Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at school predicted A level grade

189 replies

user29 · 14/09/2022 18:27

How can DD be predicted a lower grade than she has proved she is capable of achieving (by a margin) in her mock?

OP posts:
Whokno · 14/09/2022 20:48

Libertyqueen · 14/09/2022 20:39

This isn’t helicopter parenting. School should have a system for how they are arriving at predicted grades and shouldn’t have a problem explaining it to parents.

It's the very definition of helicopter parenting. Young adult faces a challenge, young adult is not required to do anything about challenge (including a simple question) & parent takes it upon themselves to sort it out and get involved in some sort of "appeal" when in reality there are only two options 1) predicted grade is unfair, in which case young adult should have a sensible conversation with teacher or 2) predicted grade is fair, in which case over invested parent should stay out of it. The mental health rate at oxbridge is the reason I think that teaching your child to be resilient is more important than the name of the uni they go to.

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:47

I would point out that the subject teacher still hasn't given the PGs to the students. Her application has to be submitted by 23rd september , so i emailed the teacher to ask.

OP posts:
titchy · 14/09/2022 20:46

She doesn't need the A star in Biology though if she's predicted A stars in her other subjects Confused

Thatsnotmycar · 14/09/2022 20:45

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:33

Yeah

Oxbridge don’t require an A* specially in Biology.

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 20:45

I understand why it’s stressful but refusing to engage with the teacher isn’t going to help.

There is no A grade in AS levels, which is why you don’t have that grade boundary when looking at the mock marks. The A work (the most challenging content) tends to appear in the second year of the course. Therefore, given that we are only a week or so into the A2 year of the course, it’s quite possible the teacher simply hasn’t seen any A quality work from any pupil yet, so cannot justify an A prediction.

I wouldn’t advise going in with a stack of ‘evidence’ like you know better than the teacher… A better conversation (ideally between your DD and their teacher if I’m honest) would be to ask about the A prediction and whether there will be any opportunity between now and submitting her UCAS form (which I appreciate will be early) to demonstrate her ability to achieve an A* grade, given that the mock won’t have contained that content.

The school may well have a policy about this kind of thing - it’s very difficult to predict an A* when that content hasn’t even been taught yet. I’m sure you can see how it can cause trouble later if there’s no evidence to back up what turns out to be an over-prediction.

(Just in case… I previously ran UCAS applications in a large school, currently an A level examiner)

EnidSpyton · 14/09/2022 20:43

I am an experienced secondary teacher and Head of Department.

Your DD needs to have a conversation with her teacher about how the grade was calculated. Predicted grades are supposed to be discussed with the pupil and it is not good practice for them to be handed out without a dialogue. I am surprised that your DD's school has just given them out without a contextual conversation.

Predicted grades aren't just calculated on what your child achieves in a mock exam. The teacher will also consider the quality of class and home work completed so far and the level of knowledge and understanding they show during lessons. A brilliant mock exam as a result of cramming is not necessarily reflective of their actual ability and a one off good performance cannot be relied upon to be repeated. So we have to look at the big picture.

I also consider how pupils cope with exams when I predict. If I know a pupil is likely to become very nervous in the exam room, go blank, write a load of nonsense, etc, then I will be more cautious with their predicted grade as I can't guarantee they will perform to their true ability on the day.

Also, if this is about being predicted an A star rather than an A, then you need to understand how difficult it is for teachers to predict A stars. The grade boundaries shift every year as the % required for one is based on the whole cohort's achievement in that exam session. Unless a pupil is consistently brilliant in EVERY element of the syllabus and I am confident their coursework is of A star standard, I would be very reluctant to give an A star as a prediction. Some Headteachers even actively discourage teachers predicting them unless a pupil really does need them for a Oxbridge application, as it sets up very high expectations that could be problematic later on.

In short - your DD needs to speak to her teacher. She's in sixth form. She needs to be taking charge of this herself, not having her parents email in before she's even attempted to find out why the teacher has made the decision they have.

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:42

MmeMeursault · 14/09/2022 20:41

If the lower grade was based on AS then it is likely to differ for the full A-Level. In any event you can't get A* at AS in any subject as they're only available for A-Level. Might be that the teacher took the AS mock grade rather than translated it up.

Just ask. Or rather: get your teen to ask.

If thst is the case, how would anyone ever get predicted A*

OP posts:
Noteverybodylives · 14/09/2022 20:42

Can you say what she is predicted and what she got on the mocks?

If she needs a 9 but is predicted a 2 then they’re not going to offer her a conditional place.

But if she’s predicted an 8 and she’s getting a 9 then I’d hope they would take her predicted grade with a pinch of salt and wait for her actual grade.

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:41

Whokno · 14/09/2022 20:34

How is she going to manage at uni if she can't ask a teacher a simple question? I'd be less worried about what uni she goes to, and more about how she's going to thrive once she gets there. (And I have quite a bit of experience of students who have had helicopter parents)

We will cross that bridge when we come to it.
UCAS say predicted grades should be achievable and ASPIRATIONAL
The other subjects have all based PGs on the mocks, Surely tehre should be a schoolwide policy rather than leaving it up to individual departments to dream up their own method.

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 14/09/2022 20:41

Of she's applying to Oxbridge then all the more reason she should be finding out herself.

MmeMeursault · 14/09/2022 20:41

If the lower grade was based on AS then it is likely to differ for the full A-Level. In any event you can't get A* at AS in any subject as they're only available for A-Level. Might be that the teacher took the AS mock grade rather than translated it up.

Just ask. Or rather: get your teen to ask.

Libertyqueen · 14/09/2022 20:39

Whokno · 14/09/2022 20:34

How is she going to manage at uni if she can't ask a teacher a simple question? I'd be less worried about what uni she goes to, and more about how she's going to thrive once she gets there. (And I have quite a bit of experience of students who have had helicopter parents)

This isn’t helicopter parenting. School should have a system for how they are arriving at predicted grades and shouldn’t have a problem explaining it to parents.

IrisVersicolor · 14/09/2022 20:38

These are adults in a position of power who Students have been drilled for 13 years not to question.

What kind of school teaches students not to question adults? Very much the opposite of my school.

Noteverybodylives · 14/09/2022 20:38

Is this for university?

Are you saying she won’t get on the course if predicted grade is too low, even if she gets the required grade?

Predicted grades are set a certain way and they are the minimum grades which would be achieved if the student progresses at the exact same rate as they have been.

But we know that many students often work harder coming up to their exams so can reach a higher potential or go the opposite way and don’t progress as well as they could do.

I would speak to the university themselves and give them her mock grades and ask if she’s allowed a provisional place which most unis offer, which means if she gets the correct grades then she can get on.

Libertyqueen · 14/09/2022 20:37

Based on what you’ve said it does seem straightforwardly wrong. I would query it ASAP. Ask for the head of department to explain their logic. It could just be an admin error by the school office somewhere. It certainly doesn’t seem to make sense.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 14/09/2022 20:37

Maybe she actually didn't make the grade?

Whokno · 14/09/2022 20:34

How is she going to manage at uni if she can't ask a teacher a simple question? I'd be less worried about what uni she goes to, and more about how she's going to thrive once she gets there. (And I have quite a bit of experience of students who have had helicopter parents)

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:33

PassMeThePineapple · 14/09/2022 20:02

Is this to apply to Oxbridge? I think the Russel group unis require A for Biology rather than A star

Yeah

OP posts:
Looneytune253 · 14/09/2022 20:33

When I spoke to dds college end of last year they said the predicted grades were given by the teachers before they did the mocks. The mocks weren't there for that reason. It was based on class work and general standards throughout the year. It was opposite way round for us. Dd got consistent a* thru the year in class but flunked the exam. Thankfully her predicted grade was ok.

PassMeThePineapple · 14/09/2022 20:32

TheOrigRights · 14/09/2022 20:29

I know it's not what you're asking but frankly I think it's utterly bonkers that someone needs to get an A* in the subject they want to study at university.

Surely a student who has a B or above is intellectually able to study a degree in that subject.

I'm so thankful it wasn't so harsh in the early 90s. I didn't do well in my A levels, got into an average uni, did very well and have had a successful and rewarding career in the field.

Dd was predicted A for Biology and got offers from 4 Russell group unis with that to do Biology. I assume op is applying to Oxbridge?

titchy · 14/09/2022 20:31

I'm on the app so can't follow easily - are you saying she needs an A star prediction but has an A prediction? With the other subjects she has A star predictions?

If so I really won't make any difference to her offers. If she's aiming at Oxbridge then she'll have sat UKCAT which is arguably far more important than the star.

Bear in mind the grade boundaries next year will be far higher than for this year, so predicting one grade lower than the one achieved on this year's paper seems reasonable.

TheOrigRights · 14/09/2022 20:29

I know it's not what you're asking but frankly I think it's utterly bonkers that someone needs to get an A* in the subject they want to study at university.

Surely a student who has a B or above is intellectually able to study a degree in that subject.

I'm so thankful it wasn't so harsh in the early 90s. I didn't do well in my A levels, got into an average uni, did very well and have had a successful and rewarding career in the field.

noblegiraffe · 14/09/2022 20:27

Kids ask for a bump in their predicted grades all the time. No idea why you're making such a big deal about asking.

Dahlietta · 14/09/2022 20:26

Am I understanding correctly that she has been predicted an A and she needs an A*? And that the mock exam in which she performed so well was an AS paper and she is doing A level?

My guess would be that the department is reluctant to predict As. In my experience, the way this goes is that the student goes to see the teacher and says, "I really need an A prediction for my university choice - remember how well I did" and the teacher gives in and says "Okay, but please understand that this doesn't necessarily mean you're going to get it", but that's dependent on the school obviously.

ocs30 · 14/09/2022 20:20

One of mine got shockingly low predictions across subjects. She had moved schools at 6th form so other than her (very good) GCSE grades, they didn't really know her as well as the kids who had been there all along. She was I think distracted by the new social life, and even though she was doing ok on her mocks, the school was very ungenerous in their predictions. We asked if she thought the predictions were right and she said no. We knew the school was likely off, but didn't think there was much point in pushing back, so decided she would take a gap year without doing any applications and see how things turned out. In the end, she got 3A* and a Cambridge place- I think she was somewhat motivated by wanting to prove them wrong- and did some really worthwhile work experience and volunteering during the year. Would yours consider something like that?

Just to add, in your shoes, I would make sure it isn't some kind of error.

Swipe left for the next trending thread