Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is really what the queen wanted??

144 replies

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 21:31

Hospital appointments cancelled, funerals delayed and food banks closed. Businesses adopting ridiculous measures to prove how much they loved the queen and are mourning her. I guess, the queen can't be held responsible for the stupidity of businesses such as center parcs but didn't the media say that the event of her passing and the subsequent period of mourning were carefully planned and had her stamp of approval?

However, if she was the kind of person who would have wanted someone's medical appointment to be cancelled just because of her then doesn't that mean that she wasn't really that nice a person? In other words if she was as altruistic and service minded as we would like to think she was wouldn't she have been horrified by this circus and by what is happening apparently for the sake of mourning her passing?

And if this circus wasn't her idea then don't you think that either the royal family or the government are milking the death of an apparently not just highly respected but also beloved person purely for their advantage? Are they not going down in your esteem?

Yabu: we have to mark this historical event in as dramatic a way as possible and show in clear terms that we are in fact mourning. Besides you are not just mistaken but also very disrespectful. Off with your head.

Yanbu: yes, the proportion that this event has taken on is very worrying and it's a shame that the royal family, businesses and large parts of the country are all playing along with this populist jingoism.

OP posts:
Weefreetiffany · 15/09/2022 23:18

I Think the royal family should be paying for the whole shebang, not the tax payer. Charles saved a fair whack by not paying inheritance tax. At a time where cost of living is becoming hard for so many how can they justify allocating funds to this?

blubberyboo · 15/09/2022 23:16

My sister works in the NHS and when she started phoning people to reschedule a lot of them were surprised that she even phoned they just assumed it would be cancelled and they’d get another letter. Many of them were relieved because they didn’t want to miss the funeral themselves.

and if everything had gone ahead

I work in a different field and one day last week none of my customers turned up for their appointments with me because they were out on the streets watching Charles and Camilla arrive in town.

so imagine how many nhs appointments would have been wasted anyway with no shows!

many nhs staff will end up working Sundays to catch up the same way they have been doing since covid.

so Yabu

iamjustwinginglife · 15/09/2022 23:14

luxxlisbon · 15/09/2022 21:44

I really don’t think the reaction is disproportionate. I’m absolutely not a royalist but she was the monarch of Britain and the commonwealth for 70 years. I’m not even paying attention to the news etc but it is literally the biggest thing in the monarchy for over the 70 years and probably for some time to come, I don’t think the response/ coverage/ bank holiday is disproportionate.

This!!

She was our Queen. Of course the country should mourn her and if you don't want to then that's fine.

I wonder if the people who have had their appointments cancelled are as "outraged" as the people who are commenting 🤔

SuperCamp · 15/09/2022 23:14

OP, you seem to think the Queen and / or the Royal Family are responsible for decisions by independent organisations.

Although the ceremonies / content of services etc will have been either laid down by ye ancient tradition or decided in consultation with the Queen and her family and close advisors, the behaviour is the public and choices of organisations are down to them.

The Gvt website guide is very clear on this www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-demise-of-her-majesty-queen-elizabeth-ii-national-mourning-guidance/the-demise-of-her-majesty-queen-elizabeth-ii-national-mourning-guidance
^^
“There is no expectation on the public or organisations to observe specific behaviours during the mourning period

Public services will continue as usual, although there may be some changes to service availability on the day of the State Funeral”

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/09/2022 23:13

TempsPerdu · 15/09/2022 23:06

This what I don't understand: isn't all the inconvenience caused and the apparent show of self serving entitlement making the royal family less popular?

I think those of us who think it’s all a bit excessive are meant to look at the blanket media coverage and the teary vox pop tributes and the 5 mile queue and conclude that we are in a tiny minority.

I’m a royalist and I think the 5 mile queue is total and utter lunacy.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/09/2022 23:12

The Queen, above all, committed herself to duty and tradition and went to great lengths to uphold the significance of the monarchy. I think she’s want that importance and significance to still be upheld.

I think we need to stop making the mistake that all little old ladies are benevolent and selfless - I respected the Queen enormously, and have been devastate by her death…but no one but her family know her. I couldn’t describe her personality, not if you paid me to! That’s how she wanted it to be and how it should be - monarchs are not celebrities or caricatures. And so how would any of us know if she’s the type of woman who’d Fret over other people’s hospital appointments? Would she even give a shit? She did her job incredibly well but this ‘the Queen wouldn’t want this’ has to stop because none of us have a clue what her personal opinions would be. Just that she upheld her duty.

Bbqchicken · 15/09/2022 23:11

YANBU

Lisbeth50 · 15/09/2022 23:09

Regarding your second point: Was it and is it really that common? Having a monarch as the head of state is often compared to having a president but I don't remember many bank holidays being declared and so many services being cancelled when presidents have died.

I remember Ronald Reagan having a state funeral which involved the coffin on a gun carriage very much like the Queen's. I've just googled it and the period of mourning was 7 days, the coffin was transported to various places, he lay in state for 3 days with people queuing up to file past and the government was shut down on the day of the funeral. So quite similar really.

TempsPerdu · 15/09/2022 23:06

This what I don't understand: isn't all the inconvenience caused and the apparent show of self serving entitlement making the royal family less popular?

I think those of us who think it’s all a bit excessive are meant to look at the blanket media coverage and the teary vox pop tributes and the 5 mile queue and conclude that we are in a tiny minority.

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 23:00

TempsPerdu · 15/09/2022 22:52

When it all comes down to it, none of this is really about the Queen, or what she wanted after her death. As others have said, at its heart all the pomp and circumstance is about establishing Charles as our new monarch and shoring up support for the monarchy. Maintaining the status quo, essentially, and avoiding any vacuum where people might begin to question the idea of a hereditary monarchy. The take-home message for her subjects is: ‘this is how things were; the is how things are; this is how things will always be.’

As I heard someone point out on the radio this morning, we now have the technology to run a pretty efficient timed ticket system for the lying in state, so the massive queue needn’t have been a thing. But the optics of having streams of people shuffle along in a queue for hours, pilgrimage style, is obviously better for giving the impression of an establishment that has overwhelming public support.

This what I don't understand: isn't all the inconvenience caused and the apparent show of self serving entitlement making the royal family less popular? Wouldn't most people think that this whole thing is a bit unnecessary and distasteful especially when it's causing suffering for real people.

OP posts:
Cattenberg · 15/09/2022 22:59

Someone told me that the Queen’s funeral couldn’t be held on a Sunday, as that wasn’t the tradition.

I’m not keen on tradition for tradition’s sake. I think we should keep the traditions that still work and ditch the ones that don’t. The country’s infrastructure clearly can’t cope well when a bank holiday is called at short notice. Issues with childcare and transport force some essential services to grind to a halt.

bellac11 · 15/09/2022 22:57

An employer doesnt have to give the holiday on that day, so its not hard to organise a skeleton staff at all, you simply say we are remaining open and some of you can take the day off but I need a couple of people who want to work but I cant allow everyone to take Monday as a BH so either draw straws or volunteer to work it

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 22:55

bellac11 · 15/09/2022 22:50

Its nothing to do with the RF or the queen whether businesses cancel things

The argument about businesses having to close because schools are shut, well most of them are open on normal bank holidays, hospitals are, holiday parks are so this is nonsense

Whats happened is that businesses are shutting in some fake 'respect' thing, otherwise you wouldnt have had organisations like British Cycling instructing their club members not to go cycling on Monday!!!!

Ive had operations and even outpatient appointments on bank holidays before, we always eat out or we're on holiday on bank holidays so theres no reason for things to shut just because schools are shut, where do they get staff from on those days normally?

There are enough people who are not interested in the funeral for businesses to run a skeleton staff on Monday and then those same people take their BH another day as annual leave later on.

I think, it's a combination of both . Since the bank holiday is so sudden it's difficult to make arrangements maybe to organise skeleton staff. I don't know. I prefer to think that employers are pushed into this rather than that they are just hoping to get brownie points with their conservative clientele by being sadder than thou.

OP posts:
TempsPerdu · 15/09/2022 22:52

When it all comes down to it, none of this is really about the Queen, or what she wanted after her death. As others have said, at its heart all the pomp and circumstance is about establishing Charles as our new monarch and shoring up support for the monarchy. Maintaining the status quo, essentially, and avoiding any vacuum where people might begin to question the idea of a hereditary monarchy. The take-home message for her subjects is: ‘this is how things were; the is how things are; this is how things will always be.’

As I heard someone point out on the radio this morning, we now have the technology to run a pretty efficient timed ticket system for the lying in state, so the massive queue needn’t have been a thing. But the optics of having streams of people shuffle along in a queue for hours, pilgrimage style, is obviously better for giving the impression of an establishment that has overwhelming public support.

donquixotedelamancha · 15/09/2022 22:51

YABU. This is exactly what she wanted. She planned most of this.

Her entire life was about showing up to places, normal life stopping and people marvelling at the pomp because their betters had arrived.

She spent her entire life in unimaginable opulence, with everyone deferring to her in every way; all paid for by her subjects.

She would have had neither clue nor interest about the lives of those inconvenienced by all this, such trivialities were beneath her.

