Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
blubberyboo · 15/09/2022 23:37

I also am uncomfortable with the describing yourself request.

it is something deeply personal and I think many people would find difficulty with it. Person B probably felt a bit attacked in front of colleagues then when the trainer persisted. she obviously didn’t explain her need for it very well but if she did and person b still didn’t want to comply then it should have been dropped. Personal A then should have moved on to another participant to show how the description would have helped them

how does person A know what disabilities person B or any other staff also have before demanding such a request? Person B may be on the autistic spectrum and really struggle to engage like that .

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 23:35

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 23:26

@MsPincher

Have you seen person Bs employment contract?

What do you think?

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 23:34

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 23:20

@Novum

Many of these comments are giving major all lives matter vibes

If you're not blind or visually impaired who the heck do you think you are to decide a request made by a blind or visually impaired person to make them feel more included in something is unreasonable

Ask why it's necessary if you really lack the imagination to understand why this is common sense - but to outright deny it's reasonability is really shitty

I'm half hoping these are trolls but a few I've seen on here for ages which is sad

You don’t get to override other peoples concerns just because you’ve decided that they must comply with your wishes. you also don’t get to demand everyone else does what you want because you know best. People are entitled to their own feelings and opinions whether or not they have a visual impairment.

many people here have already explained why they feel uncomfortable with the trainers behavior in some cases related to their own disabilities and protected characteristics. who the « heck do you think you are « to ignore and dismiss those concerns?

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 23:26

@MsPincher

Have you seen person Bs employment contract?

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 23:26

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 22:40

@EgonSpengler2020

Did you miss the part about 'saying it's woke for doing it'?

Also in this case there is a serious risk of repetitional harm which is definitely gross misconduct in almost everywhere I've ever worked

It’s definitely not gross misconduct even if thé trainers description was entirely accurate

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 23:24

Novum · 15/09/2022 23:17

Read the answers upthread about why this might be helpful to the trainer. I still don't understand on what basis you claim to know better about what may be helpful to a blind person than, um, a blind person. Nothing wrong with asking them politely to explain it, plenty wrong in saying "I just don't see how this could possibly make any difference to you."

And your entire scenario is irrelevant to OP's question anyway. If that were B's situation, they could very easily have found a polite way of saying no. But they chose to be rude and confrontational.

And I would say 'no' politely.
I have said upthread that the rudeness is a separate issue and should be dealt with in a disciplinary.
Do you not understand how wanting someone to give them physical description of themselves could make someone very uncomfortable?

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 23:20

@Novum

Many of these comments are giving major all lives matter vibes

If you're not blind or visually impaired who the heck do you think you are to decide a request made by a blind or visually impaired person to make them feel more included in something is unreasonable

Ask why it's necessary if you really lack the imagination to understand why this is common sense - but to outright deny it's reasonability is really shitty

I'm half hoping these are trolls but a few I've seen on here for ages which is sad

Novum · 15/09/2022 23:17

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 23:05

Yes I would seriously go into a session like that and say 'im not willing to give a physical description of myself '.
Could you please tell me how saying that would prevent the trainer from doing their job?
It could actually add to the value training session, in that it could open up discussion about why this information is wanted by the trainer. Where one person's rights and comfort end and anothers begin and how those rights should be balanced. How a man asking a young woman to give a physical description of herself, in front of a room full of people might make her very uncomfortable. And then that man demanding this information from her under threat of disciplinary action, may not be ok.

Read the answers upthread about why this might be helpful to the trainer. I still don't understand on what basis you claim to know better about what may be helpful to a blind person than, um, a blind person. Nothing wrong with asking them politely to explain it, plenty wrong in saying "I just don't see how this could possibly make any difference to you."

And your entire scenario is irrelevant to OP's question anyway. If that were B's situation, they could very easily have found a polite way of saying no. But they chose to be rude and confrontational.

Princessglittery · 15/09/2022 23:14

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:35

Sorry! Visually impaired trainer with a cane and other disabilities. Don't distract guide dog and describe your appearance. Person B kept patting dog and didn't want to describe themselves. I think she also said "you can tell I'm a woman".

Both the requests were reasonable.

The Guide Dog is working and petting it sends the wrong message I.e. not working time.

The describe yourself is to help the trainer to recognise a person through their voice, the direction of their voice, possibly key features if they have some vision e.g. a red top, black hair etc. This then helps them to make sure everyone is following the training, answering questions, perhaps if they have some vision nodding or raising a hand.

As a law firm you need to emphasis any Employment Tribunal would consider these requests to be reasonable and would find in favour of the trainer.

AssumingDirectControl · 15/09/2022 23:14

GretaVanFleet · 15/09/2022 23:02

But what you’re describing isn’t the scenario as you are describing yourself, it’s not a discussion. All you need to say is probably your height, hair colour and if you feel comfortable maybe hair length. They’re not asking a male colleague to comment nor do you have to give your inside leg measurement and bra size. Person A’s aim isn’t making people uncomfortable, they are visually impaired, I don’t think people are appreciating how hard that must be.

