Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sadder about Eddie Butler than the Queen? 🤷🏼‍♀️

40 replies

emsiewill · 15/09/2022 19:20

Just heard the news that Eddie Butler has died in his sleep while on a trek in Peru. Raising money for prostate cancer. Only 65.

www.bbc.co.uk/sport/rugby-union/62919134

Now he is someone that^^ I really will miss. The voice of so many rugby matches as well as many other occasions which required the gravitas that he could bring to voiceovers. Only yesterday a segment about Westminster Hall was played on the BBC with him doing the voiceover. A sad day. 😢

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
emsiewill · 16/09/2022 13:22

hamdden12 · 16/09/2022 07:24

I'm Welsh and yes it's sad but I feel the Queen has been a bigger part of our lives and I don't think you can compare the diplomatic work she's done for all those years to commenting on rugby.

I'm not comparing the work they've done, and I'm not speaking for anyone else. I'm just saying that personally I feel sadder about him than I do about the Queen.

OP posts:
DrivingCadillacsInOurDreams · 16/09/2022 07:41

Totally with you on this!! His death has really shocked me, such a loss to the rugby world - and not just for the Welsh!

ParanoidGynodroid · 16/09/2022 07:35

You can be sad about whomever you like. People touch our lives in different ways and mean different things to us. Part of the shock and sadness with Eddie is that he was not very old. The queen was a monumental figure, and few of us will have known anything other than her reign; however, she was 96, so it's been expected.

My old dog has not long left... when he goes I know I'll be much sadder than I have been for recent human family members who have passed!

hamdden12 · 16/09/2022 07:24

emsiewill · 15/09/2022 19:44

I'm waiting for someone else who is Welsh to come along and back me up on this. He was a legend, taken far too soon. I'm sure even if you don't know his name, you would recognise his voice from many major sporting and national, occasions.

Here's one example

I'm Welsh and yes it's sad but I feel the Queen has been a bigger part of our lives and I don't think you can compare the diplomatic work she's done for all those years to commenting on rugby.

Needesppressonow · 16/09/2022 07:17

I’m Welsh by the way but my English husband is equally as shocked and sad. I loved listening him and Brian Moore as a double act commentary team

Olamiamore · 15/09/2022 22:59

I'm Welsh and totally shocked by this. Eddie and Bill McClaren were the voices of rugby for my lifetime so far. He seemed like such a lovely man.

I do understand what you mean as it's more of a shock than the Queen, given she was 96 and clearly frail. However I wouldn't say I'm more saddened by Eddie passing but it feels more personal somehow - perhaps as he is similar in age to my dad who is also an old Welsh rugby player.

WelshMoth · 15/09/2022 22:52

A brilliant wordsmith, an amazing player, an Oxford Graduate (French and Spanish), a patriot and proud Welshman. We've shed a tear in this household - Eddie Butler will absolutely be missed.

RIP Eddie. Cwsg yn dda, Cawr o Gymru. You are already sorely missed. Daffodil

noworklifebalance · 15/09/2022 22:38

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 15/09/2022 20:55

Surely we can be sad about both losses? Grief isn't a finite emotion , we can share it between as many loved ones as we want to..!

I may have misinterpreted the OP and I may generally be waaay of base here, but my feeling is that there are many more random celebs that have touched or been a part of people’s lives to a far greater extent than the Queen.
For most, I suspect, she was just in the background not really impacting on our lives in any meaningful way. The apparent outpouring of grief are just people (not all, mind) wanting to be a part of a historical moment rather than mourning the loss of someone.

emsiewill · 15/09/2022 22:06

Spinstdu · 15/09/2022 20:52

Rugby commentary will never be the same without him.
He had a magnificent voice for broadcasting and his partnership with Brian Moore was the best.

Speaking of Brian Moore...😢

To be sadder about Eddie Butler than the Queen? 🤷🏼‍♀️
OP posts:
emsiewill · 15/09/2022 22:03

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 15/09/2022 20:55

Surely we can be sad about both losses? Grief isn't a finite emotion , we can share it between as many loved ones as we want to..!

Absolutely! And I didn't say I'm not sad about the Queen, just that I'm sadder about Eddie Butler.

OP posts:
FartOutLoudDay · 15/09/2022 20:58

Oh gosh, I hadn’t heard the news until I saw this thread. Can’t believe it. Watching rugby just won’t be the same at all. I’m with you OP, a real shock and sadness to this one.

OctopusBreath · 15/09/2022 20:57

I'm Welsh. Not a fan of rugby at all but this is really sad- Eddie Butler was a legend and was quite active politically in recent years. It's a great loss.

balalake · 15/09/2022 20:56

May he rest in peace and thoughts for his family and all who knew him. No age at all.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 15/09/2022 20:55

Surely we can be sad about both losses? Grief isn't a finite emotion , we can share it between as many loved ones as we want to..!

Superbabe64 · 15/09/2022 20:53

Me too. It is too sad. Only 65.
We will never hear that gorgeous voice in future live rugby games anymore 😔

StarbucksSmarterSister · 15/09/2022 20:53

I'm waiting for someone else who is Welsh to come along and back me up

I'm half Welsh and I'm here. I was shocked. 65 is young 96 is not. On age alone his death is sadder but he was bloody lovely.

It doesn't mean the Queen's death isn't sad but Eddie's is far sadder to me.

Spinstdu · 15/09/2022 20:52

Rugby commentary will never be the same without him.
He had a magnificent voice for broadcasting and his partnership with Brian Moore was the best.

Needesppressonow · 15/09/2022 20:47

V sad too, Will miss the voice of rugby, such a beautiful voice

wb3 · 15/09/2022 20:40

Anonymous1980 · 15/09/2022 19:24

Not being unreasonable but I've never heard of him.

You may not have heard of him but you have heard him.

pompomdaisy · 15/09/2022 20:27

Sadder about Bernard Cribbins personally.

WoodlandMummy · 15/09/2022 20:10

noworklifebalance · 15/09/2022 19:41

Olivia Newton-John’s death brought a tear to my eye and did make me reflect back to my childhood/teenhood.
The Queen - not so much (putting it politely)

Same 🤷🏻‍♀️

emsiewill · 15/09/2022 20:08

@BobinogBobbleHat my friend lived next door to him when he lived in Monmouthshire. He was a lovely neighbour by all accounts.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 15/09/2022 20:04

I’m gutted to hear this. Lovely guy full of enthusiasm.

BobinogBobbleHat · 15/09/2022 20:03

emsiewill · 15/09/2022 19:44

I'm waiting for someone else who is Welsh to come along and back me up on this. He was a legend, taken far too soon. I'm sure even if you don't know his name, you would recognise his voice from many major sporting and national, occasions.

Here's one example

Well, I'm English, living in Wales, but I'll back you up on that.

I'll really miss his voice. He and Brian Moore together were one of the joys of rugby on TV.

I once met Eddie Butler at a christingle service at a tiny church in the Monmouthshire countryside. (He wasn't the only TV person there, surprisingly, but my ds stole the show by falling down the chancel steps carrying a flaming orange)

Theoscargoesto · 15/09/2022 20:03

He was a legend. I’m English and he really was a rugby legend. RIP Eddie.

Swipe left for the next trending thread