Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OH won't move because he has to travel a bit further

119 replies

ChickpeaStew23 · 15/09/2022 23:08

AIBU - I’ve wanted to live in the countryside (Devon / Cornwall ideally) and run a self catering cottage/s for as long as I can remember. I’ve always dreamt of bringing my children up in a more rural way of life, and having my horses in the garden. I’m financially able to now do this (inheritance, sadly), and either buy somewhere with said business, or somewhere smaller where I would no longer need to work, and OH could work less. This is of course area dependent - some places are waaay out of our price range to be able to do that. However, he is now unwilling to move because the area means he has to travel further to do his hobby, which is something he does once a week. Currently he often travels up to 2.5 hours to do this. The area I’m looking in would turn this into 3 / 3.5. To be clear, there is absolutely no other reason he doesn’t want to move (work, family etc) and has said he is up for moving as there is nothing keeping us here. Places which are closer to his hobby, would mean a more expensive house and not a total lifestyle change as both of us would need to keep our jobs. AIBU to think that he is being unreasonable for not compromising on 1 - 2 hours of extra travel there and back once a week? A cheaper house would mean we could live mortgage free and we’re in our early 30s (we live in a very expensive area currently). We could also potentially buy a property to let too, so we would be financially secure. I understand that I want my hobby in the garden so why should that take priority over his hobby, and I’m trying to see his perspective, but….

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 16/09/2022 08:15

I think that there's a big difference between 2.5 hours travel and 3.5 hours.

You would stop work and have your horses, he would have to continue to work and probably not be able to access his hobby.

There must be a better compromise.

Technosaurus · 16/09/2022 08:14

Just your post about house size not mattering OP. In that case, look elsewhere and you'd be surprised what you can get for similar money, then either live more financially comfortably or use the saving on the house purchase to send the kids private and not have to care about school catchments etc.

midgetastic · 16/09/2022 08:13

Still for the first time I think the OP migh my actually have a DH with an outing hobby - seems only one place in the country up so it and nowhere up north

although I am now trying to think of places within 3/5 hrs of Devon / Cornwall that are not within closer reach to the midlands ( Shropshire) for example

BigFatLiar · 16/09/2022 08:10

Also, every single local is a frothing bigot ready to run visitors and incomers through with a pitchfork the minute we sniff them out.

Having been to Cornwall & Devon i can confirm this, (also applies to parts of Wales).

Just be careful where you go, we're not that rural and buses stop at 7pm none on Sundays/Bank Holidays. Some of the nearby areas have 1 bus a day in/out of town. We were amused on a walk to notice the timetable on a bus shelter saying there was a bus to a nearby town on Tuesday morning across the road in the other shelter the bus from the town was Thursday, they were the only services.

Technosaurus · 16/09/2022 08:07

If you're in a position to up sticks and live mortgage free in Devon or Cornwall, surely you can do the same almost anywhere in the country except London. Sounds like your goal is to be mortgage free and have a horse in the garden, whereas he's not overly sold on Devon or Cornwall.

If you start going further North you could probably buy a much bigger house and paddock with much bigger holiday let options, and he could be closer to his intriguing hobby (my money is on skydiving)

ChickpeaStew23 · 16/09/2022 08:02

Nope I'm not dead set on it having to be Devon at all, we had viewings booked on 2 places and neither were there (they both sold beforehand), and we've looked at multiple areas - I just said ideally Devon, because I know it better than other areas and it's not a thousand miles from family. I'm more than willing to compromise on location, but it has to be affordable - there is a monumental difference in prices across the country, and it's not 'to get a bigger house' - we don't actually want a bigger house! But just somewhere where we can live financially comfortably (business or no business attached, we can both carry on doing similar jobs if need be) with some land and decent schools and not the complete middle of nowhere!
I really don't think living in a slightly more rural county automatically means your children live socially deprived lifestyles and there isn't anything to do for anybody!
To add some balance, I currently travel 7 hours over the week to look after my horses if you look at it in travel time (or I have to pay someone to do them for me). He currently travels around 5 hours in 1 day or stays over now, so it is only the extra bit.

OP posts:
Namenic · 16/09/2022 07:57

i would also rent before buying to make sure it is what u want

Vikinga · 16/09/2022 07:57

I want to know what the hobby is lol.

Namenic · 16/09/2022 07:56

6hours travelling once per week is a lot. Are there any areas that are more suitable for you both?

