Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? disabled person 'over sensitive'

609 replies

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:28

Person A has multiple disabilities and asks if everyone in a group can do something as a reasonable adjustment.
Person B refuses to do so. Person A asks again and explains why adjustment is needed. Person B tells person A they are 'woke', 'over sensitive' and that they (person B) will not be 'dictated to' by someone who doesn't even work here.
Person A complains to me (D&I advisor) and head of HR (my manager).
Neither me, nor manager were present.
Person A is an external disability awareness trainer and the group are a group of staff we had asked them to train on disabilitiy awareness as we had identified a need for it (as you can see!).
We struggled to get sign ups - expecting 30 but only 10 signed up. All other 9 people were positive about the session content.
Head of HR thinks Person A should 'let it go' because we are paying them, they are meant to be teaching us right from wrong, so should have expected that reaction and just dealt with it.
Head of HR thinks Person A was rude to 'single someone out' although neither of us were there to witness it (cause we had 'other things to do' - I did protest!)
I think we should action this but as you can see, my job isn't an easy one!

YABU - the trainer should have expected this / dealt with it themselves
YANBU - the trainer was right to complain and we should do something

OP posts:
deeperthanallroses · 16/09/2022 05:33

ManateeFair · 15/09/2022 19:37

Person B is a twat and your Head of HR is colossally incompetent. Person A is 100% correct to complain. Being paid as a contractor doesn’t mean it’s OK for people to treat you like that and refuse to make even the tiniest accommodations for your disability.

This, I cannot imagine a workplace policy where the patting the dog behaviour is not in breach of the employee code of conduct. Which applies to employee behaviours. The analogy upthread where the tesco worker would probably be fired is fair. Other analogies- if B carefully moved obstacles into As path, or someone came in on crutches and b took a crutch. B should be given a warning, your head of hr should be fired, and my sympathies to A. This can’t be a magic circle firm can it?? If I knew which one and we used it id try and stop using them, the culture sounds like a place we wouldn’t want to be associated with.

lickenchugget · 16/09/2022 05:30

Person A (trainer) said they wanted to know appearance to know who they are talking to and get an equal experience, as sighted people woudl know what we all look like.

I wouldn’t have wanted to do this either. I work in HR/recruitment and I don’t think this is standard, reasonable adjustment; this is a personal preference of Person A. What someone looks like has no bearing on their ability to do their job, so there is no requirement for Person A to know this in a work-related capacity. Actually can foresee how forcing people to describe themselves would lead to more HR issues in itself.

Obviously no one should be patting a guide dog.

marvellousmaple · 16/09/2022 05:16

How the heck does knowing the colour of your hair or what you are wearing help a blind person train people? I would have been like person B. Said nothing. Wouldn't have patted the dog though as that is not helpful for the dog .
If the trainer had asked them to speak about where they were sitting, their name and their experience . That would be reasonable.

sashh · 16/09/2022 05:07

From ACAS

What is reasonable
What's 'reasonable' will depend on each situation. The employer needs to consider carefully if the adjustment:

  • will remove or reduce the disadvantage for the person with the disability
  • is practical to make
  • is affordable by the employer or business
  • could harm the health and safety of others

As a sighted person I can see who I'm training, I think it is reasonable for the trainer to know roughly who they are training, as I said previously, training might change depending on the demographic being trained, the trainer can't do that if the are VI.

The employer could have provided a list of employees, possibly with photographs that someone could have described. As a supply teacher it is normal to be given a list of students with their pictures.

PriOn1 · 16/09/2022 04:45

That's an Australian site advising educators

I'm assuming the OP is in the UK and probably in England so English law applies, and this is a VI trainer not a student.

Yes, but I still think it’s arguable that forcing other employees to describe themselves is not something A needs to do their job, which is what I would assume reasonable adjustments are for.

I think it’s possible the UK has become so bogged down in inclusivity that it has been forgotten that other people’s needs have to be taken into account and balanced.

Big difference between “I can’t read my mail and therefore work need to find a means by which I can, in order to do my job” and “it’d make me feel happier if I knew what everyone looked like”.

So if “everyone else must describe themselves, even if it makes them uncomfortable” is now indeed considered a valid “reasonable adjustment” then the UK is going to experience a huge backlash from other employees who (quite reasonably, in my opinion) don’t feel the request is reasonable. The trainer can explain it might help, and why, but it should be a request, not a demand. Perhaps “woke” is a reasonable description, if there were other similar examples which were said to be “reasonable adjustments” when “inclusivity” isn’t really what reasonable adjustments were introduced for..

Being allowed to have a guide dog in the work place, and that the guide dog should be allowed to do its work unimpeded is a reasonable request/adjustment. The other isn’t.

itsgettingweird · 16/09/2022 04:30

I think there are plenty of people who feel discriminated against because of the way they look who might want to keep that information away from others when they can. The fact that most people are able to judge you without your engagement doesn’t mean you wouldn’t reasonably want to avoid that when you have the opportunity.

Then Don't use the information you are unhappy to share.

It's really not hard to describe yourself by just saying hair or eye colour. Or height. Or colour of jumper. Or if you're wearing trousers of shorts.

sashh · 16/09/2022 04:13

PriOn1 · 16/09/2022 04:09

Found a website that supplies a list of reasonable adjustments for visually impaired people. They are all much more practical and reasonable and impact less on others than “describe yourself”.

”Describe yourself” sounds like a request to improve the visually impaired person’s feeling of inclusion. It doesn’t sound like a reasonable adjustment. The employer would have to assess the impact on other employees and this thread demonstrates well that a good number of other employees might reasonably object. A can do their job perfectly well without having a description, it’s something they want, not something they need so they can do their job.

I think there’s a misunderstanding here of what “reasonable adjustments” are.

www.adcet.edu.au/students-with-disability/reasonable-adjustments-disability-specific/blind-and-vision-impaired

That's an Australian site advising educators.

I'm assuming the OP is in the UK and probably in England so English law applies, and this is a VI trainer not a student.

PriOn1 · 16/09/2022 04:09

Found a website that supplies a list of reasonable adjustments for visually impaired people. They are all much more practical and reasonable and impact less on others than “describe yourself”.

”Describe yourself” sounds like a request to improve the visually impaired person’s feeling of inclusion. It doesn’t sound like a reasonable adjustment. The employer would have to assess the impact on other employees and this thread demonstrates well that a good number of other employees might reasonably object. A can do their job perfectly well without having a description, it’s something they want, not something they need so they can do their job.

I think there’s a misunderstanding here of what “reasonable adjustments” are.

www.adcet.edu.au/students-with-disability/reasonable-adjustments-disability-specific/blind-and-vision-impaired

sashh · 16/09/2022 03:41

amazeandastonish · 15/09/2022 18:35

Sorry! Visually impaired trainer with a cane and other disabilities. Don't distract guide dog and describe your appearance. Person B kept patting dog and didn't want to describe themselves. I think she also said "you can tell I'm a woman".

Person B needs to be disciplined. I walk with a stick and occasionally use a wheel chair, I wouldn't expect anyone to play with my mobility aids and the same is true of a guide dog.

Not describing appearance is odd, name, age, what you are wearing - just things so the VI person can identify you.

The training could well be tailored to a group differently depending if it is middle aged women or a group of teens.

NumberTheory · 16/09/2022 03:23

Wouldloveanother · 16/09/2022 00:21

Keep that information away from who? The only people who can’t immediately ascertain it are people with limited vision.

I’m finding all this ‘uncomfortable describing myself’ stuff to be plain ridiculous. I’m surprised you can all handle the normal challenges of life if describing your clothing colour and height is somehow triggering.

