Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
EgonSpengler2020 · 15/09/2022 21:37

The problem with asking someone to describe themselves is not just the self esteem issues the individual may have, but in a woke workplace it could backfire on the person describing themself, and also it could pressure someone into having to express something that is a protected characteristic.

Eg. I'm a middle aged white women, whose overweight and has brown hair.

Why does anyone in the workplace need to know my age bracket? could announcing that I'm white, cause offence to someone else? I don't want to have to say outloud that I'm fat, and the brown hair bit is just glossing over the greys!!

And, how does any of this effect how I do my job or how the VI person does their's or at least it shouldn't.

I understand that it must be a strange and frustrating way to live if sightloss was later in life, but I'm not sure the trainer (person A) has really thought this through.

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 21:34

As I understand it, a reasonable adjustment, is to enable a person to do a job. Could somebody please explain to how the refusal to supply a physical description of yourself to a blind colleague, prevents them doing their job ?

PriOn1 · 15/09/2022 21:32

They said they weren't interested because it's all woke nonsense. It's in the OP.

You are missing the point.

B allegedly said that to the trainer.

OP has only the trainer’s word for that. OP does not state whether the other employees backed up the trainers account. So far, it’s one person’s word you are relying on and you have no idea whether that person is reasonable or not.

I used to deal with complaints for a living, and a complaint is what this is.

At the moment, OP has a complaint from a single person, who gave their point of view.

As a minimum, I would expect her to get B’s point of view. She also has a number of witnesses to the events.

Just as an example, perhaps B felt picked on by A throughout. Perhaps B’s behaviour was a reaction. Perhaps A is lying about B’s behaviour.

On the face of it, B appears to have behaved very badly indeed, but as a minimum, she should be allowed to give her side before any decisions are made about the appropriate action to take. Having done that, you may reasonably conclude that B is every bit as bad as person A said, and act accordingly, but B should always be allowed to respond to accusations made against her.

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 21:29

Doesn't matter of the trainer was shot or what the dog was like.

The blind person asked someone to stop stroking their working guide dog.

They should have stopped.

timeofillusion · 15/09/2022 21:27

PestorPeston · 15/09/2022 21:18

Person A may prefer to be described as an excellent piano player who also has an embarrassing amount of sheepskin slippers. Why do you insist one defining someone by their protected characteristics?

Have you done any D&I training recently?

I'm not saying that A is a bad trainer - they're probably great. What I'm trying to say is that we have no idea what A is like, or B, or the other attendees, or even the guide dog! We're all making judgements based on assumptions and guesswork. OP is the one with the facts, or should be if she's actually investigated this properly which seems unlikely from what little she's written.
We can all make stories that fit the facts on the face of it but they could all be wrong.

NumberTheory · 15/09/2022 21:26

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 20:50

@NumberTheory

Because the entire reason they're there is to learn about how to be inclusive of those with disabilities

Refusing to do this shows how not inclusive this person is

You can go on an assertiveness training course and even though the whole reason you’re there is to learn to be assertive it doesn’t mean you’re going to be capable of each step the second you’re told to just do it.

If people are genuinely uncomfortable with describing themselves that might be something the session could work on - how to come up with a useful spiel you can use in the future that you’re happy with and that will be useful to someone who is VI.

Regardless, if you discipline people who have voluntarily gone along to a training session for feeling too uncomfortable to participate in a part of it, you’re going to build resentment, not improve people’s capacity to be inclusive.

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 21:18

And is it reasonable for me to say 'no' to the request for a physical description? Or if I was a Tesco employee, should I face disciplinary action for refusing such a request from a customer ?

Would you ask all the visually sighted people who could see that info to shut their eyes so as not to see your physical appearance?

If not - the question is why you'd want to keep it hidden from someone who couldn't see it without a description?

Obviously not all VI people want or would ask for this information.

Bit in the context of disability training it's designed to get people to consider why they'd want to or actively decide to hide information from a blind person readily available to a sighted one.

PestorPeston · 15/09/2022 21:18

timeofillusion · 15/09/2022 21:12

We are of course all assuming that because A was VI and had various disabilities that they were also an excellent trainer. They may actually be a really crap trainer and, although obviously all too aware of the difficulties they and others face, useless at getting that message across or dealing with anyone who asks sensible questions. The other attendees may be the sort of people that are terribly compliant, wouldn't say boo to a goose and would say that training was superb because they thought it was expected of them. Fact of the matter is that we don't know and are having to base our judgement on what little OP has told us. And that's remarkably little (and quite possibly just a wind up).