George4567 · 16/09/2022 07:53

I live in Devon. Next week I am going on holiday to Cornwall. The journey will take 4 hours. Devon and Cornwall is not an homogeneous mass that can be measured from the other side of Taunton. The idea of an extra hour is a myth. (On a summer weekend I can take an hour to drive six miles)

Lovetogarden2022 · 16/09/2022 07:53

I agree that moving house (especially longer distances) needs two yeses. Myself and my partner had this dream of moving to a more rural location etc (again, not middle of nowhere but on the edge of a village near a big town, similar to you). I am SO grateful every single day that we chose to stay in our original location and just move to a bigger house! My friends who've moved have all regretted it massively, even the ones who've had a "lifelong" dream of living in the countryside. It's a big upheaval and one you need to think very very carefully about - if your husband is getting cold feet for ANY reason DO NOT MOVE! I too wouldn't want to move further from my hobby, especially if it meant possible 7 hour round trips (this will be significantly longer during the season if in Cornwall!).

Tlolljs · 16/09/2022 07:50

What hobby does he do that it’s 2.5 hours away now, and will be 3.5 hours if you move.

catfunk · 16/09/2022 07:48

He'd be driving 7 hours in one day for a hobby? 😳

Bagzzz · 16/09/2022 07:47

Neither are being unreasonable. Do you know anything about running this type of business (self catering and the separate letting) and how would it change your income?

How old are your children and are there facilities for any hobbies that you might like them to do?

Paq · 16/09/2022 07:46

I can confirm that there is absolutely nothing to do in any part of Devon and Cornwall. Us locals sometimes paint walls just for the excitement of watching them dry. Which they don't because it rains every single day.

Also, every single local is a frothing bigot ready to run visitors and incomers through with a pitchfork the minute we sniff them out.

Teenagers are locked in cellars until they are old enough to handle a pitchfork and the excitement of watching paint drying.

Hotandbothereds · 16/09/2022 07:43

You should compromise on location, are you going to see the place up north that he was keen on?

He could look for different work even if it’s unlikely he’ll find similar to what he does now.

Theres tonnes of places that are rural where you could set up your business idea & have your horses, open your ideas a bit wider to where you could relocate to.

Novum · 16/09/2022 07:40

Are you saying he would have to spend 6 or 7 hours travelling to do his hobby? That really is a bridge too far, especially if you went to Cornwall where that could easily stretch to even longer in the summer.

SleeplessInEngland · 16/09/2022 07:39

Having had 7 teenagers I can assure you that I never once had them moan about not being able to see their mates

Christ, my sympathies.

balalake · 16/09/2022 07:38

No to the holiday let, cannot offer much on the hobby though seven hours travelling once a week is a lot.

Agree with the comment about rural children and life skills.

NCHammer2022 · 16/09/2022 07:37

I wouldn’t want to move to Devon or Cornwall in my early 30s either for plenty of what I’m sure you’d consider spurious reasons so I’ve got some sympathy. Most reasons for not wanting to make a huge life change are fairly valid imo.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 16/09/2022 07:30

Life is about compromise. Start compromising.

DDivaStar · 16/09/2022 07:26

He is perfectly entitled to want to hacecaccess to his hobby. Why are you so set on Devon and Cornwall? Surely the compromise would be to look at other areas.

eighteenmonthstogo · 16/09/2022 07:16

Goodness me there is a lot of ignorance about the countryside on this thread.

It might surprise you but we do actually have social lives and so do our kids !

Having had 7 teenagers I can assure you that I never once had them moan about not being able to see their mates . In fact if anything it's made them all a lot more independent and resourceful than friends from the city who are completely flummoxed if everything is not immediately available to them.

They learned the bus /train system from an early age and made it a priority to learn to drive by 17. A really important life skill. When younger they also used their imaginations to create fun with friends and neighbours. Rather than relying on manufactured entertainment in town. It also helps that 'the back of nowhere' is actually, often a much friendlier place than the city . A place where I never once said more than good morning to my neighbour.

I absolutely understand why you want to bring you kids up in the country OP. For me it was a complete hard line and it has been as wonderful as I thought it would be.

My only advice is do not fixate on Devon and Cornwall. (and another holiday let is not going to endear you to the locals !) There are so many more places to explore. The UK is still somewhere between 88-95% pasture/arable/forest so there is plenty to choose from if you look for a compromise.

Willyoujustbequiet · 16/09/2022 07:05

Your idea makes perfect sense to me but then I live fairly rurally. I don't understand a couple of replies about the countryside.....lived in a city for uni and hated it. I couldn't wait to escape the noise and dirt and give my kids a healthier life.

Mouthfulofquiz · 16/09/2022 07:04

@Keyansier nothing to do in Devon and Cornwall? What an odd thing to say. Also, what’s wrong with the people here? I think we’re quite nice. If a little easily trickable into replying to your goady post!