Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
CheesyTattie · 17/09/2022 12:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 12:09

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 11:37

I don’t think being triggered or made to feel uncomfortable outweighs a blind person’s needs. It just doesn’t when the request is one as innocuous as this.

Then I'm afraid we're going to have disagree on this point. I think the rights and needs of of people with physical differences (some of whom are, of course themselves, disabled) should not simply be thrown uncritically out the window when they come up against someone with competing needs.

I agree.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 12:09

Because a tangible, physical disability that severely restricts your life takes priority over a fleeting moment of ‘discomfort’? What next, unplugging someone’s life support to charge your phone because you feel ‘uncomfortable’ with it being out of battery?

The mental health needs of people with physical differences (particularly the ones described in the post you quote) or anxiety should not, in my view, simply be tossed aside because someone with competing needs has decided they want visual description of everyone on the meeting.

Some of the online events, usually the arts based ones, I've been on (I'm on a lot of diverse meetings through work) have included a caveat at the beginning that people don't need to turn their cameras on if they don't feel comfortable doing so. In those cases, there does tend to be an acceptance that you don't need to see someone or have a visual image of them in your mind in order to interact meaningfully with them.

On the one hand, that kind of caveat may be reassuring to people with mental health/anxiety issues and so forth, but does potentially create a problem for people with hearing loss who need to lipread. Another example of competing needs...

Kendodd · 17/09/2022 12:08

I think you did get a poor trainer in to be honest. There is obviously no need for anybody to be rude to a visitor of course.

In the update it turned out the trainer didn't say 'describe yourself ' they said please describe your top colour or hair colour and only if you want to.

I would have no problem with this. What I have a big problem with particularly is that VI men can demand young women 'describe themselves' to him and that she should be forced to do so under threat of the sack. Others on this thread seem to think this is fine though and name call anyone who should dare disagree.

Hobnobswantshernameback · 17/09/2022 12:08

The ableism on this thread is disgusting but utterly unsurprising.
describing this basic courtesy to someone with VI as a performance is one of the most cunty things I think I've read here
fuck sake

Greengagesnfennel · 17/09/2022 12:03

Person B is a dick.

You DEFINITELY have a work culture issue if the other 9 people in the room didn't make this clear to person B at the time.

In a normal place they would be expressing concern to you about person B.

JoeMaplin · 17/09/2022 12:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This!!

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 12:00

stayinghometoday · 17/09/2022 11:57

@Wouldloveanother

I don’t think being triggered or made to feel uncomfortable outweighs a blind person’s needs. It just doesn’t when the request is one as innocuous as this.

I disagree. Why does the blind persons feelings need to be prioritised over other peoples? There can be lots of obvious reasons people don't want to describe themselves. People in transition, for instance, or who were severely burnt or are visually disabled. All very obvious descriptions with which it would feel silly to describe yourself as wearing a blue shirt. One disability doesn't trump anothers.

Because a tangible, physical disability that severely restricts your life takes priority over a fleeting moment of ‘discomfort’? What next, unplugging someone’s life support to charge your phone because you feel ‘uncomfortable’ with it being out of battery?

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 11:58

Anyone else sick and tired of the word ‘uncomfortable’?

stayinghometoday · 17/09/2022 11:57

@Wouldloveanother

I don’t think being triggered or made to feel uncomfortable outweighs a blind person’s needs. It just doesn’t when the request is one as innocuous as this.

I disagree. Why does the blind persons feelings need to be prioritised over other peoples? There can be lots of obvious reasons people don't want to describe themselves. People in transition, for instance, or who were severely burnt or are visually disabled. All very obvious descriptions with which it would feel silly to describe yourself as wearing a blue shirt. One disability doesn't trump anothers.

Aprilx · 17/09/2022 11:51

Theeyeballsinthesky · 17/09/2022 11:40

Yes it would seem being asked to say “I’m eyeballs I’m short with dark hair wearing a blue dress” apparently sets off all kinds of deep psychological trauma

And yet, quite a lot of people have already said that it would make them feel uncomfortable. Just because you are happy in yourself, it doesn’t mean everyone is. I wouldn’t want to describe myself as I am overweight and I don’t particularly want to say this out loud, but yet not saying it and people might think I am oblivious. I would find it a very uncomfortable situation. I don’t know what triggered means and I wouldn’t be traumatised but I don’t want to do it and don’t see why I should.

I would also maintain that this is not a reasonable request necessary for somebody else to perform their duties. I would suggest the trainer needs to actually study what reasonable requests might look like before selling their services as a trainer in such matters.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 11:44

Seriously? Being "triggered" because someone has asked them to describe themselves?

You can't imagine how people with physical differences could feel very uncomfortable in a situation where they are asked to visually describe themselves?

If the visual description was given certain parameters, ie, the trainer said, "could you describe what colour of clothing you're wearing", it seems harmless enough to me (if likely to be pointless when a dozen people respond with "black!"). But that's rarely how I've seen it framed and responded to. Rather in my experience so far, people have tended to respond with a rather more detailed description of themselves - race, sex, hair colour, sexual orientation, gender orientation, body type, ability status, age, room background, etc, etc).

