Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
Wanderingowl · 17/09/2022 10:46

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 10:23

Huh?

I have a deformity; which is very noticeable. It is what it is, if asked to describe myself I would leave it out or include it depending on what I felt like. It isn’t ‘fucking cruel’ for somebody to suggest you just don’t mention it if you don’t want to, nor is it ‘fucking cruel’ for them to ask you to describe yourself to assist a colleague with limited vision.

We’ve reached the point with introspection now where even the most mundane and inoffensive of social interaction are somehow ‘triggering’ to somebody. It’s getting really ridiculous and actually preventing people from having normal exchanges and relationships with others.

We’re not protecting mental health by accommodating every person’s every sensitivity. What we’re doing is creating unnecessary competing interests, degrading resilience and complicating social interaction by having a unique set of rules for every individual. It isn’t necessary.

Do you really think that it's actually going to help the person with visual impairment? Do you really think that someone is going to remember 10 people's names, description of themselves and the voice that name and description came from. Unless they have an eidetic memory, which doesn't appear in non-fictional adults, they just won't.

It's not actually helping people, it's a performance. A performance that is making other people feel very uncomfortable. Ok, it wouldn't have made you uncomfortable, but it would have made me. And it would have made the numerous other people who have said it would make them uncomfortable, uncomfortable. And all of us who have our reasons to not be made feel uncomfortable in the work place, have a right not to want to be made uncomfortable. It's all exactly as you describe in the last paragraph, but I'd argue that by having everyone make a ridiculous performance of describing themselves to be supposedly helpful, we are creating unnecessary competing interests, degrading resilience and complicating social interaction by having a unique set of rules for every individual. Someone who is visually impaired absolutely needs to have accommodations made for them. But they don't get to ask for everyone else to be put in a position that will make many of them uncomfortable just to show how 'kind' they are in a performance that isn't actually helpful.

Youdoyoutoday · 17/09/2022 10:26

The woman patting the guide dog is a massive arsehole and completely in the wrong! Of course she was singled out because she kept doing something she was repeatedly asked not to!! Is she really that fucking stupid?

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 10:23

Wanderingowl · 17/09/2022 10:11

Maybe actually read what I wrote before commenting. I don't want to be put in a position where I don't have to mention it because then everyone knows that I chose not to. Either way, I've just made everyone else think about my face. And I've had to think about it. About what's wrong with me. I'm just going about my life merrily not thinking about something being wrong with my face. And now I've just had to. It's actually really not fucking ok to do that to me. It's unthinkingly cruel.

Huh?

I have a deformity; which is very noticeable. It is what it is, if asked to describe myself I would leave it out or include it depending on what I felt like. It isn’t ‘fucking cruel’ for somebody to suggest you just don’t mention it if you don’t want to, nor is it ‘fucking cruel’ for them to ask you to describe yourself to assist a colleague with limited vision.

We’ve reached the point with introspection now where even the most mundane and inoffensive of social interaction are somehow ‘triggering’ to somebody. It’s getting really ridiculous and actually preventing people from having normal exchanges and relationships with others.

We’re not protecting mental health by accommodating every person’s every sensitivity. What we’re doing is creating unnecessary competing interests, degrading resilience and complicating social interaction by having a unique set of rules for every individual. It isn’t necessary.

Wanderingowl · 17/09/2022 10:11

Regularsizedrudy · 17/09/2022 10:08

But you could just say “I have brown hair “

Maybe actually read what I wrote before commenting. I don't want to be put in a position where I don't have to mention it because then everyone knows that I chose not to. Either way, I've just made everyone else think about my face. And I've had to think about it. About what's wrong with me. I'm just going about my life merrily not thinking about something being wrong with my face. And now I've just had to. It's actually really not fucking ok to do that to me. It's unthinkingly cruel.

Regularsizedrudy · 17/09/2022 10:08

Wanderingowl · 17/09/2022 09:56

No sorry, if I'm talking to someone 1 on 1 I wouldn't mind describing what I look like. But in a crowd, no I think I'd actually be really uncomfortable. I have a congenital facial disfigurement and I don't actually want to have to draw attention to it, to be quite honest. It's something I make no effort to hide but equally I don't want to draw attention to it. By mentioning it I'd be drawing attention to it but also by not mentioning it, I would be drawing attention to it to everyone who could see it but would notice I hadn't mentioned it. It's something that I believe people notice right away about me and then sort of forget as they get to know me and it's just part of me (I assume that's how it is for most people, as it's how it is for me). But by either mentioning it or conspicuously not mentioning it everyone thinks about it again. It make me think about it. And I hate that. I really fucking hate it. It just comes out of nowhere and makes me self-conscious and sad.

So I while I sympathise with someone someone who is visually impaired, I don't want to describe myself to a group for reasons that are just as valid, and people who don't even think about why it would make someone really uncomfortable are being just as 'ableist' as they are accusing people who don't want to do it as being. To be quite honest, unless the visually impaired person has a startlingly good memory, I don't think they are at all likely to even remember how each of the 10 people described themselves. So I don't think it is a genuine exercise, rather than a way to make people 'check their sight privilege' rather than an exercise to help someone visualise their surroundings.

But you could just say “I have brown hair “

Wanderingowl · 17/09/2022 09:56

NoSquirrels · 15/09/2022 18:47

So, judging from the responses on here, if a visually impaired person said to you “Would you mind describing your appearance to me a little? It really helps me visualise who I’m talking to” the majority of people would refuse, based on ‘feeling uncomfortable’? Not just say “Sure, I’m about 5’3”, have brown hair and wear glasses. I’m wearing a black trouser suit and Doc Martens” or whatever.

No sorry, if I'm talking to someone 1 on 1 I wouldn't mind describing what I look like. But in a crowd, no I think I'd actually be really uncomfortable. I have a congenital facial disfigurement and I don't actually want to have to draw attention to it, to be quite honest. It's something I make no effort to hide but equally I don't want to draw attention to it. By mentioning it I'd be drawing attention to it but also by not mentioning it, I would be drawing attention to it to everyone who could see it but would notice I hadn't mentioned it. It's something that I believe people notice right away about me and then sort of forget as they get to know me and it's just part of me (I assume that's how it is for most people, as it's how it is for me). But by either mentioning it or conspicuously not mentioning it everyone thinks about it again. It make me think about it. And I hate that. I really fucking hate it. It just comes out of nowhere and makes me self-conscious and sad.

So I while I sympathise with someone someone who is visually impaired, I don't want to describe myself to a group for reasons that are just as valid, and people who don't even think about why it would make someone really uncomfortable are being just as 'ableist' as they are accusing people who don't want to do it as being. To be quite honest, unless the visually impaired person has a startlingly good memory, I don't think they are at all likely to even remember how each of the 10 people described themselves. So I don't think it is a genuine exercise, rather than a way to make people 'check their sight privilege' rather than an exercise to help someone visualise their surroundings.

Johnnysgirl · 17/09/2022 09:37

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 02:08

Person B needs to be fired. Unforgivable.

It's obvious most of the people on this thread have never actually worked with or spent time with disabled-led organisations or disability-friendly workplaces, or with groups of disabled people.

Maybe go and learn just the tiniest thing before mouthing off? As someone who works for a disabled company some of the comments here are so ignorant it would make me laugh if they weren't so stupid and harmful!

You work for a disabled company?

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 09:24

Princessglittery · 16/09/2022 23:32

@Johnnysgirl clearly you have never delivered training to a group of people.

Sounds like you never have either.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 02:08

Person B needs to be fired. Unforgivable.

It's obvious most of the people on this thread have never actually worked with or spent time with disabled-led organisations or disability-friendly workplaces, or with groups of disabled people.

Maybe go and learn just the tiniest thing before mouthing off? As someone who works for a disabled company some of the comments here are so ignorant it would make me laugh if they weren't so stupid and harmful!

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 17/09/2022 01:20

Would the trainer have found this more helpful?

"I am a partially-blind white woman in my late 40s. I have thick purple glasses, a large purple headset and grey-blonde hair tied back in a ponytail.”

“I’m a white cis man, in my mid-50s. I’m tall, with greying dark curly hair. My pronouns are he / him.”

“I use they/them pronouns. I am a nonbinary East Asian person in my 20s. I have long dark hair and facial hair.”

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 17/09/2022 01:07

Antarcticant · 15/09/2022 18:56

But what if the obvious things to say are ‘I wear a hijab and have a very prominent birthmark’, for instance.

That's why neutrally worded questions would be a good approach. Height, colour and style of clothing, for example. You could say 'I'm 5'4 and wearing loose black clothing' for example, without mentioning the hijab if you didn't want to.

If you were to say you were 5'4" that may not be of any use if you're seated.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 17/09/2022 01:00

Depends if B patted the dog initially and then stopped after realising this was a working dog. Insofar as declining to describe herself physically, absolutely OK. I would have asked the trainer what information she needed and offered a place description, i.e. I'm the second person on your left/I'm sitting at 2 o'clock.
If B was the only woman in the group, her comments that she was a woman and sounded like one 😉were factual and not woke.

Princessglittery · 16/09/2022 23:32

Johnnysgirl · 16/09/2022 19:55

Just like the visually impaired trainer is set apart from the other participants by not having the visual information required to do her job properly
How exactly was she prevented from doing her job properly?

@Johnnysgirl clearly you have never delivered training to a group of people.

Kendodd · 16/09/2022 23:07

Novum · 16/09/2022 21:49

Most people have pointed out that you could comply with a request to describe yourself by using precisely the criteria actually requested here, i.e. colour of clothes or hair. You were ignoring that through the thread and are still doing so.

Yes, and as I have said, if blind customer in Tesco's has said 'can you just tell me what colour you're wearing so I can follow you' no problem. Much more difficult to to misinterpret or make a young woman feel uncomfortable than saying 'describe yourself for me' wtf is the problem with blind people doing that instead? Why the absolute insistence any request for verbal information about personal appearance is fine and should be complied with regardless of how others feel?

SeasonFinale · 16/09/2022 22:01

Seriously on what planet do you need to be to not know that you don't pet guide dogs.

You are in a law firm. Ignore your HR department and go to Head of Employment Department or the Managing Partner and let them know that their own HR Manager doesn't recognise disability discrimination!

Novum · 16/09/2022 21:49

Kendodd · 16/09/2022 18:18

Well asking someone what colour they're wearing, if they don't mind saying, is very, different to a blind person demanding others describe themselves, which many posters on here seem to think have an absolute right to be complied with. It seems the trainer understood that wouldn't be ok to make demands like that.

Frankly I can't believe some posters think a man can demand a shop assistant give him a physical description of herself and that she should be sacked if she refused. It's like 'me too' has completely passed them by.

Most people have pointed out that you could comply with a request to describe yourself by using precisely the criteria actually requested here, i.e. colour of clothes or hair. You were ignoring that through the thread and are still doing so.

Novum · 16/09/2022 21:41

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 16/09/2022 16:02

So what is the head of HR going to say to B? ‘ Please co operate with trainer’s requests whilst in a voluntary training session? ‘ Yes, okay.

‘ be a nicer person? ‘ hmmm.

although the passionate advisers for the trainer will disagree, I’m not sure that this would help ‘ inclusivity’ in the long run ( especially in light of the ‘singled out’ comment).

"Don't be a dickhead. The law applies to you just as much as anyone else". I'd be tempted to send B off on a longer course on every aspect of equality law.

Butchyrestingface · 16/09/2022 21:13

But @Butchyrestingface that isn't what was said, people were asked to say their hair colour or clothing colour, so no need to mention hair type, hair style, length etc at all, or if you're all in black and so are several others you could mention shoe colour, hat colour, scarf colour.. lots of options.

But people on this thread HAVE talked about the need to describe hair colour. And it's not difficult to imagine a scenario where if everyone else on a call has described their hair, then the person who HASN'T done so, will be on the receiving end of "oh, you didn't mention your hair - what colour is it?"

People with physical differences may just not want to talk - or think - about their appearance at all, especially in front of potential strangers - it can be quite a triggering subject.

WiddlinDiddlin · 16/09/2022 21:04

But @Butchyrestingface that isn't what was said, people were asked to say their hair colour or clothing colour, so no need to mention hair type, hair style, length etc at all, or if you're all in black and so are several others you could mention shoe colour, hat colour, scarf colour.. lots of options.

At no point was it a full and detailed description, just an in person 'so that I can remember who I am talking to/have talked to' identifier.

Id not be happy if someone asked 'whats the most obvious feature about you so I can tell you from someone else' because I know most people would immediately think of my size and that upsets me... but if asked to tell you clothing colour or hair colour.. easy, after all I chose the colour I am wearing today, nothing embarrassing about that.

Butchyrestingface · 16/09/2022 20:55

They have a protected characteristic too so if asked to describe their hair could respond "for religious reasons I keep it covered and I'm not happy with disclosing that info"

I don't keep my hair covered for religious reasons. I've had alopecia since I was a teenager and would not want anyone asking me on a call to 'describe my hair'. I would probably be quite upset and embarrassed at being put on the spot, however unwittingly, in front of other people about this aspect of my physical appearance.

Person B was obviously being a dick about the dog and the way they expressed themselves more generally. But I have sympathy with people who are uncomfortable at this growing trend of being asked to give visual descriptions on calls.

Playdohkid · 16/09/2022 20:52

Thanks for your update @amazeandastonish .

How bizarre that B had to be asked several times to stop patting the dog. You’d think once would be enough.

We find with the guide dogs in our family, you do get the occasional person when out and about, who takes great delight in giving the dog a sneaky fuss while the owner hasn’t noticed. The person stays silent and the owner has no idea what’s happening and why their dog is distracted. It’s almost like these people get a thrill out of fussing the dog without the owner noticing. Maybe some sort of power/control thing. Often older men do this in our case.

Women will usually ask if they can fuss the dog and if it’s an appropriate time, the owner will do their best to say yes as they know how valuable it is to build positive relationships with the public.

Playdohkid · 16/09/2022 20:38

Johnnysgirl · 16/09/2022 19:55

Just like the visually impaired trainer is set apart from the other participants by not having the visual information required to do her job properly
How exactly was she prevented from doing her job properly?

I am visually impaired and explained in a previous post on this thread, if I was training a group how much easier it would make my working day if I had a vague description of participants - top/hair colour. As I have some sight, having this information would help me to engage with participants better , which would mean a better experience for all concerned.

Discovereads · 16/09/2022 20:14

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:35

Sorry! Visually impaired trainer with a cane and other disabilities. Don't distract guide dog and describe your appearance. Person B kept patting dog and didn't want to describe themselves. I think she also said "you can tell I'm a woman".

This is all you needed to say. Yes you need to take action, a trainer with disabilities shouldn’t be ignored and mocked in such a way.

GretaVanFleet · 16/09/2022 20:11

AssumingDirectControl · 16/09/2022 09:21

Did you not read my full post?

Yes I did @AssumingDirectControl and the second part is the type of thing that would be said as an introduction to the course attendees describing themselves. Why would you think people are quietly laughing because you omit something?

@NoSquirrels at the beginning of this little thread has hit the nail on the head.

MinnyMous · 16/09/2022 20:11

I'm a bit baffled that your company hasn't told the participants of the training that they have to engage with it. If someone refused to do a section of online training you wouldn't give them the credit for completing the course as they wouldn't have. Same goes for face to face training. Perhaps Person B needs to go back and engage with a disability trainer in order fulfil the company's expectations that all employees have to undertake the training - and perhaps that needs to be mandatory for all staff, like any other diversity training.