Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to spot the shite fathers early on?

260 replies

StellaStacey · 15/09/2022 04:59

I'm newly single in my late 20s. I want to think about settling down and starting a family with someone.

I see so many of the same sort of posts on here about women having children with their partners and the father not being a parent at all or doing any household chores whatsoever. The man insisting he has a right to undisrupted sleep because he works a paid job and has zero appreciation to the hard work and exhaustion that goes into raising a child. I seriously at points consider staying childless because I don't think I can cope with this kind of setup and want to avoid it at all costs, not only because of how physically exhausting it must be but the mental torment of a partner completely disrespecting and think so little of you as the mother of their child. I know I would never get over the resentment. I read some of the posts on here and I want to scream at these men who are driving their partners to such breaking point for being completely and utterly useless. My god you are heros and extremely resilient if you have been in this situation.

As I jump onto the dating scene again I wanted to ask, are these useless twats easy to spot early on? Are there warning signs? If you ended up in this situation was it obvious looking back that it would be like that but you were love blind to the signs? What are the red flags? Did your DP completely change when a baby came along or did they always have these tendencies to avoid all responsibility?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blocked · 26/09/2022 11:33

I think the most important thing is that he really wants a family and shows he's committed to you and your baby. He'll make mistakes, as will you, but you figure it out and learn together. You make it clear from day dot that he will be caring for the child by himself at times and follow through with that - a lot of the uselessness stems from 'I can't do it' because they've never been left alone to get on with it simply because mums are off on maternity leave and are always there. No one's fault, just the way it goes sometimes.

itsaich · 26/09/2022 11:06

Just talk to your dates.
Tell them what you're looking for in life, that you want a family, not necessarily with them of course, but it shouldn't be a secret that this is your ultimate goal in dating.

Discuss what type of future you want and that will include family life. It's getting to know someone. They will reveal the type of set up they want eventually and you can use that to decide whether or not to get serious about them.

EdgeOfACoin · 26/09/2022 10:20

I haven't read the whole thread and I imagine it's been said before, but I just wanted to say that Mumsnet can give a skewed impression of things at times. The people who are in secure relationships with partners who do their fair share are not posting for advice on the subject on the relationship board.

My husband is a hands-on father and we split domestic chores equally. My friends all seem to have partners who do their fair share too. Don't be too pessimistic about the prospect of meeting a guy who is capable of parenting properly.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/09/2022 10:08

@LaurenM87 it's like thinking Boris Johnson would be a good PM or a good dad because 'he's a bit of a laugh'

BudgetBlast · 26/09/2022 09:22

WillPowerLite · 15/09/2022 05:38

He lives independently (possibly with flatmates) and pays his bills, manages any debt, which should be sensible debt (mortgage, student loan, etc) and not dodgy overspending. His place is clean and tidy. Because he cleans it himself.

He cooks a good variety of meals well and cooks regularly for you.

He does his own laundry and his clothes look reasonably weel-cared for.

He has a history of being a responsible adult who keeps his word.

Essentially, he is an adult who takes good care of himself.

He supports you and your goals. Not just by saying he does, but by making you tea if you're stressed or offering to pick up groceries. Practical help.

You share goals. You share a vision for family life.

This is an excellent post.

LaurenM87 · 26/09/2022 09:20

EBoo80 · 15/09/2022 07:17

I honestly don’t think you can tell. Seeing male friends let down their partners has surprised me time and again. My DH is an exceptional partner, and would have failed lots of the red flags mentioned up thread when we met.
I think the ‘does he like kids’ is especially deceptive actually. I know some men who everyone describes as ‘great dads’ because they like to play with kids, are fun etc. that’s not parenting. That’s babysitting.

100% agree with this! Everyone used to say how my husband would be the most amazing dad as he was so good with my friend's kids. Yes he's good at carrying on and making them laugh but won't do any night feeds and hasn't so much as bought my DD a nappy! Some men aren't that outgoing and would maybe feel silly playing with kids but could be the best dads to their own. A child needs commitment and stability not a clown.

LaurenM87 · 26/09/2022 09:17

My husband has always been selfish and always seemed to royally fuck up at the times I needed him most. I do wonder if he is terrified of responsibility and self sabotaged to avoid having to ever be my rock. So selfishness is a major red flag! Don't think a baby will change them, it only further highlights the depths of their selfishness!

However, I don't regret a single things as I now have my DD who I love more than I could have ever imagined. Yes it can be tough feeling like you're doing it alone but it's so worth it!

LaurenM87 · 26/09/2022 09:12

Paq · 15/09/2022 05:44

Avoid golfers, cyclists and football season ticket-holders 😀

Seriously though, anyone who thinks they can't possibly miss their hobby for anything won't change when a baby arrives.

Add boaters to this 😂 my soon to be ex husband always loved his boat more than me! Since having our gorgeous girl he's hardly missed a weekend on it while I've not even managed a session at the gym!

Luxembourgmama · 18/09/2022 18:23

EBoo80 · 15/09/2022 07:17

I honestly don’t think you can tell. Seeing male friends let down their partners has surprised me time and again. My DH is an exceptional partner, and would have failed lots of the red flags mentioned up thread when we met.
I think the ‘does he like kids’ is especially deceptive actually. I know some men who everyone describes as ‘great dads’ because they like to play with kids, are fun etc. that’s not parenting. That’s babysitting.

Very true

Kindofcrunchy · 18/09/2022 15:53

Eh, it can be hard to generalise. For example I have a messy, video-gaming, football season ticket holder who on paper would look like a LTB but is actually the most supportive, caring husband and father you could ask for. So the mess and the xbox and the football are all fine by me

Poptart4 · 18/09/2022 15:46

My ex was a great dad to our first 3 children for 13yrs. Did his fair share of nappy changes, night feeds etc... was fully involved with his children. Then we had our 4th (planned) child and I don't know what happened. He completely lost interest in spending time with any of his children. Barely gave the 4th child the time of day.

Maybe he had a midlife crisis? I don't know, I just know he totally checked out of family life. Which is why he's now an ex.

There's some good advice on here OP but there are no guarantees. Sometimes people change.

And i have to say there's some very misogynistic comments on this thread from posters basically saying the mothers should have known and its their fault for picking crap dads. God forbid we hold men accountable for their own actions 🙄

JulesCobb · 18/09/2022 11:54

LimeTwists · 18/09/2022 11:11

I’d ask him if he’d be happy to be a stay at home dad or work part time while I worked full time, if that’s ever how the finances worked out best. The answer will be revealing. Anyone who laughs out loud at the ridiculousness of you earning more money even though you’re a mum needs binning.

There are a lot of shit dads who are happy not to earn while their wives earn. It doesnt mean theyll actually look after the children or do any housework.

LimeTwists · 18/09/2022 11:11

I’d ask him if he’d be happy to be a stay at home dad or work part time while I worked full time, if that’s ever how the finances worked out best. The answer will be revealing. Anyone who laughs out loud at the ridiculousness of you earning more money even though you’re a mum needs binning.

Roxy69 · 18/09/2022 10:54

autienotnaughty · 15/09/2022 06:02

Great question wish I'd done this! Definitely no bad temper as stress of child will just magnify that. Self sufficient, good with money - knows how to save/budget. Same long term values/plans. Also think by about what you want? Would would you want to work or be a sahm, does this man supporting working mothers and value the contribution of sahm. Make surecc C your discipline ideas are on same page. Also you need to fancy him, find him funny and consider him a friend.

Good answer. Also doesn't drink to excess too often or gamble. Big red flags.

Flamingosrule · 18/09/2022 02:02

This thread is so interesting 😂
in my experience. DD1s dad was always immaculately dressed .. owned a business and a house but was a total player and l later found out he cheated on me countless times. When I found out I was pregnant - he tried to force me into abortion - I was 19 weeks!!
needless to say we split up and he left me with an expanding belly - I had no friends ( he’d made sure of that over the years we had been together - total control freak)
Wasn’t there at the birth (my mum was -and I’m glad she was!) he visited me after with 24 red roses - stayed 30 minutes at most - reeked of aftershave and told me he was off to “wet the babies head”
once she was born he was back on the scene .. lasted until she was about 5 .. constantly letting her down, leaving me to deal with her crying her eyes out 🙄

then I met my current man…totally out of the blue.. he’s amazing 🤩. He took to DD1 immediately and she did to him! He was a total scruff when I met him.. he would keep his suit jacket on to disguise the fact he couldn’t be arsed to iron his shirt … we used to live 3 hours away from each other and I’d go and clean his place when I got there on a Friday evening 🙈he had to be prompted to shave .. and still does 🙄 he moved up here in 2006 and we’ve got two extras DS who’s 15 and DD2 is 14
he plays football and golf and watches on tv 😩 but works so hard and provides for us
Btw .. DD1 is 23 and doesn’t want anything to do with her sperm doner,.. that’s her own decision

I guess what I’m saying is that you can’t pre-empt where your life will lead you - when you know, you will know!

good luck Xx

ellyeth · 17/09/2022 18:27

If he is generally OK but makes disparaging comments about women or you while in the company of friends.

If he talks a lot about his own childhood and his experiences as an adult (eg his job, his colleagues, etc) but seems to tune out when you do the same and never remembers any of the things you have told him.

If he is fairly even tempered most of the time but when anything untoward happens, becomes bad tempered and blames you.

If he had a strange or disrupted family background where he has been bullied or overlooked. It sounds mean not to be supportive of someone who has experienced this, but, unless you are very resilient, you may find his inexplicably changing moods leave you constantly on edge and mentally exhausted.

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 17/09/2022 15:45

Paq · 15/09/2022 05:44

Avoid golfers, cyclists and football season ticket-holders 😀

Seriously though, anyone who thinks they can't possibly miss their hobby for anything won't change when a baby arrives.

My husband is a golf pro, will never be sorry I married him, best man (other than my father and grandfather who are on par) I have ever had in my life!

My advice;
is his moral compass set at the same position as yours?
Do you share the same views on money, children, life?
Is he communicative and open?
Does he treat you well (support your goals and dreams and put you first when you need him?)
Can he cook and clean?
What relationship does he have with his mother (not too clingy, not too distant)?

Christmasfun2022 · 17/09/2022 12:21

Also we were together 10 years before kids, been through getting a dog, house move, big trips abroad so knew each others faults (appreciate this isn’t always possible if your older)

Christmasfun2022 · 17/09/2022 12:07

Me and my husband have two young kids and run along ok, albeit with a few issues. Looking at us and our circle of friends, reading stories I think these were important things that I spotted early on with DH.

  1. has a stable job and not always changing jobs.
  2. good with kids and we have the same life goals.
  3. a few long standing friends who are not ‘laddish’
  4. no history of lots of short relationships, not a player.
  5. clean and tidy with good personal hygiene, good at cooking and doing jobs around the house.
  6. bascially kind and caring.

a few things not so good (but we have worked on)

  1. what was his home life like? My DH came from a background where his Mum did everything, all the cooking, kids, cleaning and I (think?) she liked it this way. Due to this upbringing we did have some issues with him expecting me to be default child carer, but we have managed to have conversations and think he gets this isn’t acceptable so these cycles can be broken. Also his dad doesn’t express emotions so have the same issue with DH being quite closed sometimes.
  2. relationship with mum is a tricky one - he will do stuff for her and is a good son but isn’t always proactive about contacting her - however not always a reflection on the bloke as his mum can be difficult and makes clear his younger sister is the ‘favourite’. Also she doesn’t contact him often.
AliasGrape · 17/09/2022 12:06

My DH waved a few of these red flags in the early days - mummy still did his washing for example (he’s lucky I was already in love with them when I found that out to be fair). Hadn’t had much of a serious relationship before (one relatively long term one but was long distance and didn’t actually see much of each other). Did not cope at all well with a stressful time when we first moved in together and I needed care/ support - that one nearly broke us up and all I can say is that he was going through something pretty major himself, he did realise what a twat he had been and we both learned an awful lot.

I’m not sure what made me overlook those things, other than I’m far from perfect and probably had a fair bit of scarlet bunting myself when we first met. And we always managed to talk about it, communicate and do better next time.

He’s a properly brilliant dad. Was amazing through fertility struggles, pregnancy during Covid, traumatic birth and long hospital stay, PND and has always been hands on, does his share and has a brilliant and close bond with DD. Still doesn’t do much washing but he does do plenty of other stuff so it works out equal!

Cakecakecheese · 17/09/2022 11:41

JazbayGrapes · 17/09/2022 11:38

First and foremost - does he even WANT kids? Men usually give clues early on that they don't.

Or what are the reasons why they want kids? My ex wanted to be able to leave his assets to someone, erm just bequeath them to a donkey sanctuary or something, that's not a reason to bring a human into the world!

LizzieW1969 · 17/09/2022 11:38

entropynow · 15/09/2022 07:33

Poor DH then. Married him at 39, no LTR prior for him (very shy with women). Completely equal at chores and parenting.

Same with my DH, who I met when he was 37. He’s now a great dad to our 2 adopted DDs of 13 and 10 and a loving partner to me. It’s definitely 50:50, in fact he’s done more than me the last couple of years because I’ve had Long Covid.

He did pass other tests mentioned on this thread, though, he’d been independent for many years, was good with money, honest to a fault and kind to his mum.

JazbayGrapes · 17/09/2022 11:38

First and foremost - does he even WANT kids? Men usually give clues early on that they don't.

Cakecakecheese · 17/09/2022 11:31

You can't have a guarantee with these things but if you look carefully and try to be objective you might find some clues. My ex said he wanted to have children but I knew it wasn't going to be with me because he had no patience, he had hobbies he'd be unlikely to reduce, his flat was gross and full of toot and he had a tendency to ask annoying questions, imagine that along with an inquisitive toddler!

After we broke up I met my partner who.is kind, patient, had lived on his own for a while and his house was clean and just generally felt like he was meant to be a dad. It's early days as our baby is only 7 weeks but he and I are working well as a team which is what you need to be with a baby.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 17/09/2022 11:10

BoxOfCats · 15/09/2022 05:14

A few things come to mind, I'm sure others will be along with more.

  • How does he treat his mother?
  • Has he ever had to live independently before?
  • What is his current living environment like? Tidy? Chaotic?
  • Does he seem to be financially secure? I don't mean mega rich, but things like an inability to budget would be a red flag for me
  • Do you value the same things, have similar priorities in life?
  • Does he treat you with respect? I don't mean words or grand gestures... but things like how he behaves when you are ill or when you have a disagreement

To add, does he value your free time away from him as well as with him.

By this I mean does he care about the fact you want to do other things, and not, he wants to do other things away from you so he's happy not to spend time with you.

Too many dad's go out cycling or golfing or whatever on the weekend cos they have a Big Man Job, and don't care that they leave their wife with all the childcare responsibilities.