Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to spot the shite fathers early on?

260 replies

StellaStacey · 15/09/2022 04:59

I'm newly single in my late 20s. I want to think about settling down and starting a family with someone.

I see so many of the same sort of posts on here about women having children with their partners and the father not being a parent at all or doing any household chores whatsoever. The man insisting he has a right to undisrupted sleep because he works a paid job and has zero appreciation to the hard work and exhaustion that goes into raising a child. I seriously at points consider staying childless because I don't think I can cope with this kind of setup and want to avoid it at all costs, not only because of how physically exhausting it must be but the mental torment of a partner completely disrespecting and think so little of you as the mother of their child. I know I would never get over the resentment. I read some of the posts on here and I want to scream at these men who are driving their partners to such breaking point for being completely and utterly useless. My god you are heros and extremely resilient if you have been in this situation.

As I jump onto the dating scene again I wanted to ask, are these useless twats easy to spot early on? Are there warning signs? If you ended up in this situation was it obvious looking back that it would be like that but you were love blind to the signs? What are the red flags? Did your DP completely change when a baby came along or did they always have these tendencies to avoid all responsibility?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 15/09/2022 08:38

Does he pull his weight?

A man who thinks he's 'helping' you by loading the dishwasher is not going to see taking care of his child any differently.

You want a man who cleans his house, cooks his food, does his laundry etc without drawing attention to it and wanting praise.

Does he think his job is more important than yours?

That's how it'll be if you have a child with him. He can't possibly leave work to pick up his child cos he's a big important man with a big important job.

What's the relationship like between his parents? Does his father pull his weight?

There are very few genuine surprises when it comes to how people will behave in a specific situation. (I say very few because obviously there are times when a person ticks every box then years down the line turns into a fucking monster)

But that aside, you need to look at their behaviour in other situations and you can normally extrapolate from that.

you need to observe and understand their behaviour for a long enough period because most (but not all) people can't wear their masks for ever.

Most of all, don't let your feelings lead you. Love is all well and good but decide with your head not your heart. Don't let emotions make you overlook behaviours that are clear indicators this person will let you down.

SunSparkle · 15/09/2022 08:34

When you’ve been in the relationship a little while, it’s perfectly responsible to talk about hopes for the future including kids and talk about things like:
how long and who will take parental leave
what religion will they be
what do I want to do with discipline
what type of schooling do I want my child tk attend
how do we feel about childcare
will either of us go part time

me and my partner had been together over 15 years before we started trying for a baby and in some ways I think that’s more difficult as you’ve had a huge amount of time just being a couple so you need to make sure you’re ready to add another person into that. I felt we got a lot of stuff out in the open, talked about fears and what we didn’t like from how we were parented, I made it clear I didn’t want to give up work so We would have to be able to afford childcare. It was so much better to get those expectations agreed before she came along.

PileofLogs · 15/09/2022 08:34

Foronenightonly01 · 15/09/2022 08:23

Avoid anyone who has ‘gaming’ as their hobby - all my friends who married blokes who spent lots of time doing this have found they’ve married a ‘man child’. I’m not sure why apart from maybe their on screen time has reduced their experience of the ‘real world’ and they end up immature and clueless. Huge generalisation I know, but this is my lived experience 🤷🏼‍♀️.

Completely agree. Not saying everyone who enjoys gaming is like this but for some men it’s almost a way of opting out of life.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/09/2022 08:33

Flipping this round, I remember being in a house share and my now husband coming round and not just doing our washing up after I'd cooked, but my housemates stuff that had been left out as well, and putting the bin out that we'd let pile up, as he recognised that they were being inconvenienced having an extra person in the house sometimes and wanted to contribute

Also spending a chunk of his bonus on hobby equipment for us both, it was money I'd never have spent at the time but he wanted us both to enjoy the hobby together and didnt feel right about getting himself the fancy stuff and me not.

He is still considerate, does stuff without being asked, and generous. Literally does at least half of everything including mental load, got up with the kids in the night to try and soothe them even though he was working and I was breastfeeding etc (unless they clearly just needed a feed as that would have been madness)

His dad is the same, when they stay with us he will pitch in with housework, doing stuff with the kids (not loads but as much as his mum)

Although he is quite shouty as a parent - I would never have guessed as he literally never shouts, ever, unless he is watching sports on tv, otherwise. But it's how his parents were with him when he was little (they are not shouty people in general either) and it kind of came back out when he had kids. So there are some things I think you wont know until it happens.

21secondstogo · 15/09/2022 08:32

I agree about the selfish hobby. They don’t change.

In my exh’s case, how he treated his mother (and his father for that matter) was also relevant.

sageandrosemary · 15/09/2022 08:31

Gauge his attitude towards absent fathers in general.

Oblomov22 · 15/09/2022 08:29

Btw, my Dh is far from perfect. He Has loads of great qualities many of which I was looking for in a partner, he's old-fashioned, loyal is extremely quick witted. he's stable and doesn't get flustered and we can communicate and by God we've needed to - been through some shit (nothing to do with us but problems with the school and children that nearly broke me. I'm surprised we're not divorced to be honest. It's a credit to us that we aren't. )

He's also quite sulky and can be controlling. But I'm not shrinking violet and I simply have never let him get away with such a nonsense. But he's a diamond. I chose well.

As a pp said, Think about their absolute worst quality and whether you can cope with it - that's a very good reminder.

KosherDill · 15/09/2022 08:28

Don't rush it. It takes years, not months, to establish a balanced relationship.

ganvough · 15/09/2022 08:26

And someone who isn't completely uncompromising about a hobby that takes him away every weekend. I have hobbies too but don't prioritise them over DP all the time. Balance is important or you'll be doing all the childcare while he's hobbying.

ganvough · 15/09/2022 08:25

He lives independently (could be flatmates or alone) and cooks, does laundry, cleans up after himself, has no serious debt and has savings, is happy to make you a coffee/tea or cook for you. And shows an interest in YOUR work I.e supportive, proud of your achievements and asks questions. Finally is happy to at least occasionally tag along to things you like but he doesn't. Makes effort with your family and friends.

I find if they've had some experience of a pet when growing up or are comfortable around children - can play with them etc - it's a good indicator they've got a nurturing side so being a dad won't be a hated chore. Also I avoid massive workaholics past 30 - in your youth it's ok but if they haven't found work life balance by 30 they'll struggle.

user443741922 · 15/09/2022 08:25

I would also suggest not listening to everything said on MN.
It is only 1 side of the story and (sometimes) is being told by a bitter or deeply hurt person.

I think lots of people ignore early concerns or red flags because they really like the person. We have all been there! But these red flags do usually end up biting us on the way out 😂

Please don't be put off from having children because of what you read on here. There are some great relationship, parents and even co-parenting relationships!

Foronenightonly01 · 15/09/2022 08:23

Avoid anyone who has ‘gaming’ as their hobby - all my friends who married blokes who spent lots of time doing this have found they’ve married a ‘man child’. I’m not sure why apart from maybe their on screen time has reduced their experience of the ‘real world’ and they end up immature and clueless. Huge generalisation I know, but this is my lived experience 🤷🏼‍♀️.

MillyWithaY · 15/09/2022 08:21

AquaticSewingMachine · 15/09/2022 07:34

I don't think you can always tell. But I will say that something that has blown my fucking mind since I started reading MN is the number of women lumbered with a shit dad and partner who admit "He's always been selfish". Why, and how, would you ever let someone you could honestly describe as "selfish" knock you up?!?

So, definitely, if you've ever before kids thought "he is kind of selfish", don't go there.

I agree with this. There are so many posters who say their husband/partner has walked out on them/cheated on them, and that they're 'devastated', 'can't believe he'd ever do that', 'love him so much and just want him back', 'he's the last person on earth you'd think would act like that', 'honestly thought we had the perfect marriage'! And then in the next sentence '3 years on and I couldn't be happier. I can't believe what I ever saw in him, he was always a selfish knob, my DP is the love of my life'. So they weren't really happy, he wasn't the 'last person you'd expect' and they didn't think they had the 'perfect' marriage.

Love really is blind. I know plenty of women who are or have been in bad relationships, and everyone else can see it and can predict it won't last, but you can't tell people. That chemistry that happens between people overrides any kind of sense.

Oblomov22 · 15/09/2022 08:20

@namechange30455

if you classify that as victim blaming, so be it. The victim may be to blame. If there were red flags that they chose to ignore.

if someone chooses to cheat, the Buck stops with them. They are to blame.
Can you spot someone who has the propensity to cheat. Often.

Name me a scenario where you think the blame never, 0%, lies with the woman. That she takes zero responsibility for not spotting red flags earlier?

BertieBotts · 15/09/2022 08:18

Kashmirsilver · 15/09/2022 08:07

🙄Imagine sitting down with a potential partner-parent and asking how one would behave in the event of a split.😂
Er, I deffo wouldn't be having a child.

Why not? Talking about break ups is a really important thing to be able to do. If you're scared of breaking up then you don't have a secure relationship.

Also, though, it's not like it's a first date question! You can get a sense of how somebody feels towards their exes by spending time with them. People who are resentful and angry towards their exes is a red flag.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 08:16

I think sometimes as well you get partners who are a somewhat manageable level of shit after one child and then it's the second that tips things over.

BertieBotts · 15/09/2022 08:15

Agree about:

Hobbies having priority over your relationship. The hobby will continue to take priority over family life/duties. It really doesn't matter what the hobby is. E.g. gaming is often trotted out as a red flag but DH is a gamer and a brilliant dad - the gaming comes about fifth or sixth in his priorities - kids, me, work, house, family come first.

"Liking kids/being great with kids" is not a good metric. Being a good parent weirdly isn't about how much you "like kids". In fact that can be a red flag because some people who love (other people's) kids tend to like them when they are behaving well, happy, when they can do whatever they like to spoil them etc - they don't always see that flip side of when your toddler is screaming and scratching your face or your teen is resentful and grumpy, they want to be fun parent all the time, they don't want to do the hard stuff like discipline and getting up at night.

Also, if you're young enough to have time to wait I think it makes sense to go slow and be with somebody for several years before TTC. When you're older, you can afford to go for it a bit quicker because you'll have some relationship experience already. But some issues don't really show themselves until several years into a relationship.

I found this a brilliant read about choosing long term relationships

www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/life-and-relationships/why-you-will-marry-the-wrong-person-20160707-gq0k55.html

BellePeppa · 15/09/2022 08:13

PileofLogs · 15/09/2022 07:39

And “how would I feel if my son turned out just like my partner?” Is a good question.

That is an excellent question and really sums up what you should ask yourself before getting in too deep.

NippyWoowoo · 15/09/2022 08:12

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:26

Usually shite fathers will be shite partners

But some women put their blinkers on and don't see the early stage red relationship based flags and carry on to breed with them

I don't for a second believe any of the women who post on here moaning about their husbands or partners not stepping up as parents when they say 'they were wonderful before the baby' I would bet my house if people anonymously surveyed their family and friends before they had a baby most, if not all, would say they'd predict he'd be a shit father.

A partner who gladly does their fair share in a relationship is a lot more likely to do the same with a child

Someone who is as invested in your career as you are so won't think you're a default parent

One who is open to discuss children, how it would work with time off, who offers to split the parental leave and does so

Absolutely this. One of my friends said 'he changed after the baby, he was perfect before'. No mate, he wasn't. Some people just see what they want to see.

Basket20 · 15/09/2022 08:11

I think it is very difficult to tell. Everyone thought my DH would be brilliant and he barely passes. I have friends who DH really stepped up and there was concern that they would not but they have been brilliant. Tbf I think the same happens with women. There are women who think they will make an amazing mother but really struggle when they become a Mum. Others are treated as if they are "not maternal" but when they have children they really take to it. Men pick women based on who society (and their Mother) says is suitable as a Mother but it can all change when the baby arrives.

TheOGCCL · 15/09/2022 08:11

You basically need a feminist. Our society is still so entrenched in gender stereotyping that many men, and women, find it hard to look beyond the traditional family set up. This leads to expectations the female will lead the care giving which does a disservice to both genders but often gives men a get out of jail free card. Look for someone who can see the inequality.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 08:10

For those problems that are foreseeable, which I don't think is all of them, the worst choices I've seen from both men and women when it comes to babies and marriage have mostly been time pressure ones. Where one or both of them is at the stage where they've decided they feel ready for the particular life step and therefore that automatically meant the person they were with must be suitable. All my friends are getting married, desperate for a baby etc. The 'lights have gone off' thing mentioned upthread and the hormonal urge for children.

IMustMakeAmends · 15/09/2022 08:08

Bear in mind that people are nuanced! It depends what matters to you and what you can live with.

My DH is a bit shit around the house. Has a 'big' job and very little time or inclination for anything else. I probably do 90% of the physical graft around the house and kids.

He's also kind, gentle, loving. He's great with money and does all the finance stuff/bills/car/tech etc. He supports my work, appreciates what I do. He loves the children fiercly and tries his very best to make parents night, sports day etc. He's doesn't raise his voice and is like a calming presence in the house that we all depend on. He doesn't have any time consuming hobbies and would far rather spend his free time with us than with anyone. He's not interested in laddy culture and cares about women's rights etc.

There are so many good points about him, but yes I could list some things that make him a pain in the arse to live with. 🤷‍♀️

Kashmirsilver · 15/09/2022 08:07

BertieBotts · 15/09/2022 08:00

Great question! I think it's really hard to know what the signs of a good/bad father are in advance of actually being a parent. I just looked at my ex playing with kids and thought aww, that would be nice Confused But anybody can play with kids for half an hour. It's living with them day in day out and managing their lives for two decades through phases where they don't even seem to like you - that's a totally different thing. It's challenging, and above all, you want to pick a partner that will be an asset and complement you through that challenge. Probably the longest and most intense of your life.

How does he treat you when you are vulnerable - sick or tired or struggling with MH or anything like that. Does he take the load off you, show concern, try to make things better for you? Or does he ignore you (or even get huffy). You will be vulnerable for a long time with pregnancy/young children. See also: animals, women in his family (mother/sisters), people serving him (restaurant staff, shop staff, his staff at work etc) Do not look at what he says, look at what he does and how he says things.

Agree totally with pulling his weight in the home and proactively - he should not wait for you to ask him to put a wash on or make dinner. He should see that it needs doing, and do it.

More of a relationship one - what's his absolute worst habit/worst quality? (Ignore what it actually is, how do you feel about it?) Is it "It's really really bad but it only happens occasionally, so I can live with it" - you can't. Is it "I wish he wouldn't do that but probably he'll stop as he gets older" - he won't. Is it "Some people would find it a deal breaker but it (genuinely) doesn't bother me" - check yourself that it really doesn't, but this is fine. You need his worst quality to be something minor and annoying, not worrying, not scary, not dangerous, not even frustrating. Do not expect him to change automatically when kids come along. Most people find that very hard to do and he might not even be assuming he will have to.

How do you work together on projects e.g. planning a holiday, planning a wedding, or another family orientated event, redecorating a room. There should be a balance. You don't want him taking over, you don't want him sitting back letting you do everything so that he basically just shows up. Can you discuss and accommodate both of your preferences, do you value his input because it's genuinely good, does he value yours? Is it a good outcome at the end?

What is he like as a person? Is he somebody that you want your future child/ren to look up to? Would you be proud if your child grew up to be like him, as he is now? Don't take on a project because you want to mother somebody. You want kids, you'll have them to mother. Choose a finished article for your co-parenting partner. See also: Shared or at least compatible beliefs about things like religion, diet (vegan/sugar/organic/alcohol etc), pets, discipline, cleanliness, socialising, money etc.

If he already has children, what's his relationship like with them/the ex? This is more complicated but essentially you're looking for signs that if you split up, he'd still have the children's best interests at heart, and not use them to hurt you. Break ups happen - people grow apart. You need somebody who would be pragmatic and fair in that instance.

How do you disagree? What happens? Are you able to discuss productively with both seeing the other's side? Or do you avoid discussions, does he turn nasty, do you end up feeling it's your fault, are you scared to disagree in case he leaves? It doesn't need to be perfect, but it does need to be safe (no threats, no violence, even directed at objects) and productive (there is a mutually acceptable resolution at the end, not just ignoring the issue or avoiding it).

🙄Imagine sitting down with a potential partner-parent and asking how one would behave in the event of a split.😂
Er, I deffo wouldn't be having a child.

Sceptre86 · 15/09/2022 08:05

Some men do change after marriage or kids however many were lazy shits before and the partner just didn't notice because it didn't inconvenience them too much. Throw a baby, sleep deprivation into the mix and Mike's inability to cook a meal or arrange his own roadtax is now another burden on already tired shoulders. That's when the shit hits the fan when the female partner (usually) expects him to understand that the baby takes priority so they need to pick up more of their own tasks and the man can't understand why his partner is nagging him about traits or behaviour she never took issue with before. I see it time and time again.

To avoid I sussed dh out in the early days but I was mid 20s and he was early 30s. I blatantly told him what I was after in a partner and if he wasn't interested or didn't display any of those traits, I would have moved on, plenty of fish in the sea and all that. It could have come across as forthright but by then I knew what I wanted and wasn't going to waste my time. It's having the confidence to do that and knowing that you can't change people, if they are haphazard and live a chaotic life, can't budget they aren't the best person to have kids with. Of course for those men that change after kids are born there isn't much you can do to anticipate that, however you can be confident in yourself, discuss and ditch them if need be. You never have to just make do but that comes from protecting yourself financially and knowing your own self worth.