Could be the kind of calls I'm on. In some cases it's taken an age just to get through the visual descriptions and onto the main business of the event.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 17/09/2022 11:40

Yes it would seem being asked to say “I’m eyeballs I’m short with dark hair wearing a blue dress” apparently sets off all kinds of deep psychological trauma

TigerRag · 17/09/2022 11:38

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 11:32

People with VI have commented on this post to explain why descriptions are helpful

Unless you're visually impaired who the fuck are you go say it's not helpful and merely a performance

And (some) people with physical differences have explained that visual descriptions would make them feel uncomfortable/triggered, etc. Competing needs, etc.

I don't think there's been too many (any?) who don't think Person B in this scenario isn't a horror though.

Seriously? Being "triggered" because someone has asked them to describe themselves?

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 11:37

I don’t think being triggered or made to feel uncomfortable outweighs a blind person’s needs. It just doesn’t when the request is one as innocuous as this.

Then I'm afraid we're going to have disagree on this point. I think the rights and needs of of people with physical differences (some of whom are, of course themselves, disabled) should not simply be thrown uncritically out the window when they come up against someone with competing needs.

OvernightBloats · 17/09/2022 11:36

Why would the trainer need to know what someone looks like? Would it make a difference in the way she treated them?
What difference does it make to her if someone is blond or brunette? Short or tall? Fat or thin? etc.
Describing myself to a group of people would make me very uncomfortable and I would struggle to understand the motive of the trainer in asking me to do this.

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 11:34

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 11:32

People with VI have commented on this post to explain why descriptions are helpful

Unless you're visually impaired who the fuck are you go say it's not helpful and merely a performance

And (some) people with physical differences have explained that visual descriptions would make them feel uncomfortable/triggered, etc. Competing needs, etc.

I don't think there's been too many (any?) who don't think Person B in this scenario isn't a horror though.

I don’t think being triggered or made to feel uncomfortable outweighs a blind person’s needs. It just doesn’t when the request is one as innocuous as this.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 11:32

People with VI have commented on this post to explain why descriptions are helpful

Unless you're visually impaired who the fuck are you go say it's not helpful and merely a performance

And (some) people with physical differences have explained that visual descriptions would make them feel uncomfortable/triggered, etc. Competing needs, etc.

I don't think there's been too many (any?) who don't think Person B in this scenario isn't a horror though.

Johnnysgirl · 17/09/2022 11:25

Aprilx · 17/09/2022 11:19

It is not a reasonable request, it makes no sense as a request whatsoever. She can either see sufficiently to distinguish between people, or they would have to describe themselves every single time they speak, “I’m April, the fat one in a green dress”. How is that any more helpful than me just saying “I’m April”.

Indeed...

Aprilx · 17/09/2022 11:19

Princessglittery · 16/09/2022 19:22

@Kendodd In the example you have given a request for a description would not be reasonable.

In the OPs situation the trainer had some vision and asked people to describe their hair colour or clothing colour do they could distinguish them. A reasonable request.

It is not a reasonable request, it makes no sense as a request whatsoever. She can either see sufficiently to distinguish between people, or they would have to describe themselves every single time they speak, “I’m April, the fat one in a green dress”. How is that any more helpful than me just saying “I’m April”.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 17/09/2022 11:09

@Wanderingowl do you have a disability? If not, I think you need to own your privilege and take a few mins. discomfort.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 17/09/2022 11:07

Person B sounds like a cunt. I would be very worried about how they might respond to a client with disabilities. It's really shocking that this is a law firm OP

Aprilx · 17/09/2022 11:06

I don’t know why you keep calling this a reasonable adjustment. Not patting a dog when asked not to do so is not a reasonable adjustment, it is just basic manners. I am not blind and if I tell somebody not to pay my dog they shouldn’t. No reasonable adjustment here, very surprising that a law firm haven’t got a better grip of what reasonable adjustments mean.

And then on to the describing yourself, well I would refuse that too. It is not a reasonable adjustment, unless somebody is drawing me, I don’t see how me describing myself is a reasonable adjustment that I need to make to enable them to do their work.

I think you did get a poor trainer in to be honest. There is obviously no need for anybody to be rude to a visitor of course.

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 10:53

Wanderingowl · 17/09/2022 10:46

Do you really think that it's actually going to help the person with visual impairment? Do you really think that someone is going to remember 10 people's names, description of themselves and the voice that name and description came from. Unless they have an eidetic memory, which doesn't appear in non-fictional adults, they just won't.

It's not actually helping people, it's a performance. A performance that is making other people feel very uncomfortable. Ok, it wouldn't have made you uncomfortable, but it would have made me. And it would have made the numerous other people who have said it would make them uncomfortable, uncomfortable. And all of us who have our reasons to not be made feel uncomfortable in the work place, have a right not to want to be made uncomfortable. It's all exactly as you describe in the last paragraph, but I'd argue that by having everyone make a ridiculous performance of describing themselves to be supposedly helpful, we are creating unnecessary competing interests, degrading resilience and complicating social interaction by having a unique set of rules for every individual. Someone who is visually impaired absolutely needs to have accommodations made for them. But they don't get to ask for everyone else to be put in a position that will make many of them uncomfortable just to show how 'kind' they are in a performance that isn't actually helpful.

PP who is visually impaired said it would help her, and that’s enough for me to know a moment of ‘discomfort’ is the right thing to do.

CheesyTattie · 17/09/2022 10:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.