I am very fat. In this scenario, I could either say I’m fat, which would make me feel horribly embarrassed, or I could avoid it, which would make me spend a long time being preoccupied with thinking that everyone was quietly laughing at me for not stating the obvious.

what would be better and more inclusive would be the trainer saying “please could everyone share one thing about their appearance today” which would give them a touchstone for each person but avoid putting others in a difficult situation.

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 23:11

@Kendodd

What do you not understand - it's not about being able to do one's job

It's about inclusion

Also making a point about reasonable adjustments for inclusivity of those that are disabled during a disability awareness course is very much that persons job.

Asking them to make those adjustments is part of the course, therefore part of the trainers job

Novum · 15/09/2022 23:08

EgonSpengler2020 · 15/09/2022 22:56

If it was a VI person giving a presentation on a completely unrelated topic, then maybe you'd have a point, but surely a dedicated session on disability and inclusion is exactly the place to have these discussions in the open, so that everyone can understand what impact one persons 'reasonable adjustments' could have on someone else's needs.

You can certainly ask politely how it helps them. You don't get to tell them their reasonable adjustments are woke and over-sensitive.

GabriellaMontez · 15/09/2022 23:06

I am curious about whether the requirement to self-describe included an instruction to share pronouns.

This will be part of the missing information that the op hasn't shared. Possibly because she hasn't asked the other participants for their version.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/09/2022 23:06

I agree with PP that we may not be getting the full story here. Why should B say ‘I’m a woman’? Had the trainer asked for the dreaded pronouns? That would explain why B may have felt disgruntled before the session got going?

I have run a lot of training sessions on all sorts of topics in my working life ( not about sexuality awareness though, I think I would rather starve). I can’t remember ever complaining about an attendee, although like every trainer, I occasionally experienced some fairly bizarre and inattentive behaviour. One of the skills which a qualified trainer should have is to run the group harmoniously and in an involving way . If an attendee was being totally disruptive, I would ask them to leave, and attempt to get the group to agree that this was the best course of action.

I’m not sure that the trainer had the proper qualifications to run a training session,,perhaps they would have benefitted from a moderator to run the group, and they could be there to describe the interventions which they would find helpful.

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 23:05

Novum · 15/09/2022 22:49

Well, perhaps you should ask a blind person that question. But people on here have given a number of reasons. Would you seriously go to a session like that where a blind person tells you what would help them to do their job and start arguing with them about it? Can you see how incredibly crass that would be?

If you are going to say that your discomfort should absolve you from this, I hope you have already told your employers about this disability so that they can make the reasonable adjustments that you apparently require. But are you seriously saying that there is absolutely no way you could comply with this request and be comfortable? Even if it's just a matter of saying, say, "I'm average height, blonde hair, and I'm wearing a blue jumper today"?

Yes I would seriously go into a session like that and say 'im not willing to give a physical description of myself '.
Could you please tell me how saying that would prevent the trainer from doing their job?
It could actually add to the value training session, in that it could open up discussion about why this information is wanted by the trainer. Where one person's rights and comfort end and anothers begin and how those rights should be balanced. How a man asking a young woman to give a physical description of herself, in front of a room full of people might make her very uncomfortable. And then that man demanding this information from her under threat of disciplinary action, may not be ok.

GretaVanFleet · 15/09/2022 23:02

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 15/09/2022 18:51

I would have done it to be polite and be inclusive, but actually I hate when people comment on or discuss my physical appearance at work. It tends to be men who do it. What I look like has zero bearings on the reason that I am at work (which is to use my brain and do a good job). If someone felt similar, plus add in some body/ appearance hang ups I can understand it might make them feel uncomfortable. And that should be respected.

But what you’re describing isn’t the scenario as you are describing yourself, it’s not a discussion. All you need to say is probably your height, hair colour and if you feel comfortable maybe hair length. They’re not asking a male colleague to comment nor do you have to give your inside leg measurement and bra size. Person A’s aim isn’t making people uncomfortable, they are visually impaired, I don’t think people are appreciating how hard that must be.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 15/09/2022 23:02

playing with a working guide dog is very much not ok. It's similar to playing with the brakes on a wheelchair user's chair. Totally shitty behaviour.

But it's fine to not want to describe yourself. Loads of reasons why someone might not be ok with that. It's not a reasonable adjustment if you are asking someone to confront something that they don't normally have to cope with at work with no notice if that's something that will cause them issues.

I am curious about whether the requirement to self-describe included an instruction to share pronouns. Google for the 'Pronouns are rophynol' article for why this might go against someone's beliefs - beliefs that have been established in law as legitimate and worthy of protection under the equalities act. I can see how being told to set aside my beliefs as a "reasonable adjustment" for someone else would get my back up and make me very uncooperative.

EgonSpengler2020 · 15/09/2022 22:56

Novum · 15/09/2022 22:49

Well, perhaps you should ask a blind person that question. But people on here have given a number of reasons. Would you seriously go to a session like that where a blind person tells you what would help them to do their job and start arguing with them about it? Can you see how incredibly crass that would be?

