Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OH won't move because he has to travel a bit further

119 replies

ChickpeaStew23 · 15/09/2022 23:08

AIBU - I’ve wanted to live in the countryside (Devon / Cornwall ideally) and run a self catering cottage/s for as long as I can remember. I’ve always dreamt of bringing my children up in a more rural way of life, and having my horses in the garden. I’m financially able to now do this (inheritance, sadly), and either buy somewhere with said business, or somewhere smaller where I would no longer need to work, and OH could work less. This is of course area dependent - some places are waaay out of our price range to be able to do that. However, he is now unwilling to move because the area means he has to travel further to do his hobby, which is something he does once a week. Currently he often travels up to 2.5 hours to do this. The area I’m looking in would turn this into 3 / 3.5. To be clear, there is absolutely no other reason he doesn’t want to move (work, family etc) and has said he is up for moving as there is nothing keeping us here. Places which are closer to his hobby, would mean a more expensive house and not a total lifestyle change as both of us would need to keep our jobs. AIBU to think that he is being unreasonable for not compromising on 1 - 2 hours of extra travel there and back once a week? A cheaper house would mean we could live mortgage free and we’re in our early 30s (we live in a very expensive area currently). We could also potentially buy a property to let too, so we would be financially secure. I understand that I want my hobby in the garden so why should that take priority over his hobby, and I’m trying to see his perspective, but….

OP posts:
ChickpeaStew23 · 16/09/2022 10:00

FloydPepper · 16/09/2022 09:45

I think you’re being a bit selfish

you want to move your hobby will be in your doorstep. That means his will be a very long way away. You’re justifying this by saying at the moment your cumulative travel to yours is the same as his will be in the future ON ONE DAY.

partnership means compromise. All I’m seeing is you getting what you want and sod him.

That wasn't really the main point I was trying to make, more that he currently is more than willing to travel 5 hours in a day at present, yet an extra bit on top of that is a dealbreaker against a complete lifestyle change for the whole family & the financial security that would come with a move away from where we are now. I work with people who travel into the city at 2+ hours every day, so perhaps have a different perception of long travels.

OP posts:
Scepticalwotsits · 16/09/2022 09:59

TimeForTeaAndG · 15/09/2022 23:33

I think you're romanticising a lifestyle. Living rurally can be really really shit.

I don't live all that rural but we have one train an hour so drive if we want to get anywhere. It's single winding carriageway for about 15 miles so if you get stuck behind someone and the other lane is busy then it can add at least an extra 30 minutes to your journey time until you hit dual carriageway....

Have you been to these locations and stayed more than a weekend/fortnight?

Lucky to even have a train. In Devon most likely won’t be the case.

I live semi rural (rural setting, but near a major city) to try and get the best of both but honestly sometimes feel we get the worst of both.

bad roads, I public transport having to hit the main rat runs to get into the city.

courgettigreensadwater · 16/09/2022 09:56

Keyansier · 15/09/2022 23:28

I would hate to live in Devon or Cornwall for the complete lack of anything to do there and would gladly spend more on a house to be away from those areas and the people. But that's just my personal opinion.

You could both compromise and move somewhere that's still 2.5 hours away from his hobby but you want to move to Devon/Cornwall because it's your lifelong dream. It's not his.

He's pretty stupid to not jump at the chance of being mortgage free so young. But...countryside...sheesh.

Rude

FloydPepper · 16/09/2022 09:45

I think you’re being a bit selfish

you want to move your hobby will be in your doorstep. That means his will be a very long way away. You’re justifying this by saying at the moment your cumulative travel to yours is the same as his will be in the future ON ONE DAY.

partnership means compromise. All I’m seeing is you getting what you want and sod him.

Fizbosshoes · 16/09/2022 09:40

I'm also intrigued what the hobby is!
I'm glad I run I can do that from my doorstep.

Back to topic I think maybe compromise is needed. However also bear in mind the extra work involved (childcare, housework, garden, holiday let arrangements - if you go down that route etc) for you, OP if he is out for extended periods of time to pursue the hobby.(or tired after driving 7 hours!) A lot of hobbies can cause resentment when the other partner is picking up the slack at home, or does not get time to follow their own interests.

StopFeckingFaffing · 16/09/2022 09:32

Neither of you is being unreasonable

The move obviously has a lot of advantages for you but not for him so I can totally understand why he is less keen

If you can choose a different rural area which has property for similar (or lower) prices than Devon which would be a shorter travel distance for his hobby then that would seem like a good compromise

Keha · 16/09/2022 09:27

I think that adding two hours of travel to a one day hobby every week is quite a lot. Psychologically, I think it's quite different to having to do 7 hours over a week. You are both allowed to have your preferences and needs and you are allowed to want what you want, but if his hobby is really important to him I don't think he's being especially unreasonable.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 16/09/2022 09:20

I can't focus on the issue until I know what the hobby is!

midgetastic · 16/09/2022 09:20

MyneighbourisTotoro · 16/09/2022 09:15

Please don’t run a holiday let in Devon of Cornwall! There’s a massive housing crisis with so many families stuck in temporary accommodation because all of the rentals have been turned into holiday let’s, you’ll become part of a huge problem.

This is true in many beautiful rural areas

MrsMariaReynolds · 16/09/2022 09:19

Oooh, another mystery "hobby"! Haven't read one of these in awhile. MN at its best. 😁

AlbertaAnnie · 16/09/2022 09:16

I’m very curious about what this hobby is now! 🤣

MyneighbourisTotoro · 16/09/2022 09:15

Please don’t run a holiday let in Devon of Cornwall! There’s a massive housing crisis with so many families stuck in temporary accommodation because all of the rentals have been turned into holiday let’s, you’ll become part of a huge problem.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 16/09/2022 09:12

Juicelooseabootthehoose · 15/09/2022 23:28

It's all well and good saying you went to live in Devon but whereabouts do you live now? If you say something like Newcastle, I can kind of see his point!

Well given it's adding about an hour to his hobby trip it's not going to be THAT far is it?!

@ChickpeaStew23 if this has always been your dream and you're going to get so much out of the move & your inheritance (Sorry 💐) is funding it, I think he's being a selfish idiot, saying he won't go because it'll take an extra hour for his hobby once a week.

I hope you have & will 'ring fence' your inheritance & previous house investment.
do what's best for you & yours, he can come or not!! 🤷🏻‍♀️

FaultybutFabulous · 16/09/2022 09:07

What's the hobby?

toomuchlaundry · 16/09/2022 09:01

Maybe let us know what the hobby is and posters in Devon and Cornwall may be able to say whether this particular hobby is available

ChilliPB · 16/09/2022 08:58

I think you need to sit down and discuss your priorities together.
You mention children - do you think he’ll continue his hobby once you have kids? If it’s taking up a lot of time, it’s something to consider - you don’t want to move for his hobby, then he gives it up when you have kids.
You talk about reducing hours/not working - have you thought through what this means in your 30s? It’s amazing to have a chance to be mortgage free or on a low mortgage but if you don’t work, do you have enough to cover you for your living costs and pensions forever? I’d work, perhaps in a less stressful job or less hours, but I’d want to be contributing a lot into savings/pension. The work questions might impact where you live.

I am sure there is some compromise that gives you both what you want but I think there’s some pretty major decisions and thinking to be done.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/09/2022 08:53

To add some balance, I currently travel 7 hours over the week to look after my horses if you look at it in travel time (or I have to pay someone to do them for me). He currently travels around 5 hours in 1 day or stays over now, so it is only the extra bit

I don't think this is quite making the point you think it is. Presumably you visit the horses daily, so that's 30mins in each direction each day. Or, less than most people commute to work. Yet you think that's harder than 5hrs in a single day?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/09/2022 08:53

Imagine driving on the M5 or A30 to get to your hobby😂

Last time l went to Cornwall the M5 and A30 were just one long traffic jam.

Ducksurprise · 16/09/2022 08:50

eighteenmonthstogo

I disagree, I find city teenagers do not cope well with rural living, nor for that matter many adults.

Mine love where they live but it is a different world.

Lalliella · 16/09/2022 08:43

There must be places cheaper than Devon where you can have a rural life near to an ice rink or whatever he needs for his hobby. My mum lives 2.5 hours away and I can visit her in a day. I’d struggle if it was 3.5 hours, I’d prefer to stay over. If he starts doing this he’ll be away a good chunk of the weekend - how would that work with the kids?

midgetastic · 16/09/2022 08:37

Curling gives you all of Scotland in scope

Isithotinhere · 16/09/2022 08:32

Obviously where you live as a family has to be a joint decision, but he sounds like he's thinking of his convenience to his hobby (which is already a crazy travel time away) while you're thinking of a better lifestyle for your family, as well as fulfilling a dream which I imagine the person who left you the money would be delighted with.

As with everyone else, I'm wondering why he can't do the hobby nearer to home, and what it is that he travels 5 hours there and back for, or stays over to do. That takes a lot of time away from what could be family time, housework etc.

Aqwertyone · 16/09/2022 08:31

I’m guessing his hobby is curling.

I would be looking for somewhere else that meets both your needs. Land for the horses (although it is a fairly lonely life having them at home), a cheaper place so you can give up / reduce work and closer to his hobby.

What is it that attracts you to Devon/Cornwall so people can suggest other places - do you want to be near the coast? Climate?

astuz · 16/09/2022 08:20

The compromise here is to find a semi-rural location that is close to his hobby (closer than now ideally - 4 hours of driving each weekend is a lot of petrol money). I live in a semi-rural location in the midlands - it's exactly what you're describing, and it's lovely. We can get to most places in England within 2.5 hours, apart from the far flung areas eg. Cornwall & East Anglian coast.

This is just one place in the UK that I know about because I happen to live here, but there must be hundreds of other similar places all across the UK.

Welliesintherain · 16/09/2022 08:17

Yabu

but if you’ll be mortgage free does he have the option to change jobs?
otherwise it seems unfair the move would mean you no longer work yet he had increased travel time to work