Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is really what the queen wanted??

144 replies

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 21:31

Hospital appointments cancelled, funerals delayed and food banks closed. Businesses adopting ridiculous measures to prove how much they loved the queen and are mourning her. I guess, the queen can't be held responsible for the stupidity of businesses such as center parcs but didn't the media say that the event of her passing and the subsequent period of mourning were carefully planned and had her stamp of approval?

However, if she was the kind of person who would have wanted someone's medical appointment to be cancelled just because of her then doesn't that mean that she wasn't really that nice a person? In other words if she was as altruistic and service minded as we would like to think she was wouldn't she have been horrified by this circus and by what is happening apparently for the sake of mourning her passing?

And if this circus wasn't her idea then don't you think that either the royal family or the government are milking the death of an apparently not just highly respected but also beloved person purely for their advantage? Are they not going down in your esteem?

Yabu: we have to mark this historical event in as dramatic a way as possible and show in clear terms that we are in fact mourning. Besides you are not just mistaken but also very disrespectful. Off with your head.

Yanbu: yes, the proportion that this event has taken on is very worrying and it's a shame that the royal family, businesses and large parts of the country are all playing along with this populist jingoism.

OP posts:
MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 13:33

Lemonyfuckit · 16/09/2022 10:31

I agree OP. I'm not a royalist but I liked the Queen - her stoicism and sense of duty and public service. I think it's fitting that there is a degree of pomp and circumstance to this, but yes, completely agree it's gone too far, and is anathema to that very sense of duty we're all professing to admire so much. I do not believe she would have wanted things like medical appointments and other people's funerals cancelled 'out of respect'. The Centre Parcs stuff is ludicrous. I think it massively suits the government to encourage this OTT fawning 24/7 rolling news coverage / absolutely everything must stop in light of the period of national mourning (effectively no government scrutiny at present) - it's all bread and circuses isn't it.

Yes..maybe I'm cynical but I thought the timing is perfect for Liz truss. All she has to do at the moment is wear black, look sombre and express her condolences..much easier than actually talking about the difficult issues affecting the country and its people at the moment.

OP posts:
MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 13:28

GoneWithTheWine1 · 16/09/2022 08:06

Hospital cancelled my sons peadtirican appointment for Monday and guess when they rescheduled it for...?

30th JANUARY 2023!

It's a absolute disgrace. My son needs to see his doctor as his medication isn't working and is making him very unwell and all I'm getting from the hospital is "oh well we have extreme back logs right now we can't help it."

It's all backwards.

Omg that's crazy. I'm so sorry. I feel for people who have had their appointments cancelled. My DD was seeing a pediatrician for a few years to investigate several things and every time I eagerly awaited these appointments. If any of them had got cancelled I would have been beside myself (as I was with my dad when his appointment got postponed)

Can you contact your GP to ask him him to fast track his reference? Surely a medication review can't wait for another 4 months.

OP posts:
DownNative · 16/09/2022 13:17

Cattenberg · 16/09/2022 12:42

DownNative, I was giving a few examples of how essential services are interdependent, so the closure (or reduced service) of one will affect another, especially if the change happens with little notice. What proof do you need of this?

This post is still a Strawman Argument Fallacy since I was challenging someone else on their assertion that childcare issues was leading to NHS cancellations.

It was always one of my points that other explanations were available.

You're incorrect that I asked for evidence of knock on effects on various organisations. Hence, Strawman Argument Fallacy.

You need to read what someone says more carefully.

Pedallleur · 16/09/2022 12:44

70 yrs since the last one. the Beatles/Stones were children. men wore hats and people were working in factories. Women were nott allowed mortgages unless their husbands were there and cars were few. World changed and maybe the funeral idea hasn't apart from being televised.

Cattenberg · 16/09/2022 12:42

DownNative, I was giving a few examples of how essential services are interdependent, so the closure (or reduced service) of one will affect another, especially if the change happens with little notice. What proof do you need of this?

DancingBudgie · 16/09/2022 12:34

Neither the queen nor the rest of that family give a shit about ' their public '.
She gives even less of a shit now she's dead.
If anyone thinks they do then they're deluded.

DownNative · 16/09/2022 12:22

Cattenberg · 16/09/2022 10:48

Down Native, not all hospital appointments for Monday have been cancelled, but some have, including mine.