This is what we owe her for her wonderful lifetime of service.

bellac11 · 15/09/2022 22:50

Its nothing to do with the RF or the queen whether businesses cancel things

The argument about businesses having to close because schools are shut, well most of them are open on normal bank holidays, hospitals are, holiday parks are so this is nonsense

Whats happened is that businesses are shutting in some fake 'respect' thing, otherwise you wouldnt have had organisations like British Cycling instructing their club members not to go cycling on Monday!!!!

Ive had operations and even outpatient appointments on bank holidays before, we always eat out or we're on holiday on bank holidays so theres no reason for things to shut just because schools are shut, where do they get staff from on those days normally?

There are enough people who are not interested in the funeral for businesses to run a skeleton staff on Monday and then those same people take their BH another day as annual leave later on.

MyLovelyPen · 15/09/2022 22:49

I don’t think she was a particularly nice person tbh 🤷‍♀️ and yes I absolutely think the bread and circuses is exactly what she would have wanted. The serfs need to know their place - and man do they revel in the servitude 😳.

BigFatLiar · 15/09/2022 22:44

Just because it's been made a holiday doesn't mean your employer needs to give it. Depends what your contract says.

Most big events like this come with a bank holiday, the jubilee was a long weekend difference being everyone had time to plan, the Queen dying while expected wasn't on a schedule.

MichaelAndEagle · 15/09/2022 22:39

Surgery hasn't been cancelled at the NHS Trust i work for, and lots of other appointments are going ahead too. Individual trusts have been left to decide.

I don't really know what I think the answer to your question is I must admit. Funeral on a Sunday certainly would have made a lot of things easier.

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 22:37

user1471427614 · 15/09/2022 22:35

I dont believe she would have wanted hospital appointments cancelled. I've been waiting over 6 months for my young son's appointment which is now cancelled. Who's know how long and how much additional pain he will be in. I'm sure she wouldnt have wanted people to suffer.

I'm so sorry to hear that. I hope he'll get a new appointment soon!!

OP posts:
MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 22:35

PurpleWisteria · 15/09/2022 22:22

A lot of cancellations are so that people can watch the funeral, as I understand it.

Staff have told bosses they will stay home even if places were open.

Hardly her late majesty's fault.

I think a lot of cancellations are because the government declared a bank holiday. Once schools and nurseries said that they will close many other places didn't really have a choice but to give their employees a holiday.

I'm happy I'm getting a holiday but on balance I don't think it's worth someone else having their medical appointment cancelled. I remember how long my dad always has to wait for any kind of appointment and how relieved we always are when he finally gets an appointment. If his surgery had been cancelled we would have all been immensely stressed. Is it worth causing someone this kind of distress and other complications (also for other important services) just for a gesture? What is more important in real terms? A living person requiring help or a gesture to show respect for a dead person?

OP posts:
user1471427614 · 15/09/2022 22:35

I dont believe she would have wanted hospital appointments cancelled. I've been waiting over 6 months for my young son's appointment which is now cancelled. Who's know how long and how much additional pain he will be in. I'm sure she wouldnt have wanted people to suffer.

walkingonsunshinekat · 15/09/2022 22:28

luxxlisbon · 15/09/2022 21:44

I really don’t think the reaction is disproportionate. I’m absolutely not a royalist but she was the monarch of Britain and the commonwealth for 70 years. I’m not even paying attention to the news etc but it is literally the biggest thing in the monarchy for over the 70 years and probably for some time to come, I don’t think the response/ coverage/ bank holiday is disproportionate.

I do, its bonkers!

She is dead, not coming back & had no real power and treating her passing like a Pharaoh is beyond crazy.

Who really gives a fuck? in RL, i'm just not seeing it. Even if 4m turn up in London om Monday (authorities est 1m) that still leaves approx 64m who didn't.

No idea if this is what she wanted, probably was.

I think we may look back on this in much the same way as we do about lockdown.

LampLighter414 · 15/09/2022 22:27

Yep it is what she wanted. She believed in her god given right to be Queen and wants her family to remain billionaire monarchs for as long as possible. Maximum pomp, disruption and center stage for Charles to swoop in and continue like nothing has happened and before the plebs can bother to question whether they actually need the biggest benefits claimants in the country anymore

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 22:26

LovingTheseAutumnSnippets · 15/09/2022 21:52

Presidents are flying in to pay their respects, monarchs also. Many of the most important people in the world are coming here to pay their respects to someone who influenced the world for 70 years, but her own subjects can’t even pay her a bit of respect.

Yes, NHS should remain open and carry on important treatment, but other things, no.

I’m getting weary of the virtue signalling on this website.

Could you please explain what you mean by virtue signalling as I don't see how it applies in this context.

OP posts: