Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To turn down a job because they refused flexible working even though it was higher paid.

215 replies

SummerFlops · 14/09/2022 18:37

I have been offered a job which is more money. Not massively loads. It's in my home town so no travel costs. So taking into account that and the slightly higher pay, I would be better off by £190 per month.

I asked if I could work flexibly in the mornings and afternoons to do a school run for one academic year so till July 2023. I would make the time up by working earlier from home and later in the evening. School run takes 20 mins max there and back so 40 mins of the day total.

The reason why I asked was so that I could help out my partner who has to do 2 school runs at different schools so pretty hectic. No after school club possible. This is just for this academic year and then she will be fine as eldest will be in secondary and can make own way.

The manager refused saying that that isn't what they do and there's an expectation that everyone needs to be in the office and available at any time if anything comes up. Like what i have no idea - I am not an ER doctor or anything. She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

Looks like they don't have a flexible working culture and I feel like turning the offer down but at the same time the extra money would be nice too!

YABU - of course they don't have to accept your request and you're being silly for expecting it.

YANBU - they don't seem like a forward thinking organisation and they'll be other stuff stuck in the dark ages. Run for the hills.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OnGoldenPond · 20/09/2022 02:12

vivainsomnia · 15/09/2022 16:28

So what job in the public sector gets no meetings, phone calls, urgent information requests during 8:30 and 9:30 and 2:30 and 3:30?

Doesn't sound like an efficient service to me!

It's central finance in a university so not public facing. Most meetings still on Teams and booked well in advance so can be flexible. Most of the job can be done anywhere and involves independent working. Granted it would be more difficult in a more public facing role.

OriginalUsername3 · 16/09/2022 09:00

OriginalUsername3 · 16/09/2022 08:52

I think not allowing flexibility is blithering here nor there tbh. Some do, some don't. For different reasons. But this comment.

She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

Is the red flag. Its a perfectly acceptable request it doesn't show anything about your commitment to your work other than that you are more committed to your family. She sees that as a bad thing. A company that sees your family coming over your work as a bad thing is a bad employer. No doubt they'll be expecting you to work free overtime otherwise you're not committed and work during your holidays, otherwise you're not committed.

It won't be worth it.

Blithering=neither

OriginalUsername3 · 16/09/2022 08:52

I think not allowing flexibility is blithering here nor there tbh. Some do, some don't. For different reasons. But this comment.

She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

Is the red flag. Its a perfectly acceptable request it doesn't show anything about your commitment to your work other than that you are more committed to your family. She sees that as a bad thing. A company that sees your family coming over your work as a bad thing is a bad employer. No doubt they'll be expecting you to work free overtime otherwise you're not committed and work during your holidays, otherwise you're not committed.

It won't be worth it.

ittakes2 · 16/09/2022 08:42

She sounds horrid so it looks like you dodged a bullet. I would never be rude to someone declining a role you never know when you might meet them again in the industry and they could be your boss!

IglesiasPiggl · 16/09/2022 07:24

tickticksnooze · 14/09/2022 18:49

She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

I would take that as a warning on their culture and decline.

Absolutely this. Their culture is crap, don't work there. They have no understanding that juggling priorities does not represent a lack of commitment to any of them. I can't imagine a workplace in this day and age that doesn't get that. Dinosaurs.

Heatherbell1978 · 16/09/2022 06:55

They're being completely unreasonable. I work from home and although kids are in wrap around care, it's not unusual for me to have to do a school run - that's an hour out my day but I make it up/don't take lunch etc. It's a culture thing - it's almost expected at my workplace that people do some form of flexing in their day. I'd steer clear as they won't come through and be supportive if you had some kind of home emergency

GoldenOmber · 15/09/2022 21:40

If the culture and technology is there it's not an issue.

But it is an issue in some jobs, no matter how much technology you have or how flexible the culture is. My job is also public sector and computer-based and we just couldn’t manage people popping in and out as and when, because there is a constant unpredictable stream of things you really do need to be at your desk or close to it to be able to sort out. Doesn’t mean we are not flexible but it does mean that this particular kind of flexibility isn’t one that works everywhere.

I entirely accept that there are some jobs where it would be fine, and that yours is one of them and the job the OP applied for might have been one of them too, and I’d be a bit Hmm myself that their reason for refusing OP’s request was apparently “you don’t sound committed” rather than “that wouldn’t fit the requirements of this job.” But I am baffled by the number of people in these discussions who just won’t accept that it wouldn’t work everywhere and that isn’t just about old-fashioned presenteeism.

RagingWoke · 15/09/2022 21:20

vivainsomnia · 15/09/2022 13:38

People saying not everyone can have flexibility in their jobs are being obtuse. If your job can be done from home / flexibly - those are the jobs we're talking about
Our jobs are flexible working from home but we have yo be available from 9 to 4. That's because that's when meeting gs are set up. Meetings that include anywhere from 3 to 15 + people. Some informal, some very formal. Most people bring their own expertise to these meeting.

I can imagine having a discussion about whether to go ahead with a project, going over the budget and suddenly say 'sorry guys, continue without me for 1h, I've got to get the kids, but it's OK, I'll be back and you can all wait to move things forward until I do'!

Then there's the issue of catching up. 'Sorry boss, can you go over all what was said during the 1h I missed? I can't get my head around the figures that were submitted, why did they change?'

Unless you work in a field that means you don't interact with others, or meetings are all very set between 9:30 and 2:30, how does it work? What jobs do you do?

It's not always an hour, it's not always school runs to be accommodated.

For example I'm working on a large project (public sector, very complex) with 20+ on the project team. Some work 3 or 4 days, some do school runs, some have other caring responsibilities, a couple have so many meetings they have no availability for days or weeks at a time, most of us at some point have appointments. We work around it, because everyone is flexible and respectful and it works really well. Meetings can be anything between 8-6 and on the rare occasion something urgent comes up we all have work phones.

If the culture and technology is there it's not an issue.

JackandSam · 15/09/2022 18:15

vivainsomnia · 15/09/2022 16:28

So what job in the public sector gets no meetings, phone calls, urgent information requests during 8:30 and 9:30 and 2:30 and 3:30?

Doesn't sound like an efficient service to me!

I'm a social worker. As I said above, it's not possible every day. But certainly several days a week. I do more than my hours every week and we are the highest performing team in the city, I attribute that to being flexible and valuing staff for what they do.

JackandSam · 15/09/2022 18:13

tickticksnooze · 14/09/2022 18:49

She also insinuated that I wasn't committed to the job by asking this.

I would take that as a warning on their culture and decline.

Same.

To be fair, we wouldn't allow you to make it a formal arrangement, and there would days (when on training or on duty) where it simply wouldn't be possible but I do the morning drop off most days and pick up twice a week. I'm available on the phone and catch up before and after.

Gardenista · 15/09/2022 18:08

vivainsomnia · 15/09/2022 16:28

So what job in the public sector gets no meetings, phone calls, urgent information requests during 8:30 and 9:30 and 2:30 and 3:30?

Doesn't sound like an efficient service to me!

Lots of public sector roles are not dealing with members of the public - so finance, IT, HR , governance services etc it would not be an issue to work flexibly - any desk based job where you are mainly working alone not with other people

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 17:11

There are many types of jobs and sectors within the public sector, not just those that deal with the public on a day to day basis.

vivainsomnia · 15/09/2022 16:28

So what job in the public sector gets no meetings, phone calls, urgent information requests during 8:30 and 9:30 and 2:30 and 3:30?

Doesn't sound like an efficient service to me!

OnGoldenPond · 15/09/2022 16:24

Lots of people are allowed to do this kind of thing at my workplace but it is public sector so different kind of culture. Maybe look for a job in the public sector?

rainbowmilk · 15/09/2022 14:21

I’m in the public sector and so many of my colleagues do the twice daily school run, saying they’re logged on for an hour from 8am and then again after 5pm. In reality they’re never contactable at these times and you can only get an answer from them on anything between 10-12 and 1-2.30. They’re never at meetings outside of these times either.

They all maintain that “as long as the work is done it’s fine” but the bulk of the work is being done by others, not by them. If I were an employer, having seen this widespread behaviour, I’d never approve what you’ve requested because I’d suspect you’d be faffing with the kids getting ready 8-9 and then doing childcare 3.30-5 and then maybe doing a bit of work 5-6 if there was anything left for you to do by then.

Jconnais1chansonquivavsenerver · 15/09/2022 13:40

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 12:58

Where we work we have meeting etiquette such as reducing the reliance on them, not arranging over set times etc. I am happy for my team to do school runs. I am happy to arrange calls around that. I find flexible employer tends to lead to flexible employee. Again, I guess it depends on the role.

If I were still in the work force, @LuciferRising, you would be my kind of boss! As others have mentioned above, it's been my experience that employer and employee can both benefit greatly from mutual flexibility. I'm seeing and hearing a bit about "quiet quitting" at the moment, which to my mind is a reaction of some people to employers' demands that people give more of themselves than contractually required to their employers without any reward for it. If Jacob Rees-Mogg has his way, at Truss's behest, in the UK, there'll be a lot more "quiet quitting" as he tries to send workers' rights back to Dickensian times.
I'm so glad I'm out of it, but so sad for our children and grandchildren. Sorry, I digressed.

vivainsomnia · 15/09/2022 13:38

People saying not everyone can have flexibility in their jobs are being obtuse. If your job can be done from home / flexibly - those are the jobs we're talking about
Our jobs are flexible working from home but we have yo be available from 9 to 4. That's because that's when meeting gs are set up. Meetings that include anywhere from 3 to 15 + people. Some informal, some very formal. Most people bring their own expertise to these meeting.

I can imagine having a discussion about whether to go ahead with a project, going over the budget and suddenly say 'sorry guys, continue without me for 1h, I've got to get the kids, but it's OK, I'll be back and you can all wait to move things forward until I do'!

Then there's the issue of catching up. 'Sorry boss, can you go over all what was said during the 1h I missed? I can't get my head around the figures that were submitted, why did they change?'

Unless you work in a field that means you don't interact with others, or meetings are all very set between 9:30 and 2:30, how does it work? What jobs do you do?

LuciferRising · 15/09/2022 12:58

Where we work we have meeting etiquette such as reducing the reliance on them, not arranging over set times etc. I am happy for my team to do school runs. I am happy to arrange calls around that. I find flexible employer tends to lead to flexible employee. Again, I guess it depends on the role.

GoldenOmber · 15/09/2022 12:45

I think people see flexible working as different things.

Yes, exactly. My workplace is pretty flexible in that it will allow compressed hours, term-time working, hybrid working (although not usually full WFH), all sorts of different working patterns, flexi time, etc etc etc. But I wouldn’t expect to have a request like OP’s granted because it wouldn’t fit the way we work.

It seems like OP knows enough about her sector to be confident that this workplace could allow this and just doesn’t want to. But I’m surprised to see so many other people who think ‘flexible’ should mean ‘being allowed to work how and when you please on your own personal schedule’, and any employer which wouldn’t be ok with anything you might want is being a ‘dinosaur’.

Florin · 15/09/2022 12:28

I think people see flexible working as different things. The problem is you are missing the same times everyday which means everyone who needs to work with you has to work your times too so if everyone tried to do this it would be impossible to book in meetings and it has to be fair to everyone. There is a big difference between you asking for set times in the business day off everyday to how a lot of people work where flexible working is counted as something like: This week I have meetings in the office or at a clients office on Monday, Wednesday and Thursday so if all stays quiet I will work ay home Tuesday and Friday (and May do a quick school run on their home days) unless something pings in the diary or say to their boss in a months time I have little Jimmy’s nativity 9-10 so can I go to that and work from home and make the hour up in my lunch break. That’s certainly how everyone I know works flexibly.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 12:25

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 11:57

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior I don't really get the point your making as a self employed contractor like a window cleaner can make their own hours and work around their lifestyle
Someone working for a corporate business doesn't necessarily have that luxury. Neither does a surgeon who is on call for when they're needed. Or a firefighter who is on call and works when needed
This is not the same as someone in a 9-5 corporate job
What was the point you were trying to make ?

That's actually pretty much my exact point. That the poster thinking it's odd for MNers not to take into account the norm across the population, rather than their own sector, is weird in itself. Because of course people don't do that, for all the reasons you list.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 15/09/2022 12:12

Glitteratitar · 15/09/2022 09:49

With the extra money you will be making, why can’t you hire a childminder?

It's £190 a month. Most of that will get swallowed up by the increase in energy prices I'd have thought.

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 11:57

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior I don't really get the point your making as a self employed contractor like a window cleaner can make their own hours and work around their lifestyle
Someone working for a corporate business doesn't necessarily have that luxury. Neither does a surgeon who is on call for when they're needed. Or a firefighter who is on call and works when needed
This is not the same as someone in a 9-5 corporate job
What was the point you were trying to make ?

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 11:53

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 11:45

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior "Our window cleaner chooses his own hours and works flexibly around school pick ups (he is my cousin's friend so I know the circumstances). Do you think he ought to be like well nah actually, the cashier at Tesco and the surgery team at the hospital can't decline to work on the school run, so I guess I'm not entitled to organise my working life around my other commitments to the best of my ability either? And does this apply only to flexibility, or to other aspects of jobs too?" This makes absolutely no sense

Can't tell whether you're asking me to clarify there or not so I will. What I'm asking is whether the poster I responded to thinks people do or should consider whether the flexibility they want is something the entire population have access to, and if so whether this applies to other aspects of their work too such as salary. I don't think that makes any sense myself.

OLP2019 · 15/09/2022 11:45

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior "Our window cleaner chooses his own hours and works flexibly around school pick ups (he is my cousin's friend so I know the circumstances). Do you think he ought to be like well nah actually, the cashier at Tesco and the surgery team at the hospital can't decline to work on the school run, so I guess I'm not entitled to organise my working life around my other commitments to the best of my ability either? And does this apply only to flexibility, or to other aspects of jobs too?" This makes absolutely no sense

Swipe left for the next trending thread