2022 19:27

hellosunshineagainxxx · 16/09/2022 08:58

She is 20/21 and you are 36. She is going to be a bit self absorbed and selfish. Make up with your sister but give less of yourself to the relationship until she matures a bit.

This

Thereisnolight · 16/09/2022 18:54

I think the parents are often to blame for these poor relations between siblings. Not always but often.

Like I said, c’mon, detach a bit OP. Be an adult in your dealings with them and expect the same in return. Blank any childish behaviour and step away until it stops..

And afford the same respect to your mostly spoiled younger sister. She may be spoiled but she may also be angry at being treated like a child. I’m with her on the grandma thing. Grandma sleeps in her bed, spills water, expects your sis to hand over her pillow, then bitches about her when she doesn’t. I’d be with your sis on this one. At the very least, I wouldn’t go in all heavy-handed on her for it - it’s really not your bizz. Respect her and she may return the favour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread