Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stranded in Italy by RyanAir should we sue?!

110 replies

Plentifulpenguins · 16/09/2022 08:46

My husband and I are in our late 40s flew to Perugia for a much-desired holiday after my terminal cancer diagnosis as a final hurrah and we were due to stay at a hotel there. We flew with RyanAir to Perugia but 15 minutes from landing they said we were diverting to Bologna for weather reasons and then changed it to Pisa. We landed in Pisa which is 4 hours from Perugia, at 9pm, and assumed Ryanair would help us get back to Perugia. They told us they’d put us all on a bus but when we cleared security there was no bus!!!!!!!!!!! Im not well enough to drive and my partner is unable to drive so we couldn’t get a car hire.We waited until midnight trying to call taxis, hotels and Ryan air and nobody would help as there were no hotels available and over 100 passengers stranded including a couple with a newborn baby!!! In the end we and several others slept on the floor outside the airport because nobody from Ryanair was around and there was nowhere in the airport or neighbouring places to stay!!!!. At about 4am we managed to get a taxi and paid 675 euros to go to Perugia, and have almost arrived. I can’t even get hold of Ryanair and was just told via an automated email to put a claim through their online system. AIBU to bring legal case against Ryan air because they couldn’t even provide any alternatives and just left us stranded?? Does anyone even know how to do this or whether I’m wasting my time?

OP posts:
Dotjones · 16/09/2022 10:01

Put in a claim but be aware that airlines can use weather as an "extraordinary circumstance" to get out of paying you.

maranella · 16/09/2022 09:58

Bubblebubblebah · 16/09/2022 09:38

I don't think they will pay you the taxi..they will simply state there are trains for fraction of that cost

Yes, having done some very basic investigation, I agree this is a worry.

I went on Google maps and checked public transport from Pisa International Airport to Perugia vs. car. Car takes 3 hours and 4 mins. Train via Florence takes 3 hours and 27 mins (so not much longer) and costs under €19 per person. If I were Ryanair looking at this claim I'd ask why the travellers didn't take the train.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 16/09/2022 09:55

Travel insurance claim surely??

notimagain · 16/09/2022 09:49

@Geamhradh

Cripes that news is grim...

Given that situation it's not impossible Ryanair had a plan to bus outbound passengers from Perugia to Pisa and then use the same buses to take the OP and companions Pisa> Perugia... so there would have been a very lengthy delay before coaches arrived.

Whatever the reality the communications went wrong somewhere.

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:47

"When it happened to us in Pescara, it was a good 2 hours before we heard anything, and then dp and I (and baby dd) only managed to get onto the first coach that came because dp was outside having a fag."

Yeah, it happened to us in France and half of the passengers were missing from the waiting area. Probably 2/3 hours until the coaches came but they'd all disappeared. Some of them popped up on social media complaining about being stranded there/no coaches etc. The fact is they'd walked straight out of the terminal and completely missed the waiting area (not surprising since there was no obvious Ryanair representative nor any signs!)

Quartz2208 · 16/09/2022 09:43

There is a clearly set out process for getting a claim both from Ryanair and from travel insurance.

The only thing you have to overcome with Ryanair is the weather but it is definitely worth starting

Geamhradh · 16/09/2022 09:43

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:38

"So the easiest way is still two changes, bus to Florence then the train"

That's just one change. A "door to door" one at that from directly outside the terminal. But no, the easiest alternative is the direct bus to Perugia.

It doesn't matter anyway for the OP since they got a taxi. I'm just wondering if there was a bus supplied by Ryanair but the OP and others were badly directed and headed straight outside the terminal? They usually hold you in a side area or closed part of the terminal while arranging buses but, because of their sheer incompetence when it comes to communication, some passengers miss the transport.

I'd agree with that supposition. When it happened to us in Pescara, it was a good 2 hours before we heard anything, and then dp and I (and baby dd) only managed to get onto the first coach that came because dp was outside having a fag.

Geamhradh · 16/09/2022 09:41

Wannabeskinnyminny · 16/09/2022 09:35

This happened to us in Kraków, Ryanair left approximately 400 people stranded by cancelling a couple of flights.Again, weather was given as excuse but I had been taking screen shots of weather apps in region and knew this wasn’t accurate.In our case, they put us on buses to bring us to another airport. Buses turned back after an hour’s journey , back to airport, and guess what, not a Ryanair official in sight!
My advice, keep EVERY receipt. Log your complaint, but you will get an email denying responsibility from them . Persevere, as probably 90% of people don’t and hence, this works for Ryanair most of the time. You may need to contact the travel ombudsman of the country (Italy in your case) and file your complaint through that office. There are some agencies online that will fight this case for you. We persevered through the Polish ombudsman’s office and eventually Ryanair had to reimburse us for the cost of hotel, meals and 2 flights to each to get home. It took 2.5 years but got back €700 each! Good luck with your claim.

"Le Marche and Umbria are on their knees, caused by the floods yesterday evening. The worst hit area is the province of Perugia where there have been more than 200 emergency interventions by the Fire Services and last night, all flights into and out of local airports were grounded or diverted"

Today's news. 8 dead, 4 missing now.

Don't think Ryanair have made it up tbf.

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:38

"So the easiest way is still two changes, bus to Florence then the train"

That's just one change. A "door to door" one at that from directly outside the terminal. But no, the easiest alternative is the direct bus to Perugia.

It doesn't matter anyway for the OP since they got a taxi. I'm just wondering if there was a bus supplied by Ryanair but the OP and others were badly directed and headed straight outside the terminal? They usually hold you in a side area or closed part of the terminal while arranging buses but, because of their sheer incompetence when it comes to communication, some passengers miss the transport.

Bubblebubblebah · 16/09/2022 09:38

I don't think they will pay you the taxi..they will simply state there are trains for fraction of that cost

Wannabeskinnyminny · 16/09/2022 09:35

This happened to us in Kraków, Ryanair left approximately 400 people stranded by cancelling a couple of flights.Again, weather was given as excuse but I had been taking screen shots of weather apps in region and knew this wasn’t accurate.In our case, they put us on buses to bring us to another airport. Buses turned back after an hour’s journey , back to airport, and guess what, not a Ryanair official in sight!
My advice, keep EVERY receipt. Log your complaint, but you will get an email denying responsibility from them . Persevere, as probably 90% of people don’t and hence, this works for Ryanair most of the time. You may need to contact the travel ombudsman of the country (Italy in your case) and file your complaint through that office. There are some agencies online that will fight this case for you. We persevered through the Polish ombudsman’s office and eventually Ryanair had to reimburse us for the cost of hotel, meals and 2 flights to each to get home. It took 2.5 years but got back €700 each! Good luck with your claim.

Geamhradh · 16/09/2022 09:34

I've been on a Ryanair diverted flight and a BA one. In both cases, whilst it wasn't immediately clear what was going to happen to us, buses did arrive and take us back to the original landing airport. I landed in Pescara very late one winter Sunday and it did take a couple of hours (as you might imagine for a last minute diverted flight) for the coaches to arrive.

The weather up there is shocking at the moment, there are reports of 7 deaths and 3 missing people this morning due to flash floods etc.
Obviously, we don't always think straight at these times, but had it become clear in due course that coaches weren't coming (where did the other passengers go? What did the staff at Pisa advise?) the sensible idea would be to go to one of the hotels near the airport and then move on this morning.

Not sure what will happen if there WAS a coach and you didn't get it. That may be when your insurance will be needed. I'm no huge fan of Ryanair but I doubt they would get away with not providing a solution to stranded passengers.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 16/09/2022 09:32

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:23

"you have to go into Florence then change again part way along to get to Perugia"

You don't change again after Florence for Perugia. And there is a bus to Florence Central which leaves directly outside the terminal at Pisa airport.

There's a train from Pisa airport to the main station in Florence.
I hope you get sorted OP
For those suggestion claiming on travel insurance, the OP, sadly, has a terminal diagnosis and it may be that they have chosen to travel without insurance. I would never advise this but can fully understand why someone in their position would do it.
I hope you don't let it spoil your trip.

Skinnermarink · 16/09/2022 09:28

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:23

"you have to go into Florence then change again part way along to get to Perugia"

You don't change again after Florence for Perugia. And there is a bus to Florence Central which leaves directly outside the terminal at Pisa airport.

So the easiest way is still two changes, bus to Florence then the train. I’ve done it myself but the direct trains don’t run all day and it can be more of a Piss (a)about. Certainly late at night or early morning you’re going to have difficulty.

i don’t travel with a lot of luggage or have a terminal illness, either.

Hiddenplastic · 16/09/2022 09:28

Share the story with a newspaper but also put in an online claim. If they reject it, take it to the Civil Aviation Authority.

Easyjet cancelled one of our flights recently and all remaining flights that day were booked so we were left stranded in another country. Managed to get a hotel but when I put in a claim, Easyjet refused to compensate us for the hotel stay. I referred it to the CAA who ruled in our favour and we got the money back.

notimagain · 16/09/2022 09:28

Firstly really sorry to hear about the circumstances behind your trip and sorry to hear about what happened last night.

In the event of a diversion coaches/buses for a couple of hundred passengers can rarely be organised at the drop of a hat, it usually takes time to organise. I certainly wouldn't expect to clear arrival formalities straight away and find a fleet of buses to be waiting outside the terminal.

In the case of one Ryanair diversion I'm aware of from family the aircraft ended up at an airport about 200 km from where they were supposed to go. In that case coaches to final destination were arranged by the airline but they took a couple of hours to organise.

Are you able to find out from e.g. social media if Ryanair organised coaches for anybody on the flight or if everybody was dumped?

nobody from Ryanair was around

Not really surprising, most airlines use sub-contractors for ground handling these days ( e.g Menzies) so it's quite possible there would be no Ryanair company staff around, which wouldn't help.

Only other advice I can give is keep all receipts with a view to pursuing this when you get home.

Good Luck

KangFang · 16/09/2022 09:28

Twitter is your friend here.
I would also contact the national UK newspapers about this.

budgiegirl · 16/09/2022 09:26

You can’t expect anything from RyanIr, they’re terrible to customers and staff

You can expect them to follow their legal responsibilities. No more than that, I agree, but they have rules that all airlines must follow.

Rewis · 16/09/2022 09:24

I think there are quite a few steps before you can get into suing them. Start with making a claim on the ryanair website. Keep receipts of everything!

budgiegirl · 16/09/2022 09:24

According to EU rules, a flight which is diverted to another airport, which does not serve the same town, city or region as the airport for which the booking was made, has to be treated as a cancelled flight. By landing in Bologna instead of Venice the airline cancelled your flight to Venice, since the Bologna airport does not serve the same town, city or region as the Venice airport. You have the same rights as in case of a flight cancellation; in addition, you can claim the costs you incurred for getting to Venice.
Had the airline provided for your onward transport to Venice, e.g. by bus or taxi, the flight would have been considered delayed

This.

The destinations given are obviously different, but this is taken from the EU website. According to this, Ryanair effectively cancelled your flight, so you can make a claim for this, plus expenses. I suppose the only woolly area is whether they will say the 'cancellation' was due to extraordinary circumstances (weather), but I find it hard to believe they don't still have a responsibility to get you to your final destination, whatever the circumstances of the diversion.

This is exactly what travel insurance is for

Um. no it's not. Ryanair have a duty of care, it's not for travel insurance to make up for their shortcomings. That said, if you get no joy from Ryanair, you could possibly try your travel insurance.

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:23

"you have to go into Florence then change again part way along to get to Perugia"

You don't change again after Florence for Perugia. And there is a bus to Florence Central which leaves directly outside the terminal at Pisa airport.

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:20

"It’s not an ‘easy’ train ride at all with luggage etc, you have to go into Florence then change again part way along to get to Perugia. Plus the OP isn’t exactly in rude health!"

Changing at Florence is as easy as the airport is with luggage. For less than £20 each it's much preferable to sleeping at the airport and then stressing about £700 in a taxi! Or else there is the bus, direct from Pisa. It's about £7.

Ryanair will hopefully reimburse the cost

Luredbyapomegranate · 16/09/2022 09:19

Sorry to hear that

Put a claim into the system, listing your medical issues.

Focus on enjoying your holiday

If you have any problems with the claim then get citizens advice to help when you get back home.

Skinnermarink · 16/09/2022 09:14

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 09:01

£675 euros? Why didn't you get the train? Shock

I had similar with Ryanair and some passengers left the terminal building when in fact there was a side room that they wanted us to wait in for our buses. No signage or anything and some people missed it completely. You might find there were buses for those who remained inside.

It’s not an ‘easy’ train ride at all with luggage etc, you have to go into Florence then change again part way along to get to Perugia. Plus the OP isn’t exactly in rude health!

UpTheAnte · 16/09/2022 09:09

HewasH20 · 16/09/2022 08:56

This is exactly what travel insurance is for. Did you try their emergency helpline or just rely on Ryanair (who will probably try to bat any claims straight back to your insurance anyway)?

It's really not what insurance is for. Airlines cannot just dump a plane load at an alternative airport and expect insurers to foot the bill.

OP, I hope you arrive safely and have a lovely holiday.