Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To turn down a job because they refused flexible working even though it was higher paid.

215 replies

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 18:37

I have been offered a job which is more money. Not massively loads. It's in my home town so no travel costs. So taking into account that and the slightly higher pay, I would be better off by £190 per month.

I asked if I could work flexibly in the mornings and afternoons to do a school run for one academic year so till July 2023. I would make the time up by working earlier from home and later in the evening. School run takes 20 mins max there and back so 40 mins of the day total.

The reason why I asked was so that I could help out my partner who has to do 2 school runs at different schools so pretty hectic. No after school club possible. This is just for this academic year and then she will be fine as eldest will be in secondary and can make own way.

The manager refused saying that that isn't what they do and there's an expectation that everyone needs to be in the office and available at any time if anything comes up. Like what i have no idea - I am not an ER doctor or anything. She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

Looks like they don't have a flexible working culture and I feel like turning the offer down but at the same time the extra money would be nice too!

YABU - of course they don't have to accept your request and you're being silly for expecting it.

YANBU - they don't seem like a forward thinking organisation and they'll be other stuff stuck in the dark ages. Run for the hills.

OP posts:
Confusion101 · 15/09/2022 00:34

And just to add, you keep saying it's only temporary but will go on until July 2023.. Its going to last the guts of a year. Not exactly what I would call temporary! 🙈

Confusion101 · 15/09/2022 00:32

When I read your OP I could see where u were coming from and upon reading this:
I would work an hour at home. Do school run. Go to office. Do school run and then work from home after
I've changed my mind. I think that is a lot to ask of an employer who doesn't know you. The promise of working an hour in the morning before the school run would raise a few red flags like would you actually be working, or would you be getting your family ready. You would only be settling into a task and you would have to run to school. Same in the evening. All the time setting up and closing up laptop... Obviously you know you would work but just seeing it from the view of the employer I think it is an unreasonable request.

Feetache · 15/09/2022 00:00

Once you've picked up the child what will you do with them ?

Overandunderit · 14/09/2022 23:52

In this situation, the company know what their business needs are more than you and have made them clear to you. You don't know whether what you're proposing is reasonable (what's reasonable to you is irrelevant). They may have turned down similar requests so wish to maintain consistency.

Find something else if you need that kind of flexibility, many places offer it.

Anothernamechangeplease · 14/09/2022 23:37

It would work for some jobs and not for others. None of us can possibly say whether it's indicative of an inflexible working culture because we don't know what their reasons were for refusing the request.

Summerandsimmer · 14/09/2022 23:28

YANBU. I moved jobs recently because of the poor culture in my previous company being very inflexible and wanted "bums on seats" everyday.

I now work for a flexible company with a much better culture, and I can WFH and do school runs.

In return for the flexibility, I actually work more (my choice) than my 9-5 hours and willingly put in longer hours to get things done, since trust and goodwill is a two-way street.

Don't settle for a company that already questions your commitment without even working with you. It's their loss.

itsjustnotok · 14/09/2022 23:26

I guess it depends on the role. Ask by all means but some mumsnetters seem to think all jobs should be flexible and if they aren’t, are likened to dinosaurs. Not all jobs have the capacity to offer flexi work to everyone. I used to work in retail and there was a lady who requested late starts and early finishes, she threatened to sue and it all got quite nasty. The company gave her what she wanted and it resulted in everyone else having to go short staffed at opening and closing. We ended up losing staff because they got fed up of it. I know childcare is bloody hard but sometimes it feels like requests should be given regardless of the impact it has on everyone else, including the business.

Icamebyfilm · 14/09/2022 23:21

It’s not 40 mins.

its an hour.

Tuilpmouse · 14/09/2022 23:19

jackstini · 14/09/2022 23:14

If it's only 20 mins you need, can you take it as lunch break?

It's ok to ask, but it's quite a big ask up front before they really know you

Not really... You don't want to take a job, and only realise they're inflexible a week or so in, by which time it's too late, and you have a nightmare sorting school pick ups, and potentially paying for after school clubs that eat up your additional earnings!

Tuilpmouse · 14/09/2022 23:16

I wouldn't take it.... Not just because of your request, but it is likely that they will be inflexible about loads of other stuff to...

If you go, be ready for leave dates to be more tightly controlled than they need to be giving you logistical headaches.

Them taking a very dim view of you needing time when your child is I'll.

Not being able to go to special assemblies or sports days etc.

jackstini · 14/09/2022 23:14

If it's only 20 mins you need, can you take it as lunch break?

It's ok to ask, but it's quite a big ask up front before they really know you

Icamebyfilm · 14/09/2022 23:08

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 18:48

Really? That's interesting. I would be in the office all the time but would leave to do the school run. It literally would be a 20min trip. Obviously if there were meetings etc that would take priority. I'm surprised that organisations aren't more open to flexibility after the pandemic.

No because by the time you let everyone be flexiable than there is no room for meetings because everyone is away doing their own thing.

Rosewaterblossom · 14/09/2022 23:06

anon666 · 14/09/2022 23:02

I guess they know best what would fit with the job and their culture.

I've been in a lot of jobs where this would be an issue, where you need to be full on. Other jobs could have accommodated it.

Some office jobs are in reality 10 hour days, and so docking 40 minutes off the standard 7.5 hours would be seen as taking the piss.

Yes things are changing, but some jobs are changing more than others. I think you were right to stay in your current job if the flexibility is important.

Most jobs are still stipulated responsibilities amd hours, especially if face to face. It's one thing for a valued member of the team who you trust and can see pulls their weight. It's a whole other when you get someone who thinks the whole world revolves around them, has no flex and isn't a team player.

Sometimes if you ask this stuff at the wrong moment as a new team member, it comes across badly.

Covid forced alot of companies to have no choice but to change the way people do their jobs which in effect changed their culture. Suddenly companies who were clunky and rigid before realised "oh yes" we can adapt and change and be flexible!

anon666 · 14/09/2022 23:02

I guess they know best what would fit with the job and their culture.

I've been in a lot of jobs where this would be an issue, where you need to be full on. Other jobs could have accommodated it.

Some office jobs are in reality 10 hour days, and so docking 40 minutes off the standard 7.5 hours would be seen as taking the piss.

Yes things are changing, but some jobs are changing more than others. I think you were right to stay in your current job if the flexibility is important.

Most jobs are still stipulated responsibilities amd hours, especially if face to face. It's one thing for a valued member of the team who you trust and can see pulls their weight. It's a whole other when you get someone who thinks the whole world revolves around them, has no flex and isn't a team player.

Sometimes if you ask this stuff at the wrong moment as a new team member, it comes across badly.

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 14/09/2022 22:56

Skimmed the thread but wanted to say my company would have no issue with this as long as all work got done by its deadline. It wouldn't be a formalised arrangement, more of a need to know basis, but would certainly not be a problem.

C152 · 14/09/2022 22:52

It's a bit of both. Given how most employers attitudes towards flexible working have changed post-pandemic, it's not unreasonable for you to ask about flexible working (though I think you were a bit foolish to tell a propsective employer it's for childcare reasons - I probably would have asked if their policies have changed, like so many other companies, to allow WFH 2-3 days per week), but it's not unreasonable for them to say no when there are lots of people looking for work. Employers often pick the easiest option, not necessarily the best. If they interviewed other candidates with a similar skill-set and experience as you, but the other candidates were willing to work the set hours from the office, I can see why they'd choose someone who was a closer fit to their requirements.

Their approach does speak volumes about their culture and how they judge and value employees though...so it sounds like it probably wouldn't have been a good fit for you anyway.

Dexterdoo · 14/09/2022 22:51

More companies are moving away from presenteeism and trusting their employees to just get their work done. Sadly it sounds like your new place isn't one of them. At least you know before you started.

Also agree some of the responses on here are ridiculous. Yes what the op is asking for isn't that unusual since the pandemic. Wake up.

CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:48

Well, be sure to let me know should I ever interview you, @SummerFlops.

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 22:44

CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:28

I'm not a dinosaur, @SummerFlops.

Far from it.

However, an interviewee asking to pick up primary aged children mid-work day would raise every eyebrow I had.

Who is providing the after school childcare?

If they need picking up, surely they need looking after?

This is a ridiculous hill to die on. I can't imagine many employers thinking this is a reasonable ask, unless it's a hugely niche field and the employee is the most sought after.

Trust is earned, not given. The decisions I make for a known employee who's work ethic I'm sure of, could be very different to someone I have no experience of.

@CantFindTheBeat

My dp looks after the children once they are at home as she had finished work by then. Childcare is not an issue.

You'd risk losing good people for a temp flexibility arrangement? Madness. Sorry but I think you might be exactly the type of manager I wouldn't want.

OP posts:
CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:43

@Discovereads

And this employer, who's said no to any flexible working, is going to do that, are they?

Cocopogo · 14/09/2022 22:43

YANBU more employers need to get on board with flexible working. I’m lucky, my boss lets me work flexibly and I can come and go as I please so long as I get my hours in and the job is done well.

Discovereads · 14/09/2022 22:39

CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:36

Well you wouldn't get employed as your comprehension isn't really up to much.

Where have you read that you can take Parental Leave in hours?

On Gov.uk

”You must take parental leave as whole weeks (eg 1 week or 2 weeks) rather than individual days, unless your employer agrees otherwise or if your child is disabled. You don’t have to take all the leave at once.”

So if your employer agrees to doing it by hours, you can. :)

Discovereads · 14/09/2022 22:37

See, www.gov.uk/parental-leave

Sorry I misspoke earlier, it’s 18 wks per child. Not per year.

CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:36

Discovereads · 14/09/2022 22:32

I’d turn down the job too because of culture and all that. But if I felt naughty, I’d swap my request from flexible working to unpaid parental leave for 1hr per day. By law you get up to 18 weeks per year and there’s no requirement to have worked for an employer to request it. It’s until the child turns 18 and is for any non-emergency need, ie an appointment. Doing the school run would qualify imho, and would only use up 190hrs of your 720hrs entitlement.

Well you wouldn't get employed as your comprehension isn't really up to much.

Where have you read that you can take Parental Leave in hours?

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 22:34

Just to clarify a few things

  • this isn't a customer facing role. Noone will need to cover for me. No impact to anyone.
  • I would work an hour at home. Do school run. Go to office. Do school run and then work from home after
  • my dp does all school runs on days I go into the office / have meetings. Her work is very flexible. I just wanted to support her as this year it's just a bit hectic.

People saying not everyone can have flexibility in their jobs are being obtuse. If your job can be done from home / flexibly - those are the jobs we're talking about. Not the bloody ER doctor or the Tesco checkout operator!

OP posts: