Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is really what the queen wanted??

144 replies

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 15/09/2022 21:31

Hospital appointments cancelled, funerals delayed and food banks closed. Businesses adopting ridiculous measures to prove how much they loved the queen and are mourning her. I guess, the queen can't be held responsible for the stupidity of businesses such as center parcs but didn't the media say that the event of her passing and the subsequent period of mourning were carefully planned and had her stamp of approval?

However, if she was the kind of person who would have wanted someone's medical appointment to be cancelled just because of her then doesn't that mean that she wasn't really that nice a person? In other words if she was as altruistic and service minded as we would like to think she was wouldn't she have been horrified by this circus and by what is happening apparently for the sake of mourning her passing?

And if this circus wasn't her idea then don't you think that either the royal family or the government are milking the death of an apparently not just highly respected but also beloved person purely for their advantage? Are they not going down in your esteem?

Yabu: we have to mark this historical event in as dramatic a way as possible and show in clear terms that we are in fact mourning. Besides you are not just mistaken but also very disrespectful. Off with your head.

Yanbu: yes, the proportion that this event has taken on is very worrying and it's a shame that the royal family, businesses and large parts of the country are all playing along with this populist jingoism.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sunglassesonthetable · 17/09/2022 22:27

The truth hurts.

Sorry, are we doing lyrics or something?

BambinaJAS · 17/09/2022 21:55

sunglassesonthetable · 17/09/2022 15:37

*Lets be 100% clear here..

This is not patriotism. Its enforced nationalism run amok.

Not surprised you are unable to tell the difference.*

Enforced Nationalism? You sure? What liked North Korea or something?

Loving the comedy gold of " let's be 100% clear here" though.

The truth hurts.

This is precisely why England is in decline.

And no, it will just get worse from here. Too many delusional people running around the country.

sunglassesonthetable · 17/09/2022 15:37

*Lets be 100% clear here..

This is not patriotism. Its enforced nationalism run amok.

Not surprised you are unable to tell the difference.*

Enforced Nationalism? You sure? What liked North Korea or something?

Loving the comedy gold of " let's be 100% clear here" though.

FrazzleDazz · 17/09/2022 15:35

We have remained open (engineering firm) but have the staff were given an option to have it off if they wanted to, but it would be down to their own holiday allowance to cover. Businesses are not obliged to give it as holiday, nor should they have to foot bill in such uncertain economic times. About 85% are coming in on Monday after being offered a choice. I am off but it because I have holiday left, if I didn't I would go in without question.

mycatisannoying · 17/09/2022 15:28

Truth is, she didn't really give much of a shit.

bellac11 · 17/09/2022 15:09

BambinaJAS · 17/09/2022 12:16

Lets be 100% clear here..

This is not patriotism. Its enforced nationalism run amok.

Not surprised you are unable to tell the difference.

I think you might have made an error about what the difference is between patriotism and nationalism.

In what way is it nationalist to commemorate the death of the monarch of a number of nations and head of the commonwealth?

GlassDeli · 17/09/2022 15:04

Lets be 100% clear here.

It's clearly your opinion, but that's all.

This is not patriotism. Its enforced nationalism run amok.

I disagree. Who exactly is 'enforcing' it? Anyone who isn't interested can do what they do on other occasions they aren't interested in, such as the May bank holiday, Halloween or Christmas.

There are instances where some things have been cancelled which some of us might disagree with, like medical appointments. However, the other 99 per cent of what is happening on this one-off occasion is appropriate.

Do you also complain about the other bank holidays during the year, where people also have the day off work?

Not surprised you are unable to tell the difference.

And you've rounded off with a personal attack. Well done you Biscuit

BambinaJAS · 17/09/2022 12:16

GlassDeli · 16/09/2022 23:15

I think she deserves this send-off and paying of respects, not least because she wasn't actually a showy, ostentatious person. She lived up to her promise to do her duty and serve her country, for many decades. That obviously involved wealth. But that aside, she was happy with her headscarf and horses.

doesn't that mean that she wasn't really that nice a person?

Do you think a smug, selfish, attention seeking type should get the ceremonial treatment instead, just because it is 'what they would have wanted'?

People who work at Center Parcs etc. should also have the opportunity to experience the ceremony on Monday. No doubt the big bosses will give themselves the day off, so why should those on the 'shop floor' miss these important events? Obviously vital services will continue, but this is such a unique circumstance that I think the bank holiday is the right call.

It isn't 'populist jingoism'. Many of us think the Queen was deservedly popular because of her character and behaviour. Surely it isn't impossible to be popular for good reason, or does the word 'populist' invariably have to be pasted on top?

Patriotism isn't jingoism. There is actually nothing wrong with liking your country and the Queen, or taking part in your own country's cultural traditions. Obviously Britain hasn't always got it right, but nor has anywhere else. Yet, around the globe, most people are happy to be positive and proud of their own country. It seems it's just the British who enjoy self flagellation and virtue signalling.

Lets be 100% clear here..

This is not patriotism. Its enforced nationalism run amok.

Not surprised you are unable to tell the difference.

RancidOldHag · 17/09/2022 07:37

antelopevalley · 16/09/2022 23:05

I agree you do not normally cancel events during a 10-day period of mourning. So many things have been cancelled to avoid a backlash from royalists.

I suggest you read up on national mourning for a monarch.

This is vastly more 'light touch' than has ever happened before

GlassDeli · 16/09/2022 23:15

I think she deserves this send-off and paying of respects, not least because she wasn't actually a showy, ostentatious person. She lived up to her promise to do her duty and serve her country, for many decades. That obviously involved wealth. But that aside, she was happy with her headscarf and horses.

doesn't that mean that she wasn't really that nice a person?

Do you think a smug, selfish, attention seeking type should get the ceremonial treatment instead, just because it is 'what they would have wanted'?

People who work at Center Parcs etc. should also have the opportunity to experience the ceremony on Monday. No doubt the big bosses will give themselves the day off, so why should those on the 'shop floor' miss these important events? Obviously vital services will continue, but this is such a unique circumstance that I think the bank holiday is the right call.

It isn't 'populist jingoism'. Many of us think the Queen was deservedly popular because of her character and behaviour. Surely it isn't impossible to be popular for good reason, or does the word 'populist' invariably have to be pasted on top?

Patriotism isn't jingoism. There is actually nothing wrong with liking your country and the Queen, or taking part in your own country's cultural traditions. Obviously Britain hasn't always got it right, but nor has anywhere else. Yet, around the globe, most people are happy to be positive and proud of their own country. It seems it's just the British who enjoy self flagellation and virtue signalling.

antelopevalley · 16/09/2022 23:05

I agree you do not normally cancel events during a 10-day period of mourning. So many things have been cancelled to avoid a backlash from royalists.

bellac11 · 16/09/2022 22:50

I didnt say it was mostly only emergency services that are operating, you're suffering from the mumsnet curse of making things up that people havent said.

Lots of businesses are open, pubs, restaurants, shops etc.

And the ones that are not, thats their business decision

Lots of events take place on bank holidays so I dont understand your meaning

At the end of the day, some business will decide to close either or both because their own staff dont want work and/or their customers are likely not to want to go out and be customers.

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 22:41

bellac11 · 16/09/2022 21:24

It would interesting to get the facts about how many NHS trust actively cancelled appointments and their reasons,, such as something which was pointed out that they dont want a lot of no shows and wasted time

Anywhere else that isnt normally open on a bank holiday wont be open, not much difference.

If businesses choose to close, like centre parcs although that might have changed that now, that is their choice. a stupid choice if you ask me but nevertheless their own business decision.

Emergency services are still functioning

Normal bank holidays are very different to a bank holiday that has been declared just a week ago. On other bank holidays institutes don't need to cancel events because they wouldn't have planned them to occur in the first place.

And do you really think it's great if it's mostly only emergency services that are functioning?

OP posts:
bellac11 · 16/09/2022 21:24

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 21:08

Just read this thread.

It would interesting to get the facts about how many NHS trust actively cancelled appointments and their reasons,, such as something which was pointed out that they dont want a lot of no shows and wasted time

Anywhere else that isnt normally open on a bank holiday wont be open, not much difference.

If businesses choose to close, like centre parcs although that might have changed that now, that is their choice. a stupid choice if you ask me but nevertheless their own business decision.

Emergency services are still functioning

L1f30fp1 · 16/09/2022 21:16

God give over with these threads, they’re so tedious,it’s one day!!!!The vast majority of people want the day off and to watch the funeral. You don’t, live with it. Our local food banks aren’t open every day anyway. Trot on down to your local food bank and volunteer if you feel that strongly.

