Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
Freedomfighters · 18/09/2022 14:23

Starting a meeting with everyone giving a visual description of themselves has been the norm and standard for every meeting I've been in for the past probably five years and I've never seen any issues. Some people give a less detailed description and it's fine.

That just isn't true. It may be what you do, but asking for a physical description just isn't the norm. You're not the only person who works / lives / moves in this world you know.

PaperBlinds · 18/09/2022 14:17

Persistant patting of the service dog is a dick move and not acceptable.
However, public self-description is an example of where attempts at inclusivity/reasonable adjustments challenge problematic attitudes and reactions can cause problems.

Both the request and the discomfort expressed can be reasonable responses and also both true, at the same time. Asking for a description of yourself seems perfectly reasonable to accomodate someone who can see what you look like. But not everyone knows how to respond (or even why it's useful) and some people can't respond without it raising issues for them. All of this depends on how the question was phrased; it was a training event after all, and therefore explaining needs to be part of the process - eg what does that person want to know, what you can usefully or helpfully say, what you might not want to say, how much to say, in order that people can work out something that is both accomodating and helpful, and comfortable for all parties). Of course if all this was done, and Person B reacted the same way, they are being a PITA and clearly don't want to get it.

It is a new thing for a lot of people, and the whole point of training is to address ignorance, inform and improve skills. The attitude that "everyone should know this" is naive. While personally I think Person B is both a dick and holds some probably quite ill-considered views, aren't they exactly the person the training is aimed at? Helping them see how to behave in a non-discrimintory way, possibly to find a middle-way through their issue about self-description (which maybe not about bloody-mindedness or predjudice, but about fear and anxiety). Disability awareness training isn't about already knowing what is best thing to do or there wouldn't be much point and you wouldn't have called anyone in to do it.

I think it is really hard to do any kind of EDI training and especially if you have lived experience of the protected characteristics too, and a trainer should have the support, strategies and protection of their own, and that of the company if they feel threatened or discriminated against. Did you not get a set of ground rules and expectations for the session?

I have seen trainers leave a session for a break, opt out of session until the work until the group addresses some of the issues arising themselves, refuse to work with cetain companies and all of these are reasonable self-protections and can actually be a very effective tool in training. It's exhausting and not very rewarding work. But at the same time the point is to deal with the problematic attitudes as they arise. If the trainer felt Person B's behaviour was beyond their acceptable boundaries, then they need to be listened to, but perhaps they might be able to suggest how this might be dealt with? if Person B is clearly not open to the training, that needs addressing - but at a "this is what this company believes and this what is expected in your role" level.

I also think that EDI training should be required (for everyone including all senior and executive staff) and should be part of corporate strategy. It isn't a bolt-on or optional if you feel like it, or a sticking plaster. I am slightly concerned that neither you nor the head of HR were at the event to mediate/observe. Had steps been taken to look at risks for trainer and staff or take the temperature (clearly cool to luke warm by the up take numbers) or to thoroughly investigate what the trainer was going to do or say and if they were a good fit for where your company is actually at, at this point. Training resulting in a complaint of this kind suggests that none of this was worked out before the session took place and that a lot more work is needed by the company and it's unfair to any trainer you employ, until this is done.

I feel like both Person A and B have been set up to fail here - not necessarily your fault - but working in a company that isn't actually interesting or embracing this work is a hiding to nothing.

deeperthanallroses · 18/09/2022 13:24

Does it really matter whether describing yourself is a highly recommended behaviour? The patting the dog after being told not to should be a formal warning on its own so I’d focus on that and your head of hr is woefully inadequate for the job. I wouldn’t bother getting bogged down in the other detail, you have shitty colleagues and a terrible workplace culture and will progress faster at changing it if you focus on things that are more black and white - low hanging fruit op, tackle the more contested points later when you’ve improved the basics. So maybe 5 years later if you’re lucky.

Aprilx · 18/09/2022 13:10

*appearance not experience!

Aprilx · 18/09/2022 13:09

WTFNowPeople · 18/09/2022 08:43

Eh? You go for a job interview, a course or on a date and you’re asked “How would you describe yourself?” and that’s rude?? Give me strength!

I have never been asked to describe my physical experience in an interview. And if I were, I would find it very inappropriate and would probably terminate the interview.

ASimpleLampoon · 18/09/2022 12:38

Totally unacceptable. Surprised you even have to ask

TheWheeledAvenger · 18/09/2022 12:38

Freedomfighters · 18/09/2022 12:34

Sure. But how much if that is alleviated by a brief 2D description of a persons vital statistics.

I already said at maximum it should be clothes colour, if the person has enough useful sight for that to be of use to them.

In other settings, obviously it's nice to know what people actually look like. But it's not going to work in a formal training setting where people don't know each other and don't feel comfortable sharing more detailed information.

But it does work. Like I said, it's the norm within the disability world or in certain industries that regularly work with disabled people (or in industries that would probably be considered "woke")

Starting a meeting with everyone giving a visual description of themselves has been the norm and standard for every meeting I've been in for the past probably five years and I've never seen any issues. Some people give a less detailed description and it's fine.

I think people are just scared because it's unfamiliar to them. If they actually saw it in practice then perhaps they'd be less scared.

ddl1 · 18/09/2022 12:34

Asking for a description isn't requiring a really personal account in this case. It is a person with extremely limited vision asking for cues that may assist them in locating and identifying people. A totally blind person might not be able to use such cues at all (note that most severely visually impaired people are not totally blind); and fully sighted and even many partially sighted people would not need to have them pointed out. But it would be very useful to some people.

Yes, there are genuine reasons why some people might not want to even state their hair colour (surely colour of clothes should not present a difficulty, however). But the fact that B used the term 'woke' here, and that she was so incredibly rude and unco-operative as to persist in patting a working dog, after being asked not to, suggests that she was just being stroppy for the sake of it.

Freedomfighters · 18/09/2022 12:34

Sure. But how much if that is alleviated by a brief 2D description of a persons vital statistics.

I already said at maximum it should be clothes colour, if the person has enough useful sight for that to be of use to them.

In other settings, obviously it's nice to know what people actually look like. But it's not going to work in a formal training setting where people don't know each other and don't feel comfortable sharing more detailed information.

Johnnysgirl · 18/09/2022 12:28

I get why people would want to know. It's obvious really. So much of the picture is missing when you can't see what people look like / communication through body language etc
Sure. But how much if that is alleviated by a brief 2D description of a persons vital statistics?

Freedomfighters · 18/09/2022 11:51

5zeds · 18/09/2022 10:58

@LittleSid i wouldn’t, I’m not sure what you’d want to know for🤷🏻‍♀️

I get why people would want to know. It's obvious really. So much of the picture is missing when you can't see what people look like / communication through body language etc. Although it still can't be expected that people should comply with in depth descriptions about their body. I wouldn't. Not in that environment.

If the request is to identify who is where in the room (if someone has enough useful sight) then it is a reasonable request too. It would be better if the reasons why were explained to people and to ask for descriptor of the colour of clothes, not physical features. I'm sure people would get more on board with that if it's not intrusive and they can understand why.

TheWheeledAvenger · 18/09/2022 11:42

LittleSid · 18/09/2022 10:50

How is being visually impaired being "woke"?
Struggling to comprehend this behaviour from a law firm. OP - start looking for a new job. You sound like a nice person and you could anonymously whistle blow on the way out. What a rubbish company.

Some people think anything that involves not treating minorities or marginalised groups like shit is "woke."

The kind of people who rant about wokeness hate anyone who is marginalised.

TheWheeledAvenger · 18/09/2022 11:40

If anyone can give an actual reason why "disabled company" is bad and disabled people shouldn't be allowed to use it then I'm all ears.

Until then, given that "disabled company" is the norm and so many companies use it, I will continue to use it and not listen to bullies trying to dictate what words disabled people are and are not allowed to use.

All this fuss and tantrumming because a disabled person chose to use a term you've never heard of before!

TheWheeledAvenger · 18/09/2022 11:37

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 17/09/2022 20:03

You are a bit much, you've continuously denied using the phrase disabled company, and now you are resorting to ad hominem attacks on people who have called you out on it.
Please stop pretending that this is word-policing: language is important; you change the language, pretend x means y and then realise you have created a fiction which can be used to attack reasonable people pointing out your own incoherence.

What on EARTH are you talking about?

I've never, ever "denied" using the phrase disabled company, I've said a million times that disabled company is very common and MY and others choice of term.

Why are you so outraged and furious that an actual disabled person uses the language of their own choosing?

Why are you so obsessed with word policing, censoring disabled people's language, and making ad hominem attacks on them when they do not comply?

5zeds · 18/09/2022 10:58

@LittleSid i wouldn’t, I’m not sure what you’d want to know for🤷🏻‍♀️

LittleSid · 18/09/2022 10:57

ManateeFair · 15/09/2022 19:37

Person B is a twat and your Head of HR is colossally incompetent. Person A is 100% correct to complain. Being paid as a contractor doesn’t mean it’s OK for people to treat you like that and refuse to make even the tiniest accommodations for your disability.

✨️✨️✨️ this ✨️✨️✨️

LittleSid · 18/09/2022 10:54

Soontobe60 · 15/09/2022 19:00

Why is it ‘inclusive’ to describe your appearance? Would you describe what you look like to someone on the end of a phone?

I'm going to assume you typed this because you can see, and pls, correct me if I'm wrong.

Don't take it for granted because you can see. Imagine living in a world with limited detail. I would certainly ask for a description to have an idea at least.

LittleSid · 18/09/2022 10:50

How is being visually impaired being "woke"?
Struggling to comprehend this behaviour from a law firm. OP - start looking for a new job. You sound like a nice person and you could anonymously whistle blow on the way out. What a rubbish company.

LittleSid · 18/09/2022 10:45

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:35

Sorry! Visually impaired trainer with a cane and other disabilities. Don't distract guide dog and describe your appearance. Person B kept patting dog and didn't want to describe themselves. I think she also said "you can tell I'm a woman".

Person B is a twat and needs to be pulled up for such behaviour. My 8yo knows not to bother a working dog SMH.

GeekyThings · 18/09/2022 10:17

After reading all the updates (the OP just didn't give enough detail to decide):

I think with regards to petting the dog B was completely in the wrong, and had no right to feel singled out because she was doing something that she'd been asked not to do, and quite frankly she should have known not to do.

I think with regards to the personal details question - I actually think person A was at fault in that instance. Person A may have tried to phrase it politely by adding if you don't mind, but she should have been aware that by doing this in a small group there is still group pressure to do what they've been asked. Which means she should have been more careful about what she asked, and she shouldn't have included hair colour, she should have stuck with clothing colour, as that is a less personal question.

If I were in HR I would probably also say it's not an HR matter. It seems more like a line management issue, and an H&S issue, unless it's part of a series of incidences by person B. A one off where B was a little bit at fault but also a little bit not at fault doesn't seem like something that should be raised at that kind of level, it's complete overkill. You can note the incident just in case there are further incidences that require raising. B should be told by her line manager that she was in the wrong for petting the dog and be told that any further incidences could trigger disciplinary actions; and the organisation should send out something across the business reminding employees that they are required to follow ALL health and safety rules when they are working for the company, regardless of location.

I would probably also feed back to the trainer that the hair colour question was inappropriate in that environment as there may be many good reasons why people wouldn't want to answer (baldness, sexism, medical issues, religious headwear, etc etc). But I would apologise for B petting the dog, and let her know that the issue was being dealt with.

GretaVanFleet · 18/09/2022 10:08

Johnnysgirl · 18/09/2022 09:50

I know you were. I meant the "describe yourself" is not necessary, not the filling in of a non existent form.

My point being people comparing being uncomfortable with a disability like they’re on a par. They need to realise their insecurities are their issue and believe it or not most people don’t even notice the thing that they believe everyone is focusing on. That said some people will never feel comfortable with themselves which is sad because letting that stuff go and loving yourself is life changing.

Marvellousmadness · 18/09/2022 10:01

Person B should not be petting a guide dog
But person A should set her straight on that.

Person A cant demand another persn to discribe theselves that's bonkers.

WTFNowPeople · 18/09/2022 09:52

Freedomfighters · 18/09/2022 09:07

Being asked to physically describe yourself at a job interview would be rude. Describing your skill set and experience obviously would not be.

Do you get asked to physically describe what you look like at interviews?

And that’s the point, it’s about interpretation and what people are comfortable saying. Ideally person A would explain the type of detail they do/don’t need and would allay any concerns regarding the participants.

Johnnysgirl · 18/09/2022 09:50

GretaVanFleet · 18/09/2022 09:47

I was being sarcastic. Well they do say it is the lowest form of wit.

I know you were. I meant the "describe yourself" is not necessary, not the filling in of a non existent form.

GretaVanFleet · 18/09/2022 09:47

Johnnysgirl · 18/09/2022 09:27

Why? It's not something that needs to happen at all. The "adjustment" would be just that. It's not necessary.

I was being sarcastic. Well they do say it is the lowest form of wit.