Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to spot the shite fathers early on?

260 replies

StellaStacey · 15/09/2022 04:59

I'm newly single in my late 20s. I want to think about settling down and starting a family with someone.

I see so many of the same sort of posts on here about women having children with their partners and the father not being a parent at all or doing any household chores whatsoever. The man insisting he has a right to undisrupted sleep because he works a paid job and has zero appreciation to the hard work and exhaustion that goes into raising a child. I seriously at points consider staying childless because I don't think I can cope with this kind of setup and want to avoid it at all costs, not only because of how physically exhausting it must be but the mental torment of a partner completely disrespecting and think so little of you as the mother of their child. I know I would never get over the resentment. I read some of the posts on here and I want to scream at these men who are driving their partners to such breaking point for being completely and utterly useless. My god you are heros and extremely resilient if you have been in this situation.

As I jump onto the dating scene again I wanted to ask, are these useless twats easy to spot early on? Are there warning signs? If you ended up in this situation was it obvious looking back that it would be like that but you were love blind to the signs? What are the red flags? Did your DP completely change when a baby came along or did they always have these tendencies to avoid all responsibility?

OP posts:
BellePeppa · 15/09/2022 08:04

Redqueenheart · 15/09/2022 07:50

I don't think you can always predict how someone will react to become a parent but I would avoid anyone who:

  • hasn't got their life together financially
  • isn't emotionally stable (doesn't react well to stress and setbacks and can't control their anger) and selfish
  • has some dodgy views about women and equality and is not pulling his weight in term of sharing chores
  • is lazy
  • regularly uses drugs and alcohol
  • has mental health issues they are unwilling to recognise and address
  • has a history of so called ''psycho' exes
  • is a porn consumer
  • is not up for a committed monogamous relationship with you.

Also the biggest mistake is to expect that you can change your partner or that they will magically change when a child comes. If they are a lazy, selfish, immature person, this is not going to improve when they become a parent.

I think this list is much more reliable than a list of things that are positive. In this particular situation (looking for a good life partner) focusing on the negative aspects of a person is more valuable than focusing on the positives. How many times do we read of some arsehole who can be ‘really lovely’ as well so it clouds judgement.

anotherscroller · 15/09/2022 08:04

Wow such great advice here.
I would add points for having done work that involves caring for people in some way.
avoid short tempers!

namechange30455 · 15/09/2022 08:02

@Oblomov22

"If you've got an ounce of emotional intellect then a lot of these problems that you read on the relationship boards won't happen to you."

That's what's naive. Smug, naive and victim blaming all wrapped up in one very black-and-white sentence.

You are sitting there happily thinking "oh, that could never happen to me". Sure, it may be less likely if you pick a man "carefully" (as per this thread) and don't opt for the bloke who is red flag central, but it CAN STILL HAPPEN.

BogRollBOGOF · 15/09/2022 08:01

Never expect to train him to get better, he's not a puppy, or a fix-up project.
Watch out for the red flags early on, but they're not foolproof.
If his behaviour slips 18m in when there's still no commitments involved, move on. Don't fall for the sunk costs fallacy.
If he's crap with baby #1, and you're just coping, don't have baby #2. It won't get better.

Some of them you can't see coming. Some of them, you do wonder why she's enabled such transparent behaviour so long and ended up stuck in an isolated dependent hole when the red flags were hanging out like a jubilee display.

It's also worth considering your own background and values. What is your normal? What's your default?

BertieBotts · 15/09/2022 08:00

Great question! I think it's really hard to know what the signs of a good/bad father are in advance of actually being a parent. I just looked at my ex playing with kids and thought aww, that would be nice Confused But anybody can play with kids for half an hour. It's living with them day in day out and managing their lives for two decades through phases where they don't even seem to like you - that's a totally different thing. It's challenging, and above all, you want to pick a partner that will be an asset and complement you through that challenge. Probably the longest and most intense of your life.

How does he treat you when you are vulnerable - sick or tired or struggling with MH or anything like that. Does he take the load off you, show concern, try to make things better for you? Or does he ignore you (or even get huffy). You will be vulnerable for a long time with pregnancy/young children. See also: animals, women in his family (mother/sisters), people serving him (restaurant staff, shop staff, his staff at work etc) Do not look at what he says, look at what he does and how he says things.

Agree totally with pulling his weight in the home and proactively - he should not wait for you to ask him to put a wash on or make dinner. He should see that it needs doing, and do it.

More of a relationship one - what's his absolute worst habit/worst quality? (Ignore what it actually is, how do you feel about it?) Is it "It's really really bad but it only happens occasionally, so I can live with it" - you can't. Is it "I wish he wouldn't do that but probably he'll stop as he gets older" - he won't. Is it "Some people would find it a deal breaker but it (genuinely) doesn't bother me" - check yourself that it really doesn't, but this is fine. You need his worst quality to be something minor and annoying, not worrying, not scary, not dangerous, not even frustrating. Do not expect him to change automatically when kids come along. Most people find that very hard to do and he might not even be assuming he will have to.

How do you work together on projects e.g. planning a holiday, planning a wedding, or another family orientated event, redecorating a room. There should be a balance. You don't want him taking over, you don't want him sitting back letting you do everything so that he basically just shows up. Can you discuss and accommodate both of your preferences, do you value his input because it's genuinely good, does he value yours? Is it a good outcome at the end?

What is he like as a person? Is he somebody that you want your future child/ren to look up to? Would you be proud if your child grew up to be like him, as he is now? Don't take on a project because you want to mother somebody. You want kids, you'll have them to mother. Choose a finished article for your co-parenting partner. See also: Shared or at least compatible beliefs about things like religion, diet (vegan/sugar/organic/alcohol etc), pets, discipline, cleanliness, socialising, money etc.

If he already has children, what's his relationship like with them/the ex? This is more complicated but essentially you're looking for signs that if you split up, he'd still have the children's best interests at heart, and not use them to hurt you. Break ups happen - people grow apart. You need somebody who would be pragmatic and fair in that instance.

How do you disagree? What happens? Are you able to discuss productively with both seeing the other's side? Or do you avoid discussions, does he turn nasty, do you end up feeling it's your fault, are you scared to disagree in case he leaves? It doesn't need to be perfect, but it does need to be safe (no threats, no violence, even directed at objects) and productive (there is a mutually acceptable resolution at the end, not just ignoring the issue or avoiding it).

BellePeppa · 15/09/2022 07:59

BoxOfCats · 15/09/2022 05:14

A few things come to mind, I'm sure others will be along with more.

  • How does he treat his mother?
  • Has he ever had to live independently before?
  • What is his current living environment like? Tidy? Chaotic?
  • Does he seem to be financially secure? I don't mean mega rich, but things like an inability to budget would be a red flag for me
  • Do you value the same things, have similar priorities in life?
  • Does he treat you with respect? I don't mean words or grand gestures... but things like how he behaves when you are ill or when you have a disagreement

Unfortunately ticking all those boxes still doesn’t guarantee they’ll be a devoted and present father. I speak from personal experience,

CaptainCorellisBagpipes · 15/09/2022 07:57

@Windowtea "If he's a lazy fuckwit before kids who doesn't tidy up after himself that will not magically change after them"

^ this with bells on

My ex lived in a shared house and blamed the mess on the others (!)

He was working away from home when we were first married so he wasn't there to make a mess. When he changed to 9-5 I got a rude awakening.

He also assumed that I would be the default parent even though I earned (a lot) more than he did.

Thank goodness I never had kids with him.

Springflowersblooming · 15/09/2022 07:57

probably not wise to make life decisions based on Mumsnet threads. Ppl without dh problems dont post threads asking for advice with them. None of my real life friends or family are feckless like you describe or like the awful partners on the threads here. Genuinely, none of them.

dustofneptune · 15/09/2022 07:52

OP, to be honest?

I really think the answer is not to worry about how to find the perfect man to raise a family with, but instead to know that you will always be ok.

You can't control things in life. You do the best you can with the information you have, and you roll with it. Having kids can really change people. People who seem together and prepared can absolutely find parenting overwhelming and just check out. People who are generally aimless, untidy, lazy, etc., can totally turn it around once they have kids, because it gives them a real sense of meaning and purpose.

I think "green flags" to look for depend on what you'd like from a life partner. So... it could be things like playfulness, level-headedness, ability to provide and hold down a stable job, desire to be a stay at home dad (if you'd prefer to be the one working), etc.

The biggest thing I'd personally look for?

Ability to communicate with love and respect.

You're going to run into problems as a couple - whether you have a pet together, are travelling on holiday, have kids, etc. There will always be issues to solve. So that's the number one thing I'd look for, because then you know you have someone you can communicate with, who is humble enough to adjust their approach when you raise an issue, and who is confident enough to raise issues when they are having trouble too.

You can also look at things like their desire to have kids and why they want them. How they feel about stay-at-home parenting (for you or them). Their values - do they have strong opinions that you'd disagree with, like boys shouldn't cry or play with pink "girlie" toys? What is their perspective on giving sweets and junk food to kids? Stuff like this. It's the kind of stuff you get to see over time.

Most importantly, I just wouldn't rush. The first year is honeymoon period - so if you can give it longer, wait at least a few years, live together, etc., you're more likely to see whether or not you are compatible.

But ultimately, think more about your ability to support yourself generally in life. Sometimes unexpected things happen and you can only do so much to try to pick a good partner.

Redqueenheart · 15/09/2022 07:50

I don't think you can always predict how someone will react to become a parent but I would avoid anyone who:

  • hasn't got their life together financially
  • isn't emotionally stable (doesn't react well to stress and setbacks and can't control their anger) and selfish
  • has some dodgy views about women and equality and is not pulling his weight in term of sharing chores
  • is lazy
  • regularly uses drugs and alcohol
  • has mental health issues they are unwilling to recognise and address
  • has a history of so called ''psycho' exes
  • is a porn consumer
  • is not up for a committed monogamous relationship with you.

Also the biggest mistake is to expect that you can change your partner or that they will magically change when a child comes. If they are a lazy, selfish, immature person, this is not going to improve when they become a parent.

ElfinsMum · 15/09/2022 07:49

Things I used to reassure myself that he was going to be a good dad:

  1. I like his dad and he loves his dad
  2. beta type, maybe even a bit boring
  3. v intelligent especially at maths so just assumed he would be a good earner
  4. Reliable, loyal and brilliant in a crisis (this is the only one that has been really helpful in reality)

Things I wished I had asked:

  1. Why don't you understand why people love pets? (An exceptional mathematician who doesn't really get people or pets... anyone spotting any red flags?!)
  2. Do I love him or do I love mothering him?
  3. Who does the motherload in his birth family?
  4. Does his birth family seem happy?
  5. Does he enjoy work?
pastypirate · 15/09/2022 07:47

How willing is he to put himself out? Parenting well is about putting your own needs aside.......for at least 18 years. It's a great thread idea and a great question.

queenMab99 · 15/09/2022 07:47

All the signs mentioned by pp are right, some are obvious, some harder to discern. However in my experience, even taking all those things into consideration, you just never know, and once you have sussed out the really bad ones, you just have to take a chance.

Oblomov22 · 15/09/2022 07:45

"But there are no guarantees that’s enough."

That is also true. there are no guarantees for any of us. Some of it is luck. but we can narrow the chances somewhat.

MsTSwift · 15/09/2022 07:45

Dh is an amazing dad.
Really good honourable person , female friends who adore him, was serious about wanting to be a father, excellent job L, super capable, annoyingly good at everything!

He finds his mother very annoying and likes cycling so not sure those are markers!

PileofLogs · 15/09/2022 07:39

And “how would I feel if my son turned out just like my partner?” Is a good question.

Kashmirsilver · 15/09/2022 07:37

You need to talk about family life beforehand. His expectations and yours, somewhere in the middle will be reality. The problem with a lot of family setups is square peg round hole syndrome.
Will the parents adjust their life choices, and friendships-careers-hobbies to adapt to the new circumstances? Far too many couples have either unrealistic expectations or set out on a path to personal and familial oblivion.

PileofLogs · 15/09/2022 07:37

How does he talk about women generally? Big red flag is he’s charming to you and your friends but talks in a misogynistic way about other women, and that includes women who you might find genuinely objectionable.

AquaticSewingMachine · 15/09/2022 07:34

I don't think you can always tell. But I will say that something that has blown my fucking mind since I started reading MN is the number of women lumbered with a shit dad and partner who admit "He's always been selfish". Why, and how, would you ever let someone you could honestly describe as "selfish" knock you up?!?

So, definitely, if you've ever before kids thought "he is kind of selfish", don't go there.

entropynow · 15/09/2022 07:33

LHReturns · 15/09/2022 05:19

If he has made it into his 40s without ever having a long term serious relationship. Red flag - won’t be good at compromise.

Poor DH then. Married him at 39, no LTR prior for him (very shy with women). Completely equal at chores and parenting.

BuckarooBanzai · 15/09/2022 07:31

I did a shopping list for my DD's father. I can honestly say I couldn't have got it more wrong if I tried. Needless to say he ticked all the boxes with bells on! He is a hideous human being and father. The mask really came off when I was pregnant which is quite common with abusers. Fast forward to my lovely DP who is the love of my life but not a box ticker. DP is the most wonderful father to all his kids and my damaged teens.

MorrisZapp · 15/09/2022 07:29

When you're ill, tired or just under the weather, is he kind and patient or does he huff and puff and imply you're making it up?

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:29

@WrongWayApricot

How long had they kept that a secret for!?

That's mad

WrongWayApricot · 15/09/2022 07:28

A problem is, some things they don't let you know until you get up the duff. I remember being about 4 months pregnant and my ex announced his mother was an alcoholic and he wouldn't trust her alone with a pet rock. I'd met her, spent time with her, thought she was lovely. Turned out whenever I was due round a massive operation took place to keep her sober and pretend the family got on with each other. After I was pregnant that gradually faded. The massive rows then happened in front of me.

Also pay attention to the father son relationship, there can be a crazy amount of hidden baggage there.

I don't know if these things can be spotted, and I think it's cruel when the family work together to try and keep the gf around. If left to his own devices I reckon my ex would have been easy to spot. His home would have been a shit hole, he would have been out of a job, he wouldn't have been able to afford to go on dates etc. If your son is a dick let women see that and save everyone heartbreak. Don't wait until they're 8 months pregnant and then out of the blue tell the poor woman actually you think your son is a really bad person.

Pay attention to 'banter' even when he says 'oh that's just what Jim is like, I haven't the heart to tell him I don't like his sexist jokes'

Pay attention to relationships with sisters.

See how he reacts when you want to choose things, pay close attention. Is he enthusiastic about your choices, does he try to make that happen, or do your choices always seem to be unable to happen for one reason or another and you always end up doing what he'd suggested.

Also, might be controversial, if he has ever asked to borrow even a small amount of money while dating or told any single lie (no matter how small/white) it would be over immediately now. No benefit of the doubt for me anymore. I don't care if a tiny tornado appeared out of nowhere and stole only your wallet, I don't care how kind you thought you were being when you lied, you're not in my life anymore after that point. Because that gradually became big lies and lots of money, ever so slowly.

I think it goes without saying that if you're getting to be choosey about partners don't start dating men who already have children. It's an easy way to never have the hassle of being a step mum if you consider those men ineligible from the get go.

Oblomov22 · 15/09/2022 07:28

@ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat

Well first of all I did say that some people don't show their red flags straight away. If you read my post.

Secondly people do change. So A man who might not of done such a silly things when you first met him suddenly has a midlife crisis. this does happen.

But sadly they probably were lots of red flags and you just didn't notice. We are all human. We miss things. Choose to ignore things. At the start and all the way through. Clearly he did have the ability to be the type of person to cheat. All along. I would never cheat never it's not in my nature and I know that but he clearly wasn't of that ilk. I'm sorry you don't like that fact, but it's the truth.