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 21:08

bellac11 · 16/09/2022 21:07

Who has said that, and are they the majority of the public?

Just read this thread.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 16/09/2022 21:07

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 21:05

It's adulation when people say it's ok to cancel NHS appointments or food banks because the queen has died and it's more important to mark her passing.

Who has said that, and are they the majority of the public?

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 21:05

bellac11 · 16/09/2022 21:02

Is it adulation?

I certainly am not experiencing that myself but am glued to the proceedings because I like the entertainment, the processes, the uniforms, the colour, the choreography, learning about the history

It's adulation when people say it's ok to cancel NHS appointments or food banks because the queen has died and it's more important to mark her passing.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 16/09/2022 21:02

Is it adulation?

I certainly am not experiencing that myself but am glued to the proceedings because I like the entertainment, the processes, the uniforms, the colour, the choreography, learning about the history

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 20:51

I thought better of the queen and Charles before all this. I never had astrong opinion but I think I can see why a republic is preferable. This blind adulation and attitude that anything is acceptable just because it concerns the queen is worrying. The fact that people don't care that living people are made to suffer more for the sake of a gesture towards a dead person is incredible and the idea that we ALL need to be respectful and be seen to be respectful is scary.

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 16/09/2022 15:52

Harry & Mag could have done their bit to modernise it but they choose not to.

They had tons of support but decided it wasn't the job for them.

Coybubbles · 16/09/2022 14:14

If GP and hospital appointments are being cancelled then it’s an absolute farce.

Im so sick of hearing about King Charles 3rd and how the media are bigging him up. When he was grimacing at the help for not removing that pen case or some such thing he just came across as a petulant twit. Andrew is still parading around after doing god knows what…it’s the height of arrogance…and everyone has forgotten how awful Charles and Camilla were to poor Diana.

I still have respect for the Queen but some of that was lost when she bailed out her little prince rather than make him face the music. It just felt like she knew the end was coming so she put family above country this time.

When this is all over I think the monarchy should be abolished. Harry and Meg could have modernised it and when they walked around I saw a genuine connection between them and the younger generation….whether people like it or not ,young people connected to their woke-ness and warmth and the diversity they could offer. The royal family shot themselves in the foot there.

Topseyt123 · 16/09/2022 13:49

5128gap · 15/09/2022 21:57

If the queen thought along the lines of most sensible people, I doubt it would have crossed her mind that people would be so ludicrous as to fail to differentiate between things that needed to continue like surgeries, funerals, providing food, and things that could be closed for the morning so people could watch her funeral.
I can't quite believe that people responsible for vital services have interpreted the bank holiday in this way, and I find it actually quite frightening they have excercised such poor judgement. It feels like the responsible adults have left the building.

This would also be my take on it. What is happening in some quarters is a ludicrous overreaction.

Surgery and urgent medical appointments should be going ahead. Guests should not have faced a 24 hour eviction by a holiday company (Center Parcs) with most having nowhere to go.

Common sense needs to prevail.

MyMourningIsSadderThanYours · 16/09/2022 13:37

Just to be clear.. I'm not saying that if the queen had wanted this madness it's ok or we should carry out all her wishes.

What I'm saying is that there is an incongruence that doesn't compute for me: if the queen wanted this disruption of people's lives to honour her passing and ensure the continuity of the crown then obviously she wasn't as service minded and altruistic as we would like to think she was and therefore doesn't deserve to have people suffer for her.

If she didn't want it then why are we doing it?

OP posts:
jokingfox · 16/09/2022 13:35

I was genuinely sad when I heard her passing, end of an era etc but now cannot wait until this is over. I think the moment the schools were announced to be closed at such short notice was so obvious this was all going to happen. The schools could have watched the funeral on screen and managed the minutes silence even better marking forcing down their throats this 'historical' event. I don't know any family in school or outside of school now who is going to make their way to London or Windsor to take their children to watch it live. Maybe local families who live on route might but the majority won't due to logistics, affordability and are not that bothered. I think if I had a school aged child I would have preferred dc to be at school watching it and absorbing it whereas at home dc would be pottering around but anyway. Whilst planning all of this to ensure Charles is strategically accepted in his role, we will have a generation of children who's not going to give a shit when this happens all over again in 20 years time. Attitudes change very quickly especially in time.