Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To turn down a job because they refused flexible working even though it was higher paid.

215 replies

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 18:37

I have been offered a job which is more money. Not massively loads. It's in my home town so no travel costs. So taking into account that and the slightly higher pay, I would be better off by £190 per month.

I asked if I could work flexibly in the mornings and afternoons to do a school run for one academic year so till July 2023. I would make the time up by working earlier from home and later in the evening. School run takes 20 mins max there and back so 40 mins of the day total.

The reason why I asked was so that I could help out my partner who has to do 2 school runs at different schools so pretty hectic. No after school club possible. This is just for this academic year and then she will be fine as eldest will be in secondary and can make own way.

The manager refused saying that that isn't what they do and there's an expectation that everyone needs to be in the office and available at any time if anything comes up. Like what i have no idea - I am not an ER doctor or anything. She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

Looks like they don't have a flexible working culture and I feel like turning the offer down but at the same time the extra money would be nice too!

YABU - of course they don't have to accept your request and you're being silly for expecting it.

YANBU - they don't seem like a forward thinking organisation and they'll be other stuff stuck in the dark ages. Run for the hills.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 11:35

saraclara · 15/09/2022 11:22

Mumsnet really is a bubble.

I find it really odd when people feel entitled to this kind of flexibility, when the vast majority of the population don't even begin to have that advantage, and many businesses aren't remotely in a position to offer it.

I find it odd that anyone would think people do or should take into account the population as a whole, rather than what's the norm in their role and sector when it comes to assessing jobs.

Our window cleaner chooses his own hours and works flexibly around school pick ups (he is my cousin's friend so I know the circumstances). Do you think he ought to be like well nah actually, the cashier at Tesco and the surgery team at the hospital can't decline to work on the school run, so I guess I'm not entitled to organise my working life around my other commitments to the best of my ability either? And does this apply only to flexibility, or to other aspects of jobs too?

Codingand36 · 15/09/2022 11:33

I live in Cornwall, part time in the private sector is still frowned upon here.

Most mums have to work in the public sector if they want flexibility here.

Otherwise you'll get sweaty men asking you "who's at home cooking dinner if you're at work until 5:30pm...."

True story. 👍

saraclara · 15/09/2022 11:22

Mumsnet really is a bubble.

I find it really odd when people feel entitled to this kind of flexibility, when the vast majority of the population don't even begin to have that advantage, and many businesses aren't remotely in a position to offer it.

LakieLady · 15/09/2022 11:18

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:58

You and @LakieLady worked for 15+ years in a role which is interesting I guess I'm talking about a new generation who just expect to dictate their working conditions from the off
I'm guessing you never did that starting out and nor did I !!

Actually, I knew the organisation had a flexible approach when I applied for a job back at the start of 2007, and it was one of the things that made them attractive as an employer. They've won awards for being a family-friendly employer.

And they're flexible in other ways too, especially staff development. If they think someone has an aptitude for, or interest in, a particular type of work, they'll often arrange secondments so they can develop those skills. A lot of people have switched to working in very different roles, eg MH work to facilities management, because they found they had a talent for it.

billy1966 · 15/09/2022 11:11

SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 10:44

Just an update before I leave the thread. I have spoken to the manager this morning explaining my reasons for declining the job. She was quite abrupt and cut the conversation short. I am disappointed tbh but there's a silver lining in every cloud.

I think I will stick with my current role which is working fine for us as a family. Ill keep an eye out for other jobs though.

My dp will just have to get through the next 9 months and then things will be much easier for her.

I think you have made a good call.

She sounds awful.

Questioning your commitment would be enough.

I think you would have always been on the backfoot based on her reaction.

Give feedback to the company if you can.

Her manner put you off accepting their offer.

It is amazing how flexible these unflexible companies expect YOU to be!

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 11:10

ArcticArchitect · 15/09/2022 11:03

I had an interview recently and the MD told me that the other applicants had no caring responsibilities and therefore they're more employable than me.

I can't exactly complain, because all the little Director men go and do business lunch, probably compare dick and 4x4 sizes and play golf. My reputation would be in tatters.

The world of architecture everyone 👏

Good lord that's sad in this day and age and I can't believe they actually said that when it's blatant discrimination and illegal !!

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 11:09

@ILikeHotWaterBottles I'm not disagreeing with you I'm sure there are many shit employers out there
A couple of points

  • op said she was offered a job so did she apply or was she approached ? I would expect if she was approached they've already decided they need her and should be willing to negotiate on terms
  • the manager sounds like they need some training !
  • playing devils advocate I can imagine they would expect some blow back from existing employees with no flexible hours if they hire someone new on different terms - I can relate to that but doesn't mean it's right - just becomes a case of if we do that for them we have to do it for everyone and in a small business that could be scary
LakieLady · 15/09/2022 11:05

I've declined jobs before do the same reason with no regrets, and told them why so they know they're losing ppl because they aren't flexible.

I used to work on a project that was delivered by 3 geographical teams. One team had a control freak manager.

Senior management noticed that that team had much higher staff turnover than the other two, and started asking searching questions at exit interviews and next-in-line supervisions. It quickly became apparent that it was down to the inflexibility of that particular manager, and they had to change their ways.

ArcticArchitect · 15/09/2022 11:03

I had an interview recently and the MD told me that the other applicants had no caring responsibilities and therefore they're more employable than me.

I can't exactly complain, because all the little Director men go and do business lunch, probably compare dick and 4x4 sizes and play golf. My reputation would be in tatters.

The world of architecture everyone 👏

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 15/09/2022 11:01

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:53

@ILikeHotWaterBottles that's a seriously extreme example and I agree a terrible employer ! Most SANE employers would of course allow sickness or disability leave or make allowances for such injuries (in fact i it's the law where I'm from to do so!) so your example is just silly frankly !
The reality is that before covid most people did not work from home and that's because MANY people are not productive working from home . My business allowed it on a case by case basis usually determined by tenure and proven trust. Often these cases were return to work mums etc.
I'm sure we'd make allowances for broken legs too !!
I just don't think it should be a given to expect to work from home anymore - yes we can be flexible for picking up kids and work around childcare but that should be discussed and not expected

It's the law where I am from too, doesn't mean there aren't still shit companies out there. That one was international! Not a small company, just a shit one. Run by shit managers.

Ops job can be done from home, like mine can. And like mine, hers is common that it is done from home. If you want to be a rarity and have people in the office, you need some VERY good incentives, like a lot more money, benefits etc. Not a small amount more and the indication that you are going to be dragged through the mud if you dare think differently.

I don't think you've had much experience with a shit company which is good. But I have and this one has red flags galore. Run away is the only option unless desperate.

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:58

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 10:50

Flexible meaning what though ? And you mention working for multiple companies? Does trust with tenure count for nothing ?

I worked for my first organisation for 19 years and now sector has exploded and there is a lot of opportunity.

I do not think most people will take the piss. Maybe it is different across sectors? Maybe difference in culture and attitudes.

You and @LakieLady worked for 15+ years in a role which is interesting I guess I'm talking about a new generation who just expect to dictate their working conditions from the off
I'm guessing you never did that starting out and nor did I !!

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:53

@ILikeHotWaterBottles that's a seriously extreme example and I agree a terrible employer ! Most SANE employers would of course allow sickness or disability leave or make allowances for such injuries (in fact i it's the law where I'm from to do so!) so your example is just silly frankly !
The reality is that before covid most people did not work from home and that's because MANY people are not productive working from home . My business allowed it on a case by case basis usually determined by tenure and proven trust. Often these cases were return to work mums etc.
I'm sure we'd make allowances for broken legs too !!
I just don't think it should be a given to expect to work from home anymore - yes we can be flexible for picking up kids and work around childcare but that should be discussed and not expected

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 10:53

did not expect the company I worked for then to care about my kids - they are not the companies responsibility.

This attitude is wrong. Kids, caring responsibilities etc. Who does that impact the most? They don't have to care about your kids but they should understand about equality and equity and how their working practices impacts these.

LakieLady · 15/09/2022 10:52

The reality is most people will take the piss

If you're consistently appointing pisstakers, @OLP2019 , you might want to take a look at your recruitment practices to see where you're going wrong.

I've worked for 15 years, in a variety of roles, for an organisation with approx 1,000 staff. In that time, I've encountered 2, maybe 3, pisstakers. They either left because they were rumbled quickly and put under performance management or changed their ways.

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 10:50

Flexible meaning what though ? And you mention working for multiple companies? Does trust with tenure count for nothing ?

I worked for my first organisation for 19 years and now sector has exploded and there is a lot of opportunity.

I do not think most people will take the piss. Maybe it is different across sectors? Maybe difference in culture and attitudes.

G5000 · 15/09/2022 10:48

I did not expect the company I worked for then to care about my kids - they are not the companies responsibility.

The company I work for does care about my kids, dogs and grandparents. It's a massively successful company with amazing employee retention. And yes we can take 20 min to pick up kids if needed.
Yes there are plenty of jobs where you have to have your backside on the seat during your contracted hours, but most office jobs do allow for flexibility.

LakieLady · 15/09/2022 10:45

YANBU, OP.

One of the reasons I've stayed with my current employer is because they have an incredibly flexible approach to issues like this. I could do the same job in the public sector and get 25% more money, but I really value the way they treat staff.

And it cuts both ways, too. I'm p/t now, but am always ok about changing my hours to accommodate training, meetings etc if I possibly can, as are my colleagues, most of whom are also p/t.

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:45

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 10:37

I only work for flexible companies. Flexible companies are more inclusive. I could earn a lot more but choose flexibility. Times have moved on. Life has moved on. Those organisations still stuck on antiquated working practises just because it was what was done before will not have a good culture. Depending on your sector there are plenty of flexible companies out there.

Don't compromise on what you want if you do not have to.

Flexible meaning what though ? And you mention working for multiple companies? Does trust with tenure count for nothing ?
The reality is most people will take the piss so as an employer you have to find a balance
Before covid almost no one worked from home and now many people don't want to return to the office
Companies need to take that into account but also must consider productivity and culture in long term planning
My example as a business owner is my head of sales selling up and moving hours away and not wanting to commute now the office is open again but the core of his role is managing sales people a lot of which traditionally is done face to face - so where does that leave me when I have a team without a leader

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 10:45

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:39

Yes but we're not talking about wfh it's asking for exceptions before even being hired
If a long term trusted employee asked for this then I would absolutely think it should be considered but I don't believe not allowing it from the offset is a red flag from a company
Employers also have to trust that work is being done and people aren't taking the piss
I think that is earned

We are talking about wfh. In the OP it says that the manager expects everyone to be in the office and available all the time, ie no wfh. Which actually, given what OP has said about her other roles in the sector, would mean it's this employer who is the exception. The majority of people talking about red flags in the thread have been referring to this.

SummerFlops · 15/09/2022 10:44

Just an update before I leave the thread. I have spoken to the manager this morning explaining my reasons for declining the job. She was quite abrupt and cut the conversation short. I am disappointed tbh but there's a silver lining in every cloud.

I think I will stick with my current role which is working fine for us as a family. Ill keep an eye out for other jobs though.

My dp will just have to get through the next 9 months and then things will be much easier for her.

OP posts:
ILikeHotWaterBottles · 15/09/2022 10:44

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:28

Ridiculous to say it's a red flag and insinuate all sorts of future issues ! As PP said the pandemic made everyone assume they could work from home forever and come and go as they please and that's just not a reality in many workplaces
Doesn't mean they're not a good place to work but probably means you should look elsewhere

For someone to suggest 'you're not committed enough' when they barely know you and all you've done is made a simple request, not an order, is ridiculous. If you think that's normal, you really shouldn't ever be a manager.

That kind of attitude is the attitude of a bad company, who will likely suggest you're not committed for daring to be sick. I actually got told by one such company that they would have given me a disciplinary for having a broken leg if I hadn't kept working in the office. I couldn't drive! I couldn't get there. But I could work from home, that wasn't good enough though.

If you think that's right, you're the one who needs a reality check.

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 10:43

Employers also have to trust that work is being done and people aren't taking the piss

Employers should treat people professionally and as mature adults. When going for a role, I see what they can offer me too. If I don't like the offer I wouldn't take it unless I needed to.

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:39

Yes but we're not talking about wfh it's asking for exceptions before even being hired
If a long term trusted employee asked for this then I would absolutely think it should be considered but I don't believe not allowing it from the offset is a red flag from a company
Employers also have to trust that work is being done and people aren't taking the piss
I think that is earned

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 10:37

I only work for flexible companies. Flexible companies are more inclusive. I could earn a lot more but choose flexibility. Times have moved on. Life has moved on. Those organisations still stuck on antiquated working practises just because it was what was done before will not have a good culture. Depending on your sector there are plenty of flexible companies out there.

Don't compromise on what you want if you do not have to.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 10:31

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 10:28

Ridiculous to say it's a red flag and insinuate all sorts of future issues ! As PP said the pandemic made everyone assume they could work from home forever and come and go as they please and that's just not a reality in many workplaces
Doesn't mean they're not a good place to work but probably means you should look elsewhere

Nah, the belief that everyone needs to be in the office for the sort of role OP is talking about is a red flag, particularly in a sector that appears to have been ahead of the game in offering wfh pre pandemic. Very few people never want any flexibility at all, even those who do genuinely prefer to be fully office based.