Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think keeping ds in at break is an inappropriate punishment?

62 replies

Faithin · 14/09/2022 19:40

Ds is 9, autistic and currently being assessed for adhd.
today he had to stay in at break time to write an apology to a teacher for not doing his work in a maths lesson.
he told me that during m maths he left the class crying, was upset, got told he had to go back in and complete the work, he didn't do anything naughty as such but didn't do any of the work (because he finds it difficult)
his ehcp says he needs a lot of support, regular movement breaks, and to be able to leave the classroom when he is overwhelmed etc obviously in more detail but along those lines
I only know about this because he managed to poke a hole in his had with a pencil during the time he was being kept in at break so he explained what happened.
AIBU to be really annoyed? Why are they making an autistic 9 year old write an apology to a full grown adult for struggling at school?? For things related to his difficulties with learning?

OP posts:
Faithin · 14/09/2022 20:16

cansu · 14/09/2022 20:04

I disagree. I have two children with asd. Children with asd are all different. Some cannot function in a mainstream environment because they can't cope with the demands or the sensory overload. However, some do function well enough with support to access the curriculum and make progress. Sometimes they (like other kids) make choices that are not the ones they need to or should make. He presumably needs to work on his maths. There is a finite amount of time in a lesson. If he decides on a given day to not do his work then there needs to be a consequence for this. I would personally prefer that to be doing the maths he didn't do during part of lunchtime or completing a few questions before going out to play. If you decide now that his disability means he never faces any consequences, you are effectively saying that none of the rules apply. The parts of the story you are missing are undoubtedly the numerous attempts the adults involved made to help your son engage with his learning. I have worked with many children with asd. There have been some children for whom the classroom setting did not work even with skilled one to one support and plenty of safe spaces and adaptations. I have had some children whose needs were high but whose parents worked with me to ensure that the child engaged and did what they were capable of. I have also had parents who wanted their child to do well but were not able to trust the staff. You have made the decision to be annoyed without even speaking to the adults. You have made this call based on what your nine year old autistic child has told you.

I have good reason to be annoyed this is nowhere near the first incident of this school not treating ds right.
yes that might be true for your children but it is not the case for ds. Autism isn't the only thing going on for him, he almost certainly has adhd also (just waiting in the report from his assessment but it's very obviously) His 'working memory' scored at the 8th percentile. So in the very low range. Working memory being vital to be able to focus on things like worksheets and especially maths where you need to hold the numbers in your mind.He cannot will himself into being able to do it.

OP posts:
Sometimeswinning · 14/09/2022 20:07

Does he have a TA who supports him 1:1? We would have a consequence for missing break if he had been disruptive for the class at my school.

But in the situation you have said, no way. He would be given work he was able to achieve or had a lot of support during the lesson if we believed he could do it. I would most definitely be asking some questions!

FarmerRefuted · 14/09/2022 20:06

It sounds like he needs more scaffolding at the start of the lesson to check that he has understood the task and that he knows where to start, possibly questions broken down and given to him one at a time so he's not overwhelmed by what seems like a huge list in front of him. There should then be someone checking in with him during the task to make sure he's still on track, still coping, and still understanding what's needed then a check in at the end to make sure he's completed everything and that he's happy with it, also that he's confident he gets it and to go over anything he's unclear on.

School have massively dropped a ball here considering that he's been so disregulated and distressed by the lack of support that he's basically sat there self-harming instead of doing the work. I'd also be asking what safeguarding measures will be taken to prevent a reoccurrence of this.

cansu · 14/09/2022 20:04

I disagree. I have two children with asd. Children with asd are all different. Some cannot function in a mainstream environment because they can't cope with the demands or the sensory overload. However, some do function well enough with support to access the curriculum and make progress. Sometimes they (like other kids) make choices that are not the ones they need to or should make. He presumably needs to work on his maths. There is a finite amount of time in a lesson. If he decides on a given day to not do his work then there needs to be a consequence for this. I would personally prefer that to be doing the maths he didn't do during part of lunchtime or completing a few questions before going out to play. If you decide now that his disability means he never faces any consequences, you are effectively saying that none of the rules apply. The parts of the story you are missing are undoubtedly the numerous attempts the adults involved made to help your son engage with his learning. I have worked with many children with asd. There have been some children for whom the classroom setting did not work even with skilled one to one support and plenty of safe spaces and adaptations. I have had some children whose needs were high but whose parents worked with me to ensure that the child engaged and did what they were capable of. I have also had parents who wanted their child to do well but were not able to trust the staff. You have made the decision to be annoyed without even speaking to the adults. You have made this call based on what your nine year old autistic child has told you.

Faithin · 14/09/2022 20:00

PeekAtYou · 14/09/2022 19:53

If any child finds the work too hard then it's up to the teacher to find a solution to this. Punishing is totally unacceptable.
I think I know the answer to this but did he magically complete the work or did he basically wait until everyone came back in again? How was his mood for the rest of the day when he'd been denied his break which might have meant that he was refreshed for late morning work ?

He didn't complete the work or write the letter, he ended up really upset because he really hurt himself with his pencil and stabbed a hole into his palm during the time he was meant to be writing the letter, so he was really fixated on that and that it hurt and was bleeding etc so the whole thing just put him in an awful mood tbh and definitely didn't help the situation at all

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 14/09/2022 19:53

It's not an appropriate punishment.

I'd ask for a meeting with the teacher (with the SENCO as well) and talk to them about it.

PeekAtYou · 14/09/2022 19:53

If any child finds the work too hard then it's up to the teacher to find a solution to this. Punishing is totally unacceptable.
I think I know the answer to this but did he magically complete the work or did he basically wait until everyone came back in again? How was his mood for the rest of the day when he'd been denied his break which might have meant that he was refreshed for late morning work ?

FarmerRefuted · 14/09/2022 19:52

I'd ask for a meeting with the SENCO to review what support he currently has and what support he needs to ensure things like this aren't happening in future.

He should not be losing breaktime as a punishment full stop and he certainly should not be losing it due to behaviour related to not being supported properly in lessons. Did you know you can get it written to his EHCP that removal of break is not to be used with him?

Faithin · 14/09/2022 19:51

Seashor · 14/09/2022 19:44

There’s clearly a whole lot more to this; there always is! Just ask his teacher what happened.

A whole lot more in what way?
Regardless, keeping a very hyperactive sensory seeking child inside at break time is never going to be an appropriate way to deal with the situation. He struggles massively to remain in the class for the time he is supposed to let alone extra time.

OP posts:
violetcuriosity · 14/09/2022 19:49

Children wit ASD should not be made to write apology letters as a punishment, they need clear action/consequences that follow a natural path. He should be using a now and next board to show that maths is now and reward/motivator is next, if he doesn't do the now/maths he can't move onto next/reward. Sounds like the teacher needs some educating on ASD friendly teaching strategies (I'm assistant head at a special school for children with ASD)

Seashor · 14/09/2022 19:44

There’s clearly a whole lot more to this; there always is! Just ask his teacher what happened.

Faithin · 14/09/2022 19:41

*hole in his hand

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread