Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To turn down a job because they refused flexible working even though it was higher paid.

215 replies

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 18:37

I have been offered a job which is more money. Not massively loads. It's in my home town so no travel costs. So taking into account that and the slightly higher pay, I would be better off by £190 per month.

I asked if I could work flexibly in the mornings and afternoons to do a school run for one academic year so till July 2023. I would make the time up by working earlier from home and later in the evening. School run takes 20 mins max there and back so 40 mins of the day total.

The reason why I asked was so that I could help out my partner who has to do 2 school runs at different schools so pretty hectic. No after school club possible. This is just for this academic year and then she will be fine as eldest will be in secondary and can make own way.

The manager refused saying that that isn't what they do and there's an expectation that everyone needs to be in the office and available at any time if anything comes up. Like what i have no idea - I am not an ER doctor or anything. She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

Looks like they don't have a flexible working culture and I feel like turning the offer down but at the same time the extra money would be nice too!

YABU - of course they don't have to accept your request and you're being silly for expecting it.

YANBU - they don't seem like a forward thinking organisation and they'll be other stuff stuck in the dark ages. Run for the hills.

OP posts:
MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 15/09/2022 08:33

I’d have just asked to start later and work later/through lunch to make up rather than both. Though, the committee comment puts me off

Dailymash · 15/09/2022 08:22

Not unreasonable, if they want you to be available at all times what happens when it’s your lunch break? Or do they not allow anyone to leave the building for lunch? They’re stuck in the dark ages, you’re better off out.

RagingWoke · 15/09/2022 08:21

bodie1890 · 15/09/2022 06:56

YANBU

I think some people on this thread don't realise that flexibility works both ways.

Most days you can have your arrangement of picking up the kids, if you don't have other commitments.

Days when you do have other commitments, you make another arrangement.

Flexibility from both the employer and employee, to accommodate each other's needs as much as possible. It's actually basic respect.

Some people just don't seem able to cope with any out of the box thinking. I would run for the hills with a manager like that tbh.

Absolutely this. Flexible working can be amazing for both employed and employee, where it's appropriate (obviously some roles just aren't compatible with it).

Eg I have flexible working, wfh most of the time and do school runs turned down an offer for a huge amount of money because they had no flexibility. In my current job I travel often to meetings all over the country rather than have a local office. I can do a 4/5 hour day when it's quiet or 14 hours when it's busy.
My hours work for my home life but because I'm flexible the other way too it's never an issue. I am very much pro flexible working and I think if more companies adopted it they'd see huge improvements in productivity and retention.

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 15/09/2022 08:16

I do this a few days/week. Have done since the pandemic. Prior to that, life was a rush, after school club, after school club pick up, fitting in activities for the DC and a rushed dinner. Now I often leave at 3, grab the kids, start work again at 3:45 for a couple of hours whilst they play/watch TV (older primary so don’t need supervision)… My job isn’t customer facing and those I work with can be online from 6:30am - 7pm so sometimes I cover one end of the day, sometimes the other, even though the organisation I work for is more 9-5. My hours actually benefit our clients and give them more flexibility. Equally, if I want to finish at 3 I can start at 6:30/7. So long as major meetings, which are always 10-2 anyway, are covered, who actually cares if the work is getting done?!

bumblingbovine49 · 15/09/2022 07:43

Look for another job. You will find a better one with more flexible employers

At my work we have be trying to fill an analyst roles and are advertising for the fourth time in nine months . The role has been empty the whole time. In the first two of the rounds we had fewer than 10 applications and only 1-2 were worth interviewing and none were appointable . We have an incredibly family friendly environment and very flexible working policy. Our team is great and very friendly . I am not just saying that , I honestly think in 30 years of working this is the best set of colleagues I've worked with for being friendly, open, efficient , dedicated and hard working with no difficult people at all ( and let's face it there is usually at least one in any team of 20-30 people)

. Our pay is probably at the bottom of end of average though so that doesn't help but our salaries are fairly set and hard to increase as we are a university

Filling job roles at the moment is not at all easy unless you are offering the whole package

Andromachehadabadday · 15/09/2022 07:17

I don’t even understand how this is an issue to be honest.

Their hours of work don’t suit you and they aren’t willing to give the flexibility you want.

They are at the bottom of their industry. Not a great a company.

Just like any job offer that doesn’t meet your needs, you reject it and move on.

They don’t have to give you what you want and they don’t want you enough to try and give you it. You don’t have to work for them, because it doesn’t suit your life.

I work for a company that I turned down 3 times in 2 years because it didn’t suit me at the time. They finally created a role that did. And here I am.

