Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to lower my childrens a pocket money to match their stepsisters

340 replies

ormav · 15/09/2022 16:16

I have a daughter (15) and a son (12) with my ex. Originally when their mum and I started giving them pocket money we went with a formula of £3 multiplied by how old they were. Since their mum and I divorced 7 years ago I have been responsible for paying the kids their pocket money. I have kept to the original formula we agreed on. So now our daughter get £45 a week and her brother gets £36 a week.

Last year their mum got married. Her husband also has a daughter (14), so my kids have a stepsister now. Apparently she just found out how much our children are getting for their pocket money. She found out when my sons was talking about saving up for a new computer and she asked how he could afford it and how much money he got. He told her how much and how it was based on how old they were.

Now that she knows my ex and her husband say it’s caused a lot of trouble in their household leading to jealousy issues and fighting. This is because their stepsister only receives £10 a week. Both my ex and her husband said that I need to lower the kids allowance. They say that inequality like that between children in the same household can severely adversely affect their sibling relationship. I think that if there is inequality in their household that it is their responsibility to deal with it, not mine. I told them they should should raise the amount his daughter gets if it’s an issue.

They told me that they couldn’t afford to give her that much, but even if they could they wouldn’t because they don’t believe children their ages should have access to the amount of money they have. They say that continuing to give them this much pocket money will also make them spoiled, entitled and bad with money.

My ex later said she assumed I was giving them a normal amount even though I just stuck with the formula we did and agreed upon a long time ago. She says that I obviously should have stopped raising it when it reached normal amount (I’ll point out here that she never said what a normal amount it).

I have since looked up the regular range for pocket money and I’ll acknowledge that theirs is on the higher side. That’s said I do not believe it is adversely affecting them. They do not act spoiled or entitled. They never demand to have things and accept when things don’t go as planned. They do their chores without complaint and do well in school. They get along very well with others their own age with the exception of their stepsister because she calls them spoiled. I would also they are the opposite of bad with money as they both have saved up a significant amount in their accounts and aren’t just spending their money on pointless things as soon as they get it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LAWinterofOurDiscountTents · 17/09/2022 17:43

It's OP's business what his kids get, not the stepsisters, not the non resident parent, and definitely not MNers.

I'd probably point out that main that that will affect that sibling bond that she's worried about is the fact that they are not siblings. And to butt out.

sweetbambi · 17/09/2022 17:42

@Aprilx how do you know it is a stupid amount? you have no idea what the kids pay for out of that money.

Aprilx · 17/09/2022 17:23

I agree it is not your problem and I think it i snot right to cut their pocket money.

But I also think you are giving them a stupid amount of money, how can you not know that.

Charcy · 17/09/2022 17:19

iwantasandwich · 15/09/2022 16:20

Ignore those fixating on the amount

I was given similar to that amount when I was 15 (17 years ago now) and grew up in a council house so it's hardly too much considering inflation and their ages

🤣🤣 alright then.

sweetbambi · 17/09/2022 17:16

@sheepdogdelight this is true but I do also think it is worth pointing out everyone's budget is different. even for adults you will have some with more disposal income then others. it's a fact of life that not everyone will be able to afford the same things.

sheepdogdelight · 17/09/2022 16:39

ClassieLadyK · 17/09/2022 15:50

I just don't understand where all the people are saying that's to much.

If your kids buy school lunch that's 4 dollars which is 20. Then say they want to go do something on the weekend. A movie ticket is like 10 bucks now, that doesn't leave much left over. For savings or buying anything they want.

I know the fun park in our town cost 40 bucks to do all activities, so what happens when these kids wanna go out with there friends. You either have to give them extra money anyway, or give them an allowance big enough they can handle it all themselves.

It's not too much if they are paying for bus fares and food and toiletries and ....
But from what OP has said, that doesn't seem to be the case and the money is just for socialising/fripperies.

A 40 buck fun park is a very occasional activity, not an every week activity. The teens budget the big cost activities in with cheaper ones. That's why people have said about learning to budget. If a DC has so much money they can do whatever they want and still have loads left over, then there is no need for budgeting at all.

ClassieLadyK · 17/09/2022 15:50

I just don't understand where all the people are saying that's to much.

If your kids buy school lunch that's 4 dollars which is 20. Then say they want to go do something on the weekend. A movie ticket is like 10 bucks now, that doesn't leave much left over. For savings or buying anything they want.

I know the fun park in our town cost 40 bucks to do all activities, so what happens when these kids wanna go out with there friends. You either have to give them extra money anyway, or give them an allowance big enough they can handle it all themselves.

ivykaty44 · 16/09/2022 18:35

Tryingtokeepgoing Totally agree with you

Tryingtokeepgoing · 16/09/2022 11:27

womaninatightspot · 15/09/2022 20:21

Discuss with children, give them 10 quid a week each and put the remainder in savings for them. Same result but everyone has same disposable income.