Person A may prefer to be described as an excellent piano player who also has an embarrassing amount of sheepskin slippers. Why do you insist one defining someone by their protected characteristics?

Have you done any D&I training recently?

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 21:15

PriOn1 · 15/09/2022 21:01

I'd buy that if it wasn't for the fact when person B was told not to strike the dog they ignored it and carried on. They clearly weren't interested in learning a thing.

Well yes, almost certainly. I’d still ask them why though, before making a decision about what action to take.

Meant stroke 🫣

They said why.

They said they weren't interested because it's all woke nonsense. It's in the OP.

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 21:13

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 20:59

@Kendodd

You seem to be extremely paranoid

Do you not understand that it puts people on a level playing field

You can see what they look like, other people who aren't VI or blind can see what you look like, it's reasonable for them to ask. Especially if they're visually impaired and have limited vision

And is it reasonable for me to say 'no' to the request for a physical description? Or if I was a Tesco employee, should I face disciplinary action for refusing such a request from a customer ?

timeofillusion · 15/09/2022 21:12

We are of course all assuming that because A was VI and had various disabilities that they were also an excellent trainer. They may actually be a really crap trainer and, although obviously all too aware of the difficulties they and others face, useless at getting that message across or dealing with anyone who asks sensible questions. The other attendees may be the sort of people that are terribly compliant, wouldn't say boo to a goose and would say that training was superb because they thought it was expected of them. Fact of the matter is that we don't know and are having to base our judgement on what little OP has told us. And that's remarkably little (and quite possibly just a wind up).

EgonSpengler2020 · 15/09/2022 21:08

The continued patting of the good dog when asked/reminded not to, is not acceptable.

The insistance on needing others to describe themselves when they may not be comfortable doing so, is not a reasonable adjustment. It is unnecessary, I work remotely from colleauges in our control room who in nearly 2 decades I have never met and have no idea what they like, but recognise their voice straight away, I don't need to know their appearance to do my job. Obviously some people can be quite uncomfortable about their body and appearance, to the point of diagnosable MH disorders in extreme cases, so I don't think it is reasonable to ask a professional contact you have just met to describe themselves for this reason.

knittingaddict · 15/09/2022 21:04

I've known a lot of blind and partially sighted people through my parents and not one has ever asked me or anyone around me to describe themselves. I personally find it a very odd request.

FontSnob · 15/09/2022 21:03

Person b was a wanker. (Im assuming its moved on since page one but they were enough of a wanker to merit me not reading the fucking thread)

PriOn1 · 15/09/2022 21:01

I'd buy that if it wasn't for the fact when person B was told not to strike the dog they ignored it and carried on. They clearly weren't interested in learning a thing.

Well yes, almost certainly. I’d still ask them why though, before making a decision about what action to take.

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 20:59

@Kendodd

You seem to be extremely paranoid

Do you not understand that it puts people on a level playing field

You can see what they look like, other people who aren't VI or blind can see what you look like, it's reasonable for them to ask. Especially if they're visually impaired and have limited vision

ArchieStar · 15/09/2022 20:58

Haven’t RTFT so apologies if this is a repeated question… but surely in a LAW FIRM they are aware of the equality act? And they could be sued under this?

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:57

PriOn1 · 15/09/2022 20:56

I’m generally quite uncomfortable with training sessions where I might be expected to do things I haven’t mentally prepared for. Indeed I walked out of a work event a couple of weeks ago, because I was prepared for lectures and panel discussions, where audience input would normally be in the form of voluntary questions, and instead was being asked to do various verbal exercises with a stranger who happened to be sitting beside me.

So I can imagine a situation where B thought they were going to have reasonable adjustments explained to them, and instead found themselves having to participate. So it does rather depend whether B is someone who genuinely needs reasonable adjustments herself, or is just an awkward sod.

Am I correct in thinking that reasonable adjustments, in the normal way of things, would be agreed between the manager and employee, and then introduced to the rest as something that the manager had agreed to, and was therefore more official? Presumably other people could then object to management directly if they disagreed? Any attack on the employee themselves or failure to comply with the adjustments would also be for management to deal with.

But if this was a trainer, I would expect her to be able to train people and, to an extent, that should involve being able to deal with difficult trainees.

It does sound like B was beyond reasonable and the trainer would be within her rights to ask B to leave the session and explain to the manager(s) who brought her in, why she had done so. I would then expect the manager(s)to talk to B about it, to hear B’s side, and find out why she behaved so badly.

