Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be over this Queen funeral malarkey already?

136 replies

GuyMontag · 14/09/2022 23:03

It is sad our Queen has died.

On a personal level it's sad for her family.

At a public level it's a momentous occasion for us because she was our head of state so we need to know what's happening next.

But do we really need this ten day event? When the PM left he just gave a wee speech. This is going on forever. Loads of things cancelled, BBC on wall to wall Queen setting.

It's a bit unnecessary isn't it?

Better off trying to figure out what we want from Bonnie Queen Charlie or whatever the fuck he's calling himself, than all this rigmarole.

Or AIBU?

OP posts:
BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:50

I do agree the TV channels should have sorted out something so it isn't wall to wall wherever you go.

BBC1 and their others at least could have been more reasonable.

Euridicefortuna · 14/09/2022 23:50

She wasn't just our Queen ,she had territories over seas where she was head of state. It's not just us that would like to say good bye .She lived an extraordinary life and has seen alot of change. She deserves a funeral that will do her justice. You don't have to watch/listen if you don't want to.It's easily avoidable, I have seen nothing (don't watch tv) but will watch Monday.

Guiltycat · 14/09/2022 23:48

There is no place for sneering at their emotional connection, irrespective of your PERSONAL opinion. They have a right to their feelings don't they?

And the people who think the mass hysteria (is it really mass though? Most people don’t seem to give a fuck) is annoying have a right to their feelings too don’t they?

There. Both sides have expressed their feelings. Marvellous.

Except, you feel uncomfortable when others are expressing their feelings about this. So are insinuating that they should keep it to themselves because it’s important to you and upsetting, right? While simultaneously ignoring that this behaviour/event is making THEM feel uncomfortable.

Ah the wonderful new age circle of using emotional victimhood to debate. Who will win? No one knows, because it can never, ever end.

Jalepenojello · 14/09/2022 23:48

I pay zero attention to the royal family and have continued to do so. It hasn’t effected my life in any way what so ever. I choose to not spend time on any of the events so far or the news at this time. For 90% of it can be avoided I’d say YABU.

CapMarvel · 14/09/2022 23:46

BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:38

CapMarvel
I am sorry my tone was patronising, genuinely. I was aiming for exasperated but missed I think.

I get that you think it is stupid, but I am fed up with reading sneering jibes about people to whom this actually matters. It may well be illogical, when does love become logic in the first place!?

For a lot of people this matters a great deal. There is no place for sneering at their emotional connection, irrespective of your PERSONAL opinion. They have a right to their feelings don't they?

Of course people have the right to their feelings, but likewise I can feel the whole reaction to it has been ridiculously overblown. The bbc are reporting it like the end of the world is nigh when really, what it comes down to, is an incredibly privileged woman rather unsurprisingly passing away after a long life of luxury.

Not everyone thinks the royals are special, but fuck me if we aren't all being expected to act like we do.

GuyMontag · 14/09/2022 23:45

@LimpBiskit it's not just live TV though. I mean I knew that was going to be a write off. But there are some little things I like - radio 3 record review, the proms etc - that have been completely cancelled in favour of dirgemusac. Broadcasting radio 3 record review is neither unpatriotic nor triggering. And yet we are apparently too deep in mourning to hear it.

And this bullshit I've been getting about train tickets all week is completely unnecessary. I'm not going anywhere near London. I mean all power to those who are but I'm getting pissed about on my entirely unrelated but long anticipated trip.

OP posts:
BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:45

FlissyPaps this is very definitely not mass hysteria. Very very far from it.

And of course the other stuff didn't happen, because a lot of it hadn't been invented yet.

But people from all walks of life DID walk past his catafalque, as they did for his father and grandfather. This is nothing new. The techno is, but the Public response isn't.

j712adrian · 14/09/2022 23:43

I'm not a Royalist, at all.

However, what strikes me is that this is a long ceremony designed a long time ago probably for young and fit people - not for a new King in his 70s.

He's showing the strain - an incredible piece of film tonight from US channels showing another paddy over pens - with Camilla looking incredibly distressed indeed. I'd also be worried by his swollen hands.

Goodness knows what state he'll be in by Monday night.

GuyMontag · 14/09/2022 23:40

Well that is entirely why we are going to hell in a handcart imo. "It's just my opinion you can agree or disagree" and all of that crap. Fuck off. If you are incapable of debate don't put your hat in the ring.

OP posts:
BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:38

CapMarvel
I am sorry my tone was patronising, genuinely. I was aiming for exasperated but missed I think.

I get that you think it is stupid, but I am fed up with reading sneering jibes about people to whom this actually matters. It may well be illogical, when does love become logic in the first place!?

For a lot of people this matters a great deal. There is no place for sneering at their emotional connection, irrespective of your PERSONAL opinion. They have a right to their feelings don't they?

LimpBiskit · 14/09/2022 23:36

I'm glad I've no live tv. The entire circus is mostly passing me by.

lemonyanus · 14/09/2022 23:33

I quite enjoy the royal events (I LOVED the platinum jubilee) but I feel a bit wrung out by this one, not sure why. It's everywhere and it's taking up a lot of headspace but I can't seem to look away and everyone is talking about it.

GuyMontag · 14/09/2022 23:33

@Fudgemaker alas the country apparently being in mourning is affecting me personally. I've got an event I've paid a lot of ££s for that I'm very keen to go to this weekend.

I've had at least six emails from the train company I bought tickets from to get me there and back - yes I'm going, no I'm not, yes I'm going but only on the 81st of June next year please see our terms and conditions for further information, it's a pain in the fucking hoop. I have no interest in any of this whatsoever and am just trying to do what I planned but everywhere I look it's black banners, Paddington, flying corgis and look-at-me coffin selfies.

OP posts:
FlissyPaps · 14/09/2022 23:33

BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:27

You speak as if this event is something new. It is not. Read your History. Educate yourself THEN make a judgement with your reasoning.

I very much doubt the mass hysteria, live streams of the coffin lying in state, mobile phones and cameras plastered in the RF’s faces whilst they’re publicly grieving and bloody wristbands being allocated to grief tourists mourners wanting to walk round the coffin all happened in the days after George VI’s death.

A lot of it is very much new. Today is completely different world since the last state funeral.

Don’t dare patronise someone and tell them to read up on history before having an opinion.

Luredbyapomegranate · 14/09/2022 23:30

It’s quite long, but I guess people want to be able to visit the lying in state and it takes a while to get the global VIPs organised.

It’s not like you have to really engage though. I’m not.

CapMarvel · 14/09/2022 23:29

BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:27

You speak as if this event is something new. It is not. Read your History. Educate yourself THEN make a judgement with your reasoning.

Appreciate the patronising tone, thanks for that.

Call it history, call it protocol or whatever, it's still stupid.

BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:28

Suggest you start with the death of Edward VII if you need a pointer re State Funerals.

BMW6 · 14/09/2022 23:27

CapMarvel · 14/09/2022 23:24

YANBU. I mean, there was always going to be a fuss but honestly I think the country has collectively lost it's mind.

You speak as if this event is something new. It is not. Read your History. Educate yourself THEN make a judgement with your reasoning.

Sallyandsam · 14/09/2022 23:27

There has been more pageantry and events because the Queen died in Scotland. Hence
the service in St Giles and Scottish lying in state. Now it’s England’s turn. I can’t begrudge the Queen 10 days of mourning after 70 years of service.

I do however feel incredibly sorry for the King, dealing with the death of his mother and a punishing schedule of physically demanding events. He’s 72 ffs and looked exhausted and broken today as he soldiered on.

Guiltycat · 14/09/2022 23:25

I agree it’s pretty unbearable op. I’m in the gritting my teeth stage. Luckily my family/friends aren’t particularly forelock tuggy so as long as I avoid social media it’s fine.

I briefly visited Facebook but logged out quite quickly. The usual crowd (You know, anyone that ever does a ‘challenge’ involving filming/photographing themselves or changes their profile picture for EVERY event) are like grief vultures picking over a carcass. But then they would be like that with any event they could use to make it all about them.

GreenManalishi · 14/09/2022 23:25

@Fudgemaker interested to know how a change of monarch is affecting "literally the world"? On a practical daily level, what's the impact, if we discount the mourning bit, a bonus bank holiday and some different looking money at some point in the future?

CapMarvel · 14/09/2022 23:24

YANBU. I mean, there was always going to be a fuss but honestly I think the country has collectively lost it's mind.

RubyJam · 14/09/2022 23:24

Fudgemaker · 14/09/2022 23:20

YABU... this is a momentous historic event affecting literally the world. There's plenty of other TV channels or in fact the option of turning your TV off, it would be easy to avoid the 'malarkey' if you wanted to make the effort!

Agree.
Its a once in a lifetime event.
Its history, the kids are interested, it’s a national event.
Honestly if you are so bored just watch a box set …

Thedogscollar · 14/09/2022 23:23

Your Bonnie Queen Charlie comment just shows how ignorant you are.

On that note you'll have guessed I think YABVU.

MissPoldark · 14/09/2022 23:22

Sorry OP you also really lost me at whatever the fuck he's calling himself
totally unnecessary

Swipe left for the next trending thread