Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:33

That’s the point though isn’t it. I can’t really describe myself without announcing to everyone that I’m a mixed race fat middle aged woman. I could make up that I’m a young Chinese man. Would that be better?

But you can.

I'd say I'm 5"7 with brown hair and blue eyes. I wouldn't explicitly say I'm white.

Why can't you say you're 5"6 with brown hair and blue eyes and not mention your race? Do you feel it's important to you to describe it? (Genuine question). Do you not feel comfortable leaving that out?

But it still remains the blind person won't have singled you out because they won't have been able to know!

StarbucksSmarterSister · 15/09/2022 20:32

Person B is an idiot. Your Head of HR needs training, never mind the rest of you.

Antarcticant · 15/09/2022 20:32

The fact remains that even if Person B had a very good reason for not wanting to describe herself, that was not an excuse to insult and berate the trainer.

Person B could have politely refused or excused herself from the room.

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 20:31

Novum · 15/09/2022 20:25

Good grief. Of course employees have to make reasonable adjustments, because ensuring that their conduct doesn't make their employer vicariously liable for unlawful conduct is an absolutely basic element of their duties. Do you imagine that, say, it would be OK for a shop assistant to refuse to clear obstructions from the path of someone in a wheelchair because "it's not for employees to make reasonable adjustments"?

Of course not petting a guide dog is a reasonable adjustment. They are incredibly carefully trained, they should not have idiots distracting them from their job by playing with them. And who are you to tell a blind person that it won't help them to have the people they are training describe themselves?

It’s not for the employees to make reasonable adjustments for the employer. you’ve got it the wrong way round.

And neither of the things are reasonable adjustments anyway. There’s no unlawful conduct here nor any question of liability or loss. A trainer came to train people, they didn’t like how one of them behaved (we don’t know Bs side), they were paid and went on their way.

bellac11 · 15/09/2022 20:30

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 20:20

Actually if an employee has an anxiety disability it could be a reasonable adjustment not to put them on the spot or ask them to speak in public.

Absolutely, I referred earlier to hidden disabilities and this applies to me, I can cope with various things but I would not be able to talk about my personal appearance in a room full of people without being affected, for various reasons that others on here also have stated they suffer from

Its incredible that this is not being recognised and acknowledged as something that is not appropriate. And until you're put in the position of that you wouldnt be walking around making people aware that its not appropriate for obvious reasons. Where is my protection at work?

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:30

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 20:22

If it was physical appearance , the trainer wanted described, has anyone asked why that was wanted by the trainer?

There's a whole thread here explaining it!

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:29

Actually if an employee has an anxiety disability it could be a reasonable adjustment not to put them on the spot or ask them to speak in public.

True.

However someone that needed that type of reasonable adjustments would have either had HR tell the retainer beforehand in confidence, personally vina form or had a word privately beforehand.

They are very unlikely - if they have anxiety about speaking in front of a group - to have waited until they are asked to speak in front of a group to explain. On the basis that they can't do that.

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 20:29

MikeWozniaksMoustache · 15/09/2022 20:22

You said you struggled to get sign ups to the session, so it was voluntary? I would question the motive behind B’s attendance at this session. It seems like they attended to be purposely combative and make a “point”… anyone slinging around woke as an insult knows what they’re doing and they’re doing it to be offensive.

This is a very good point

Did this person attend in some form of protest as they think it's ridiculous and 'woke'

NoSquirrels · 15/09/2022 20:28

I can’t really describe myself without announcing to everyone that I’m a mixed race fat middle aged woman

Of course you can!
“I’m about 5’5, I’ve got dark hair and I’m wearing a blue jumper today.”

Job done.

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:28

Inclusivity works lots of ways and there seems to be little recognition that asking people to describe themselves is likely to result in people assuming they mean their physicality and feeling uncomfortable, anxious and that its intrusive and difficult for a number of reasons. Bear in mind that in this situation this is front of other people, not just one to one with someone.

So now it's the disabled persons fault that someone assumed they meant something they probably didn't.

Surely someone qualified enough and intelligent to be a lawyer can understand just ask for clarification?

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 20:27

@MsPincher

You clearly have 0 idea about the wide severity ranges for visual impairment

It's actually quite impressive you're still banging on about this just making yourself look worse and worse as you go on

Novum · 15/09/2022 20:25

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 19:31

Describing yourself isn’t a reasonable adjustment. Petting guide dog when asked not to is rude but not sure if it’s really a reasonable adjustment. Also it’s not for the employee to make reasonable adjustments - you’ve got bit the wrong way round.

what qualifies you as a D& I advisor?

Good grief. Of course employees have to make reasonable adjustments, because ensuring that their conduct doesn't make their employer vicariously liable for unlawful conduct is an absolutely basic element of their duties. Do you imagine that, say, it would be OK for a shop assistant to refuse to clear obstructions from the path of someone in a wheelchair because "it's not for employees to make reasonable adjustments"?

Of course not petting a guide dog is a reasonable adjustment. They are incredibly carefully trained, they should not have idiots distracting them from their job by playing with them. And who are you to tell a blind person that it won't help them to have the people they are training describe themselves?

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 20:24

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:19

How does knowing what people look like if you can’t identify them visually fix an imbalance? I’m a mixed race woman and if someone in a similar position asked me to describe myself I might be suspicious that they were trying to use me to make a point.

So the blind person who can't see you chooses you to make a point about describing yourself sue to your race?

Despite having no vision to even know your race unless you decide to use it as part of the description 🤦🏼‍♀️

That’s the point though isn’t it. I can’t really describe myself without announcing to everyone that I’m a mixed race fat middle aged woman. I could make up that I’m a young Chinese man. Would that be better?

in either case it’s irrelevant how I look if she can’t identify me visually anyway. If she can, I don’t need to identify myself.

MarsupiIami · 15/09/2022 20:24

Honestly, a lot of people are bloody weird about reasonable adjustments.

Someone today said another colleagues adjustment (which was a tiny tiny thing) was disadvantaging him. It doesn't affect him in any way and I told him that 😂. It's really hard sometimes to get people to understand you're not getting special treatment, I tend to not mention any non visible adjustments I have to avoid weird comments.

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 20:22

If it was physical appearance , the trainer wanted described, has anyone asked why that was wanted by the trainer?

MikeWozniaksMoustache · 15/09/2022 20:22

You said you struggled to get sign ups to the session, so it was voluntary? I would question the motive behind B’s attendance at this session. It seems like they attended to be purposely combative and make a “point”… anyone slinging around woke as an insult knows what they’re doing and they’re doing it to be offensive.

CombatBarbie · 15/09/2022 20:21

osmanthusfragrans · 15/09/2022 18:51

The dog thing is ridiculous, but how long as describing yourself been "a thing"? I've only recently heard about this, so I'm wondering if it's something new. I don't really understand how having a physical description of people makes much difference. It will never be the same as actually seeing someone, and surely voices are usually distinct enough to provide the necessary differentiation between people. I wouldn't mind saying what color I'm wearing, if someone is partially sighted and it would help them tell people apart, but further than that? I don't see the point.

Seriously? You don't see the point in giving a blind person a description so he can visualise you in his head, have you ever met a blind person?

OP you're firm has got big problems!! The fact it's law is more laughable. Please tell me its not employment law.

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 20:20

ManateeFair · 15/09/2022 20:11

It’s also mind-boggling that people can’t see that disliking something or being nervous about it doesn’t mean you have a free pass never to do it. Some people are anxious saying anything at all in a room full of people, but that doesn’t mean they have a free pass to remain silent in a situation where speaking up is necessary to be fair to everyone else in the room.

Being anxious about saying “I’m a woman with brown hair wearing a blue dress” is not a disability. It doesn’t exempt you from behaving fairly to someone who is.

Actually if an employee has an anxiety disability it could be a reasonable adjustment not to put them on the spot or ask them to speak in public.

NoSquirrels · 15/09/2022 20:20

Inclusivity works lots of ways and there seems to be little recognition that asking people to describe themselves is likely to result in people assuming they mean their physicality and feeling uncomfortable, anxious and that its intrusive and difficult for a number of reasons. Bear in mind that in this situation this is front of other people, not just one to one with someone.

We don’t know that the VI trainer didn’t give explicit instructions on how to ‘describe yourself’ - I’d think it’s quite likely they prefaced the request with lots of ‘describe yourself in a way you’re comfortable, it would be helpful to me to know a bit about your height or hair colour or what you’re wearing today.’

In those circumstances it really is the person with a disability at a disadvantage, not you, so even if you find it an uncomfortable request to fulfil doesn’t mean you shouldn’t try to do it.

In any case, this is an interesting thread and I hope it has given more people the opportunity to reflect on their knee-jerk reaction that it’s unreasonable and intrusive. And perhaps come up with a way they’d describe themselves that doesn’t make them feel vulnerable should they ever be in this situation.

lunar1 · 15/09/2022 20:19

Neither are really adjustments though.

A working guide dog shouldn't be interfered with when they have their harness on. My children were taught that from being old enough to walk to the park. Nobody who struggles with that should be working in a law firm.

Describing yourself is up to the individual and not something that should be a rule or pressured over. Nobody knows what physical or mental health issues another person is going through. A reasonable adjustment for one person can't be something that oversteps others well-being.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 15/09/2022 20:19

The whole thing sounds complicated, but I don’t think it needs to go any further than the point where person b distracted the guide dog. That crosses a massive line IMO. It’s so personally intrusive and plain rude to continue if asked to stop that it hits a bottom line where any other unreasonableness in the situation disappears in comparison.

How would you react to a complaint about someone sticking stickers over someone’s glasses, damaging their wheelchair or moving their walking aid out of reach?

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:19

How does knowing what people look like if you can’t identify them visually fix an imbalance? I’m a mixed race woman and if someone in a similar position asked me to describe myself I might be suspicious that they were trying to use me to make a point.

So the blind person who can't see you chooses you to make a point about describing yourself sue to your race?

Despite having no vision to even know your race unless you decide to use it as part of the description 🤦🏼‍♀️

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 20:18

@itsgettingweird

I'm shocked so many are willing to out themselves as such idiots on here with this tbh

Novum · 15/09/2022 20:18

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 20:10

There isn’t any need for her to ask people to describe themselves though so she could identify them. If she can’t identify them visually, I don’t see how them describing themselves is going to help. It’s not going to make any difference on her identifying them.

to be honest it sounds like something more was going on. We need at least both sides of the story here.

there is no issue of reasonable adjustments though.

She is at a disadvantage as compared with a sighted trainer because the sighted trainer knows what everyone looks like. Likewise she was at a disadvantage compared with everyone else in the same room, for the same reason. Bear in mind that few people are 100% blind, it may well help her to know that John is the tall blur, Mary is the blur with dark hair, Fred is the one with a blurry red shirt, etc.

Frankly, if a blind person tells us that this will make their life easier, it's incredibly patronising for sighted people to tell them they don't need it.

GabriellaMontez · 15/09/2022 20:18

It sounds like you've not spoken to anyone one the course about their version of what happened.

Only the trainer and the written feedback. Please correct me if I'm wrong on this.

Why would you ask on a forum without getting the other side of this first?