Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to lower my childrens a pocket money to match their stepsisters

340 replies

ormav · 15/09/2022 16:16

I have a daughter (15) and a son (12) with my ex. Originally when their mum and I started giving them pocket money we went with a formula of £3 multiplied by how old they were. Since their mum and I divorced 7 years ago I have been responsible for paying the kids their pocket money. I have kept to the original formula we agreed on. So now our daughter get £45 a week and her brother gets £36 a week.

Last year their mum got married. Her husband also has a daughter (14), so my kids have a stepsister now. Apparently she just found out how much our children are getting for their pocket money. She found out when my sons was talking about saving up for a new computer and she asked how he could afford it and how much money he got. He told her how much and how it was based on how old they were.

Now that she knows my ex and her husband say it’s caused a lot of trouble in their household leading to jealousy issues and fighting. This is because their stepsister only receives £10 a week. Both my ex and her husband said that I need to lower the kids allowance. They say that inequality like that between children in the same household can severely adversely affect their sibling relationship. I think that if there is inequality in their household that it is their responsibility to deal with it, not mine. I told them they should should raise the amount his daughter gets if it’s an issue.

They told me that they couldn’t afford to give her that much, but even if they could they wouldn’t because they don’t believe children their ages should have access to the amount of money they have. They say that continuing to give them this much pocket money will also make them spoiled, entitled and bad with money.

My ex later said she assumed I was giving them a normal amount even though I just stuck with the formula we did and agreed upon a long time ago. She says that I obviously should have stopped raising it when it reached normal amount (I’ll point out here that she never said what a normal amount it).

I have since looked up the regular range for pocket money and I’ll acknowledge that theirs is on the higher side. That’s said I do not believe it is adversely affecting them. They do not act spoiled or entitled. They never demand to have things and accept when things don’t go as planned. They do their chores without complaint and do well in school. They get along very well with others their own age with the exception of their stepsister because she calls them spoiled. I would also they are the opposite of bad with money as they both have saved up a significant amount in their accounts and aren’t just spending their money on pointless things as soon as they get it.

OP posts:
Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 15/09/2022 22:13

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 21:40

Why do you think he should care?

Because his kids have a new family to settle into? As someone else said blended families are normally shit for the kids. If the adults involved can do something about it they should.
His kids can have the money but just less in the other kids face. What’s wrong with that.

Again. These people are not their family. The adults have made a decision that the children have to live with.

He sint involved it's not his house.

Why? Why should they have less? When their father has provided a better life for them?

A lot actually.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 22:12

KosherDill · 15/09/2022 21:59

This is what I've been thinking, too. The issue should have stopped at their doorstep, with the OP and kids not involved at all.

I don’t think a lot of people are seeing beyond the amounts. For whatever reason there’s resentment even on here in regards to the sums involved. Some posters want to see it cut regardless of how outrageous the reasoning.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 22:08

Honestly if the mother keeps pushing this what’s likely to happen is that the kids will move to their father’s full time. They’re at an age where they indeed vote with their feet.

that’ll solve the problem though, won’t it? No inequality in the same household.

billy1966 · 15/09/2022 22:01

Carry on as before.

Your ex has some cheek interfering in a set up that she doesn't contribute to and has worked well.

The amount you give them, while largish is covering activities, and they are saving some too.

I think some new step sister being jealous, has absolutely no bearing on what has worked well for you, for years.

I wouldn't entertain it.

KosherDill · 15/09/2022 21:59

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 21:38

Actually I’d say the real problem here is that the mother, who agreed to, and never had any previous issue with this arrangement, is willing to fuck over her children to make her new husband happy.

This is what I've been thinking, too. The issue should have stopped at their doorstep, with the OP and kids not involved at all.

SeasonFinale · 15/09/2022 21:58

You do you. The kids live with you the majority of time. They seem like they are handling the responsibility well which is a good thing and paying for their luxuries too.

Maybe tell your kids it is sometimes easier not to speak about finances with other people because it leads to jealousy and issues.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 21:58

“inequality like that between children in the same household can severely adversely affect their sibling relationship”

Yes, because cutting pocket money solely because their mother’s new husband’s kid is jealous will definitely not have an adverse affect on the ‘sibling’ relationship. Cut it down to a tenner and it’ll be happy families for sure.

Ooopa · 15/09/2022 21:55

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 21:40

Why do you think he should care?

Because his kids have a new family to settle into? As someone else said blended families are normally shit for the kids. If the adults involved can do something about it they should.
His kids can have the money but just less in the other kids face. What’s wrong with that.

Yeah changing their pocket money or removing it from them to save instead to appease their new step sibling sounds like a great way to create harmonious and loving relations between all the kids.

It's really none of the 14 year olds business what her dad's new partners kids get from their dad, a man she doesn't know. And there's nothing wrong with explaining that to her.

There is no point trying to make every single thing fair in blended families. The children often have family that isn't shared and therefore can't be fair all of the time.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 21:53

Corcory · 15/09/2022 21:48

How about setting up savings accounts for your two and suggest to them that you put most of their money into it then they can have £10 cash a week to do with whatever they like. The saved money is there's too but no longer treated as pocket money.

Why? There’s no problem with the way things are for OP and his kids. They’re doing quite well saving their own money and learning how to be responsible and manage it themselves. Arguably more valuable for them than a parent doing it for them.

the problem is with the stepsister, not them.

daisyjgrey · 15/09/2022 21:51

@Boreded what?

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 21:51

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 21:40

Why do you think he should care?

Because his kids have a new family to settle into? As someone else said blended families are normally shit for the kids. If the adults involved can do something about it they should.
His kids can have the money but just less in the other kids face. What’s wrong with that.

Yes, the ex’s proposal that they should lose out in their pocket money because she got remarried and their new stepsister is jealous does indeed suggest that blended families are shit for kids.

What’s wrong with it is that there’s no good reason for them to have less, unless you think jealousy is a compelling reason.

daisyjgrey · 15/09/2022 21:50

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 21:38

Actually I’d say the real problem here is that the mother, who agreed to, and never had any previous issue with this arrangement, is willing to fuck over her children to make her new husband happy.

I agree.

Ignore all the shrieking here, you actually sound reasonable and logical. Your ex is the one who is causing problems, not the pocket money which has been plodding along using the same formula for years.

Corcory · 15/09/2022 21:48

How about setting up savings accounts for your two and suggest to them that you put most of their money into it then they can have £10 cash a week to do with whatever they like. The saved money is there's too but no longer treated as pocket money.

JemimaPiddleDick · 15/09/2022 21:46

JemimaPiddleDick · 15/09/2022 21:45

“inequality like that between children in the same household can severely adversely affect their sibling relationship”

Yeah, and cutting two of their pocket money by a third and a quarter won’t?

Eek, cutting by two thirds and three quarters I mean.

JemimaPiddleDick · 15/09/2022 21:45

“inequality like that between children in the same household can severely adversely affect their sibling relationship”

Yeah, and cutting two of their pocket money by a third and a quarter won’t?

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 21:40

Why do you think he should care?

Because his kids have a new family to settle into? As someone else said blended families are normally shit for the kids. If the adults involved can do something about it they should.
His kids can have the money but just less in the other kids face. What’s wrong with that.

sheepdogdelight · 15/09/2022 21:39

luxxlisbon · 15/09/2022 17:39

It’s also interesting that posters some posters are claiming £30 a week is a totally insane amount of money.
Genuine question, what do your teens do on the weekend for £10 a week?? Do they not socialise?
It’s funny seeing people claim these kids are more likely to get into drink and drugs when actually a fiver would get them smashed in the park but £30 means they can spend their night at Nando’s and the cinema. I know where I would rather my 14 year old was!

Nandos and the cinema is two lots of socialising.

As to what my teens did - they go to the cinema, but just have a drink afterwards and sit and chat.

Or go for a walk or a cycle ride

Or they'd walk round the shops trying on unlikely clothes and looking at makeup.

Or go to somewhere cheaper like McDonalds

Or (summer) meet in the park with food from the local shop

or they'd go round to each others houses and club together to get a pizza

Or watch a film

Or actually DD has a group of friends that meet every couple of weeks to play board games and chat

At 16, everyone gets part time jobs and then they start with slightly more expensive socialising.

DC get £50 a month (that includes phone, makeup, buying presents and socialising) and generally have money left over.

Many adults don't have £50 a week just to spend on socialising. If your DC think that is normal, that's indicative of the circles you live in, not an essential.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 21:38

Actually I’d say the real problem here is that the mother, who agreed to, and never had any previous issue with this arrangement, is willing to fuck over her children to make her new husband happy.

lickenchugget · 15/09/2022 21:34

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 19:14

I don’t know. I can see that from the kids point of view it’ll be very much us and her. The step daughter won’t be able to much with them unless they sub her.
Its not a great message for teens especially as they don’t earn the difference in money.
Can’t you tell them that they’ll get £10 to spend at their mums and you’ll stick the rest in an account that they can spend at yours.

Why do they have to appease some unrelated, jealous person they did not choose?

The SS needs to realise life isn’t fair. You can’t just not like something and have your dad demand it’s changed to suit you.

whumpthereitis · 15/09/2022 21:27

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 21:12

Some people have more. That’s life. I was also lucky because ‘dad’s rich’, but I still appreciated it and worked hard. Kids that have less given to them aren’t inherently more virtuous, or better people

This is not mortality about rich and poor. These children are part of a new family with their mum. It’s unfair and unrealistic to expect life to be the same. They won’t lose out, they can still get the money when they are with dad and saved in the bank.

Yes, with their mother, not their father who sorts their allowance. Her choice in husband has nothing to do with OP, and does not oblige him to change a system that’s worked, and is working, well for him and his kids.

Of course they’d be losing out, and I’ve already explained why. Life with their father hasn’t changed, so why would it change? You are right though in that it is indeed unfair and unrealistic to expect life to be the same for everyone, which is a lesson the stepsister needs to learn. What’s also unfair is OP penalizing his children because their mother married a poorer man with a jealous kid. That isn’t OP’s problem, and nor is it his children’s. The ex and her new husband have to solve it without involving OP, or alienating her children. Ultimately, the stepsister has to suck it up.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 15/09/2022 21:24

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 21:12

Some people have more. That’s life. I was also lucky because ‘dad’s rich’, but I still appreciated it and worked hard. Kids that have less given to them aren’t inherently more virtuous, or better people

This is not mortality about rich and poor. These children are part of a new family with their mum. It’s unfair and unrealistic to expect life to be the same. They won’t lose out, they can still get the money when they are with dad and saved in the bank.

They aren't family. And absolutly nothing to do with OP

Why do you think he should care?

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 21:12

Some people have more. That’s life. I was also lucky because ‘dad’s rich’, but I still appreciated it and worked hard. Kids that have less given to them aren’t inherently more virtuous, or better people

This is not mortality about rich and poor. These children are part of a new family with their mum. It’s unfair and unrealistic to expect life to be the same. They won’t lose out, they can still get the money when they are with dad and saved in the bank.

GiantTortoise · 15/09/2022 20:42

It's a lot of money, but your kids do seem to be buying sensible things with it. I agree with you OP that this is your call.

shedwithivy · 15/09/2022 20:41

latetothefisting · 15/09/2022 17:16

Agree it would be completely ridiculous to stop your children's pocket money because their step sister gets less. If step sister took violin lessons or won a sports scholarship to pay for university should she have to stop these if your dc aren't musical/sporty? If step sister had a pet dog or whatever would your step sister be happy to give them up if you didn't allow your kids one? If your parents have passed away should step sister not be allowed to visit her granny because its not fair she still has hers while your dc don't? Etc etc!

Could you ask your ex wife to tell step sister that this goes towards things that she might buy stepsister, it's just a different way of doing it? Even if it still doesn't work out exactly the same, she can be vague and fudge it, she doesn't have to go into full details of what you spend on your dc.

Ultimately though stepsister needs to learn that life isn't fair - surely some of her friends get more pocket money than her?

However nearly £220 a month by the time they reach 18 is a huge amount of disposable income - my only issue with kids having that much money is the same as kids who are given the latest iPhones and that it will be a huge shock to the system if/when parents stop providing it. To put into perspective they have to work 32 hours at the minimum wage to earn that. Just something to think about as at some stage - when they are at uni or in their first job they'll probably end up with significantly less disposable income than when they were 15, which can be really gutting at a time when you are supposed to be enjoying the start of your independence!

Wise post

Peeeko · 15/09/2022 20:27

womaninatightspot · 15/09/2022 20:21

Discuss with children, give them 10 quid a week each and put the remainder in savings for them. Same result but everyone has same disposable income.

Why should OP care what some random child he's not related to is upset about?

As the mum in this situation I'd just be telling my children to be sensitive when discussing pocket money in front of their step sister but that's it. She can't and shouldn't stop her ex from giving their children something just because her step daughter is upset she doesn't get the same.

It's life. Some people have more than others. Her step siblings dad has absolutely no obligation to be fair to her.