Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stranded in Italy by RyanAir should we sue?!

110 replies

Plentifulpenguins · 16/09/2022 08:46

My husband and I are in our late 40s flew to Perugia for a much-desired holiday after my terminal cancer diagnosis as a final hurrah and we were due to stay at a hotel there. We flew with RyanAir to Perugia but 15 minutes from landing they said we were diverting to Bologna for weather reasons and then changed it to Pisa. We landed in Pisa which is 4 hours from Perugia, at 9pm, and assumed Ryanair would help us get back to Perugia. They told us they’d put us all on a bus but when we cleared security there was no bus!!!!!!!!!!! Im not well enough to drive and my partner is unable to drive so we couldn’t get a car hire.We waited until midnight trying to call taxis, hotels and Ryan air and nobody would help as there were no hotels available and over 100 passengers stranded including a couple with a newborn baby!!! In the end we and several others slept on the floor outside the airport because nobody from Ryanair was around and there was nowhere in the airport or neighbouring places to stay!!!!. At about 4am we managed to get a taxi and paid 675 euros to go to Perugia, and have almost arrived. I can’t even get hold of Ryanair and was just told via an automated email to put a claim through their online system. AIBU to bring legal case against Ryan air because they couldn’t even provide any alternatives and just left us stranded?? Does anyone even know how to do this or whether I’m wasting my time?

OP posts:
GonnaGetGoingReturns · 16/09/2022 11:00

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 10:03

They won't pay because there was a coach. Unfortunately the OP missed the arranged transport. Others on Twitter seemed to expect a line of coaches waiting outside for them too, understandably that isn't a realistic expectation. When this happens you need to stay together and stay inside the terminal.

Chalk it up OP and enjoy your trip, hope it's not affected further by the storms

This is what I'd expect too.

On a similar scale, a few years ago I was stranded at Gatwick airport during the Christmas Eve storms (booked flights via EasyJet). We had to wait all day and almost until after midnight for updates and then EasyJet finally cancelled all flights. If we'd been with BA we'd have had a chance as they were trying to get those in the air.

We had travel insurance which covered our hotel but not flights. Trying to get compensation from EasyJet for flights (and I worked for a lawyer at the time) was like trying to get blood out of a stone, basically I think it was 'act of God' (storm) so we got nothing back, I think the cost of flights but no other compensation plus costs of all our food and drink bought whilst in airport.

Ryan Air will try to wriggle their way out of this but you have travel insurance.

Meili04 · 16/09/2022 10:56

Make a claim online make sure you have the taxi reciepts etc

GrumpyPanda · 16/09/2022 10:51

Dotjones · 16/09/2022 10:01

Put in a claim but be aware that airlines can use weather as an "extraordinary circumstance" to get out of paying you.

Not true. Extraordinary circumstances can be used to get out of paying extra compensation but they still have to provide food, lodging and/or onward transport. If it can't be resolved directly with the airline there are agencies who specialize in claims against airlines- two that I know of are called flight flightright and euclaim. They'll take a percentage off the compensation though.

m00rfarm · 16/09/2022 10:50

same happened to us. Ra told us via video and message to put in a claim after we had been waiting for three hours for a non existent bus. Paid for the taxi. Got the receipt. Now being told that we should have waited for the bus! We’ve sent them the video and text message but they’re refusing to pay.

Wannabeskinnyminny · 16/09/2022 10:41

it’s not always the weather in your immediate region though

True, indeed but in our case flights with other airlines from same departures airport were arriving on time. Our screenshots helped our particular case.
Anyway, my point really is that it’s worth pursuing your claim even when Ryanair weren’t taking responsibility. In this case, they may say that buses were provided for passengers etc.There were emails flying back and forth with Ryanair in our particular case, getting us nowhere, so it can be worth it going through the Ombudsman’s office.
Op, hopefully the rest of the holiday will go to plan, 💐

Wheredoestheblackfluffcomefrom · 16/09/2022 10:37

Keep all receipts and put a claim in

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 10:37

The Ryanair bus arrived at 11pm OP. You needed to stay in the terminal as they usually walk you to where the buses are. The newborn baby would've been prioritised had they been in the right place. Unfortunately that place is rarely obvious

Stranded in Italy by RyanAir should we sue?!
Bubblebubblebah · 16/09/2022 10:36

Trains start about 4am usually in these places. I remember from when I was in Pisa and honestly, one change for the sake of like £600 pounds is usually pretty goo compromise.

That's what Ryanair will argue on top of actually providing buses as pps said

Plentifulpenguins · 16/09/2022 10:34

Yes, we do have travel insurance, thankfully. I would’ve taken the train had it not been 3am & not direct train

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/09/2022 10:33

Good luck with it, OP - but you didn't mention whether you have insurance?

Plentifulpenguins · 16/09/2022 10:30

No direct trains at 3am unfortunately!

thanks for all the replies, we have made an online claim and will put a complaint in when we return. Just feel for all those families - there was a newborn baby there!

OP posts:
ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 10:30

"Ryanair are liable to transport you to your final destination and should be required to reimburse you for the taxi costs and other incidental costs related"

Not if they provide buses but the passengers don't get on them, which appears to have happened in this case.

Geamhradh · 16/09/2022 10:30

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 10:03

They won't pay because there was a coach. Unfortunately the OP missed the arranged transport. Others on Twitter seemed to expect a line of coaches waiting outside for them too, understandably that isn't a realistic expectation. When this happens you need to stay together and stay inside the terminal.

Chalk it up OP and enjoy your trip, hope it's not affected further by the storms

Ah.
I expect that's that then. Ryanair would simply say (rightly or wrongly) that the OP chose to travel on to Perugia under their own steam.

belladonna04 · 16/09/2022 10:29

Not sure if what you've experienced can technically be considered a "delay" but when we were delayed travelling to Croatia we applied for compensation through the EU route. Ryanair qualify as an EU carrier. We got 400€ each for the 4 tickets back (flights were significantly cheaper than that btw). Process was quick and easy, money was in the bank in 2 weeks. My experience in getting compensation from Ryanair hasn't been positive in the past, so this might go some way to meeting your costs. Link is here europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/indexamp_en.htm hope you manage to enjoy your holiday despite a difficult start.

dickiedavisthunderthighs · 16/09/2022 10:28

What rotten luck. I imagine you've got enhanced (and expensive!) travel insurance due to your diagnosis so make sure that you claim everything you can.

Canyoudothis · 16/09/2022 10:24

notimagain · 16/09/2022 10:15

it’s not always the weather in your immediate region though.

Good point, you can get slot delays out of your airport of departure due to weather earlier in the day (e.g. Fog) so "weather delay" can be quite legitimate even though the sun might be shining where you are sitting right now on a delayed flight.

Back to the thread, no idea what's been mentioned in the UK but French news is covering this I don't think Ryanair will have any problem justifying diversion due weather;

www.lepoint.fr/monde/italie-sept-morts-dans-de-violentes-intemperies-dans-le-centre-du-pays-16-09-2022-2490192_24.php#11

Exactly- good point about slots too. I’ve seen passengers getting upset and understandably confused because the flight was delayed due to weather, but the weather in their departure and arrival destination was 30 degrees and sunny!

what they didn’t realise was that the aircraft had been delayed due to snow at an alpine airport earlier that day.

I really hope you manage to get your money back OP. I don’t work for Ryanair so can’t help specifically with that but just make sure you keep all your receipts. Not a great start to your holiday but I hope you can enjoy the rest of it. Good luck x

GreenManalishi · 16/09/2022 10:22

Shelve this until after your holiday, and then go through the channels with RyanAir and your insurance company if necessary.

"Sueing" Ryanair by engaging a solicitor would be costly and stressful and probably fairly fruitless. You just want to recoup your losses ideally, you're not going to be able to get a cheque for thousands out of anyone and the stress wouldn't be worth it even if you did.

You sound like you need a bloody good holiday, so try not to let this take over, get what you can out of the week and deal with the admin when you get home.

notimagain · 16/09/2022 10:15

it’s not always the weather in your immediate region though.

Good point, you can get slot delays out of your airport of departure due to weather earlier in the day (e.g. Fog) so "weather delay" can be quite legitimate even though the sun might be shining where you are sitting right now on a delayed flight.

Back to the thread, no idea what's been mentioned in the UK but French news is covering this I don't think Ryanair will have any problem justifying diversion due weather;

www.lepoint.fr/monde/italie-sept-morts-dans-de-violentes-intemperies-dans-le-centre-du-pays-16-09-2022-2490192_24.php#11

Teenyliving · 16/09/2022 10:14

Make a formal complaint and then after eight weeks take it to aviationadr which is the alternative dispute resolution Ryan air are a member of.

keep all your receipts and submit them and very clearly set out what compensation you want.

ryan air are liable to transport you to your final destination and should be required to reimburse you for the taxi costs and other incidental costs related.

Canyoudothis · 16/09/2022 10:08

Wannabeskinnyminny · 16/09/2022 09:35

This happened to us in Kraków, Ryanair left approximately 400 people stranded by cancelling a couple of flights.Again, weather was given as excuse but I had been taking screen shots of weather apps in region and knew this wasn’t accurate.In our case, they put us on buses to bring us to another airport. Buses turned back after an hour’s journey , back to airport, and guess what, not a Ryanair official in sight!
My advice, keep EVERY receipt. Log your complaint, but you will get an email denying responsibility from them . Persevere, as probably 90% of people don’t and hence, this works for Ryanair most of the time. You may need to contact the travel ombudsman of the country (Italy in your case) and file your complaint through that office. There are some agencies online that will fight this case for you. We persevered through the Polish ombudsman’s office and eventually Ryanair had to reimburse us for the cost of hotel, meals and 2 flights to each to get home. It took 2.5 years but got back €700 each! Good luck with your claim.

Just to jump on your point about weather- it’s not always the weather in your immediate region though. That plane has been on several flights in the morning and if there are weather problems in the first region, it can cause a serious knock on delay for the rest of the day. That knock on reaction is still a weather delay.

that’s why sometimes passengers get annoyed when it’s delayed because of bad weather but yet the weather looks fine- it means it was delayed because of weather earlier on. The weather in Italy will be completely different to the weather in Iceland for example.

heldinadream · 16/09/2022 10:06

maranella · 16/09/2022 10:03

I thought they still had to get you to your final destination though? They can use weather as force majeure to justify landing elsewhere (justifiable, in this instance), but not to fail to provide a bus or some other onward transport to the final destination. I fear 'reasonable costs' doesn't include a €700 taxi though!

What if your final destination is - literally - in crisis, underwater for instance? There has to be a limit on this stipulation. These floods have only just occurred and Perugia seems the worst affected. BBC and Guardian don't even have this yet! Bit concerned that OP is travelling towards a crisis zone.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/09/2022 10:06

The fictional "groundside assistance" is pretty standard, since basically they just want you through immigration and out of their hair - I had it with Virgin and with Ryanair would almost expect it

Certainly I'd do whatever it takes to get the money from them, but for now just try to enjoy your much-needed holiday - and as others have asked, do you have insurance?

BitossiBlues · 16/09/2022 10:05

KangFang · 16/09/2022 09:28

Twitter is your friend here.
I would also contact the national UK newspapers about this.

Plus Radio 4 You and Yours (which can often be very effective getting fast results) and perhaps your own regional BBC station (if you flew from a regional airport, that will be a lot of people from your locale effected and therefore a local news story of note). Companies will often react quicker to a public shaming - although Ryan Air have no shame, just legal obligations they need to fulfil.

I'm really sorry you are going through this, OP. I hope you and your DH are able to enjoy your time in Perugia. 💐

maranella · 16/09/2022 10:03

Dotjones · 16/09/2022 10:01

Put in a claim but be aware that airlines can use weather as an "extraordinary circumstance" to get out of paying you.

I thought they still had to get you to your final destination though? They can use weather as force majeure to justify landing elsewhere (justifiable, in this instance), but not to fail to provide a bus or some other onward transport to the final destination. I fear 'reasonable costs' doesn't include a €700 taxi though!

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 10:03

They won't pay because there was a coach. Unfortunately the OP missed the arranged transport. Others on Twitter seemed to expect a line of coaches waiting outside for them too, understandably that isn't a realistic expectation. When this happens you need to stay together and stay inside the terminal.

Chalk it up OP and enjoy your trip, hope it's not affected further by the storms

Stranded in Italy by RyanAir should we sue?!
Swipe left for the next trending thread