You are suggesting, because someone cannot hide characteristics from everyone, it is incumbent on them to be an active participant in their own victimisation by highlighting for everyone’s attention. I disagree that it’s appropriate to force people to do.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 16/09/2022 00:38

Wouldloveanother · 16/09/2022 00:21

Keep that information away from who? The only people who can’t immediately ascertain it are people with limited vision.

I’m finding all this ‘uncomfortable describing myself’ stuff to be plain ridiculous. I’m surprised you can all handle the normal challenges of life if describing your clothing colour and height is somehow triggering.

If they want to know your clothing colour ask that. Thats a different question to describe yourself. It's totally shit to describe people's insecurities as ridiculous. What a nasty thing to say. some people have real empathy deficits. It shows how much some people need mental health awareness training.

Wouldloveanother · 16/09/2022 00:21

NumberTheory · 15/09/2022 21:54

I think there are plenty of people who feel discriminated against because of the way they look who might want to keep that information away from others when they can. The fact that most people are able to judge you without your engagement doesn’t mean you wouldn’t reasonably want to avoid that when you have the opportunity.

Keep that information away from who? The only people who can’t immediately ascertain it are people with limited vision.

I’m finding all this ‘uncomfortable describing myself’ stuff to be plain ridiculous. I’m surprised you can all handle the normal challenges of life if describing your clothing colour and height is somehow triggering.

LampLighter414 · 16/09/2022 00:18

Refusing to describe yourself is rude but I don’t think anything wrong with it. Person A has no authority over Person B in that regard.

But repetitive petting of the dog, property of Person A, is not on really.

CombatBarbie · 16/09/2022 00:17

OK so maybe the trainer could have started himself..... Apparently I'm 5'8 with ginger hair and wearing a purple tie.....

BadNomad · 16/09/2022 00:15

As someone with autism, I am extremely uncomfortable talking in group settings anyway, but also "please describe your appearance" is too open-ended for me. What is expected, where to start, when to stop, how much detail, what is appropriate, what is not appropriate, am I saying too much, am I talking too quietly etc. I probably would have left the room in a sweat!

It would have been better for the trainer to be more specific. "Please tell me your height/hair colour/eye colour/colour of top you are wearing". Or "if you're not comfortable answering this, just tell me your name and job role". Something like that. Disability awareness.

Person B did not handle this properly.

Pilipalapal · 16/09/2022 00:14

Person B is an absolute shitbag.

larry4PM · 16/09/2022 00:11

Playing with someone's guide dog shouldn't need to fall under 'reasonable adjustment'. It falls under DBAD. Honestly, it's just basic human decency/common sense.

Asking people to describe their appearance in a group setting, without being warned beforehand? No.

Ask me to describe my appearance, and the first word that pops into my head is fat. I could maybe make a joke of that in a one-to-one scenario where I didn't feel so exposed, but I'd be humiliated at saying that in front of a group of co-workers.

Maybe there are other ways to describe me, but that's all I could come up with on the spot, and I'd feel trapped and uncomfortable, and even stupider at having to out how I was feeling to the group.

Many people have physical insecurities. I don't think it was a reasonable adjustment.

Playdohkid · 16/09/2022 00:10

As a visually impaired person with blind family members, I am amazed that so many on this thread think a simple request for a vague description of one’s self is unreasonable.

I really hope those who would feel ‘uncomfortable’ sharing very basic information, identifiable by everyone else in the room, never have to experience visual impairment - what it’s like not to be able to give your colleague a quick wave across the room, to miss out on career opportunities by not seeing the right person or by making a mistake with who someone is. Especially when it’s a senior person, it’s really embarrassing. I have had personal comments about my impairment made at work by senior staff - I still remember what they said to me 10 years later. Not to mention the terrible IT - accessible IT often crashes and slows your machine down massively, another big disadvantage at work.

All my blind relatives have had sight and of course they know what colours are and picture what people look like in their heads.

I have diagnosed and medicated social anxiety too so I do understand that feeling of ‘uncomfortableness’ but I would urge posters to reconsider any reluctance to describe as engaging with this very basic request is such a simple way to be inclusive. Even just ‘I’m wearing a purple top and have flat shoes on’, nothing intimately personal. It makes things so much easier.

if you work in an office, maybe try closing your eyes at your desk for five minutes and have a think about what things would be like if you couldn’t see at work. Believe me, you’d have far more uncomfortable and embarrassing experiences on a daily basis than a fully sighted person.

CombatBarbie · 16/09/2022 00:10

Then people need to be kinder to themselves.... Anxiety is shit, I suffer massively but have also learnt other people's adjustments will sometimes trump mine.

Its no different to stupid ice breakers on courses or team building events. I despise these too BTW

Kendodd · 16/09/2022 00:05

CombatBarbie · 16/09/2022 00:01

Why are people homing in on their weight/size..... I'm 5'7 with blonde hair and wearing a white top is all that's needed.

Maybe because that's the first thing that would come to mind and they couldn't think of anything else.

CombatBarbie · 16/09/2022 00:01

Why are people homing in on their weight/size..... I'm 5'7 with blonde hair and wearing a white top is all that's needed.

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 23:59

Many, many people have explained that this demand would make them very uncomfortable, it's not a small number of people. I would be interested to know how the people who compiled with the demand felt about it, they may not have liked it either but didn't feel confident enough to refuse.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 15/09/2022 23:57

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 20:13

I'd probably say something like "I'm fat but I could have got away without telling you that!"

But then I'm comfy around disability as my DS is disabled and competes at British disability level so spend a lot of time around people removing legs/arms/ hearing aids and being totally comfortable with who they are (they are swimmers) and I know disabled people have as great a sense of humour as the non disabled.

I just don't get why people don't treat disabled people as they'd treat anyone else or want to be treated themselves 🤷‍♀️

Reasonable adjustments are just (or should be) human nature as you want everyone to have the same access as you.

And if someone points out an adjustment they need it seems to odd to me why you wouldn't just do it?

I'm surprised how many people think they need to keep secret something everyone else in the room can see from someone because they are blind 🤦🏼‍♀️

People can see I'm fat, short, greying frizzy hair, wrinkles, massive thighs and calves, saggy boobs and am usually the ugliest person in the room. Should I say that? Clearly it's a question which needs answering in a specific and sensitive way because anxiety issues also deserve reasonable adjustments.

MsPincher · 15/09/2022 23:41

Princessglittery · 15/09/2022 23:14

Both the requests were reasonable.

The Guide Dog is working and petting it sends the wrong message I.e. not working time.

The describe yourself is to help the trainer to recognise a person through their voice, the direction of their voice, possibly key features if they have some vision e.g. a red top, black hair etc. This then helps them to make sure everyone is following the training, answering questions, perhaps if they have some vision nodding or raising a hand.

As a law firm you need to emphasis any Employment Tribunal would consider these requests to be reasonable and would find in favour of the trainer.

It isn’t the case that a tribunal would find the « requests were reasonable ». Nor that they would ever be asked to do so - the trainer has not suffered any loss nor would they be able to claim any as a result of a failure to make a reasonable adjustment. It isn’t a reasonable adjustment case.

Kendodd · 15/09/2022 23:41

If you're not blind or visually impaired who the heck do you think you are to decide a request made by a blind or visually impaired person to make them feel more included in something is unreasonable

Well, two things.
If the request from a blind person is reasonable, i would argue that it may or not be depending on the circumstances. As I said upthread, I've only really known two blind people as a volunteer driver years ago. Both middle aged men, me a young woman. I don't think it reasonable for them to demand I give them a physical description of myself. I pick them up, lead them to the car, take them where they're going, lead them in. They don't need to pick me out of a crowd. Others might argue all requests by blind people for a physical description are reasonable and should be complied with.

Secondly, is it unreasonable for a person to refuse to give a physical description of themselves if they don't want to and should they be forced to do so.

Swipe left for the next trending thread