If you are going to say that your discomfort should absolve you from this, I hope you have already told your employers about this disability so that they can make the reasonable adjustments that you apparently require. But are you seriously saying that there is absolutely no way you could comply with this request and be comfortable? Even if it's just a matter of saying, say, "I'm average height, blonde hair, and I'm wearing a blue jumper today"?

If it was a VI person giving a presentation on a completely unrelated topic, then maybe you'd have a point, but surely a dedicated session on disability and inclusion is exactly the place to have these discussions in the open, so that everyone can understand what impact one persons 'reasonable adjustments' could have on someone else's needs.

Novum · 15/09/2022 22:49

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 22:33

Why do the 'need' a verbal description, from me, of how I look?
And they have a right to this information, and for me to supply it, regardless of how I feel about it, just because sighted people have that information? I'm guessing because it would make the blind person feel more comfortable . What about my comfort? Why should I have to do something that would make me very uncomfortable? Why is my comfort less important?

And why is it a reasonable adjustment? How does refusing to make such an adjustment prevent the blind person from doing their job?

Well, perhaps you should ask a blind person that question. But people on here have given a number of reasons. Would you seriously go to a session like that where a blind person tells you what would help them to do their job and start arguing with them about it? Can you see how incredibly crass that would be?

If you are going to say that your discomfort should absolve you from this, I hope you have already told your employers about this disability so that they can make the reasonable adjustments that you apparently require. But are you seriously saying that there is absolutely no way you could comply with this request and be comfortable? Even if it's just a matter of saying, say, "I'm average height, blonde hair, and I'm wearing a blue jumper today"?

NumberTheory · 15/09/2022 22:49

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 22:34

@NumberTheory

Person B was at a course designed to show how people can be inclusive of those with disabilities

She was asked for a small action which is inclusive to the disabled host of the course

She refused and went off on one, saying it was woke

How you don't seem to understand the issues here is baffling to me

There are also many sexuality based awareness courses, my work do one every 6 months. If you went to that and refused to disclose your sexuality as part of the session and said people are woke for doing it, you'd be sat in a disciplinary real quick

It's nothing like assertiveness training. The fact you even think this shows the level of intellect you're playing with

Thank you for questioning my level of intellect and then doing this. I’m not above a bit of petty schadenfreude. I refer you back to my first reply to you at 20:45 where you will see that you have just followed your head up your own arse.

QueenB5 · 15/09/2022 22:46

@Figgygal if you work in HR, you should know that an investigation needs carried out before you can state what you have just written. I’m not saying you are wrong, but the op needs to throughly investigate and not make assumptions.

GretaVanFleet · 15/09/2022 22:46

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:35

Sorry! Visually impaired trainer with a cane and other disabilities. Don't distract guide dog and describe your appearance. Person B kept patting dog and didn't want to describe themselves. I think she also said "you can tell I'm a woman".

The dog is working and should be left alone. It would be like B brushing your hair, totally inappropriate. Ask B to wear a blindfold for a day and see how they feel about people not describing themselves, all they need to say is I’m a 5’7” female with short blonde hair, they don’t need measurements.
The whole point of a reasonable adjustment is to try and create a level playing field for the member of staff.
If B isn’t careful they could be accused of disability discrimination.

Quveas · 15/09/2022 22:43

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:35

Sorry! Visually impaired trainer with a cane and other disabilities. Don't distract guide dog and describe your appearance. Person B kept patting dog and didn't want to describe themselves. I think she also said "you can tell I'm a woman".

F** that - you claim to be a law firm and don't know that verbally attacking a disabled person in such an insulting way is illegal and wrong? Shame it was a guide dog - another dog might have bit her. How insulting to the trainer. Where I work, and we aren't at all "woke" (whatever that is supposed to denote), she have been on disciplinary charges by now. And deserve to be.

Novum · 15/09/2022 22:42

EgonSpengler2020 · 15/09/2022 22:34

One thing this thread has shown is that there are a lot of people who would feel uncomfortable if put on the spot and asked to describe themselves.

Surely that is enough to say that this is not a reasonable request or adjustment.

No. These are people working in a law firm. They should surely be bright enough to work out a way of describing themselves that they are comfortable with, or alternatively explaining that they too have a disability which means that this would cause them distress. They don't have to do it publicly, they could take the trainer aside to explain that. The only reasonable adjustment they need is being excused from complying with this request. What is simply totally inappropriate and unacceptable is ignoring it or being rude about it.

broodybadger · 15/09/2022 22:42

@MsPincher

You're really not doing yourself any favours on this post

Repeatedly not understanding why someone who is visually impaired might benefit from some descriptions to help them when meeting people and now not reading sentences properly

The biggest issue is the 'woke' element

The refusal to participate is bad enough, the woke comments are what makes this a disciplinary matter

Swipe left for the next trending thread