Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to lower my childrens a pocket money to match their stepsisters

340 replies

ormav · 15/09/2022 16:16

I have a daughter (15) and a son (12) with my ex. Originally when their mum and I started giving them pocket money we went with a formula of £3 multiplied by how old they were. Since their mum and I divorced 7 years ago I have been responsible for paying the kids their pocket money. I have kept to the original formula we agreed on. So now our daughter get £45 a week and her brother gets £36 a week.

Last year their mum got married. Her husband also has a daughter (14), so my kids have a stepsister now. Apparently she just found out how much our children are getting for their pocket money. She found out when my sons was talking about saving up for a new computer and she asked how he could afford it and how much money he got. He told her how much and how it was based on how old they were.

Now that she knows my ex and her husband say it’s caused a lot of trouble in their household leading to jealousy issues and fighting. This is because their stepsister only receives £10 a week. Both my ex and her husband said that I need to lower the kids allowance. They say that inequality like that between children in the same household can severely adversely affect their sibling relationship. I think that if there is inequality in their household that it is their responsibility to deal with it, not mine. I told them they should should raise the amount his daughter gets if it’s an issue.

They told me that they couldn’t afford to give her that much, but even if they could they wouldn’t because they don’t believe children their ages should have access to the amount of money they have. They say that continuing to give them this much pocket money will also make them spoiled, entitled and bad with money.

My ex later said she assumed I was giving them a normal amount even though I just stuck with the formula we did and agreed upon a long time ago. She says that I obviously should have stopped raising it when it reached normal amount (I’ll point out here that she never said what a normal amount it).

I have since looked up the regular range for pocket money and I’ll acknowledge that theirs is on the higher side. That’s said I do not believe it is adversely affecting them. They do not act spoiled or entitled. They never demand to have things and accept when things don’t go as planned. They do their chores without complaint and do well in school. They get along very well with others their own age with the exception of their stepsister because she calls them spoiled. I would also they are the opposite of bad with money as they both have saved up a significant amount in their accounts and aren’t just spending their money on pointless things as soon as they get it.

OP posts:
Peeeko · 15/09/2022 20:24

YANBU. The amounts are irrelevant imo. It's nothing to do with you whether the child of some guy you don't really know is upset about your children's pocket money amount.

If that's what you want to give to your children then that is your choice and I wouldn't be swayed by what some random kid has said about it.

ChickenBurgers · 15/09/2022 20:23

Ignore everyone saying it’s too much, if you have the means to do this (which you obviously do!) then what someone else thinks is too much is irrelevant. I also don’t think you should be reducing it just to appease their new step sister because it’s her dads problem if she feels it’s unfair, would be unfair to your own kids and they don’t even live there the majority of the time anyway.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 20:23

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 20:14

Stepsister is 14. Of course she’s going to be jealous, there’s grown women on this thread who’d like £40 a week for themselves.
I don’t think the Op’s kids will miss out if it’s saved rather than handed over. It’s different for the 17 year old who presumably has college friends and different expectations of a social life but tough for the younger ones.
I do think we should be giving kids the message about how we’d like the world to be not how it currently is.So yes you get money for working hard, some jobs pay more because they require more and not your dads rich and you get money for nothing.

Well yes they will, because it’s changing their normal, not because they’ve done something wrong or because it isn’t working, on account of someone else’s jealousy. They ARE saving it, and learning more about financial responsibility doing so than they would be if their dad was doing it on their behalf. I bet she’d complain about that too though, because she won’t have the same amount in savings to help her later on.

’how we’d like the world to be’ - how do you know OP isn’t? We’ve all got different ideas on that one. Even so, I’m not convinced that giving into jealousy is a particularly utopian value.

Some people have more. That’s life. I was also lucky because ‘dad’s rich’, but I still appreciated it and worked hard. Kids that have less given to them aren’t inherently more virtuous, or better people.

Jaaxe · 15/09/2022 20:22

Jesus Christ £45 a week?! That’s a crazy amount but if it’s what u want to give in pocket money that’s your choice. Not your problem they can’t match it.

I’d maybe just suggest to the 2 of them they don’t rub it in step sisters face and keep it on the down low to avoid resentment.

Or give them £10 in cash and put the rest in a savings account for them and tell them they do have access to the rest if/when they need or want it for whatever/whenever they just need to ask you. It saves any arguments and it might make them think more about how much they’re saving and save up for something they really want etc

womaninatightspot · 15/09/2022 20:21

Discuss with children, give them 10 quid a week each and put the remainder in savings for them. Same result but everyone has same disposable income.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 15/09/2022 20:20

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 20:14

Stepsister is 14. Of course she’s going to be jealous, there’s grown women on this thread who’d like £40 a week for themselves.
I don’t think the Op’s kids will miss out if it’s saved rather than handed over. It’s different for the 17 year old who presumably has college friends and different expectations of a social life but tough for the younger ones.
I do think we should be giving kids the message about how we’d like the world to be not how it currently is.So yes you get money for working hard, some jobs pay more because they require more and not your dads rich and you get money for nothing.

WTF?
That is the real world. If your parents are rich you get more.

His finances are not the business of some kid who's name he doesn't even have to learn.

PenTantrum · 15/09/2022 20:19

What sort of mother tries to stop a father giving their child money to appease her new bloke. Fuck that.

You’re happy with the amount you give them, they live with you got the majority of the time and they sound like lovely kids. Just continue to do as you’re doing.

I do feel for the step daughter. These are the kind of things that are really hard for kids when they are told they now have step siblings and live with people who have different parents with different circumstances. Blended families are mostly shit for kids in my experience. However, that’s not your problem, your only responsibility is to your own children here.

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 20:14

Stepsister is 14. Of course she’s going to be jealous, there’s grown women on this thread who’d like £40 a week for themselves.
I don’t think the Op’s kids will miss out if it’s saved rather than handed over. It’s different for the 17 year old who presumably has college friends and different expectations of a social life but tough for the younger ones.
I do think we should be giving kids the message about how we’d like the world to be not how it currently is.So yes you get money for working hard, some jobs pay more because they require more and not your dads rich and you get money for nothing.

Boreded · 15/09/2022 19:58

iwantasandwich · 15/09/2022 16:20

Ignore those fixating on the amount

I was given similar to that amount when I was 15 (17 years ago now) and grew up in a council house so it's hardly too much considering inflation and their ages

No comment…but I’m not the only one thinking it

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 19:44

Not every problem someone has requires other people, related or not, to compromise or find a solution for them.

Sometimes, someone’s problem is just that: their problem, and one they need to suck up.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 19:42

budgiegirl · 15/09/2022 18:55

but that’s a risk you take when you blend families 🤷🏻‍♀️ Different kids, different parents. ‘Equalizing’ it will create a new set of problems, because it’s only being done to pander to the step sister

It is a risk, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't be sensitive to the problems it can cause. While I'm not sure how you deal with this, I don't think it's fair to be calling it 'pandering' to the step sister.

But it isn’t a problem, not for OP and not for his kids. It’s a system that’s worked well for them.

Of course it’s pandering. The problem isn’t Op’s kids and their pocket money, the problem is the stepsister’s jealousy. The ex and her father need to deal with that with her, not take away from the others and create a different set of problems.

Op can provide more for his kids, and this is going to be true whether he cuts the allowance or not. It means that throughout life they’ll probably have access to things the stepsister doesn’t. Indeed, she’ll come across many people with more, and many people with less. That’s life, and it’s something she needs to be taught to come to terms with.

Lovemusic33 · 15/09/2022 19:41

I’m not sure why so many people are saying “it’s too much”, if you can afford it then it’s up to you how much you give your dc. Your ex sounds a bit crazy just because her partner can’t afford to give his dc the same. Maybe it’s a good time for them to teach the kids that not everything is equal and fair in life.

beachcitygirl · 15/09/2022 19:41

My 17 year old gets £50 a week from me (and im a low earner)

But i do not put my hand in my pocket for anything else except clothes she needs (not wants) and food/housing etc

She pays her own phone cost of and bill
Magazines
Make up
Transport
Clothes she fancies (fancy trainers etc)
Clubs

She ofteb buys me flowers or chocs or treats me to the movies from her own money & is proud as punch to do so.

We were out for a family meal about 6 weeks ago as a celebration & when my dh went to pay the bill she had already paid it as a treat.
We were flabherghasted and so so so proud of her. (It was over £140)

She said it made her feel warm & fuzzy & proud to be able to do that.

My pal who used to only give £10 a week to a similiar age kid but was paying all the orher stuff, did a count one week & she was paying out much more than me on adhoc basis & her kid wasnt learning to budget/be responsible/pay phone bill etc

Her kid now gets £50 a week too

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 15/09/2022 19:35

budgiegirl · 15/09/2022 18:55

but that’s a risk you take when you blend families 🤷🏻‍♀️ Different kids, different parents. ‘Equalizing’ it will create a new set of problems, because it’s only being done to pander to the step sister

It is a risk, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't be sensitive to the problems it can cause. While I'm not sure how you deal with this, I don't think it's fair to be calling it 'pandering' to the step sister.

It's not a problem for anyone OP cares about and so it's not a problem.

This is why people need to stop shoving kids together and think they're family.

Meseekslookatme · 15/09/2022 19:34

GiltEdges · 15/09/2022 16:19

I don’t think your response was unreasonable. You can spend your money however you see fit 🤷🏼‍♀️

Exactly, the resentment if you reduce the amount will be directed at you.
If they are careful spenders and good kids I'd say tough. Exes issue not yours

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 19:33

Subbaxeo · 15/09/2022 19:12

I know-which is one of the reasons why I and my DH didn’t move in together until our respective children were grown. Our children were raised quite differently and I could foresee lots of tension if we’d all just moved in together. But it’s a risk for the adults to manage not to expect the children to just suck it up. We’re not talking about occasional things like expensive holidays but something impacting on their day to day lives. I’d be cross with my ex if he had the I’ll do what I want attitude if I raised such an issue with him. A little compromise and sensitivity wouldn’t go amiss.

Sure, they can work to manage the stepsister’s expectations. She’s going to have to learn that in life some people have more than her, and this includes her stepsiblings.

Cutting the pocket money isn’t managing anything, it’s only going to create more problems. OP’s kids losing out because of a jealous stepsister isn’t going to improve any relationships, but could very easily damage the one they have with their father. This is their normal that has worked well for them, and they haven’t done anything wrong to justify it changing. The only reason the ex wants to change it is to pander to two newcomers.

ZoeCM · 15/09/2022 19:32

Sweet baby Jesus, I got one pound a week from my parents! If I was lucky, my grandfather gave me another pound.

LaughingCat · 15/09/2022 19:32

Another vote here for keeping your kids’ pocket money the same, even if I nearly fell off the chair when I read how much you give them 😂. I came from a reasonably well to do family with private schools and the like but had £1 a week pocket money until I was ten, when it went up to £3 a week until I was told at 13 to get a weekend job if I wanted extra cash - I can’t believe you didn’t stop increasing the amount either! 😂.

But that aside, you made a commitment to your kids, and you do have to honour that. It’s not nice for their stepsister but that’s an issue for your ex and her husband to solve. There’s no one right way to do pocket money and your kids seem to be working well within this framework so don’t mess with it. Your ex will find a different way to solve the issue on their side.

3WildOnes · 15/09/2022 19:31

I received over £100 a month and that was almost 20 years ago.
I would save some of it for bigger items like, an ipod, miss sixty jeans, concert tickets, etc. A bit would go on make up or a new t shirt but most would go on socialising. I would meet up with friends every weekend am we would often go to the cinema or out fir lunch or dinner.
To the posters who only give their teenagers £10 a month, do your teenagers not really go to the cinema/bowling/ice skating/coffee shops/meals out with friends? Or would you give your children money separately for this?

beachcitygirl · 15/09/2022 19:30

@Summerfun54321 maybe your kids.. not mine. She is eminently sensible

beachcitygirl · 15/09/2022 19:29

Yanbu

You parent your way. Do your jkids have bank accounts with a debit card - so that the money cannot be taken off them to "make it fair"

Pretty soon one or both of your kids may have a part-time job & will have even more money.

Even so

How your ex & her partner parent his kid is NOT your problem.

Not your circus, not your monkeys.
Ignore your ex unless your kids are being entitled brats which it doesnt sound like they are

MsRosley · 15/09/2022 19:29

That's a ridiculous amount of money, but still not the business of anyone else but your current partner.

Upwiththelark76 · 15/09/2022 19:24

Actually I’m with you OP if you can afford it then I dont see the problem . Your kids save up if they want something. I presume they are responsible with money because you are teaching them about it’s value and saving for items they want rather than demanding .

good for you !

Cantstandbullshit · 15/09/2022 19:24

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 15/09/2022 16:20

You're not setting them up well for life by giving them access to that much cash now. They will have no financial skills, no awareness of the cost of things.

That’s not true jeez MN couch experts strike again.

Their financial awareness will depend on multiple factors such as how you teach them, what they see you do with money etc not just by increasing or Lowering the amount of pocket money.

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 15/09/2022 19:23

Firstly, wow! Back to the question, I can’t believe your ex wants to do that to her own kids. Is her husband really that controlling? It’s not your fault that they can’t afford to give more money so don’t be bullied into giving less. It’s your money to spend as you choose and their problem to make up the difference if they’re that bothered. Some people have more cash in life and your ex, the step-dad and the step-sister have to learn that 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread