Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to spot the shite fathers early on?

260 replies

StellaStacey · 15/09/2022 04:59

I'm newly single in my late 20s. I want to think about settling down and starting a family with someone.

I see so many of the same sort of posts on here about women having children with their partners and the father not being a parent at all or doing any household chores whatsoever. The man insisting he has a right to undisrupted sleep because he works a paid job and has zero appreciation to the hard work and exhaustion that goes into raising a child. I seriously at points consider staying childless because I don't think I can cope with this kind of setup and want to avoid it at all costs, not only because of how physically exhausting it must be but the mental torment of a partner completely disrespecting and think so little of you as the mother of their child. I know I would never get over the resentment. I read some of the posts on here and I want to scream at these men who are driving their partners to such breaking point for being completely and utterly useless. My god you are heros and extremely resilient if you have been in this situation.

As I jump onto the dating scene again I wanted to ask, are these useless twats easy to spot early on? Are there warning signs? If you ended up in this situation was it obvious looking back that it would be like that but you were love blind to the signs? What are the red flags? Did your DP completely change when a baby came along or did they always have these tendencies to avoid all responsibility?

OP posts:
PineOrange · 15/09/2022 14:24

They only use one arm when pushing the stroller.

Too cool for walkies. 🙄

SleeplessInEngland · 15/09/2022 14:22

You can't predict how anyone will be as a parent. All the box ticking in the world doesn't stop it from being a massive leap in the dark.

Scottishskifun · 15/09/2022 14:18

I don't think I agree with the mother comments. The husbands I know who are close to their mums also expect their wives to do everything for them despite living independently before and they are lazy dad's!

For me it was seeing my DH with my nephew or friends with children he was engaging, wanting to play getting involved.
He has one of those hobbies which is just for him but we are both outdoorsy people so we take it in turns going to do our activities and also do some together.

I also knew he would be a good dad because he was caring when I was ill, wanted to spend time with me and would consult me before making plans so chose to change how he did his hobby with his friends and wanted me to join him on night out. He would also offer to pick me up from work nights out off his own back.

I think making decisions/plans with zero consultation of the other is a red flag it's their opinion or what they want to do comes first which doesn't bode well for children

StellaStacey · 15/09/2022 14:01

I appreciate all the wisdom ladies! I'm at work but am gradually reading through the advice when I can

OP posts:
user443741922 · 15/09/2022 13:31

Dinomummy2 · 15/09/2022 13:12

'You can't replicate the situation of having children in any way but to actually have them'

I think this is true. My husband was the kindest, most loving and supportive DH, he ticked many of the boxes listed here and our marriage is still in a terrible place after DC.

What happened? Well for a start his parents both died of cancer within 5 years and that changed him as a person for ever. It was like some of the kindness and humour that I so loved died inside of him forever. How could I have planned for that? Should men with older parents be added to the list of 'red flags'.

You can't guarantee that any man is going to be brilliant husband or father forever, people change over time as life circumstances impact them.

I really dislike the theme I have seen on MN lately of placing an onus on women to choose the perfect partner (as if with a crystal ball) and at the same time maintain financial independence, so that (just in case he was not the perfect partner) she is not adversely impacted financially by leaving. It places so much responsibility on women and hints that those suffering the financial and emotional impact of a marital break up only have themselves to blame.

What I do think is that the nuclear family model of motherhood does not benefit women. The women I have seen really enjoying motherhood/thriving are those with a supportive and involved network of extended family or women friends.

Love this. Very well said!

Dinomummy2 · 15/09/2022 13:12

'You can't replicate the situation of having children in any way but to actually have them'

I think this is true. My husband was the kindest, most loving and supportive DH, he ticked many of the boxes listed here and our marriage is still in a terrible place after DC.

What happened? Well for a start his parents both died of cancer within 5 years and that changed him as a person for ever. It was like some of the kindness and humour that I so loved died inside of him forever. How could I have planned for that? Should men with older parents be added to the list of 'red flags'.

You can't guarantee that any man is going to be brilliant husband or father forever, people change over time as life circumstances impact them.

I really dislike the theme I have seen on MN lately of placing an onus on women to choose the perfect partner (as if with a crystal ball) and at the same time maintain financial independence, so that (just in case he was not the perfect partner) she is not adversely impacted financially by leaving. It places so much responsibility on women and hints that those suffering the financial and emotional impact of a marital break up only have themselves to blame.

What I do think is that the nuclear family model of motherhood does not benefit women. The women I have seen really enjoying motherhood/thriving are those with a supportive and involved network of extended family or women friends.

Tiddlywinkly · 15/09/2022 12:33

There's some really good pointers on this thread. I won't add much other than to note that my dh's dad worked long hours and his mum was a SAHM. His dad did nothing around the house or change a nappy, but he was involved when he could. This situation was acceptable for both parties.

He consciously decided to not be his dad and to play a more active role in childrearing and the household. So my point is that upbringing isn't necessarily an indication of what men expect.

Caiti19 · 15/09/2022 12:16

This is the kind of stuff that should be taught in schools. If a course in this existed, I'd get my kids signed up to take it age 16, with annual refresher courses too.

Caiti19 · 15/09/2022 12:14

How does he deal with your first disagreement? Swearing/ignoring, or calm discussion?

That one from a previous poster is huge. Navigating a life of parenting together with a person capable of thoughtful, calm discussion is the difference between feeling like you have a partner who has your back or an additional child.

xogossipgirlxo · 15/09/2022 12:14

Oh and another thing: is whiny like a toddler.

xogossipgirlxo · 15/09/2022 12:14

From my experience (or rather observations):

-when you don't have kids and man already is lazy with housekeeping work, you have to ask him 100x to i.e. do the laundry or repair something,
-isn't too ambitious re work. Is happy on low salary and no progress. It doesn't mean everyone has to be doctor or lawyer, but doesn't want any progress,
-is more interested in his hobbies than your life and gets really moody when can't meet his lads for football or so.

Macbeth8 · 15/09/2022 12:10

BoxOfCats · 15/09/2022 05:14

A few things come to mind, I'm sure others will be along with more.

  • How does he treat his mother?
  • Has he ever had to live independently before?
  • What is his current living environment like? Tidy? Chaotic?
  • Does he seem to be financially secure? I don't mean mega rich, but things like an inability to budget would be a red flag for me
  • Do you value the same things, have similar priorities in life?
  • Does he treat you with respect? I don't mean words or grand gestures... but things like how he behaves when you are ill or when you have a disagreement

Disagree with this.
These are the answers to your Qs about my dh

He treats his mother amazingly..always affectionate and doing jobs for her.

He lived alone in a boarding school 3000 miles away from his parents so 100% independent.

Parents are filthy rich and always had money. He has never had a mortgage as his parents are against them so they bought his first house. He paid them £50 a month as an "interest" agreement.

He can be typically bloke-ish, leave his socks about and dirty plates but can also decide one day to do a big tidy up..always doing DIY

He has always seemed family orientated and wanted kids. He is definitely ambitious though

The respect.... question a tricky one. On and off.

But lets just say hes far from.the perfect dad and leaves everything down to me
Has a short fuse with them, shouts and can be borderline abusive!
So I just wanted to pooint out those questions could mean absoultely nothing! Take it from me and my 20 years with him.

Caiti19 · 15/09/2022 12:04

Great question. Watch him interact with his own parents (is it all take, or is there give there too), siblings, nephews, nieces (does he engage with them on their interests) over a prolonged period. This will tell you most of what you need to know.

ohdelay · 15/09/2022 12:00

I think being a good father is separate from being a good partner and relates to actually feeling the children are theirs rather than a disposable consequence of sex that they put up with for their current partners. Obviously not all men, but some do see kids as accessories and do some crazy mental gymnastics to turn all that off if the relationship ends. The flip side is the involved fathers come with involved extended families and less control.

anotherscroller · 15/09/2022 11:57

Love this thread! 🍿

cavia · 15/09/2022 11:55

BoxOfCats · 15/09/2022 05:14

A few things come to mind, I'm sure others will be along with more.

  • How does he treat his mother?
  • Has he ever had to live independently before?
  • What is his current living environment like? Tidy? Chaotic?
  • Does he seem to be financially secure? I don't mean mega rich, but things like an inability to budget would be a red flag for me
  • Do you value the same things, have similar priorities in life?
  • Does he treat you with respect? I don't mean words or grand gestures... but things like how he behaves when you are ill or when you have a disagreement

OP, I think this is an excellent list!

DdraigGoch · 15/09/2022 11:42

Paying the bill at a restaurant can work both ways. On the one hand, it would be miserable to end up living with a skinflint, you don't want someone who never pays his way or fusses about splitting the bill down to the last penny.

On the other hand, if he never ever lets you pay your way then he's not really respecting that you are an independent woman, with an earning capacity in your own right. That could be an early sign that he holds old-fashioned views on earning, expecting that you would give up your job to bring up any children. It can also be "love-bombing" where he is expecting to be able to buy your affections.

The ideal situation is someone with the generosity to offer to pay, but also the humility to put his wallet away when you say "no, it's my turn".

RedToothBrush · 15/09/2022 11:39

Wouldloveanother · 15/09/2022 06:23

It’s all about consistency, to me.

  1. Does he have a stable job, or does he seem to jump from job to job?
  2. Does he have steady friends? What are they like? Watch out for the ‘lad’ types
  3. Mums are a tricky one. They should have a respectful relationship with their mum but not be too in her pocket, eg talking every day or ‘my mum thinks…’ etc
  4. How does he deal with your first disagreement? Swearing/ignoring, or calm discussion?
  5. Dump him immediately if he asks for money, lives with his parents or has any kids from previous relationships that he doesn’t see. Ditto if he complains about paying CMS or calls his ex a ‘psycho’
  6. Don’t get pregnant for at least a few years, preferably wait until after the wedding

DH jumps job to job. Its helped his career enormously. If he had stayed in a job he would have never got his salary to anywhere near it is now. He has had to lean on me at times to achieve this, but overall its worked for us both...

He has loads of friends. Too many. Some are extremely laddie. But I like. In terms of steady friends, that's a difficult one - we met just after he left uni, so big life change. The friends he had then and the friends he has now are massively different.

He can't stand his mum. He avoids her as mum as he can. We see her a couple of times a year. And to be fair to him this is justifiable! She's a complete nightmare.

He did have a psycho ex-girlfriend. Who his friends (male and female) agree upon. He has never done anything to make me think differently.

I think there is a problem in looking for Mr perfect on paper. He doesn't exist. And actually at some point you have to take a leap of faith and overlook something which others might suck their teeth about on this thread.

What I think is important is thinking about and talking about where you see yourself in a few years. Having proper grown up conversations about money management and sharing responsibility. It's about give and take and I think having someone who demonstrates that they are willing to compromise and take the strain when you need it is the big thing. It's amazing how people don't talk about the big things before marriage. How many children ideally and what happens if things don't go to plan. Could you cope with less children or are children the be all and end all. What do you want in terms of where you live. Are you savers/spenders. What's your long term attitude to money (pensions, buying a house). Where do you want to live. Are your lifestyles compatible (this includes the sport hobby guy - it's not necessarily a deal breaker as long as if you compromise to allow him to do something, you also have a plan to allow you certain freedoms and he is prepared to make time for family too. Hobbies don't need to go, if you have a strategy that works for the whole family to accommodate it.)

I genuinely don't think there is a blue print for being able to conclusively avoid dicks. I think the biggest conflict points are attitudes to money and how people prioritise rather and whether you match or not.

I suspect DH wouldn't match well with others. But those reasons also work well for me because we are on the same page and have worked together as a team.

DdraigGoch · 15/09/2022 11:26

Assembling some flat-pack furniture together is a pretty good stress test. As is a week's holiday. Unusual options for first dates though so start with the basics of watching how he treats other people. How does he behave towards customer service staff? What are his relationships with his family like etc.

Oblomov22 · 15/09/2022 11:11

@KermitlovesKeyLimePie
i completely disagree.

emotional intelligence

the capacity to be aware of, control, and express one's emotions, and to handle interpersonal relationships judiciously and empathetically.
"emotional intelligence is the key to both personal and professional success"

we all should have it. We all can work on it. Always.

for those that don't have it, it can be learnt. If they are that abused they'll need counselling and help. We can't just let them have none. Everyone needs it. It's a basic requirement.

Winniewonka · 15/09/2022 10:59

IMO the two most important elements are look at how interested he is in you as a person.
Does he know and care about your likes and dislikes in food, Can he name your close friends, would be know which book you are currently reading or who your favourite band is?
If you are unwell, would he be concerned, would he bring you painkillers or try to cheer you up?
Everyone seems to mention the relationship with his Mother, I would say what is his Father like?
From my group of friends whose marriages have lasted over 40 years and their husbands are good fathers/grandads, without exception all their husbands came from families where they did things together e.g. camping, caravanning, sociable activities where everyone 'mucked in'. Their Dads would take all the kids fishing, hiking and other outdoor pursuits and generally ensure that their kids were independent and could fend for themselves.
Consequently, of the sons that now have their own children, they are great hands on dads and view their partners as equals.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 15/09/2022 10:56

@Oblomov22 I think that is very harsh.

Many women don't have what you call "emotion intelligence" due to their upbringing and learned behaviour from what they themselves have experience from the adults in their life.

If their Mum put up with crap, chances are they consider that "normal"

I was very fortunate to be raised by a very strong woman and and Father who despite the norms of the era in which I grew up was very much an exception when it came to pulling his weight.

My Mum would'nt have put up with a useless partner and she taught her 3 girls our value.

I have to remind myself of that when I see some of the threads on here and despair. They were not as lucky as I was.

Emotional intelligence often has sod all to do with it!

mam0918 · 15/09/2022 10:48

BoxOfCats · 15/09/2022 05:14

A few things come to mind, I'm sure others will be along with more.

  • How does he treat his mother?
  • Has he ever had to live independently before?
  • What is his current living environment like? Tidy? Chaotic?
  • Does he seem to be financially secure? I don't mean mega rich, but things like an inability to budget would be a red flag for me
  • Do you value the same things, have similar priorities in life?
  • Does he treat you with respect? I don't mean words or grand gestures... but things like how he behaves when you are ill or when you have a disagreement

My deadbeat bio dad was:

  • close to his mother (he was her precious baby)
  • a super tidy minimalist
  • financially stable business owner

Those things mean NOTHING when figuring out if hes a good father.

I'm disabled and my father has wished me dead for being a 'worthless drain to society', my mam had no idea he held those views until after I was born and he definately got louder, prouder and more shameless with those views over time so I believe her.

Hyacinth2 · 15/09/2022 10:42

DB loved my Dm and was very considerate to her but was a crap father, too busy working to give time to his DC, but his DF was a hopeless father and an alcoholic. I would look to the father of DP/DH for an idea of how they will father. That's the example they've been given.

BertieBotts · 15/09/2022 10:33

The relationship with mother thing is complex. I think probably we say this without really explaining what it means.

For me, it's about - does he value and respect his mother as a person with thoughts and opinions of her own, or does he talk scathingly about her with contempt as though she is an annoyance?

It's not about him never saying anything negative, not all mothers are lovely and supportive. But he should care about her wellbeing at least on a basic level. Also, unfortunately, all the men I knew with seriously abusive mothers had quite deep seated emotional difficulties with women - probably because we tend to play out our own childhoods in relationships - so that would be a red flag, regardless of whether his dislike of her is justified. Unresolved trauma makes relationships difficult and opposite-sex parent trauma is a killer particularly for hetero relationships.

On the other side, is his mother on a shining pedestal and can do no wrong ever? He will put her first ahead of you. You will always be seen in competition. She will probably be a nightmare MIL, especially as a grandparent. Nightmare MIL is not necessarily a huge problem, but nightmare MIL and your DH being on her side is.