Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 14:57

Johnnysgirl · 17/09/2022 14:52

Because there's no such thing as a disabled company. A company isn't a sentient being.

Feel free to write to my company and to the many other companies that use that descriptor then...

Or you could stop being a massive pedant and recognise that "disabled company" is commonly accepted and widely used shorthand for "a company that exclusively hires disabled people and works to promote disability access and inclusion within their field, and to promote and support the careers of disabled people working in that field."

Do you also object to companies and organisations calling themselves "feminist organisations" or "female organisations"? After all, organisations can't have a gender, they're not sentient beings!

Johnnysgirl · 17/09/2022 14:52

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 14:16

Yeah, why?

Because there's no such thing as a disabled company. A company isn't a sentient being.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 14:49

If the perpetually anxious and offended had bothered to read the replies from visually impaired posters, they would’ve known this before saying their ‘discomfort’ outweighs everything.

Equally, if some people would read the replies from posters with physical differences, they'd know why giving visual descriptions can be problematic and why being told that they're just anxious, perpetually offended snowflakes who need to man up, and that the needs/preferences of visually impaired people must always trump their own wellbeing, isn't necessarily going to go down well.

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 14:48

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 14:46

But would also make me feel really exposed as I would have to tell the trainer that I am bald. If I neglected to mention hair, it'd be pretty bloody obvious to everyone present why I'd done it.

On the bright side, they'd have no difficulty tracking my movements around the room.

I get that too.

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 14:47

I think, if that was the reason why the trainer in the op needed a visual description (obviously not all people with a VI have enough useful sight) then it would have been better to tell the room why. People are usually a lot more giving if they can understand that there's a useful purpose to it.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 14:46

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 14:41

That makes sense if you have enough useful sight to make use of that description.

But would also make me feel really exposed as I would have to tell the trainer that I am bald. If I neglected to mention hair, it'd be pretty bloody obvious to everyone present why I'd done it.

On the bright side, they'd have no difficulty tracking my movements around the room.

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 14:45

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 14:41

That makes sense if you have enough useful sight to make use of that description.

Most people that are registered blind have extremely limited vision, not no vision.

If the perpetually anxious and offended had bothered to read the replies from visually impaired posters, they would’ve known this before saying their ‘discomfort’ outweighs everything.

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 14:45

It's probably useful if people can remain in the seat they were sitting in as well then when they introduced themselves, rather than switching around?

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 14:41

That makes sense if you have enough useful sight to make use of that description.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 14:37

Sorry misread the thread!

Anyway re asking for names and job titles. You do that as well, of course.

The reason you need to know colour of top or hair colour is to be able to link the name/job with the actual person, and so that when people move around the room, you have the information necessary to be able to know who is moving where. This is something sighted people do without a second thought.

Knowing there is a person named John from marketing somewhere in the room (but you have no idea where they are or who they are) is not very helpful information. Knowing that John from Marketing is the vague red blur on the left is very helpful and useful information, since if vague red blur speaks, you know that is John and you can address them as John and direct comments relevant to marketing towards them. If John moves to another part of the room, it's easier to keep track of the fact they have moved.

If at the start of the day the person sitting on the left says "I'm John from marketing" but later on John goes to sit somewhere else, and Rachel is sitting on the left, or there's no one sitting on the left, but you as a VI person don't know that. Imagine trying to deliver a talk and you keep referring to Rachel as John (since you have no idea that John has moved), or you keep addressing comments to a piece of furniture as John, and everyone keeps giggling but you don't know why. Pretty humiliating.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 14:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 14:22

I’m visually impaired and have explained a couple of times on this thread now how having a vague description such as colour of top, hair colour would help me distinguish between group participants at a training session and would make me better able to facilitate the day

Why wouldn't name and job descriptions help you distinguish between participants rather then requiring people to physically describe themselves?

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 14:16

Johnnysgirl · 17/09/2022 09:37

You work for a disabled company?

Yeah, why?

Playdohkid · 17/09/2022 13:47

Wanderingowl · 17/09/2022 09:56

No sorry, if I'm talking to someone 1 on 1 I wouldn't mind describing what I look like. But in a crowd, no I think I'd actually be really uncomfortable. I have a congenital facial disfigurement and I don't actually want to have to draw attention to it, to be quite honest. It's something I make no effort to hide but equally I don't want to draw attention to it. By mentioning it I'd be drawing attention to it but also by not mentioning it, I would be drawing attention to it to everyone who could see it but would notice I hadn't mentioned it. It's something that I believe people notice right away about me and then sort of forget as they get to know me and it's just part of me (I assume that's how it is for most people, as it's how it is for me). But by either mentioning it or conspicuously not mentioning it everyone thinks about it again. It make me think about it. And I hate that. I really fucking hate it. It just comes out of nowhere and makes me self-conscious and sad.

So I while I sympathise with someone someone who is visually impaired, I don't want to describe myself to a group for reasons that are just as valid, and people who don't even think about why it would make someone really uncomfortable are being just as 'ableist' as they are accusing people who don't want to do it as being. To be quite honest, unless the visually impaired person has a startlingly good memory, I don't think they are at all likely to even remember how each of the 10 people described themselves. So I don't think it is a genuine exercise, rather than a way to make people 'check their sight privilege' rather than an exercise to help someone visualise their surroundings.

I’m visually impaired and have explained a couple of times on this thread now how having a vague description such as colour of top, hair colour would help me distinguish between group participants at a training session and would make me better able to facilitate the day.

I understand your reasons for not wanting to give a description, and K wouldn’t want to compel you to, but I strongly object to you not believing this to be a ‘genuine exercise’, when actually it is something that would really help me facilitate the day if I were delivering training to a group of people. And yes, I have a bloody good memory.

Ableism, much?

Freedomfighters · 17/09/2022 12:44

Surely you're not so silly enough to think a moment of discomfort outweighs a reasonable adjustment for someone who is disabled

It's not a reasonable adjustment. If people want to share this information then thats ok. If they choose to. But really a name and even a brief description of their job role would suffice.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 12:33

timeofillusion · 17/09/2022 12:31

Out of interest, why did none of the other attendees mention any of this in their feedback on the course? Surely if it was that big a deal at the time then at least one person, probably more, would have said something as it has everything to do with both content and trainer? I'm guessing the feedback was given in writing (normally is) so even easier to comment. OP's vagueness in the beginning ('describe your appearance') is different enough to her update ('A asked people to describe either their hair colour or clothing colour and said this was to help her distinguish between people. Apparently A said "if you don't mind" so there was a recognition in that, I think, that not everyone may want to do so.') to make me wonder if we're getting a different story later in the thread to what actually happened. Particularly since this update was right at the start - if A recognised that some might not want to, why did she ask B again? Why not just accept it? And why did B mention woke, being sensitive, not being dictated to and being obvious they're a woman? There's zero logic there, even if B is a complete asshole. Either OP has made the whole thing up or she's changed the story a lot because lots of people said they weren't happy with providing a description of themselves. It doesn't add up.

Because none of it is real

timeofillusion · 17/09/2022 12:31

Out of interest, why did none of the other attendees mention any of this in their feedback on the course? Surely if it was that big a deal at the time then at least one person, probably more, would have said something as it has everything to do with both content and trainer? I'm guessing the feedback was given in writing (normally is) so even easier to comment. OP's vagueness in the beginning ('describe your appearance') is different enough to her update ('A asked people to describe either their hair colour or clothing colour and said this was to help her distinguish between people. Apparently A said "if you don't mind" so there was a recognition in that, I think, that not everyone may want to do so.') to make me wonder if we're getting a different story later in the thread to what actually happened. Particularly since this update was right at the start - if A recognised that some might not want to, why did she ask B again? Why not just accept it? And why did B mention woke, being sensitive, not being dictated to and being obvious they're a woman? There's zero logic there, even if B is a complete asshole. Either OP has made the whole thing up or she's changed the story a lot because lots of people said they weren't happy with providing a description of themselves. It doesn't add up.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 12:29

by the way some posters have responded on here, you would really think the trainer had asked everyone to detail their first sexual encounter, or to describe their naked form in detail.

I don't think this trainer did wrong. They seem to have come up against a weapons grade arsehole.

But as a more general comment, I don't think visual descriptions are quite the neutral thing some seem to imagine, especially the way they are playing out on many of the events I've been on.

And when the presenter starts with a forensic breakdown of their gender orientation, sexual orientation, ethnicity, height, body type, hair type/colour/length, ability status, age, etc, etc, and is promptly followed by everyone else on the event doing likewise, it can be difficult to say, "I'm Jenny and I'm wearing blue dungarees" and leave it at that. A few times I've seen people being asked to expand on their descriptions (although this is far from the norm).,

Kendodd · 17/09/2022 12:22

Oh, and I haven't been rude or told anyone to fuck off or name called.

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 12:21

But asking virtually anything seems to be ‘problematic’ these days .

by the way some posters have responded on here, you would really think the trainer had asked everyone to detail their first sexual encounter, or to describe their naked form in detail.

Kendodd · 17/09/2022 12:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes they have, read the thread back.
Somebody said a blind person was in tesco and wanted a physical description of a shelve stacker they should give him one and should be sacked if they didn't. Others agreed. There is very much the attitude from many posters that a blind person has an absolute right to a physical description of people. You might agree with this, I don't.

Butchyrestingface · 17/09/2022 12:17

Surely you're not so silly enough to think a moment of discomfort outweighs a reasonable adjustment for someone who is disabled

Christ almighty

I have a disability myself. I also have a physical difference. I don't think my disability gives me the right to demand that other people with physical differences should be made to feel exposed and uncomfortable in this way. People with physical differences have needs too, some of them have mental ill issues relating to their condition.

Being aware that being asked for a visual description can be problematic for some people is not bad thing for a trainer, I don't think. In this scenario, no matter how it was framed, I think the trainer would have had pushback from Person B because they just sound like that kind of person.

Deadringer · 17/09/2022 12:15

Sounds like something that would happen at Dunder Mifflin.

Wouldloveanother · 17/09/2022 12:13

Anxiety is for the individual to deal with, not for the world to work around and avoid completely normal inoffensive human interactions. You can’t ‘work on’ your blindness.

CheesyTattie · 17/09/2022 12:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.