Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To turn down a job because they refused flexible working even though it was higher paid.

215 replies

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 18:37

I have been offered a job which is more money. Not massively loads. It's in my home town so no travel costs. So taking into account that and the slightly higher pay, I would be better off by £190 per month.

I asked if I could work flexibly in the mornings and afternoons to do a school run for one academic year so till July 2023. I would make the time up by working earlier from home and later in the evening. School run takes 20 mins max there and back so 40 mins of the day total.

The reason why I asked was so that I could help out my partner who has to do 2 school runs at different schools so pretty hectic. No after school club possible. This is just for this academic year and then she will be fine as eldest will be in secondary and can make own way.

The manager refused saying that that isn't what they do and there's an expectation that everyone needs to be in the office and available at any time if anything comes up. Like what i have no idea - I am not an ER doctor or anything. She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

Looks like they don't have a flexible working culture and I feel like turning the offer down but at the same time the extra money would be nice too!

YABU - of course they don't have to accept your request and you're being silly for expecting it.

YANBU - they don't seem like a forward thinking organisation and they'll be other stuff stuck in the dark ages. Run for the hills.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 14/09/2022 22:32

I’d turn down the job too because of culture and all that. But if I felt naughty, I’d swap my request from flexible working to unpaid parental leave for 1hr per day. By law you get up to 18 weeks per year and there’s no requirement to have worked for an employer to request it. It’s until the child turns 18 and is for any non-emergency need, ie an appointment. Doing the school run would qualify imho, and would only use up 190hrs of your 720hrs entitlement.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 14/09/2022 22:29

elizaregina · 14/09/2022 21:54

I thought legally employers have to look at being flexible?

I would urge caution however loosing money for a partner?
And his children?

The law is fairly toothless. Companies who are good with flexibility tend to be doing so because they feel it's in their interests. It's more about getting the staff you want than anything else.

CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:28

I'm not a dinosaur, @SummerFlops.

Far from it.

However, an interviewee asking to pick up primary aged children mid-work day would raise every eyebrow I had.

Who is providing the after school childcare?

If they need picking up, surely they need looking after?

This is a ridiculous hill to die on. I can't imagine many employers thinking this is a reasonable ask, unless it's a hugely niche field and the employee is the most sought after.

Trust is earned, not given. The decisions I make for a known employee who's work ethic I'm sure of, could be very different to someone I have no experience of.

Hillary17 · 14/09/2022 22:26

I’d say thanks but nope. The world has changed and I would never consider a company that didn’t embrace flexible or remote working. Their loss!

CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:23

TheDoorIsOpen · 14/09/2022 19:05

I'm an employer and I don't think your request is unreasonable at all, though for us, flexibility works both ways. So for example, if you want to take an afternoon off for a root canal, I won't ask you to take it as holiday if you don't mind me occasionally texting you on a Saturday morning to do a quick work thing.

Simple flexibility works for us but it has to be on both sides.

The implication that you might not be 'committed' because you have a life outside of work, doesn't sound like a great culture! I don't think that's worth £190 extra a month.

Hmmm.

I actually do run a company.

An afternoon off for a root canal does NOT fall under discretionary fun leave, in anyone's book.

Had you said 'school assembly', I could have seen your point.

This example does not pain you in a good light, @TheDoorIsOpen.

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 22:23

I'm surprised to see quite a few dinosaurs on MN!

OP posts:
ILoveAllRainbowsx · 14/09/2022 22:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

tonystarksrighthand · 14/09/2022 22:13

I'd turn it down. God knows what else they aren't flexible on ... ridiculous attitude they have

KeepYaHeadUp · 14/09/2022 22:09

YANBU. I've taken a big pay cut before to move from a completely inflexible but very well paid job to a salary 1/3 less but with a flexible working culture. At this stage that flexibility is worth more to me than the money, but that is my situation

Rosewaterblossom · 14/09/2022 22:06

It's very lacking in forward planning of their behalf if I'm honest.

Good workers can be hard to come by so if you come across one, a year of doing two 20 minutes drop off/pick ups is nothing in the long run as long as the work is caught up and completed.

If the OP was asking on a permanent basis I'd see their issue but this is not the case and this is partly the reason some companies struggle to find staff, especially good ones!

Bottomofthepileasusual · 14/09/2022 21:58

I do something similar. I work 34 hours.

Log on at 7.30 at home. Once DD has left for school I drive to work. I leave work at 2.30 to be home for her and I log back in at home until I finish around 5

elizaregina · 14/09/2022 21:54

I thought legally employers have to look at being flexible?

I would urge caution however loosing money for a partner?
And his children?

TiddleyWink · 14/09/2022 21:50

I’d be very surprised if the actual impact on your working time was just 20 minutes each time. Realistically you don’t get stuck into things properly when you’re keeping an eye on the clock for having to leave in a minute, and it’s hard to imagine you can genuinely leave your desk and be back within 20 minutes if it’s too far for your child to walk themselves. It takes me a good five minutes from my desk to the street in my office building!

I am fairy senior in an extremely flexible company and am a big fan of flexible working practices but honestly, I would raise an eyebrow (understatement actually) if someone I interviewed asked to do this twice a day every day. Because I think you’re being wildly unrealistic and massively underestimating the actual impact on your productivity of this arrangement. As is the case with your prospective boss, it would give me major red flags about you.

There’s flexibility and then there’s piss taking and sorry but for me, this strays into the latter. Flexibility is great. An overwhelming sense of entitlement whereby employees see it as unnecessary to have basic childcare arrangements in place, is not.

I’m clearly in the minority going by this thread but I believe flexibility is for unexpected situations, illness, emergencies. It’s not an excuse for working in a piecemeal way every day which realistically, will affect your performance.

trailrunner85 · 14/09/2022 21:28

The responses on this thread are 99% pointless because we don't know what your job is or what the impact would be on your team, on clients or on the general public if you were away for 20 mins twice a day.

As a pp said, it's all very well for posters to sit in a middle class wfh bubble and say airily "oooh it's as if the pandemic never happened" and accuse employers of being "dinosaurs" if they're not flexible.
You do realise most public facing roles carried on during the majority of Covid, right? And some never stopped at all. The bins were collected, shelves were stacked, police were on the streets, social workers were out in communities, estate agents were doing house viewings, roads were resurfaced, etc etc.

On the same lines, I bet most posters wouldn't be best pleased if you called to make an urgent child protection referral at 3pm and couldn't do it as the duty social worker was out picking up her kids. Or if your estate agent needed 20 mins out at 3.30pm on completion date so you couldn't pick up the keys to your new house. Etc.

It may be fine "in tech" to work very flexibly, but many roles simply don't allow it. I manage a very large service with some people who are public facing and some who aren't. We're as flexible as we can be with everyone, but the fact is we have to be staffed during core hours and we can't just pick up that work later. So if a new member of staff wanted 20 mins out twice a day I would have to consider very carefully the impact on the rest of my team as, if others put in the same request, I couldn't say yes to them all.

Yes, flexible working is marvellous for those who can do it. But let's not assume everybody can wfh please.

AloysiusBear · 14/09/2022 21:19

We have people working from home but taking time out for school runs is a no-go it's deemed as working from home not a childcare solution and our policy is quite strict on this.

This too. I wfh 100% but have childcare in place outside the home for 9-5.

AloysiusBear · 14/09/2022 21:15

Yanbu it's your choice.

But it's slightly implausible that you would arrive at work, get anything meaningful done before 8.30am or so, then get home, collect child, drop to school and return to the office within 20 minutes, unless the school is very near home in which case can't your child walk? Perhaps with another neighbouring kid? Or find a neighbour walking kids to the school and ask if he can tag along, I don't think people would mind this being asked for a y6 child who is likely to be independent & well behaved.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 14/09/2022 21:14

converseandjeans · 14/09/2022 20:42

I don't get the mumsnet al jobs should be flex , what if your customer faced and someone has to be available between 9-5 , I mean if your checkout at tesco you can't just leave for 20 mins to collect your kids
So many roles cannot be totally flexible its just not possible

Agree with this 👆🏻

It's a bit of a middle class luxury. Imagine the men doing the recycling popping off between 8.45-9.30. There's many jobs with no flexibility. If you factor lunch in then 2.30-3.30 only leaves about an hour meeting time prior to school pick up.

I think you could agree to pay childcare for the afternoon if they will agree to a later start.

Were you planning to collect, drop home & then leave kids home & go back in?

Not really a middle class luxury. At our school, which is shall we say not really MN approved naice, quite a few of the parents who have trades or provide services fit school runs round them. Gardeners, mobile hair and nails, window cleaners and the like. If you have your own business and work only in your locality it can be doable. They'd have more flex than in lots of traditionally middle class jobs.

SwimmingOnEggshells · 14/09/2022 21:14

Totally fair game to ask and as pp have said the received reaction to your request doesn't say much about the culture of the organisation.

Employers are going to miss out on good talent if they continue to lack flexibility.

Oligodoodle · 14/09/2022 21:11

Reading some of the comments on here it’s like the pandemic never happened!

GreenClock · 14/09/2022 21:09

It’s not the right culture for you. Everyone will be clockwatching.

holidaynightmare · 14/09/2022 20:56

@SummerFlops

We have people working from home but taking time out for school runs is a no-go it's deemed as working from home not a childcare solution and our policy is quite strict on this.

Would a childminder be an option?

TinyKittenPaw · 14/09/2022 20:56

I don’t think 40 mins out is too much per day if you say work through your lunch and use that time to collect after school.

I have this flexibility in my job. How do they cope when staff take 1 hour out at lunch time if it’s such a big deal? You’ll just be out for a different slot in the day to most people’s lunch break. Assuming you are allowed a 1hour lunch break what does it matter when in the day you take it?

Earlystartsmakemegrumpy · 14/09/2022 20:56

Windowtea · 14/09/2022 18:45

They don't need to accept it, but you don't need to accept the job either.

I don't think many companies would let you do what you're asking TBH. My employer is flexible and we WFH. But I doubt even they would allow what you've asked for if you were full time.

Really? My last 3 jobs I've had similar arrangements in place. As long as the job gets done to a high standard, they're happy

Noteverybodylives · 14/09/2022 20:55

*childminder

Noteverybodylives · 14/09/2022 20:55

Does neither school offer a breakfast or afterschool club?

Your wife could drop the older one off at breakfast club and then take the younger one.

If not is there a child one or even a trusted babysitter that could drop the oldest to school?

It’s a shame you’re having to turn down extra money just because of the school run.