Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry my friend is wasting her fertility

113 replies

Friendworried · 15/09/2022 21:47

We are 35. Up until last year she was focused on having a baby alone, having been single for 7 years and was starting to look into it and said it was definitely what she wanted.

She now has a boyfriend (he’s early 40s). He’s still married but 100% separated and they have been away together etc.

Before she met him, she was very straight forward and said at our age she’d want to move quickly and not waste time.

Its been a year and for the first 9 months, she didn’t even want to ask if they were exclusive. She’s said they’ve spoken about moving in / buying together but don’t know where and so it’s on the back burner. They both currently own but she won’t move into his because it was his home with his ex wife and says hers is too small.

She said he said if she got pregnant by accident he would ‘move to Timbuktu’. And that she’s not worried, she just wants to travel and has at least another 7 years to have kids. Overall though, she seems really happy and I know she’s wanted a boyfriend for so long. She’s recently met his parents and he’s met hers so he’s clearly somewhat serious.

It’s none of my business and I would never say anything but basically I don’t trust him. I feel like at his age and with a marriage behind him, he knows if he wants children or not and it’s not fair to waste a mid 30s woman’s time if he doesn’t want them or doesn’t want them soon.

I know AIBU but I struggled to TTC for a while and wouldn’t wish that pain on anyone, especially if she can avoid it.

OP posts:
Karamna · 16/09/2022 05:42

Does he have kids already?

What did he mean by the Timbuktu comment? Has she asked him whether he wants kids?

Aprilx · 16/09/2022 05:19

I think it is ok for a one time comment or question about it. But then leave it, you need to assume that your friend is very well aware of her body clock, most women already know this and don’t need a “helpful” friend pointing out the obvious.

And maybe she had decided she would rather have him than children. We are childless not through choice, undiagnosed so no idea if it is me or him or both of us. We still have a happy life and wouldn’t be pleased with somebody telling us to get rid of the other.

sjxoxo · 16/09/2022 04:59

You sound really over involved in her life. This is entirely her choice and absolutely nothing to do with you! People don’t need you to point out their ‘mistakes’ to them. I’d be well annoyed if a good friend had such judgey opinions on my life! x

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 16/09/2022 04:48

user1477391263 · 16/09/2022 03:00

Fertility does not take a big hit after 35. That myth was built from records in 1700s when many died in their mid 30s hence the drop in births after 35. New studies show this is not the case.

I'm familiar with the studies (old and new) that you are referring to here. It is true that the "cliff edge" is closer to 40 than 35 for modern women on average. The problem is that is just the average and there is a bell curve. The OP's friend might be able to bear children naturally until her 40s, or she might already be infertile. It's hard to know without a fertility MOT of some kind, and even those only give a very rough idea. She'd be advised to crack on, if she wants to do this. Of course, it's also possible she's genuinely changed her mind! A friendly chat might clarify things a bit.

Again not what I read. The studies I read didnt talk about aby cliff edge or curve. However, why should she be advised to crack on. It is so funny that women who say they don't want children get told all the time they will change their mind and they'll regret it etc. This is the reverse and a woman changing their mind seems to not be allowed in this instance. How ironic changing minds causes people to have any concern over a woman and her body. Why have a friendly chat at all? Why is it anyone's business what she does or doesn't do? It is rude. Basically because she doesn't conform to societies norms of having children then there must be an issue. No, let her make her own decisions and it isn't anyone's place to be asking.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 16/09/2022 04:40

user1477391263 · 16/09/2022 01:28

The scientific literature shows pretty clearly that
a) knowledge about fertility/age decline is not very good in most people
b) giving people more accurate information generally causes them move forward with their plans and try to TTC at earlier ages.

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0015028213004998

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1701216315305855

academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/12/3253/690352?login=false

academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/2/385/597899?login=false

academic.oup.com/humrep/article/30/2/353/728578?login=false

The newer studies I have read say it is minimal.

user1477391263 · 16/09/2022 03:00

Fertility does not take a big hit after 35. That myth was built from records in 1700s when many died in their mid 30s hence the drop in births after 35. New studies show this is not the case.

I'm familiar with the studies (old and new) that you are referring to here. It is true that the "cliff edge" is closer to 40 than 35 for modern women on average. The problem is that is just the average and there is a bell curve. The OP's friend might be able to bear children naturally until her 40s, or she might already be infertile. It's hard to know without a fertility MOT of some kind, and even those only give a very rough idea. She'd be advised to crack on, if she wants to do this. Of course, it's also possible she's genuinely changed her mind! A friendly chat might clarify things a bit.

LuckyPeonies · 16/09/2022 02:28

It appears he made clear to her he currently (or permanently?) has no interest in procreating. So she may have changed her mind and decided she is happy as is. Her decision to make, however it turns out.

TheBeesKnee · 16/09/2022 01:48

How many of those 7 years was she "focussed" on having a baby? It just seems like a long time without any progress/results, which makes me wonder how serious she was about it.

I think it's fine to talk to her about it, but you do need to be careful with how you phrase things. Focus on her, her plans, her wants, etc. Try not to mention him.

user1477391263 · 16/09/2022 01:28

The scientific literature shows pretty clearly that
a) knowledge about fertility/age decline is not very good in most people
b) giving people more accurate information generally causes them move forward with their plans and try to TTC at earlier ages.

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0015028213004998

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1701216315305855

academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/12/3253/690352?login=false

academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/2/385/597899?login=false

academic.oup.com/humrep/article/30/2/353/728578?login=false

Speedweed · 16/09/2022 01:25

If he didn't have children in his previous marriage, he doesn't want them. He's been consistent by saying he'd bolt if she accidentally got pregnant. He's being perfectly clear.

I'd assume your friend has changed her mind and would rather have the man than a family. And I don't think it's wrong to say to your friend you assume she's changed her mind, and see what she says.

MarieKlepto · 16/09/2022 01:01

I think she needs to pin him down, if she still wants children, and get a definitive answer now. Friends of mine have had children at 38, 39,40,41,42,43. Another, who still thought she had time, naturally, went into menopause at 37 (turns out it runs in her family but no one told her).

user1477391263 · 16/09/2022 00:52

i get what you’re saying but is losing out on motherhood such a bad thing given what a hard and thankless task it often is…

It's hard and thankless at times, but I'm very glad I did it, and almost all my friends with older children are really enjoying the benefits now. If the OP's friend says she wants children, I wouldn't try to second-guess her by assuming "actually she probably really wants to be childfree but is suffering from false consciousness and is deluded into thinking she wants children."

Re other previous posts: yes, there is a weird MN thing about not being able to offer any unsolicited advice, even politely/tactfully. As long as you go about it in a sensitive way, I don't think there is anything wrong with starting a discussion about this. What would be wrong would be to keep pushing the issue if the friend makes it clear that she really does want to wait and is not interested in changing her mind.

kateandme · 16/09/2022 00:37

Floomobal · 16/09/2022 00:05

Totally agree with this. Only on MN that friends can’t have open and honest conversations

This.

Delectable · 16/09/2022 00:37

You're a good friend OP. Mostly the types that I have but not common place in MN. You should advice your friend but be careful not to nag her. She's blessed to have you as a friend not only because you care but you're willing to spare her an ordeal you went through. You've had the experience and she doesn't need to.
However, if she choses not to learn you can with good conscience know you did well as a sister-friend.

EdgeOfACoin · 16/09/2022 00:34

women have stopped lying to each other about how wonderful motherhood is and started being more honest so is it any wonder that more and more women are giving motherhood a swerve?

Yeah, women going on about how hard and terrible motherhood is nearly put me off altogether. I was in my late 30s before I even started trying to conceive. Fortunately, I was successful.

I actually do find it a wonderful experience and I regret leaving it so late to have my first baby. I sincerely hope I haven't left it too late to have another one.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/09/2022 00:11

user1477391263 · 15/09/2022 23:58

I predict there will be an avalanche of MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS posts, since this is Mumsnet and some people are addicted to that phrase on here.

The thing is, though, most of us do actually care about our friends' happiness (because they are friends, not total strangers), and some women just don't really have a clear idea about fertility decline.

You see celebrities having babies in their late 40s (usually with donated eggs, on the quiet) and it creates an unrealistic impression.

For every woman who can still get pregnant at 45, there will be at least one more who is already basically infertile at 35, and everything in between. And it's hard to know for sure which kind of woman you'll be more similar to.

@user1477391263

i get what you’re saying but is losing out on motherhood such a bad thing given what a hard and thankless task it often is…

maybe that is playing into OP’s friends current actions and behaviour whether she is aware of it or not.

women have stopped lying to each other about how wonderful motherhood is and started being more honest so is it any wonder that more and more women are giving motherhood a swerve?

Ottersmith · 16/09/2022 00:09

Yes she is! He is wasting her time and she is too loved up to do anything about it. She should carry on with her plan regardless but she won't because she is devoting her energy to keeping the relationship going. Similar happened to me and I'm finally pregnant but am 39 so not ideal at all. 35-40 goes so quickly. I don't think there's much you can do though apart from encourage her to have an open and Frank discussion with him. That will get everything moving one way or another and that's the thing I put off because deep down I knew the answer.

Floomobal · 16/09/2022 00:05

Wouldloveanother · 15/09/2022 23:09

I am privately concerned about a couple of my friends, but I keep that to myself. I am and will always be there with an open ear, a glass of wine and a hug but I don't give advice or my opinion unless it's solicited.

I find this notion on MN that you ‘can’t give friends unsolicited advice’ to be really quite odd. Posters seem to see the role of ‘friend’ as more like ‘counsellor’ - there to pick up the pieces when it all goes wrong, rather than help them steer away from the disaster to start with.

I would say something. ‘Just to check - this is what you really want? I just don’t want you to potentially lose out on motherhood in the next few years for him if he turns out not to be the one?’

My friends wouldn’t be offended at that at all, they’d just give me their answer. Is everyone really so sensitive these days? I’ve been very grateful for the honest advice I’ve received and it’s largely turned out to be correct.

Totally agree with this. Only on MN that friends can’t have open and honest conversations

user1477391263 · 15/09/2022 23:58

I predict there will be an avalanche of MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS posts, since this is Mumsnet and some people are addicted to that phrase on here.

The thing is, though, most of us do actually care about our friends' happiness (because they are friends, not total strangers), and some women just don't really have a clear idea about fertility decline.

You see celebrities having babies in their late 40s (usually with donated eggs, on the quiet) and it creates an unrealistic impression.

For every woman who can still get pregnant at 45, there will be at least one more who is already basically infertile at 35, and everything in between. And it's hard to know for sure which kind of woman you'll be more similar to.

LuckySantangelo35 · 15/09/2022 23:58

L0bstersLass · 15/09/2022 23:53

I left it until I was 35 and I was too late.
Interfere.

its hard though isn’t it cos she may be enjoying life as it now

and people can change their mind - she may have been all for mother hood before but now has changed her mind and wants to travel

let’s face it you only have to have a quick browse of mumsnet to be put off having a kid (and that’s no slur on mumsnetters, it’s the fact that motherhood often is hard and unrelentingly and soul destroying).

More and more older women are saying ‘nah… sod my fertile years! I wanna enjoy my life cos life is too short!’

SarahAndQuack · 15/09/2022 23:55

BlooberryBiskits · 15/09/2022 23:39

^ totally agree with this. It is optimistic at best.

I think you should suggest she gets fertility testing to see how much time she does have which will help her to think of it’s still a priority or not

But testing doesn't work like this at all.

If you have ovarian reserve tested, it can only really give you negative news. If she's had that, of course, she could know that, despite being young for it, she's unlikely to conceive naturally. But the converse isn't true. She could have an AMH level that indicates she has masses of eggs, but without actually getting into trying to fertilise them, there's no very reliable way to tell whether they're viable or not, and this is crucial.

At her age, you can easily find out that the fertility game is largely over, but you cannot find any reliable evidence you're fine to wait - not because you're not fine to wait, but because we don't currently have good diagnostics.

L0bstersLass · 15/09/2022 23:53

Friendworried · 15/09/2022 21:50

@EerieSilence i know. I know it’s none of my business but up until they met, being a mum was her biggest priority, to the point she was planning to do it alone.

I left it until I was 35 and I was too late.
Interfere.

BlooberryBiskits · 15/09/2022 23:39

Cattenberg · 15/09/2022 22:31

She can’t assume she has “at least another seven years to have kids”, though. If I were her friend, I’d be tempted to put her straight on that.

^ totally agree with this. It is optimistic at best.

I think you should suggest she gets fertility testing to see how much time she does have which will help her to think of it’s still a priority or not

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 15/09/2022 23:33

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 23:25

@WeeWillyWinkie9

I've seen this BS posted on here before

Maybe it was you that time too

Fertility has its biggest drop at 35-38 In terms of success rates

The drop is more significant when looking at 38-40 and 40-42 but the biggest % drop is from 30-35 and 35-38

It really doesn't at all. There is only a minimal difference. New studies show that it is minimal and the cliff edge is a myth.

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 23:25

@WeeWillyWinkie9

I've seen this BS posted on here before

Maybe it was you that time too

Fertility has its biggest drop at 35-38 In terms of success rates

The drop is more significant when looking at 38-40 and 40-42 but the biggest % drop is from 30-35 and 35-38

Swipe left for the next trending thread