Many patients have children in school or nursery, and some won’t be able attend medical appointments without alternative childcare. (I couldn’t have taken my four-year-old to my appointment).

Many school staff have children in nursery, so couldn’t teach on Monday even if they wanted to.

Many patients and staff rely on public transport to get to work or to medical appointments and the service is normally reduced on bank holidays.

Can’t you see how announcing a bank holiday at short notice causes widespread disruption to essential services?

@Cattenberg Think you'll find I did not argue all hospital appointments for Monday have been cancelled. The various NHS Trusts I looked at simply state that SOME may be affected and they'd contact patients affected. So, that's a Strawman Argument Fallacy you started with.

Your second paragraph - Strawman Argument Fallacy again as I've said nothing about patients who've cancelled due to their own circumstances.

Your third paragraph - Strawman Argument Fallacy again for same reasons.

Your fourth - another Strawman Argument Fallacy.

Your last - Strawman Argument Fallacy again as I didn't argue otherwise. The point I was making to someone else you decided to respond to is they've no evidence that childcare issues literally leads to some cancellations. There are other possibilities available to explain any cancellations. It looks like you're relying on Appeal To Probability Fallacy at the end there. Remember that correlation is not causation.

Clavinova · 16/09/2022 12:15

if all the dads have to work?
Are most men not having the day off work on Monday?

Anon778833 · 16/09/2022 12:12

It’s over the top but the Queen’s wishes wouldn’t ever have been taken into consideration. It’s not about her wishes. That’s why the monarchy is outdated.

Clavinova · 16/09/2022 12:11

Cattenberg
I am, as it happens. But in most two-parent families I know, both parents work. And guess who usually picks up the kids?

Why are the nurseries shut in your scenario if all the dads have to work?

Yesthatismychildsigh · 16/09/2022 12:02

I doubt very much the Queen or any of the royals give the slightest thought to any of the ‘subjects’ or their lives. As long as there’s pomp and glitter it’ll bring some popularity from certain types for a while. Thus maintaining their ridiculous position.

Cattenberg · 16/09/2022 11:59

*two-parent families

Cattenberg · 16/09/2022 11:57

I am, as it happens. But in most two-families I know, both parents work. And guess who usually picks up the kids?

Clavinova · 16/09/2022 11:48

Many school staff have children in nursery, so couldn’t teach on Monday even if they wanted to.

Are most people single parents these days?

Clavinova · 16/09/2022 11:38

Poland shut down for Pope John Paul II in 2005 (the funeral took place in Rome) - Charles and Camilla were obliged to postpone their wedding by 24 hours:

With Friday declared a national holiday for the funeral, shops, local and international schools, banks and even the busy Warsaw stock exchange were shut.
www.irishexaminer.com/world/arid-10099527.html

Even before the formal announcement by Clarence House, diplomatic sources had made it clear that the prime minister would be attending the [Pope's] funeral instead of the royal wedding.

The Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Rowan Williams, who was due to bless the prince's wedding in a service at St George's Chapel in Windsor Castle on Friday also made it clear he wished to go to Rome.

The prince's acceptance of the inevitable came as the sheer scale of the Vatican obsequies became clear; more than 200 world leaders, including 100 heads of state, are expected to be present.

www.theguardian.com/uk/2005/apr/05/monarchy.catholicism#:~:text=Prince%20Charles%20headed%20off%20a,II%20in%20Rome%20on%20Friday.

Cattenberg · 16/09/2022 10:48

Down Native, not all hospital appointments for Monday have been cancelled, but some have, including mine.

Many patients have children in school or nursery, and some won’t be able attend medical appointments without alternative childcare. (I couldn’t have taken my four-year-old to my appointment).

Many school staff have children in nursery, so couldn’t teach on Monday even if they wanted to.

Many patients and staff rely on public transport to get to work or to medical appointments and the service is normally reduced on bank holidays.

Can’t you see how announcing a bank holiday at short notice causes widespread disruption to essential services?

gatehouseoffleet · 16/09/2022 10:36

RoseAndRose · 15/09/2022 21:34

I don't really like the hyperbole you chose to use in outlining the YABU option.

What is happening now is normal for state funerals - and was happening with huge crowds in the days before social media - but we have collectively forgotten that.

Actually it wasn't like this with George VI - most sporting events carried on for example.

I don't know what day his funeral fell on, if it was at a weekend, it would have been much less disruptive anyway.

MiniCooperLover · 16/09/2022 10:33

The Queen was fully aware of what would happen when she passed, she wouldn't be unaware at all that the country would fall over themselves to show how much they cared, no I care more, no I do, etc. At the end of the day she had an ego and definitely knew how things would go. That said, I imagine her plans might have been made a while ago before the world seemed determined to end itself over oil/gas/employment and she might be sad to know that all the pomp and ceremony was overtaking.

I think it should have been on a Sunday, with a bank holiday given at a later date for all to enjoy when it wasn't such a rush for businesses to try and figure out what to do, when Supermarkets weren't struggling to fill the shelves already let alone when people are rushing because god forbid all the food shops are shut for one day. That side of it is all poor planning.

Lemonyfuckit · 16/09/2022 10:31

I agree OP. I'm not a royalist but I liked the Queen - her stoicism and sense of duty and public service. I think it's fitting that there is a degree of pomp and circumstance to this, but yes, completely agree it's gone too far, and is anathema to that very sense of duty we're all professing to admire so much. I do not believe she would have wanted things like medical appointments and other people's funerals cancelled 'out of respect'. The Centre Parcs stuff is ludicrous. I think it massively suits the government to encourage this OTT fawning 24/7 rolling news coverage / absolutely everything must stop in light of the period of national mourning (effectively no government scrutiny at present) - it's all bread and circuses isn't it.

rubbishatballet · 16/09/2022 10:28

@DownNative where have I said that NHS trusts are closed? Mine certainly isn't - all urgent and emergency care is running as it would for any bank holiday. What I'm saying/have said is that it's a planning nightmare that the NHS could do without at this short notice, and that it's likely that a large proportion of elective work will need to be stood down due to staffing issues (related primarily, but not only, to childcare).

hewouldwouldnthe · 16/09/2022 10:25

It's a bank holiday. Everything closes on a Sunday so it's the same.

DownNative · 16/09/2022 10:17

rubbishatballet · 16/09/2022 10:12

"It's plainly obvious I'm asking you to demonstrate with evidence that the NHS Trusts are unable to provide enough staff due to your claimed childcare issue, for example."

But what evidence do you expect to be in the public domain at this point? It's literally all still being worked out as I write!

Then, quite frankly, I'd advise you not to make those kinds of assertions.

It does not necessarily follow that childcare issues are impacting NHS Trusts to the point they need to close. Especially since others have stated their Trusts aren't shut and still doing their scheduled appointments.

rubbishatballet · 16/09/2022 10:12

"It's plainly obvious I'm asking you to demonstrate with evidence that the NHS Trusts are unable to provide enough staff due to your claimed childcare issue, for example."

But what evidence do you expect to be in the public domain at this point? It's literally all still being worked out as I write!

DownNative · 16/09/2022 10:05

rubbishatballet · 16/09/2022 09:24

Sorry @DownNative are you asking me to provide evidence that there are a large number of people working in the NHS that are between, say, 25 and 55 years old? Probably some staff survey data online somewhere, but I'm not going to go hunting for it as clearly your point is ridiculous. And apologies not to have provided any additional evidence to back up my assumption that 25 to 55 is the age range most likely to have childcare responsibilities - I could be way off there Confused.

My final paragraph relates to what the 'choice' that you say NHS senior leaders have, is actually boiling down to in a lot of cases.

It's plainly obvious I'm asking you to demonstrate with evidence that the NHS Trusts are unable to provide enough staff due to your claimed childcare issue, for example.

You asserting such without a shred of evidence is just as bad as someone asserting the exact opposite without a shred of evidence.

Both can be dismissed without evidence too.

No, your final paragraph deals with a Strawman Argument Fallacy and your new addition also relies on the False Dilemma Fallacy too. You're suggesting there's just two possibilities for NHS Trusts to choose from. Again, without a shred of evidence.

If you're not prepared, able or willing to support your assertions with evidence, it's nest not to make them in the first place.

apintortwo · 16/09/2022 09:54

YANBU circus was exactly the word I used the other day to describe this drawn out virtue signalling and sentimental nonsense

Calling people's grief a 'circus' says it all really...