Confusion101 · 15/09/2022 07:10

A lot of parents would love the opportunity to drop and collect their kids. If I was in a company working long term, and suddenly this new employee starts and is granted an hour working from home in the morning, mid morning - afternoon in the office, and the rest of the evening working from home I'd be thinking that sounds like something I'd like. Then all of a sudden staff are requesting this set up or others and time for meetings is greatly reduced. As others have continuously pointed out, this would work for some companies but not all and the place obviously has their reason as to why they want everyone in the office! Not every job every is going to be able to bow to your needs, and you to theirs. Decline, stay where you are and leave it at that.

bodie1890 · 15/09/2022 06:56

YANBU

I think some people on this thread don't realise that flexibility works both ways.

Most days you can have your arrangement of picking up the kids, if you don't have other commitments.

Days when you do have other commitments, you make another arrangement.

Flexibility from both the employer and employee, to accommodate each other's needs as much as possible. It's actually basic respect.

Some people just don't seem able to cope with any out of the box thinking. I would run for the hills with a manager like that tbh.

Notlosinganyweight · 15/09/2022 06:55

Could you book your lunch break everyday for that time? I think the line about not being committed demonstrates that they think they own you a bit. I would stick to what you have for another year. I'm in the same boat where I have a flexible role, but stuck in a job I don't like and the pay is crap because I can't be confident that other employers will be flexible, and going to an inflexible employer would cost me any gains I make anyway.

TiddleyWink · 15/09/2022 06:54

SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 06:37

I have no idea if they have a WFH / flexible culture but naively thought they would as I have worked in the same type of organisation for over 15 years and I have always had at least a day WFH. It's been the norm for me. Some have been much more flexible than others but the least was one day from home. I was surprised to have found out that there was an expectation to be in the office at all times.

Some have been at the top of their game. Unfortunately this organisation is actually at the bottom of the heap and are struggling. They don't have a very good reputation in their field either.

I am wondering if they have lost good talent ( not talking about myself!) for not offering hybrid / WFH / flexible working. I can't be the only one that's turned a job down here for this reason. It's honestly a shame as I think I could have brought some good experience to the role and already had a few ideas that I wanted to propose which have worked really well in similar work I've done.

So did you pursue a role with such a terrible company who is at the ‘bottom of the heap’? Sounds like sour grapes to me. You’re coming across as immature and obtuse, anyone who politely points out the employer’s position is sneered at and called a ‘dinosaur’. Cringe! You’re really not coming across well. Clearly you’re not happy with the company’s response to what you’ve asked for so just turn down the role. Why come on a forum inviting opinions if you’re so adamant you’re right and anyone else is wrong?

Paigeycakey · 15/09/2022 06:49

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 18:48

Really? That's interesting. I would be in the office all the time but would leave to do the school run. It literally would be a 20min trip. Obviously if there were meetings etc that would take priority. I'm surprised that organisations aren't more open to flexibility after the pandemic.

Reasonable but I think to ask you any favours like this is a bit like gold dust. People have worked for a company for years and get declined for things like this or compressed hours.

It's a bit shit but maybe something better will come along! Good that you asked though you never know!

Squisita · 15/09/2022 06:47

Then it’s a real shame that the flex isn’t there.

SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 06:44

Squisita · 15/09/2022 06:40

YANBU, it’s pretty flexible at my company,, to the extent that some put drop-offs / pick-ups in their Outlook for all to see.

Would you actually work an hour earlier though? Not being doubtful, just noy something I could do.

Yes I actually do this in my current role. Even on the days I am in the office. My dp sorts the kids out.

OP posts:
SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 06:42

Confusion101 · 15/09/2022 00:34

And just to add, you keep saying it's only temporary but will go on until July 2023.. Its going to last the guts of a year. Not exactly what I would call temporary! 🙈

It would be 9m - take into account the school holidays and that would be more like 7.5 months! Absolutely temporary!

OP posts:
Squisita · 15/09/2022 06:40

YANBU, it’s pretty flexible at my company,, to the extent that some put drop-offs / pick-ups in their Outlook for all to see.

Would you actually work an hour earlier though? Not being doubtful, just noy something I could do.

SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 06:37

bumbledeedum · 15/09/2022 06:19

Does the company have a general home working culture?

Tbh I've always been a pretty relaxed manager but I would raise an eyebrow at Thai request (depending on the overall company culture but it sounds like your request is quite different to theirs).

You're not asking for just flexibility to do the school run, you're asking for a reasonable chunk of time as home working.

Not saying either position is right or wrong, but it does sound like your expectations and attitudes are fundamentally incompatible and it certainly doesn't seem worth the stress for an extra £190pm.

I have no idea if they have a WFH / flexible culture but naively thought they would as I have worked in the same type of organisation for over 15 years and I have always had at least a day WFH. It's been the norm for me. Some have been much more flexible than others but the least was one day from home. I was surprised to have found out that there was an expectation to be in the office at all times.

Some have been at the top of their game. Unfortunately this organisation is actually at the bottom of the heap and are struggling. They don't have a very good reputation in their field either.

I am wondering if they have lost good talent ( not talking about myself!) for not offering hybrid / WFH / flexible working. I can't be the only one that's turned a job down here for this reason. It's honestly a shame as I think I could have brought some good experience to the role and already had a few ideas that I wanted to propose which have worked really well in similar work I've done.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 15/09/2022 06:29

You could for the first xtra money pay someone to do the school run for the next year and then after that you would get the benefit.
but I would just ask your current employer to match the pay rise or meet half way. A manager suggesting I was uncommitted would ring alarm bells for me

1AngelicFruitCake · 15/09/2022 06:26

Say they grant it for you, what happens to those people that actually pay for wraparound care (that most of us have to do)? They should be granted flexible working. But how does that work if you’re all in/out at different times?

If you won’t be gone for long, why didn’t you offer to come back to work after you’ve picked up?

Tohaveandtohold · 15/09/2022 06:25

I don’t see what’s wrong in what you asked, you planned to come back and work the hours after doing the drop off and pick up.
I’ll take that as a hint that it’s not a good place to work for and will definitely continue looking for another job for more pay and better conditions.

People do this a lot at my place of work, we only go to the office one day a week but just that one day, many people take their lunch at 2:30 so they leave then and do school pick up and then log in at home for the rest of the afternoon, it’s not frowned on and for some of us whose children go to after school club who stay at the office till closing, we don’t see an issue with it.

bumbledeedum · 15/09/2022 06:19

Does the company have a general home working culture?

Tbh I've always been a pretty relaxed manager but I would raise an eyebrow at Thai request (depending on the overall company culture but it sounds like your request is quite different to theirs).

You're not asking for just flexibility to do the school run, you're asking for a reasonable chunk of time as home working.

Not saying either position is right or wrong, but it does sound like your expectations and attitudes are fundamentally incompatible and it certainly doesn't seem worth the stress for an extra £190pm.

Andromachehadabadday · 15/09/2022 06:17

I work in what’s considered part of the construction industry. We start at 8am so you starting at 9.15 would be an issue in some roles. But the afternoon would be fine.

we try and work with people as much as we can. But not every role is suitable for this.

Their attitude that it shows you have no commitment to the job, suggests it’s not a great place to work.

SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 06:14

Icamebyfilm · 14/09/2022 23:08

No because by the time you let everyone be flexiable than there is no room for meetings because everyone is away doing their own thing.

That's right. Tech companies haven't been able to schedule meetings in years - their flexibility is ruining everything.

OP posts:
SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 06:09

trailrunner85 · 15/09/2022 05:52

I would work an hour at home. Do school run. Go to office. Do school run and then work from home after

This would be fine as an irregular thing if one of my team asked for it, but not for it to become their regular working pattern. Depending on the timing of the pick ups and drop offs, you're potentially putting yourself out of three usual meeting slots (9-10, 2-3pm, 3-4pm). And then when you take lunchtimes into account too, it suddenly becomes very difficult to schedule to meet with the OP at all..

. I've already said that if meeting times clash during those times my dp can sort it. Really not a problem at all. I am flexible.

OP posts:
trailrunner85 · 15/09/2022 05:52

I would work an hour at home. Do school run. Go to office. Do school run and then work from home after

This would be fine as an irregular thing if one of my team asked for it, but not for it to become their regular working pattern. Depending on the timing of the pick ups and drop offs, you're potentially putting yourself out of three usual meeting slots (9-10, 2-3pm, 3-4pm). And then when you take lunchtimes into account too, it suddenly becomes very difficult to schedule to meet with the OP at all..

Discovereads · 15/09/2022 00:35

CantFindTheBeat · 14/09/2022 22:43

@Discovereads

And this employer, who's said no to any flexible working, is going to do that, are they?

Did you miss my first sentence which said I’d probably decline the job? And that “if I felt naughty” I’d swap to an unpaid parental leave request. It’s more to show them how unreasonable they are being before declining than with any real expectation of a “oh gosh yes how silly of us to treat you like a machine” response.