Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to read this cautionary tale of what we're sleepwalking into?

193 replies

AspireMe · 15/09/2022 15:19

unherd.com/2020/10/how-corporations-can-delete-your-existence/

Some people might say she deserved it. Others might disagree.

Some people on here think TWANW. Some corporations might in turn deem that thought as heresy.

Encouraged more and more each day to go digital, paperless and cashless... what are we walking into here?

OP posts:
DaSilvaP · 16/09/2022 19:18

TheClogLady · 16/09/2022 12:51

I'm increasingly of the view that the only reason you got freedom in the old technologies is that it was just technically too difficult to track and hence block individuals. It was easy to pretend that no authoritarian control was a principle when it was really a technical limitation. Now the technical limitations are lifted, it's clearly hard to resist.

This ^

and loads of people think it will never effect them because they are nice and only do and say things that the people around them agree with but corporations don’t care about how nice you are and they don’t have the same interests as humans.

but corporations don’t like paying taxes, right?

so should Amazon, PayPal, Stripe, and every high street bank be able to cancel the accounts of everyone who has ever tweeted or Facebook posted ‘eat the rich’ ‘tax Starbucks’ or ‘Jeff Bezos is a wanker?’

Because the tech to find absolutely every one of who has ever typed those sorts of things out on a smart phone or said it near an Alexa already exists.

if all the payment processors, owned by corporations black list us, now work can’t pay us because we don’t have a bank account.
And benefits can’t pay us because we don’t have a bank account.

So the only thing standing between us and destitution is the law that says we can’t be discriminated against for religious or political beliefs (and that we have freedom of expression for those beliefs).

And if corporations are allowed to flout that law we’re all at their mercy and we can be fucked over in an instant.

That’s where this ‘Freedom of Expression Doesn’t Mean Freedom from Consequences’ bullshit leads.

(And no, temporarily freezing a bank account while a criminal activity investigation takes place isn’t the same thing as permanent denial of service based on not liking someone’s perfectly legal but currently unfashionable beliefs)

You couldn't put it more clearly.
Hopefully there won't one day a poem like this, only available on samizdat:
"when they closed all bank accounts of A / then B / then C ... (and chucked them out of the Web) I said nothing because I can't stand A / nor B / nor C ...

When they closed all of my accounts, no one cared ..."

xogossipgirlxo · 16/09/2022 13:02

YANBU, but you chose wrong website to talk about it...

TheClogLady · 16/09/2022 12:51

I'm increasingly of the view that the only reason you got freedom in the old technologies is that it was just technically too difficult to track and hence block individuals. It was easy to pretend that no authoritarian control was a principle when it was really a technical limitation. Now the technical limitations are lifted, it's clearly hard to resist.

This ^

and loads of people think it will never effect them because they are nice and only do and say things that the people around them agree with but corporations don’t care about how nice you are and they don’t have the same interests as humans.

but corporations don’t like paying taxes, right?

so should Amazon, PayPal, Stripe, and every high street bank be able to cancel the accounts of everyone who has ever tweeted or Facebook posted ‘eat the rich’ ‘tax Starbucks’ or ‘Jeff Bezos is a wanker?’

Because the tech to find absolutely every one of who has ever typed those sorts of things out on a smart phone or said it near an Alexa already exists.

if all the payment processors, owned by corporations black list us, now work can’t pay us because we don’t have a bank account.
And benefits can’t pay us because we don’t have a bank account.

So the only thing standing between us and destitution is the law that says we can’t be discriminated against for religious or political beliefs (and that we have freedom of expression for those beliefs).

And if corporations are allowed to flout that law we’re all at their mercy and we can be fucked over in an instant.

That’s where this ‘Freedom of Expression Doesn’t Mean Freedom from Consequences’ bullshit leads.

(And no, temporarily freezing a bank account while a criminal activity investigation takes place isn’t the same thing as permanent denial of service based on not liking someone’s perfectly legal but currently unfashionable beliefs)

NecessaryScene · 16/09/2022 12:51

They can work with and provide service to whomever they like and refuse service to those they do not

Actually, no, there are a hell of a lot of anti-discrimination laws to stop that sort of thing.

If you are going to provide a service, there are legal limits on how much you are permitted to discriminate between customers.

Discrimination on belief is one of the things that is regulated - as we've been fighting to get properly upheld in recent cases like Maya Forstater's and Allison Bailey's.

NecessaryScene · 16/09/2022 12:44

@Natty13 another far more prominent example I should have remembered: Allison Bailey

Crowdfunding site shuts down black lesbian lawyer's campaign on Stonewall anniversary

What is the point of raising funds to engage in a legal fight if those against whom the suit is brought can scare the crowdfunding platform into banning the plaintiff?

NecessaryScene · 16/09/2022 12:42

suddenly turn into Orwellian nightmare

It's not going to be sudden.

Guarantees of service and freedom are locked into legacy institutions and technologies. Cash, telephones, electricity, roads, public transport.

It's accepted that those can't be revoked.

Any new technology or medium that's arisen since about 2000 does not have those guarantees. Internet, payment apps, car chargers, online shopfronts, Uber.

And as people migrate to those new technologies, the old technologies become more and more cumbersome or less accepted, so in the end you're left relying on technologies with no service guarantee that you can be barred from at any time.

And there are no real moves to extend the basic service guarantees from legacy technologies to new ones. (Contrast to say, copyright, where they endlessly try to extend that to protect companies operating in the first half of the 20th century from ever having anything go public domain).

Basically, freedoms are just expiring due to technological obsolescence, and no-one cares.

I'm increasingly of the view that the only reason you got freedom in the old technologies is that it was just technically too difficult to track and hence block individuals. It was easy to pretend that no authoritarian control was a principle when it was really a technical limitation. Now the technical limitations are lifted, it's clearly hard to resist.

TheClogLady · 16/09/2022 12:08

broodybadger · 16/09/2022 11:58

But the line isn't the law

It's whatever those organisations want it to be

As is their right

They can work with and provide service to whomever they like and refuse service to those they do not

I know

THAT’S THE PROBLEM!

corporations shouldn’t be able to refuse service to law abiding citizens who believe in something (legal) that doesn’t fit the companies corporate values or who look a bit different.

allowing companies to make these decisions is sleepwalking into a nightmare scenario - like in the Handmaid’s Tale when they subjugate women simply by turning off their bank cards, making them entirely dependent on the men.

broodybadger · 16/09/2022 11:58

TheClogLady · 16/09/2022 11:49

You Are Definitely Not Being Unreasonable.

Everyone who thinks it’ll never happen to them because their views are (currently) on the right side of history hasn’t learned any lessons from history.

of course legal action must be taken when laws are being broken, but the line is the law and corporations are not the police.

But the line isn't the law

It's whatever those organisations want it to be

As is their right

They can work with and provide service to whomever they like and refuse service to those they do not

Hawkins001 · 16/09/2022 11:54

beastlyslumber · 16/09/2022 11:47

Freedom of expression gives you the right to hold whatever view or opion you want. It does not give you the right to air those views or opinions without consequence.

No, you're the one misunderstanding. Freedom of speech means precisely that you have the right to express your views and beliefs without consequence.

Yes, you may have to face 'consequences' in terms of disagreement or ridicule, maybe even losing friends, but if there are consequences such as losing your job, your home, your access to money, your freedom etc, then it is a violation of free speech. In that situation, you don't have free speech at all.

So, to give a current example: holding up a stupid banner at the Queen's coffin procession may make people think you're an idiot, and may cause arguments, or cause people to tell you you're a dickhead. All fine. But you shouldn't be arrested for that. You shouldn't face any legal consequences.

The criminal offence, would be breaching the peace

TheClogLady · 16/09/2022 11:52

Freedom of expression gives you the right to hold whatever view or opion you want. It does not give you the right to air those views or opinions without consequence.

Of course it does. What do you think ‘freedom’ means?

If there are consequences it’s not actually freedom!

Crikey. I can’t believe people parrot this stuff.

To ask you to read this cautionary tale of what we're sleepwalking into?
Hawkins001 · 16/09/2022 11:52

AspireMe · 15/09/2022 15:19

unherd.com/2020/10/how-corporations-can-delete-your-existence/

Some people might say she deserved it. Others might disagree.

Some people on here think TWANW. Some corporations might in turn deem that thought as heresy.

Encouraged more and more each day to go digital, paperless and cashless... what are we walking into here?

Basically ctos 2.0,

TheClogLady · 16/09/2022 11:49

You Are Definitely Not Being Unreasonable.

Everyone who thinks it’ll never happen to them because their views are (currently) on the right side of history hasn’t learned any lessons from history.

of course legal action must be taken when laws are being broken, but the line is the law and corporations are not the police.

beastlyslumber · 16/09/2022 11:47

Freedom of expression gives you the right to hold whatever view or opion you want. It does not give you the right to air those views or opinions without consequence.

No, you're the one misunderstanding. Freedom of speech means precisely that you have the right to express your views and beliefs without consequence.

Yes, you may have to face 'consequences' in terms of disagreement or ridicule, maybe even losing friends, but if there are consequences such as losing your job, your home, your access to money, your freedom etc, then it is a violation of free speech. In that situation, you don't have free speech at all.

So, to give a current example: holding up a stupid banner at the Queen's coffin procession may make people think you're an idiot, and may cause arguments, or cause people to tell you you're a dickhead. All fine. But you shouldn't be arrested for that. You shouldn't face any legal consequences.

CalicoAnnie · 16/09/2022 11:44

Anythingbutsnow · 15/09/2022 16:21

It concerns me to be honest.
Now is prime time to accelerate moving towards digital only currency. Why go to the trouble of printing new money with the King's profile on? Why not use it as an opportunity to start phasing out cash?

The Royal Australian Mint make millions of $’s of coins and notes every year. They regularly change the Queens effigy and make different commemorative coins all the time. I imagine the Royal mint is the same. It’s not going to be difficult to put the Kings effigy on new coins.

Coffeaddict · 16/09/2022 11:41

Aeio · 15/09/2022 15:26

Nothing cautionary or sleepwalking about it. Normal practice under regulation relating to fraud, anti money laundering and terrorist financing.

Your post makes you sound ridiculous.

This. If they suspect the bank accounts are being used to fund or launder money associated with terrorist activity they are perfectly within their rights to close the accounts. These checks are the reason most terrorists use cryptocurrency to move money as they aren't subject to the same checks.
The rise in white nationalism is absolutely something that should be monitored and policed across multiple
Sectors. We have training on how to identify potential signs of ratification within our student population at my uni.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 16/09/2022 11:37

DisappearingGirl · 16/09/2022 10:50

I think this related thread is interesting - people getting Facebook bans for daft things, and then getting repeated bans for even dafter things once they are on Facebook's radar.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4632273-to-be-fucked-off-by-constant-facebook-bans?page=1

Yes I know that technically no-one needs Facebook - but for the OP of that thread it is her main way of staying in touch with friends and family, as well as a key route for her small business. So being banned from a major platform everyone else uses can really affect someone's life.

The solution to that issue, and a whole lot of other problems people seem to find themselves in, is to keep your views to yourself unless in an appropriate setting i.e., an anonymous forum where you can't easily be identified or somewhere where your opinion has been invited for discussion.

A huge number of people seem to have a fundamental misunderstanding about what "free speech" actually means.

Freedom of expression gives you the right to hold whatever view or opion you want. It does not give you the right to air those views or opinions without consequence.

beastlyslumber · 16/09/2022 11:34

@Natty13 Feminist group banned from using co-op bank - www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5852547/Co-operative-bank-bans-feminist-group-using-services.html

beastlyslumber · 16/09/2022 11:33

Here's another one - Co-op bank bans feminist group from using bank - www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5852547/Co-operative-bank-bans-feminist-group-using-services.html

beastlyslumber · 16/09/2022 11:26

@Natty13 There was also the Scottish woman whose name I can't remember - her fundraising website was taken down. Sorry I'm not the best with names but someone will remember. She's not the only one to have had this happen with gofundme and other fundraising sites.

Natty13 · 16/09/2022 11:26

Yeah I can read. I asked for examples in the UK, one of those is Dutch (not UK) and one is Canada (again...)

I really don't understand why peiple keep telling me this is happening to women's rights groups in this country and yet cannot back that up with a single source of evidence.

beastlyslumber · 16/09/2022 11:22

NecessaryScene · 16/09/2022 08:09

How about those who are gender critical? Or don't want to accept a mandated medical procedure? Or attended an anti royal or anti government protest?
What if those were deemed to be punishable by denying access to funds?

This has certainly happened. First two that spring to mind:

Dutch feminists: cne.news/artikel/1685-dutch-feminists-blocked-by-banks-for-critique-of-transgender-bill
Colin Wright: twitter.com/triggerpod/status/1570097217146613763

@Natty13 a couple of posts above yours contains two links

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 16/09/2022 11:19

Charles11 · 16/09/2022 00:35

This gives banks too much power.
How about those who are gender critical? Or don't want to accept a mandated medical procedure? Or attended an anti royal or anti government protest?
What if those were deemed to be punishable by denying access to funds?
I'm not saying it would happen but the potential is terrifying.

What if the government made it illegal to drink milk, leave the house after 9pm, or pronounce the letter "L"?

We can "what if" till the cows come home but there's no point worrying about scenarios that only exist in people's heads.

Why do you, and so many other posters on this thread, think a bank following their well-documented policies based on long established regulations and legal obligations will suddenly turn into Orwellian nightmare of frozen accounts for anyone and everyone?

The ironic thing here is that the Tories have been, and are still actively, forcing through changes that erode people's rights and make freedom of expression more difficult, yet are supported by many on here because "they know what a women is".

Natty13 · 16/09/2022 10:58

beastlyslumber · 16/09/2022 08:07

If banks suddenly had the right to take away women's access to their own money for being feminists, I fully believe we would all be out raising hell.

It's already happening! Women's groups have had their fundraisers banned, their paypals stopped... haven't seen you "raising hell". Seen you defending the principle that they should be allowed to do so, though.

Can you give me an example of this happening in the UK please because I haven't come across any and honestly I am struggling to believe that it has happened and there haven't at least been links posted in this thread.

DisappearingGirl · 16/09/2022 10:50

I think this related thread is interesting - people getting Facebook bans for daft things, and then getting repeated bans for even dafter things once they are on Facebook's radar.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4632273-to-be-fucked-off-by-constant-facebook-bans?page=1

Yes I know that technically no-one needs Facebook - but for the OP of that thread it is her main way of staying in touch with friends and family, as well as a key route for her small business. So being banned from a major platform everyone else uses can really affect someone's life.