Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at school predicted A level grade

189 replies

user29 · 14/09/2022 18:27

How can DD be predicted a lower grade than she has proved she is capable of achieving (by a margin) in her mock?

OP posts:
Oblomov22 · 14/09/2022 21:19

Then she needs to ask. If she hasn't got the guts to ask for a review then she's probably lacking what it takes for the top uni's anyway.

mondaytosunday · 14/09/2022 21:18

Sorry I realise that you didn't actually say she got an A star, I just read it that way. But my reasoning applies no matter what.

the80sweregreat · 14/09/2022 21:17

My son was cool about his B grade
I wasn't! It's irrational , but they were harsh

mondaytosunday · 14/09/2022 21:17

Yes if she got a high A star on her mock I would think they would predict that.
In our school we were told that they try to be optimistic but realistic. So if a student was borderline but in other aspects had indicated they were capable of the higher grade they would predict that, but not if a student was solidly in the lower grade as no point.
My daughter got an A star on her Psychology mock, but the teacher warned her she 'just' made it over the boundary so she still had work to do, but he did predict the A Star.
However another teacher predicted a grade lower than he thought she was capable of (Art, so not exam based), and said she'd get an A if she pulled her finger out.
They don't submit the grades yet so there is room to discuss. I'd be asking the teacher why, if she did do so well, they are down grading her.

Midsizegal29 · 14/09/2022 21:16

Quite often, predicted grades are a more cautious prediction. Teachers get absolutely slated if their predictions are over, so it could be that she is averaging an A at the moment (even though she scored the equivalent of an A* in the mock) based on that set of papers and other bits of work & assessments completed over the year. A predicted grade is never just based on one assessment.

The sensible thing to do would be to ask her teacher if you’d like clarification. I’m sure they’d be more than happy to explain it to you.

Noteverybodylives · 14/09/2022 21:16

I've never recovered from Ds2's B in art when he was always an A star !
I hated the exam board for years

If he got a lower grade in his real exams than he was used to/predicted then it’s most likely because of nerves on the day.

The amount of students who mess up exams simply because they’re so nervous is so sad.

It’s trying to find the line between encouraging them to try hard but also not pressure them so they don’t feel too nervous on the day.

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:14

canyouextrapol · 14/09/2022 21:06

I had students who having achieved C/D on every other previous assessments suddenly got 90 odd %. They wrote the answer to complex maths questions without showing any working. It was obvious they'd just got hold of the paper. They shouldn't have. It was still protected by the exam board. Someone admitted they had a tutor that had given it them with the markscheme. They'd just memorised the answers with no understanding, so it wasn't in any way a reflection of their actual ability. To do their predicted grade based on that would result in uni offers they'd not be able to achieve

I hope you didn't accuse a student of that with no evidence! They may just have not bothered revising til the exam

OP posts:
the80sweregreat · 14/09/2022 21:11

I've never recovered from Ds2's B in art when he was always an A star !
I hated the exam board for years

buckleten · 14/09/2022 21:11

My dd has had this exact issue last week - needed a star in a particular subject but her prediction was an a. She wrote an email to the head of sixth form explaining rationally why she felt it should be moved to an a star, and provided evidence that she was working at the required level with all her recent test results. The school make a point of not changing predictions easily, but after taking a week to consider it and talking to all her subject teachers, they agreed to put the prediction up to a star. So it is worth asking!

titchy · 14/09/2022 21:10

But Oxbridge don't need an A star in Bio for Bio/NatSci so not really clear what the problem is. Confused

schoolsoutforever · 14/09/2022 21:10

To add to that, yes, it would better (for herself and her sense of autonomy) if your daughter approaches the school/college first but I certainly have had emails from parents and I am happy to answer them.

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 21:09

So you know your DD’s predicted grade but she doesn’t? I’ll say again, it would be so much better for this conversation to be between her and her teacher….

Part of that conversation would be to ask how an A star prediction could be achieved. I never minded being asked this. The answer was never that it was solely on a mock exam which was AS material, it would have required exceptional work in all areas of the course so far, including extension work / more challenging class tests, etc. Her teacher will have an answer for this, let them give it….to your DD.

PassMeThePineapple · 14/09/2022 21:08

PassMeThePineapple · 14/09/2022 20:58

Oh ok. I assumed it must be Oxbridge requiring it as I knew non oxbridge ones didn't. What is it your dd needs the A star to do op?

Oops sorry, I missed that you said it was Oxbridge. My fault for replying in between taxiing dd around

Whokno · 14/09/2022 21:07

Oxbridge deadline is sometime in October isn't it? With predicted grades a bit earlier, but you don't need them right now. Get your sixth former to ask the teacher to leave it until the deadline (to give max time assessing work in Upper sixth) and see if she can get the prediction revised.

canyouextrapol · 14/09/2022 21:06

I had students who having achieved C/D on every other previous assessments suddenly got 90 odd %. They wrote the answer to complex maths questions without showing any working. It was obvious they'd just got hold of the paper. They shouldn't have. It was still protected by the exam board. Someone admitted they had a tutor that had given it them with the markscheme. They'd just memorised the answers with no understanding, so it wasn't in any way a reflection of their actual ability. To do their predicted grade based on that would result in uni offers they'd not be able to achieve

schoolsoutforever · 14/09/2022 21:04

Have you or your daughter emailed the school or college, explained the Oxbridge application, and asked for clarification of why A not A. They may well be happy to change the grade so worth exploring (I am an A level teacher and will change the grade depending on circs/new knowledge). If your daughter is very able and a student who is exceptionally dedicated to the subject, I would expect an A with that ‘mock’ AS grade. However, AS examinations and A level papers are quite different and in some subject the standard is hugely different.

just send a diplomatic email asking if there is a possibility of a change in prediction - it wouldn’t offend me as a teacher at all.

PassMeThePineapple · 14/09/2022 20:58

Thatsnotmycar · 14/09/2022 20:45

Oxbridge don’t require an A* specially in Biology.

Oh ok. I assumed it must be Oxbridge requiring it as I knew non oxbridge ones didn't. What is it your dd needs the A star to do op?

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:57

Whyarewehardofthinking · 14/09/2022 20:52

Predicting an A, as others have said, is extremely difficult, and I'd be even more reticent with GCSEs scored on TAGs, as they have no indication of how a student will perform in a proper exam season. I can only remember 2 occasions of predicting an A at A level for Chemistry and that was because the student constantly scored above 95% on every past paper that they were presented with, and on papers I had devised myself, plus work outside of exams was exceptional.

At this point your DD has not studied the hardest parts of the course, so an A* prediction is unreliable and could still (despite her being a great student) wrong.

Then how can anyone be predicted an A* then?
She hs gone some 'real' exams at GCSE(FM) and also at AS (maths and FM)

OP posts:
Noodledoodledoo · 14/09/2022 20:55

At Year 13 level I would fully expect your daughter to be addressing this with her teacher, form tutor, Head of Year. I am a sixth form tutor and all conversations are with the student, including issues over predicted grades, and very rarely with the parents. I would tell her she needs to ask her teachers for time to discuss it and remind them of the earlier deadline - my subject references aren't due till 23rd so thats what I am working towards.

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:54

MmeMeursault · 14/09/2022 20:51

So actually if they've not yet gone out, you don't know if the predicted grade will be an A or an A* and all this has been a waste of everyone's time and advice?

I don't understand. The teacher emailed me DD's grade in response to my query. She hasn't told DD or her classmates their grades yet.

OP posts:
Whyarewehardofthinking · 14/09/2022 20:53

I also can't star grades apparently either!

Whyarewehardofthinking · 14/09/2022 20:52

Predicting an A, as others have said, is extremely difficult, and I'd be even more reticent with GCSEs scored on TAGs, as they have no indication of how a student will perform in a proper exam season. I can only remember 2 occasions of predicting an A at A level for Chemistry and that was because the student constantly scored above 95% on every past paper that they were presented with, and on papers I had devised myself, plus work outside of exams was exceptional.

At this point your DD has not studied the hardest parts of the course, so an A* prediction is unreliable and could still (despite her being a great student) wrong.

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 20:51

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 20:45

I understand why it’s stressful but refusing to engage with the teacher isn’t going to help.

There is no A grade in AS levels, which is why you don’t have that grade boundary when looking at the mock marks. The A work (the most challenging content) tends to appear in the second year of the course. Therefore, given that we are only a week or so into the A2 year of the course, it’s quite possible the teacher simply hasn’t seen any A quality work from any pupil yet, so cannot justify an A prediction.

I wouldn’t advise going in with a stack of ‘evidence’ like you know better than the teacher… A better conversation (ideally between your DD and their teacher if I’m honest) would be to ask about the A prediction and whether there will be any opportunity between now and submitting her UCAS form (which I appreciate will be early) to demonstrate her ability to achieve an A* grade, given that the mock won’t have contained that content.

The school may well have a policy about this kind of thing - it’s very difficult to predict an A* when that content hasn’t even been taught yet. I’m sure you can see how it can cause trouble later if there’s no evidence to back up what turns out to be an over-prediction.

(Just in case… I previously ran UCAS applications in a large school, currently an A level examiner)

Apologies - on my phone and made a mess of the stars / bold type! There’s no A star grade at AS level, the A star content is in the second year, so teachers will be reluctant to predict A stars. Hope this makes sense.

MmeMeursault · 14/09/2022 20:51

user29 · 14/09/2022 20:47

I would point out that the subject teacher still hasn't given the PGs to the students. Her application has to be submitted by 23rd september , so i emailed the teacher to ask.

So actually if they've not yet gone out, you don't know if the predicted grade will be an A or an A* and all this has been a waste of everyone's time and advice?

GnomeDePlume · 14/09/2022 20:50

It is worth asking the question.

DD's school tended to under-predict. Some of this was because they werent used to dealing with applications to RG universities or applications for science subjects. A prediction of a B was considered perfectly good if not a little adventurous.

DD challenged her predicted grades and had them increased. She achieved her revised predicted grades.