And you’ve disempowered and taken away all responsibly for budgeting and saving from the children. Seems like a horribly retrograde step to me, who I cold actually make them more careless with money on the basis what’s the point budgeting and planning of someone’s going to move the goalposts on an irrational whim!!

Lovemylittlebear · 16/09/2022 10:47

Yeah that’s a good point. Hadnt thought if it like that.

I guess I was thinking if it’s not to cover travel etc but more spending money pocket money and getting used to online banking, using a card for withdrawals and potentially maintaining relationships. I guess reading all the replies there are lots of ways to view this

sweetbambi · 16/09/2022 10:42

@Lovemylittlebear it still depends on what the kids pay for out of that pocket money. if that money was used for example to even cover travel expenses and school lunch that would not leave anything left for anything else at all.

also how is it better for the parent to hold x amount of money for saving of big items rather than the child deciding how much they want to spend and how much they want to put towards saving for the bigger items. surely giving the child more so they control it teaches them more then money comes from magic and if I want a bigger item I will just ask for it.

whumpthereitis · 16/09/2022 10:41

Lovemylittlebear · 16/09/2022 10:35

Holy shit that’s a lot of pocket money.

at the end of the day it’s up to you what you give your children.

if I was in the situation and felt strongly I wanted them to have that amount I think I would chat to the kids about how they would feel about having ten pounds per week in cash and the other amount will go into a saving account. They are free then to build that money up for bigger items they would like to save for (like a computer). Just a thought but it sounds like a bit of a compromise.

His kids are saving fine themselves, and he doesn’t need to compromise. It’s not a problem for him and the kids he has the majority of the time.

whumpthereitis · 16/09/2022 10:40

CatSeany · 16/09/2022 04:34

I can see both sides here. I think the fairest way would actually be to increase the step childrens pocket money if your partner and their ex-partner can afford to. If they can't, then I think in their position I would feel upset. It wouldn't be unreasonable to do a complete overhaul and give every child £30 a week or something regardless of age. Equality seems important in a family environment. You can always put your extra aside for them separately to gift for car/house/wedding etc if you like.

On what planet is that the fairest way? 🤨 it’s pandering to jealousy, and penalizing two kids because mother dearest wants to prioritize new husband at their expense.

The system is normal for them, their father is happy to provide it, and they’re sensible kids who are managing the money well. Stepsister’s problem is stepsister’s problem to suck up, frankly. Instead of indulging her, her father and stepmother would be best placed teaching her to accept the fact that in life some people will have more than her.

And it’s not even a family environment they’re in for the majority of the time. Or any time if the mother’s new family doesn’t drop it.

Lovemylittlebear · 16/09/2022 10:35

Holy shit that’s a lot of pocket money.

at the end of the day it’s up to you what you give your children.

if I was in the situation and felt strongly I wanted them to have that amount I think I would chat to the kids about how they would feel about having ten pounds per week in cash and the other amount will go into a saving account. They are free then to build that money up for bigger items they would like to save for (like a computer). Just a thought but it sounds like a bit of a compromise.

Lalalolol · 16/09/2022 10:33

Op's question was not about if the amount he is giving his kids is a lot. Usually on mum'snet posters say they don't give unsolicited advice in RL but why they think it's ok here?

Op, don't change your parenting. Looks like your kids are financially responsible, and budget and save well.

FeatherBlower · 16/09/2022 10:29

EscapeRoomToTheSun · Yesterday 16:20

You're not setting them up well for life by giving them access to that much cash now. They will have no financial skills, no awareness of the cost of things.

This doesn’t make sense. If I child is given £5 and waxes it on rubbish on the day they receive it but another child is given £20 and spends and saves it wisely, then the second child is getting better economic life skills. More money doesn’t equate to poorer financial skills, it’s the lessons that go with the money. Teaching a child to look after their money, save and spend it on things they really want is best REGARDLESS of the amount.

as someone else said, there are lots of jealous and bitter comments on here. If the children are financially responsible that is what counts.

Lalalolol · 16/09/2022 10:29

Sorry, I just realised I wrote her being 15 when she is 14 but my point still stands.

Lalalolol · 16/09/2022 10:27

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 20:14

Stepsister is 14. Of course she’s going to be jealous, there’s grown women on this thread who’d like £40 a week for themselves.
I don’t think the Op’s kids will miss out if it’s saved rather than handed over. It’s different for the 17 year old who presumably has college friends and different expectations of a social life but tough for the younger ones.
I do think we should be giving kids the message about how we’d like the world to be not how it currently is.So yes you get money for working hard, some jobs pay more because they require more and not your dads rich and you get money for nothing.

No, stepsister's jealousy is not Op or his kid's problem. Until a year ago or so, they were completely unrelated families and kids were getting different amount per week. They were all in their teens or preteens years and by then they are used to a particular system.
Now a year ago, they are expected to be sibling to a stranger kid and on top a year later their finances are lowered to make that 'sibling' happy.
So tomorrow if stepsister's friends have much higher pocket money, their parents should also be asked to lower the amount to please step daughter. She is 15 not 5, her parents should teach her that different people can afford different things and that you can't call other kids spoiled because their parents can afford pocket money.
This is very unreasonable demand from ex and her DH, and Op has no responsibility for enforcing a relationship between his kids and his ex's step daughter if they expect Op's kids to lose on to accommodate new sister.
Op's son is 12 and was honest when step sister asked how he could afford to save for computer. In turn, step sister started calling step siblings spoilt ( which is borderline bullying. It's not kids fault what amount parents chose to give them). In a few years, would she start calling other people spoilt on social media because they will show they have something she doesn't have?
It's unfair to expect kids to be siblings suddenly because it's convenient for adults.

magma32 · 16/09/2022 10:11

Strange that people keep judging op for the amount he gives his children. Reminds me of the religious community that I know who consider you closer to god the ‘poorer’ you are. Reality is it’s just jealousy and bitterness. Don’t worry about op’s kids, they’re doing just fine by the sounds of it.

3WildOnes · 16/09/2022 10:07

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 16/09/2022 07:54

Wow that amount of pocket money a week is disgusting. Yes you should lower it, it's goady and sounds like your just showing off to me.

Why is it disgusting? I received a similar amount as a teenager. Some of my friends received an allowance like me, others were handed money as and when they needed it but I would guess we all received similar amounts.
I had an active social life and would often meet friends for coffee/brunch/lunch/dinner. We would go to the cinema or bowling or to concerts. We went to exhibitions in London. We also did free stuff and slept over at each others houses and ate pizza.

Newmumatlast · 16/09/2022 09:09

OP like others I do think your kids get an awful lot but that is up to you. It isnt for you to alter what you decide to do for your kid because if someone else's. Your ex isn't wrong that it will cause resentment and inequality. However this is just another example of the issues people can face when they have blended families. There will likely be different financial circumstances between the different people in the mix and different parenting ideas. If the parents in the mix cannot cope with that it sounds harsh but the answer is not to blend families, it is not to try and force everyone to match up. I have an adult SC so not quite as difficult for me as though she can see a difference in the financial situation her siblings are being brought up in compared to her, it isnt a direct comparison in the same way as she is already grown. However, that increased financial situation is due to me and my income. It would have been absurd to expect me to spend less on my kids and pay out for her and her household when she has her own parents responsible for her already. Similarly it would have been absurd for me to only spend the same and then have excess funds I could never ever spend. And to what level would I take it? Not buy a home with more space because she lived in a flat? Not save for their future because her mum didn't? Not let them go to any clubs because she didnt? It makes no sense. Its one thing not spending because you don't have it and another actively limiting chances to try and be equal.

sheepdogdelight · 16/09/2022 09:08

I didnt receive the level of the OPs kids but don't think that is why I'm good with money - its because I was set up with bank accounts from birth, learnt about and spoke about money and budgeting, and had a good example. That has never changed whatever sum of money I have.

To be honest, I think a lot of "good with money" is not linked to the way you are brought up. My DC are close in age, brought up the same way, but one watches every penny and saves a lot, and the other has spent his money almost before he has it. I do think OP is lucky that his children are inherently of the "good saving" model (or potentially they just have so much money they dont know what to do with it). And, based on my own experience, I do think this is luck and probably not down to anything he may have done or not done.

Chickpea17 · 16/09/2022 09:06

If the kids live with you the majority of the time is it think she being very cheeky. Letting their stepdaughter dictate how much pocket money you give your kids it's absolutely nothing to do with her. Yes it's a lot of money but it's your money and you can do with it as you please.

Newmumatlast · 16/09/2022 09:01

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 15/09/2022 16:20

You're not setting them up well for life by giving them access to that much cash now. They will have no financial skills, no awareness of the cost of things.

Why? Surely it depends on whether or not they're just given that money or also encouraged to develop the skills alongside it to manage it?

I have friends who received naff all from their parents, got jobs at 16 and spanked the lot, others didn't. Friends who got normal amounts and got into debt later and friends who got normal amounts and didn't etc. It really boiled down to whether they had been familiar with money and how it works and had a good example set for them.

I didnt receive the level of the OPs kids but don't think that is why I'm good with money - its because I was set up with bank accounts from birth, learnt about and spoke about money and budgeting, and had a good example. That has never changed whatever sum of money I have.

lickenchugget · 16/09/2022 09:00

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 16/09/2022 07:54

Wow that amount of pocket money a week is disgusting. Yes you should lower it, it's goady and sounds like your just showing off to me.

So much outright jealousy on this thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread