Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to spot the shite fathers early on?

260 replies

StellaStacey · 15/09/2022 04:59

I'm newly single in my late 20s. I want to think about settling down and starting a family with someone.

I see so many of the same sort of posts on here about women having children with their partners and the father not being a parent at all or doing any household chores whatsoever. The man insisting he has a right to undisrupted sleep because he works a paid job and has zero appreciation to the hard work and exhaustion that goes into raising a child. I seriously at points consider staying childless because I don't think I can cope with this kind of setup and want to avoid it at all costs, not only because of how physically exhausting it must be but the mental torment of a partner completely disrespecting and think so little of you as the mother of their child. I know I would never get over the resentment. I read some of the posts on here and I want to scream at these men who are driving their partners to such breaking point for being completely and utterly useless. My god you are heros and extremely resilient if you have been in this situation.

As I jump onto the dating scene again I wanted to ask, are these useless twats easy to spot early on? Are there warning signs? If you ended up in this situation was it obvious looking back that it would be like that but you were love blind to the signs? What are the red flags? Did your DP completely change when a baby came along or did they always have these tendencies to avoid all responsibility?

OP posts:
rnsaslkih · 15/09/2022 09:18

I would say it’s almost impossible to avoid.

But avoid men who already have kids. It sounds really nasty, but you just need to read the step parenting boards on here to realise that the situation makes life a lot harder.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 15/09/2022 09:18

I think the key things are (1) selfishness and (2) laziness. Those can show in lots of different ways before children. But basically if you have someone who prefers to always put himself first, or thinks he is entitled to, and someone who is lazy you have a pretty good chance of ending up with a poor partner for having children (btw, not all bad coparents are bad fathers. They are just a pain in the ass for the other parent).

AllAloneInThisHouse · 15/09/2022 09:17

I would avoid anyone who:
(…..)
is a porn consumer

This is seriously immortant addition.
Porn/ sex work etc. are so misogynistic that no one who uses or supports these things can be pro-women in any shape or form.

Discovereads · 15/09/2022 09:17

Most of these are lived experiences of what is a good vs bad partner while you are coupled up (not before you decide to date). Unfortunately, there are numerous cases of fantastic partners that turn out to be shit parents. Having a baby is also a stress point during which formerly good partners start being abusive partners.

Readmorebooks · 15/09/2022 09:16

Nrtft but I think it comes down to views on gender roles. I'm married (25+ years now) and we discussed early on what our understandings of gender roles were. I'm passionately of the view that there is no difference between men and women in terms of ability to do anything other than bear and feed children. So my expectation was always that everything else would be 50/50 in terms of stuff at home (cleaning, cooking, mowing the lawn, ironing etc) and when we had children. He had a family that was a bit ahead of its time and his mum was pretty feminist too.
So that's how it worked. We both worked 60% when we had children and looked after them the rest of the time. We both got weekends away on our own. We still manage things 50/50 though we have certain jobs we each prefer so I've never mown the lawn and he's never cleaned the hob unless he's made a spectacular mess...
I knew early on he'd be like that.
But I meet so many women now who accept such low standards from men because they think that any man is better than none - or they actually believe there to be defined gender roles. On the counter side, I see too many women who infantilise their partners, "don't trust" then with their children, feel that mothers are always better with children etc etc which can lead to men giving up or worrying they will get something wrong. My DH want as good as me at doing my dd's hair nor at picking out outfits that looked good (he's not great at doing that himself) but I didn't care - he's not me.
My young adult children I hope have learned to look for similar to us in their partners. They literally view us both equally and will talk to either of us about any of their issues etc.

femfemlicious · 15/09/2022 09:16

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 15/09/2022 06:18

Sometimes you can't know in advance, sadly. In general though I would say that from what I've seen on here and in RL, sometimes women are happy taking on the bulk of domestic chores before kids, which isn't felt as a huge deal when it's just the two of you to cook and clean up after, but add a child or two to the mix, plus still working and it's then blatantly unfair. So someone who pulls their weight before kids is what you are looking for. The number of times I've heard/read ' well they will do jobs but they don't see mess the way I do/I've got higher standards so easier if I just do it' - from the man's point if view if they've never done it why would they change once kids come along? And thats another thing - so many women seem to think that having a child will make a man change/step up. In my experience, they don't change. What they are is what they are. Its just that pre kids it doesn't seem like a big deal, but once they are here it actually is.

THIS 💯💯💯. most women dont mind doing the bulk of housework pre kids. It becomes untenable after kids because house chores magnify 100 fold after kids. Men refuse to see this because they just dont want to do more because its boring and tedious AF!

Drivebye · 15/09/2022 09:15

Not convinced you can tell this by all the things posted above. We all know men who are 'perfect' on paper then turn out to be crap once children come along.

I think the answer is to look for the attributes listed on this thread but to be very clear how you will run things and be selfish. Protect yourself by always being in a position to leave. Have your own money and independence. I don't know if it's a coincidence but the friends that seem to have navigated this best just expected the men to step up and took no crap. Even if they were working they expected them to do some night feeds. If the man doesn't step up stop doing their washing and cooking their meals and completely focus on yourself and your baby. I think there's too much pressure still for women to be expected to 'remember your partner' when the reality no one is really remembering them.

Kissingfrogs25 · 15/09/2022 09:13

The one that was very telling to me, does he take responsibility for his past mistakes in relationships? And how he speaks about his exes, if he is respectful that is a good sign of emotional integrity and maturity.
Even if difficulties were present in his past relationship, he is able to take his side of the blame, and learn from it. This shows he will be willing to be flexible and open, and that he is a man that will take future responsibilities seriously.

Kissingfrogs25 · 15/09/2022 09:10

Treating his mother well is very very different to pandering to his mother, particularly if she is a strong character. She will not like you whoever you are, and will likely be just as demanding or more demanding of his time/effort and energy when your babies arrive. She will still expect him to do her bidding and run around her regardless of what is happening in your lives.

Catastrophejane · 15/09/2022 09:08

My exH was really keen to have kids, and is still a loving, affectionate father.

he is also a complete, selfish arse who refuses to take on any of the work of parenting.

it’s less about how they are with kids, and more about how they treat women in their life.

here are the red flags I actually noticed, but ignored:

the way he treats his mother.
his aversion to housework and his messy, chaotic flatshare.
can he say sorry and own his mistakes?
does he compromise?
does he think about your preferences when planning his free time?

How does he treat his ‘enemies’? ( ex girlfriends/ annoying colleagues/ people who disagree with him on Twitter)

Kissingfrogs25 · 15/09/2022 09:08

If he is paying his sister to do his washing up run a fucking mile.

Discovereads · 15/09/2022 09:07

I don’t think you can spot them. Too in my experience, the men who treat their mothers well are mummy’s boys whose mother has spoiled them rotten by doing everything for them as a child while their father sat back and didn’t lift a finger to do any household chores or raising of them. Apart from bonhomie man to little man back slapping shit.

There’s also the issue of performative perfection. Men (and women) will perform the role of perfect partner and that includes making all sorts of perfect parent promises. The “no child of mine” or “if we had a baby, I would do….” Many can keep this up for years! Especially in regards to hypothetical parenthood…it’s soo easy to pretend you would be a perfect co-parent. It’s not until the baby is actually here that the cracks show and the whole fiction comes tumbling down.

I appreciate you motivation OP, I’d want to avoid it as well who wouldn’t? But I don’t think it’s helpful to list red flags that really are meaningless because imho the truth is you can’t predict who will be a shit father in advance and by pretending that we can, we are indirectly blaming mothers for choosing poorly who to have a baby with. This isn’t helpful to women faced with this situation as it really isn’t their fault what their partner chooses to do (despite what they may have promised), and it’s giving women another stick to beat themselves with.

RequiemForAcat · 15/09/2022 09:03

Agree with most of these, another thing I have learnt over the years is that you don’t really know someone for around 2 years. So don’t have children before you’ve been with someone for 2 years because by this time, any mask will have slipped and you’ll know what you’re getting for the future. Don’t let red flags slide.

Manekinek0 · 15/09/2022 09:02

I agree with many of the PPs. I would also add that if his friends have children really listen to how he talks about them. If he claims those friends are "under the thumb", their wives are controlling or they pity them for not having the same amount of free time then you can start piecing together how he views women and motherhood.

Good men are out there. My MIL is a feminist who was the main breadwinner for a significant part of DHs childhood. I'm not sure if that had an impact or if he's just a good man but he always pulls his weight and does more than his fair share of childcare due to my working hours.

AloysiusBear · 15/09/2022 09:01

Signs of a good bloke:

  • clear about what they want. does not avoid conversations about marriage, children, money or give vague answers to brush off questions.
  • does not expect their hobbies/job to come before everything else in life. You can spot this one if they are reluctant to schedule holidays or family visits you want because they can't possibly miss a single round of golf.
  • is kind/tolerant of children/animals
  • lives independently and doesnt constantly forget to buy things like milk, toilet paper etc. Owns cooking & cleaning equipment and uses both.
  • budgets reasonably. Red flag if they are asking to borrow money from you, regularly owe money to parents & siblings, or have a lot of debt.
  • doesn't become a different person when tired, hungry, stressed. If they are directing anger towards you, ever, because their team lost the footie, the plane is delayed, the dishwasher broke, the washing machine leaked & wrecked the floor. How people react when something bad happens is important.
  • they have good longstanding relationships in their life. Whether friends, family, colleagues, people who seem to only have transient relationships are a warning sign that people don't stick around them long.
Whokno · 15/09/2022 09:01

I think the only way is to get to know a man and give it time before you get in too deep. If he seems reluctant to let you do that, then that in itself is a red flag. I know a guy who would tick most of the boxes on this list - kind to Mum, animals, polite, fun etc. - I've known him for years (work together) and he's charming and fun. I wouldn't go anywhere near him romantically and wouldn't leave him in charge of my kids (even to babysit). He has had many women fall head over heels for him and he does well for about 6 months before his anger management, selfishness and general arrogance surfaces - by that time most of them are in too deep and end up broken hearted and confused. Thankfully he doesn't have any kids (his choice, he at least recognises he wouldn't be a good dad) - but if he did I have no doubt he'd be fun and a "great dad" for a bit, and then lose interest when they got a bit bigger.

Lunar270 · 15/09/2022 09:00

Interesting thread.

I think most of the stuff mentioned already tend to be things that make up a good partner and what you're probably thinking about anyway (or should be).

And of all the advice given, I've not read many instances of actually sitting down and having a conversation about it and what a family looks like for both of you. What will your careers, home life, social life look like? What compromises are either of you willing to accept?

But I think it's difficult, given no-one actually knows how to deal with being a parent and the way it can turn your life completely upside down. Anyone who tells you that it's possible to predict how anyone will cope feeding a baby at 12:00, 04:00 and then doing a days work is full of crap, male or female. Tiredness is a killer and I've seen it ruin amazing marriages and turn both parents into the most unpleasant individuals ever.

And after 20+ years of successful marriage I can definitely say that neither of us are the same people that we were. Our success is partly due to us being compatible but also due to us changing in ways that have complimented us. It's pure dumb luck and we could've equally grown apart. So yes, think about finding a decent partner but don't overthink it as long happy marriages with consistently good people are somewhat rare nowadays.

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 15/09/2022 08:58

MarinoRoyale · 15/09/2022 06:05

Avoid the ones who have a child already that they don’t see very often because the mother is ‘difficult’ or has ‘turned the child against them’.

Absolutely this.

Also if he is already a father - how old is the child? A man with a young child and he has already left the family unit. Avoid.

Sadly though, there aren't always red flags. Mine was a gentle giant, sweet, everyone loved him. Till he discovered tinder.

ohthehorrorthehorror · 15/09/2022 08:53

I met my husband almost 40 years ago, and the things that made me realise he was the one to settle down with were the following:
Good relationship with his parents.

History of stable relationships. No history of "crazy exes", in fact was on good terms with both significant exes.

Good with children. Wanted children at some point in the future.

Good work ethic. Sensible with money.

Had his own flat (rented) that was clean and tidy, and was a decent cook.

No drama, and was obviously very into me from the outset, without being suffocating. Accepted that I had my own interests.

Was someone who was very at ease with himself.

He's been a great husband and father.

lenny17 · 15/09/2022 08:48

Anything that makes you ask questions. Any overstepped boundaries that are repeatedly ignored.
Any behaviours you think are designed to impress you.
Trying to persuade you rather than hearing you.
If they don't get you early doors they're unlikely to do so further down the line.

Look for someone that demonstrates that they function independently as an adult, emotionally and financially.

Thank you far asking this. Having reflected on it I realise that all the flags were there from day one and I chose to ignore them. All the things I would describe from us first getting together are the same things now. Except it's far harder to make a break, now that we have a child and finances make it difficult for us to separate.

GreenIsle · 15/09/2022 08:42

I have been with dp since we were teenagers so effectively grew up together and so I never knew what kind of father he would be. We had some rough times at University due to the usual out partying and not communicating well. However he is the best father any children could ask for.

I also don't thing some of the red flags people mentioned are so black and white for example his relationship with friends or parents.

My dp has a poor relationship with his parents but that's because he puts his children first and is protecting them. He has close friends but again prioritises his children rather than nights out when needs be.

He is career driven but values family life so we work well together 50/50. I'm off on maternity leave but even yesterday dp came home from a long day of work yesterday and took the baby upstairs for an hour or so to give me a break then suggested a takeaway. This is a small example of his thoughtfulness. He does all our ironing and vacuuming because I can't stand it. He will just pay for anything that's needed.

He will take dc our at least once a week in between work to the park or cinema etc just them for quality time and we take turns putting the children to bed each night, if I'm overwhelmed he will just do it no question. Also dp goes to the gym and running but waits till everyone is in bed sleeping then he goes out.

Funny thing is people in work probably think he is highly sarcastic, very particular about things and bossy. I love when he comes home and fills me in with the lastest work gossip we tell each other everything. But with his family he is just the best really, nobody is perfect and of course can be grumpy at times but generally things are good.

AllAloneInThisHouse · 15/09/2022 08:41

Avoid men who are on bad terms with their mothers.
They harbour a lot of unresolved shit towards females.

Not all mothers are angels.
This is naive thinking.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/09/2022 08:40

Also before you have kids you need to talk. How will it affect your careers, what childcare you will use, how it will fit into your working days, how it will be financed, what you would do for kids sick days, will you share mat leave, how will chores get done if you have a difficult baby etc etc

When we were thinking about our first baby we had planned that we would both change our hours so we could do pick up and drop offs snd finances would continue to be shared for example (I wasnt expected to still pay 'my share' of bills on mat leave for example)

If he had had an attitude of 'whatever you think' (so not engaged) or implied that it was my job to sort arrangements, or any hint of sexism in which of us did which role, or he wadnt going to change anything to work around children then I'd not have gone ahead as the responsibility and logistics of it all are the kinds of things that can wreck your career and lead to resentment if the other parent doesn't pull their weight

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 15/09/2022 08:39

Right ok @Oblomov22 you obvious know a random persons relationship better than they do. I'm not the only one on here saying they were blindsided or that their partners totally changed. Guess what, my ex also used to swear blind he'd never cheat, his parents split due to infidelity and he was pretty vocal on how shit it was. But yes, I expect you're right and we're just all not as good as you at seeing what is apparently always there if you look hard enough. I find your dismissal of mine and others' real experiences pretty offensive actually. It's pretty arrogant to assume that you have superior knowledge that contradicts what many people are actually saying. Of course in lots of cases there were signs, with varying degrees of obviousness, but not always. Don't know why you find that so hard to accept.

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 08:38

Very much agree with @SunSparkle

DH and I were together for 10 years before having our first

In that time we both discussed who would be taking what time off, we both also changed jobs to be more set up for having children

Which for him included taking a pay cut for a role with more flexibility so he could do 50/50 of everything

My husbands only negative quality is what many on here would see as a good one (can't argue, grew up in an abusive home and cannot have a good argument to save his life!) but I always had high standards, I filtered boyfriends quickly when 16+ as I knew what I wanted was a family but I didn't want to end up as just a mother.