Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to spot the shite fathers early on?

260 replies

StellaStacey · 15/09/2022 04:59

I'm newly single in my late 20s. I want to think about settling down and starting a family with someone.

I see so many of the same sort of posts on here about women having children with their partners and the father not being a parent at all or doing any household chores whatsoever. The man insisting he has a right to undisrupted sleep because he works a paid job and has zero appreciation to the hard work and exhaustion that goes into raising a child. I seriously at points consider staying childless because I don't think I can cope with this kind of setup and want to avoid it at all costs, not only because of how physically exhausting it must be but the mental torment of a partner completely disrespecting and think so little of you as the mother of their child. I know I would never get over the resentment. I read some of the posts on here and I want to scream at these men who are driving their partners to such breaking point for being completely and utterly useless. My god you are heros and extremely resilient if you have been in this situation.

As I jump onto the dating scene again I wanted to ask, are these useless twats easy to spot early on? Are there warning signs? If you ended up in this situation was it obvious looking back that it would be like that but you were love blind to the signs? What are the red flags? Did your DP completely change when a baby came along or did they always have these tendencies to avoid all responsibility?

OP posts:
bodie1890 · 15/09/2022 06:41

namechange30455 · 15/09/2022 06:35

I think that's extremely naïve tbh.

I know women who jumped into relationships because they wanted children without thinking it through.

They were so desperate for a child (understandable) that almost any man would do and they weren't thinking rationally. I think this happens a lot.

Of course it verges on victim blaming to say that they 'should have thought it through more'. Many people have a very strong and primal instinct to reproduce.

JulesCobb · 15/09/2022 06:40

Skolo · 15/09/2022 06:09

Remember that you only get one side of the story on MN!

Whag is the other side of the story for men who do not take responsibility for their children?!

Hillrunning · 15/09/2022 06:40

I can see how people feel that most of the lists being given might help weed out the worst ones but for me they are just surface behaviours that can easily fall by the wayside.

Mother and father are two of most strongly stereotyped roles we have in society so for me the only thing that gives a good indication of a man's ability to father well is if they recognise that and genuinely believe in equality between the sexes. I feel the same of women too.

The second thing to consider is if they truly do want to parent. So many men I know were talked into children or just made to believe it was the inevitable next step in life. Rather then given a genuine choice. It's too big a thing to do when you didn't really want too.

Windowtea · 15/09/2022 06:40

I agree with @FishFingerSandwiches4Tea and @Oblomov22

If he's a lazy fuckwit before kids who doesn't tidy up after himself that will not magically change after them.

Spend a long time with your partner before hand. Don't rush into stages of a relationship. Get to know them properly first. I was with my DH for 11 years before we had kids. Put them in the most stressful situation imaginable and see how they react. Is there other kids in the family. How do they react with them? Do they look after and care for them. (My DH has always babysat his nieces and nephews). Look at what their parents are like because that is the relationship they have been taught to model. Talk to them about their parents relationship and what kind of parent they want to be. And if they won't talk about it, well that's a red flag too!

I also think that the most important thing any woman should do is not ignore the red flags. There are a lot of posts on there where people list off loads of what is wrong in their relationship. Just to say 'But I'm in my 30s and want a baby!'. Trust your own gut if a relationship isn't right and don't stay just for a child. Use a sperm donor instead.

namechange30455 · 15/09/2022 06:35

Oblomov22 · 15/09/2022 06:22

Oh please. This post is melodramatic. If you have an ounce of common sense and emotional integrity and if you are open emotionally then you will have thought about most of these things already and you then choose your men carefully.

Go out with a normal man who is a good man who will pull his weight and has the same goals in life and will stick around in your marriage through thick and thin and and then you will be fine.

Some men don't show the warning signs obviously. and it comes as a shock to women. But most of my messages who really do have these kind of problems clearly show that they don't have the emotional intelligence and never really thought about these things before jumping into relationships.

if you've got an ounce of emotional intellect then a lot of these problems that you read on the relationship boards won't happen to you.

I think that's extremely naïve tbh.

OctopusBreath · 15/09/2022 06:35

His relationships with his exes. "Psycho ex" is the biggest red flag I know of.

Droo · 15/09/2022 06:34

My exh ticked a lot of “good dad” boxes and acted like he was interested in friends/family’s dc but he was a terrible father.

Good signs I think are:
Patience, not being grumpy, deals well with stress, independence and if they have a pet they are solely responsible for who’s well cared for.

Birdwitted · 15/09/2022 06:32

In my case, we just lived together for years pre DC and my DH always:

  1. Did his share around the house. 50% of all chores.
  2. Was (generally) kind, considerate and not selfish - we both had our own interests but his needs didn't trump mine and we sometimes did things together.
  3. His family were very nice - not at all overbearing but interested and supportive. He had an uncomplicated, loving relationship with them.
  4. He was hugely hard working and had a massive amount of get up and go. Like he never wanted to sit in the house all day and do nothing.
  5. Money was never an issue. Like when we were first together he had more money than I did and often paid for things so we could socialise. He never made a big deal about it or seemed to mind at all. When later we had joint finances he just wasnt ever weird about it.

I appreciate it might be difficult to find a person with all of these qualities, and I also appreciate that people sometimes pick men for other stuff. My DH isn't perfect, but he is fundamentally decent. I do also know that some men seem to change a lot post children but I think how selfish you think they are is a good test.

pictish · 15/09/2022 06:31

A lot of shit dads don’t reveal the fact until they are one.

bodie1890 · 15/09/2022 06:31

I actually think it's possible to tell these things from quite early on - certainly before you commit to having a child.

I think a lot of people have children thinking it will change a relationship/ change a man, and then it often makes things worse. But they actually knew his basic personality to start with.

Look at how he is with friends'/ family's children - does he care, make an effort to interact with them? If so how? Does he talk to them or just playfight?

Does he initiate conversations with you about having children, or is it mostly one way?

How patient is he when little things go wrong in life? Does he get frustrated/ lose his temper?

Can he reflect on himself? Can he apologise if something goes wrong and change the next time?

I'd also look out for the state of his home, is it clean & tidy, is he basically together and coping with life as a single person, financially, practically, emotionally?

What do his friends say about him/ what kind of friends does he have? How 'laddish'/ mature are they?

All these things should give you some idea.

Wouldloveanother · 15/09/2022 06:29

wb3 · 15/09/2022 06:28

Should a man dump a women who lives with her parents would love another?

If he doesn't do his share of the housework without being asked before children, you're doing most of ths nappy changing.

Up to him. I don’t think the signs of fecklessness work in reverse, but I don’t think it’s ever a great sign of independence to be honest.

MrsMontyD · 15/09/2022 06:28

My ex was, on the whole, a good father until he had "a mid life crisis" affair, he completely changed overnight and was a nightmare to divorce and has been completely useless as a father ever since. You couldn't have predicted this, everyone has been shocked.

wb3 · 15/09/2022 06:28

Should a man dump a women who lives with her parents would love another?

If he doesn't do his share of the housework without being asked before children, you're doing most of ths nappy changing.

LegoFiends · 15/09/2022 06:27

TheNefariousOrange · 15/09/2022 06:03

My exh changed his surname on marriage (ti mine) and took 3 months paternity leave so I could go back to work at 6 months. He was still a useless feck.

Literally everything posted describes DD's waste of space dad. He was financially stable, a home owner, good at budgeting, kept on top of his housework, an amazing cook, really close with his mum and sister, and he was the one that actually really wanted kids (I did not, it took a lot of persuasion). It was like, as soon as I had given birth, his brain had fallen out and he was unable to adult by himself.

Oh, I don’t think it guarantees anything if he answers in a good way. But if someone tells you on a second date that it’s emasculating to take theoretical paternity leave, that definitely tells you something.
Having said that, the men I know who changed their names and took leave are all exactly the kind of person OP is looking for.

Wouldloveanother · 15/09/2022 06:23

It’s all about consistency, to me.

  1. Does he have a stable job, or does he seem to jump from job to job?
  2. Does he have steady friends? What are they like? Watch out for the ‘lad’ types
  3. Mums are a tricky one. They should have a respectful relationship with their mum but not be too in her pocket, eg talking every day or ‘my mum thinks…’ etc
  4. How does he deal with your first disagreement? Swearing/ignoring, or calm discussion?
  5. Dump him immediately if he asks for money, lives with his parents or has any kids from previous relationships that he doesn’t see. Ditto if he complains about paying CMS or calls his ex a ‘psycho’
  6. Don’t get pregnant for at least a few years, preferably wait until after the wedding
Oblomov22 · 15/09/2022 06:22

Oh please. This post is melodramatic. If you have an ounce of common sense and emotional integrity and if you are open emotionally then you will have thought about most of these things already and you then choose your men carefully.

Go out with a normal man who is a good man who will pull his weight and has the same goals in life and will stick around in your marriage through thick and thin and and then you will be fine.

Some men don't show the warning signs obviously. and it comes as a shock to women. But most of my messages who really do have these kind of problems clearly show that they don't have the emotional intelligence and never really thought about these things before jumping into relationships.

if you've got an ounce of emotional intellect then a lot of these problems that you read on the relationship boards won't happen to you.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 15/09/2022 06:22

Are they mean/stingy with money? Do they "split the bill" down to the penny? Do they expect you to pay 50% even if you only earn 20% of what they earn? Do they expect you to pay all the children's expenses because you "had" the baby and that makes it yours.

Justleaveitblankthen · 15/09/2022 06:21

Good question OP and some wise answers.
If I had my time again:
Within a few weeks you should have met a few of his friends, a few months you should meet his family (several times/not just a quick hello and bundle you away) Huge red flag if you don't.
Definitely take a few holidays together before you even think of moving in together.
Is he racist/homophobic/mysogynistic? (and he will probably be hiding this initially) eventually things will leak out.
Is he kind to a animals? Watch him around children. He doesn't have to find them fascinating, but he does need good humour and tolerance.
Watch closely his attitude to money and remember that one day your finances may be joint.
Is he mean with money? It will only get worse.
Is he controlling in any way? Make negative comments about your appearance (or more likely that of your friends he disapproves of initially, he will be saying the same about you in the future..)
I could go on.. and on.. 😏

Doorhandleghost · 15/09/2022 06:18

Sadly there aren't always red flags. There are plenty of men who would have passed these tests being outlined above but still turn out to be a selfish arse when their kids arrive.

For instance my daughter's father - he was amazing before she was born. I had to rest a lot due to complications and he did all the housework, shopping, looked after me, was generally a dream partner. He was financially secure, worldly, good to his mum etc etc etc.

Once she was born he turned - jealous, angry, selfish, wanting to be out all the time, refusing to do night shifts etc. in the end he tended towards threats of violence.

You can't replicate the situation of having our children in any way but to actually have them.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 15/09/2022 06:18

Sometimes you can't know in advance, sadly. In general though I would say that from what I've seen on here and in RL, sometimes women are happy taking on the bulk of domestic chores before kids, which isn't felt as a huge deal when it's just the two of you to cook and clean up after, but add a child or two to the mix, plus still working and it's then blatantly unfair. So someone who pulls their weight before kids is what you are looking for. The number of times I've heard/read ' well they will do jobs but they don't see mess the way I do/I've got higher standards so easier if I just do it' - from the man's point if view if they've never done it why would they change once kids come along? And thats another thing - so many women seem to think that having a child will make a man change/step up. In my experience, they don't change. What they are is what they are. Its just that pre kids it doesn't seem like a big deal, but once they are here it actually is.

AllAloneInThisHouse · 15/09/2022 06:16

No ”selfish” hobbies, eg. they take along time.

How they view other women, you know how first date red/green flag is how they treat waiters?
Same here, except about women.
Do they judge women who don’t want kids, or single women, or think women who don’t giggle and pander to all men are bitches.
This may sound crazy, but many men want women to just look pretty, giggle at their ”jokes” and cater to their lives.
So how they view women who don’t ”fall in line” is important.

Hiw they act and treat you when one of you or both of you are sick.

How they handle sex and attention.
If they are pushy / high drive, that’s can become a problem when pregnant/ baby is young.
And if they are kind of a man who is going to be jealous of the baby is going to be a problem.

I don’t think how they treat their mother is that simple.
Believed it not, but not all mothers are good and if someone (man or woman) doesn’t have a good relationship with their mom’s, doesn’t mean it’s because of the (adult)child.

Hastingsontheup · 15/09/2022 06:12

Solasum · 15/09/2022 05:50

Another vote for a stressful journey or holiday together. It is very telling how people treat others when they are tired, hungry and wanting to get home.

How he talks about his colleagues, exes, and anyone more junior than him. Fine not to like people, not fine to disparage them.

This also does he " own" his mistakes can he apologise ? Is he reflective ? Less important in the baby absolutely critical with teens.

Skolo · 15/09/2022 06:09

Remember that you only get one side of the story on MN!

MarinoRoyale · 15/09/2022 06:05

Avoid the ones who have a child already that they don’t see very often because the mother is ‘difficult’ or has ‘turned the child against them’.

TheNefariousOrange · 15/09/2022 06:03

LegoFiends · 15/09/2022 05:54

Tell him about a friend who changed his name on marriage/took leave to stay at home with the baby/is a SAHP while his wife is the breadwinner and see how he reacts.

My exh changed his surname on marriage (ti mine) and took 3 months paternity leave so I could go back to work at 6 months. He was still a useless feck.

Literally everything posted describes DD's waste of space dad. He was financially stable, a home owner, good at budgeting, kept on top of his housework, an amazing cook, really close with his mum and sister, and he was the one that actually really wanted kids (I did not, it took a lot of persuasion). It was like, as soon as I had given birth, his brain had fallen out and he was unable to adult by himself.