Only after hearing B’s side, and ideally also after hearing other people’s comments about what occurred between A and B, would I then be able to make an assessment of who was unreasonable. It sounds like B, but it’s always important to give people a chance to explain themselves, even if you have to take past behaviour into account.

I'd buy that if it wasn't for the fact when person B was told not to strike the dog they ignored it and carried on. They clearly weren't interested in learning a thing.

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 20:56

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 20:42

It's not an unreasonable demand

It's perfectly normal and common when meeting F2F with blind or visually impaired people to do that

And is quite relevant to the subject matter of the training this person opted to attend

I've only really known two blind people in my life, neither of them EVER asked me for a physical description of myself, one of them I knew very well. Both were male, I am female and I was mostly alone with them (volunteer driver). If they'd asked me to give a physical description of myself I would have been extremely offended and upset. Why do they want to know what I look like? So they can make judgments about me? Know how attractive (or not) I am. And I am shocked that people think it's ok for blind to demand physical descriptions of shop assistants.

PriOn1 · 15/09/2022 20:56

I’m generally quite uncomfortable with training sessions where I might be expected to do things I haven’t mentally prepared for. Indeed I walked out of a work event a couple of weeks ago, because I was prepared for lectures and panel discussions, where audience input would normally be in the form of voluntary questions, and instead was being asked to do various verbal exercises with a stranger who happened to be sitting beside me.

So I can imagine a situation where B thought they were going to have reasonable adjustments explained to them, and instead found themselves having to participate. So it does rather depend whether B is someone who genuinely needs reasonable adjustments herself, or is just an awkward sod.

Am I correct in thinking that reasonable adjustments, in the normal way of things, would be agreed between the manager and employee, and then introduced to the rest as something that the manager had agreed to, and was therefore more official? Presumably other people could then object to management directly if they disagreed? Any attack on the employee themselves or failure to comply with the adjustments would also be for management to deal with.

But if this was a trainer, I would expect her to be able to train people and, to an extent, that should involve being able to deal with difficult trainees.

It does sound like B was beyond reasonable and the trainer would be within her rights to ask B to leave the session and explain to the manager(s) who brought her in, why she had done so. I would then expect the manager(s)to talk to B about it, to hear B’s side, and find out why she behaved so badly.

Only after hearing B’s side, and ideally also after hearing other people’s comments about what occurred between A and B, would I then be able to make an assessment of who was unreasonable. It sounds like B, but it’s always important to give people a chance to explain themselves, even if you have to take past behaviour into account.

PestorPeston · 15/09/2022 20:55

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 19:54

@NumberTheory

In a normal situation I'd tentatively agree that a blind or VI person doesn't have the right to have people describe themselves

But this was disability training

It will have been part of the training, as it highlights the differences many (as evidenced on here) just don't appreciate

Correct I have done this training.

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:55

User354354 · 15/09/2022 20:46

Obviously is common sense not to distract a guide god. Everyone knows that, most even have notices on their jackets.

Not sure why anyone needs to describe their appearance though. 'Hi person A, it's X I am fat, my hair hasn't been washed in days and I look like I haven't slept in a few weeks' would be my description currently.

But you are choosing to describe those physical characteristics.

You could equally say "I'm 5"5, have dark hair and blue eyes"

Both your description you gave and my alternative can be seen by everyone else in the room.

But it's quite obvious yours isn't what they are asking. People know what "describe yourself means".

Even the 5yo I teach can grasp that simple task

knittingaddict · 15/09/2022 20:53

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:35

Sorry! Visually impaired trainer with a cane and other disabilities. Don't distract guide dog and describe your appearance. Person B kept patting dog and didn't want to describe themselves. I think she also said "you can tell I'm a woman".

My mum had numerous guide dogs. The person stroking the dog was an idiot. It's the number one rule when a dog is working.

I don't think it's at all necessary for anyone to describe their appearance. Both of my parents are/were blind. They would never have requested that because it's irrelevant.

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:52

The trainer can explain how it disadvantages them without insisting that people must describe themselves.

True. They could also ask why they are happy for every person in the room with sight to know their hair and eye colour, clothing etc but not them.

That would be a really good learning tool to remind those with sight what they seem to have failed to realise. People can see you!

And get them to really question why someone without sight isn't allowed to "see" them.

But judging by this thread they'd still meet people completely unable to comprehend that simple fact Grin

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 15/09/2022 20:51

OP, yanbu.

I am unsure of why one needs to describe their appearance though? How is it relevant in a law firm work situation?